Crosswinds may have challenged pilots in Pearson plane crash, expert says
J. Joseph, a 29-year veteran aviator in the United States Marine Corp., says it is much too early in the investigation to jump to conclusions about what happened, but conditions in Toronto were 'quite windy' at the time of the crash.
Joseph says high winds, especially crosswinds that blow perpendicular to the plane, could 'present certain challenges to pilots' as they try to navigate the landing at Pearson Airport.
The flight from Minneapolis crashed Monday, intact but upside down, with the wheels of the Mitsubishi CRJ-900LR jutting into the air on the snow-covered tarmac.
Several of the 76 passengers and four crew members were injured.
In an audio conversation between the airport tower and the Delta flight shortly before landing, the tower warned the pilots of a possible air flow 'bump' in the plane's landing glide path stemming from an aircraft in front of it.
But Joseph says it is unlikely that was a factor in the crash, given that air-traffic control is exceptionally skilled at planning adequate space between planes to prevent too much impact from wake turbulence, adding that the strong winds would present a bigger risk.
'Toronto in the winter with high, gusty winds, it could be very challenging,' he says. 'Those high winds and with regard to runway alignment, perhaps crosswind components in winds extremely strong from the left of the right of the aircraft, present certain challenges to the pilots.
'I've got 30,000 hours of flying airplanes. It never gets easy. I don't care how much experience you have. Every set of circumstances is different, and the conditions change very dynamically.'
But Joseph says how the plane ended upside down will still need to be explained.
"For an aircraft, particularly a large transport-category airplane, to end up in under those circumstances — upside down — is rather rare," he says. "It has happened in the past, but I will tell you candidly, it is very rare."
Joseph also says the fuselage being preserved in the crash bodes well for the investigation, as the plane's 'black box' cockpit voice recorder and flight data recorder will both likely be intact.
'There are going to be a lot of good data, real time, extracted from the data recorders, as well as the pilots and the flight crew being able to give statements,' he says.
'You learn a lot from mishaps and the investigation. The crux of why you do it in the first place is to preclude those types of mishaps from reoccurring.'
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Feb. 17, 2025.
Chuck Chiang, The Canadian Press
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
07-08-2025
- CBS News
Detroit flight attendant files $75M lawsuit against Delta Airlines, Endeavor Air over Toronto plane crash
A Detroit flight attendant is suing Delta Airlines and Endeavor Air Inc., claiming that the airlines assigned an "inadequately trained pilot to operate the flight" that resulted in a plane crash earlier this year in Toronto, Canada. An attorney for Vanessa Miles filed the lawsuit on July 28 in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan, arguing that Miles is entitled to $75 million in damages. On Feb. 17, 2025, more than 20 people were injured after flight 4819, which took off from the Minneapolis-St. Paul International Airport, flipped upside down while landing at the Toronto Pearson International Airport. Two flight crew members, two cabin crew members and 76 passengers were on the flight. Miles was a passenger and was traveling to Toronto for future work assignments at the time of the crash, according to the lawsuit. The lawsuit claims that Delta and Endeavor Air "cut corners on safety by rushing pilots through training programs and knowingly putting passengers at risk with inexperienced flight crew." CBS News Detroit reached out to Delta for comment on the lawsuit. The airline declined to comment and said it "continues to support the Transportation Safety Board of Canada's ongoing investigation." The board confirmed that it is still investigating and referred CBS News Detroit to its webpage dedicated to the investigation. Days after the crash, Delta released information about the crew on the flight, denying claims that the captain and first officer had failed training events were false. The company said both crew members were Federal Aviation Administration-certified. According to the lawsuit, Miles suffered injuries and lost consciousness, finding herself soaked in jet fuel and surrounded by smoke when she regained consciousness. The lawsuit said that because the aircraft was upside down, Miles fell to the ceiling when she unbuckled her seat belt. Her injuries became worse when she attempted to exit the plane and fell roughly 6 to 7 feet to the ground due to emergency slides not being activated. A preliminary report released on March 20 by the safety board found that as the plane was attempting to land, a piece of the landing gear called the side-stay fractured, causing the gear to retract and the right wing to separate from the fuselage. The report said that jet fuel was released and caused a fire. The report said that many passengers suffered injuries after they unbuckled their seat belts, but it was not aware of any failures of the safety belts. The report also found that an emergency locator transmitter — a device that sends distress signals — was armed but did not activate at the time of the accident. The board said the transmitter was sent to the TSB Engineering Laboratory.
Hamilton Spectator
01-08-2025
- Hamilton Spectator
Pilot dead, two passengers injured after small plane crash near Ottawa airport
OTTAWA - Ottawa paramedics say a man is dead after the small airplane he was piloting crashed into trees near the city's airport on Thursday. Emergency crews responded to a wooded area near Riverside Drive and Hunt Club Road just before 6 p.m. after reports that the small plane crashed. Supt. Marc-Antoine Deschamps says responders worked together to extricate the plane's three occupants. Deschamps says the adult male pilot of the plane was pronounced dead at the scene, and a man and woman were taken to hospital with non-life-threatening injuries. The Transportation Safety Board of Canada says they are investigating and the plane was a privately registered Grumman AA-5A. The Ottawa International Airport Authority says the airport's fire services responded to the crash along with city firefighters, but airport operations were not affected. This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 1, 2025.
