Structural concerns loom despite macro strength: Jigar Mistry
ADVERTISEMENT The markets are also looking good because, of late, we are just building on to that gains, believe that the worry around the Trump tariff tantrums as well as the slowdown everything is just abating away. Give us some sense what are you pencilling in for the markets and the bigger question is, is this up move sustainable? Share your thoughts.
Jigar Mistry: It is a dichotomous situation if I am being honest because see, clearly India is a macro darling in an otherwise turbulent world. But frankly earnings recovery is very elusive even as we speak. So, if I pencil in what we are looking at from a macro standpoint, then very clearly the CPI inflation is benign in India. We are around 4-4.5%, that looks fairly okay. Secondly, with the crude prices coming off and rupee appreciating, you are arguably looking at a trillion INR in saving from the entire economic standpoint that would obviously get dispersed differently. And thirdly, even the CAD, BOP is fairly stable and that gives you an impression that in an otherwise volatile world, turbulent world, India stands out. However, that is not translating fully into how the earnings are panning out.
So, if I look at Nifty 4Q earnings, they are up like 7-7.5% YoY, but it was almost entirely driven by banks and lending institutions, across the board, especially in the mid and smallcap the earning recovery is absolutely elusive which is a cause of concern for many of them.
Secondly, if you look at the retail behaviour, that is also very confounding because on one hand there is more money coming into SIPs, but on the another if you look at the SIP cancellation number, that is at a fairly high number. And when you look at the Demat account and do the analysis thereof, you find that there has been a direct selling that is going on in the retail accounts and the discontinuation in SIPs are the ones that opened in 2021, 2022. It eventually all boils down to flows and not as much fundamentals. If you look at the rupee appreciation, then that means that FII money has returned back to India since about a month or so.
ADVERTISEMENT Domestic liquidity continues to be high and sadly, a lot of that money is again going into sort of all the narrative stocks which is a little bit surprising. So, net-net I would say flows are strong, earnings have to catch up if we want to sustain at the levels that we are at.
ADVERTISEMENT
While you did speak about the global factors at play and also earnings, but I want to get your broader view on earnings, like about the ongoing Q4 earning season. Are there any early signs of upgrades or downgrades given how the earnings have been so far, any particular sectors that you would like to discuss and help us understand that could see upgrades going forward?
Jigar Mistry: So, this all sort of began from April to June quarter last year. Now, obviously with the onset of general elections and given the large scale of that exercise, you started seeing a generic slowdown starting from that point and we have almost completed the year with a single-digit growth on the headline indices. Now the belief system if you look at it like one view of thought is that India pretty much like we saw during COVID, in COVID we did clearly really report a FY20 drop and then in FY21 sort of relay back, very similarly one view of thought is that you should see the current situation in a similar light which is that we do not really see the slowdown in F25 and then do not really talk about the run-up in F26 and we rather look at F24 to F26 and then gauge on which sectors are doing well versus others.
ADVERTISEMENT With that standpoint, optically speaking F26 should start seeing some bit of recovery starting next quarter itself because April, May, June last year was a wash out quarter, that is one view of thought. The other view of thought is that we have actually entered a structural issue which we need to understand.
Unless you start seeing recovery in a lot sectors, it is difficult to believe on where the recovery would come from, that is point one point. Point two, there is some shift even from the policy level in India, so India did phenomenally well to curtail the fiscal deficit from 4.9% to 4.4%, but that has come as by pushing the capex out states, we analysed the past 16 states that went into elections and we have noted that their capex has slowed down to 4.5% negative. Now, centre and state capex and PSU was driving majority of the growth and that might be a little more challenging now.
(You can now subscribe to our ETMarkets WhatsApp channel)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News18
20 minutes ago
- News18
Chinas economy lags in July under pressure from tariffs, weak property market
Bangkok, Aug 15 (AP) China's economy showed signs of slowing in July as factory output and retail sales slowed and housing prices dropped further, according to data released Friday. Uncertainty over tariffs on exports to the United States is still looming over the world's second-largest economy after President Donald Trump extended a pause in sharp hikes in import duties for 90 days, beginning Monday, following a 90-day pause that began in May. As officials worked toward a broader trade agreement, China reported earlier that its exports surged 7.2% in July year-on-year, while its imports grew at the fastest pace in a year, as businesses rushed to take advantage of the truce in Trump's trade war with Beijing. But that also reflected a lower base for comparison, and manufacturers have slowed investments, hiring and production as they watch to see what comes. Chinese manufacturers also have ramped up shipments to Southeast Asia, Africa and other regions to help offset lost business in the US. Still, annual growth in industrial output fell to 5.7% in July from 6.8% in June, the National Bureau of Statistics said. Investments in factory equipment and other fixed assets rose a meager 1.6% in January-July, compared with 2.8% growth in the first half of the year. Property investments plunged 12% in the first seven months of the year, with residential housing investment dropping nearly 11%. The meltdown in the housing market hit just as the COVID-19 pandemic began, sapping one of the economy's main drivers of growth and causing dozens of developers to default on their debts. The crisis rippled throughout the economy, destroying jobs for millions of people. The government has sought to ensure that most housing that was paid for gets built, but sales remain weak despite a series of moves meant to entice families into back into the market. Since most Chinese families have their wealth tied up in property, the anemic housing market has been a major factor crimping consumer spending. In July, retail sales rose 3.7%, the slowest rate in seven months and down from a 4.8% increase in June. The unemployment rate rose to 5.2% from 5% as university graduates began looking for work. While consumer prices rose 0.4% in July from the month before, prices at the wholesale level slipped 3.6% from a year earlier in another indicator of relatively weak demand. (AP) SCY SCY view comments First Published: August 15, 2025, 11:15 IST Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
News18