Hamilton Spectator
31-07-2025
- Hamilton Spectator
Flight attendant during Delta plane crash in Toronto sues airline, claims pilot ‘inexperienced'
A U.S. flight attendant commended for her heroism during the Delta Airlines crash at Toronto Pearson Airport in February has filed a multimillion-dollar lawsuit against the airline, claiming it employed an inexperienced pilot who landed the plane at a 'catastrophically excessive rate of speed.' In a 15-page statement of claim filed in U.S. federal court this week, flight attendant Vanessa Miles, 67, alleges the airline, along with its subsidiary, Endeavour Air, 'cut corners on safety' by failing to adequately train its pilots and crew, in part resulting in the fiery crash on Feb. 17 . Miles, who lives in Detroit, claims she was severely injured after Flight 4819, travelling from Minneapolis with 80 people on board, suffered a 'violent and catastrophic drop' while landing, flipped upside down, and burst into flames on one of Pearson's runways. The crash sent at least 21 people to hospital. There were no fatalities. The allegations set out in Miles' claim, which is seeking a minimum of $75 million (U.S.) in damages, have not been tested in court. When reached by the Star, a spokesperson for Delta Air Lines declined to comment. Lawyers for Miles did not respond to the Star's request for comment by publication. An investigation by the Transportation Safety Board of Canada (TSB) into the crash is ongoing. It was just after 2 p.m. when Flight 4819, piloted by the first officer, began its touch down into Toronto. According to a preliminary report by the TSB, the plane was approaching the tarmac at nearly double the speed of a 'hard landing' and positioned at a 'flat angle.' Given the plane's tilt, its landing gear made contact with the tarmac first, causing it to collapse. While the TSB has not determined the sequence of events that followed, it noted in its report that 'the wing detached from the fuselage, releasing a cloud of jet fuel, which caught fire.' The jet began to slide down the runway, before coming to rest upside down. In the claim, lawyers for Miles say she lost consciousness while hanging upside down from her seat, held in place by only a seatbelt. When she awoke, she 'found herself soaked in jet fuel' and the cabin filled with smoke, it reads. Miles fell from her seat after unbuckling her seatbelt and, when the emergency slide failed to deploy, fell another six feet while exiting the aircraft, the claim continues. Despite her injuries, Miles 'sprang into action' to assist the crew and other passengers during the crisis, according the U.S. Association of Flight Attendants. She was among a handful of flight attendants honoured by the association in April for their 'heroism beyond the call of duty' in the minutes following the crash. Shortly after passengers and the crew evacuated, the aircraft burst into flames. The cause of the explosion has not been determined. Miles was treated at Humber River Hospital and, according to the lawsuit, suffered multiple injuries, including a broken left shoulder, a traumatic brain injury, and post-traumatic stress disorder. In the six months since the crash, Miles says she's continued to suffer from severe pain, mental anguish, and a loss of earnings, accruing medical expenses along the way. In the claim, lawyers for Miles, citing the TSB report, allege both the captain and first officer of the plane were negligent in failing to maintain a safe rate of descent during the landing approach and positioning at touchdown. It also alleges, amongst other things, that the pair failed to respond to the aircraft's automatic warning indicating that its descent rate was excessive. 'This accident was caused, at least in part, by (Delta Air Lines) knowingly assigning an inexperienced and inadequately trained pilot to operate the flight,' it reads. '(The) defendants cut corners on safety by rushing pilots through training programs and knowingly putting passengers at risk with inexperienced flight crew.' Delta declined to respond to the Star's questions about the experience levels of the pilot and crew aboard Flight 4819. In a statement released days after the crash, however, the union representing the pilots refuted claims they lacked necessary training. According to the union, the captain of the flight had been working for Endeavor Air since 2007, accumulating about 3,570 hours of total flight time by the time of the crash. The first officer had worked for Endeavor since January 2024 and had flown about 1,422 hours. 'Both crew members are qualified and FAA certified for their positions,' the union said. The lawsuit goes on to suggest Delta's safety failures 'extended beyond inadequate pilot training.' According to the claim, Delta failed to ensure its landing gear and emergency evacuation equipment were properly functioning, resulting in the evacuation slide later failing to deploy. It also alleges the airline did not make any announcements or provide guidance to passengers during the evacuation, and was slow to provide medical assistance in the direct aftermath. 'The above actions and omissions constitute gross negligence and show a willful disregard of precautions or measures to attend to safety and disregard for substantial risks,' it reads. Miles' claim isn't the first to be launched by passengers aboard Flight 4819 when it crashed. In the month after the crash, eight separate lawsuits were filed by passengers claiming the airline violated industry standards and that the crew was inadequately trained. Those claims have also not been tested in court. With files from Mark Colley and Kevin Jiang
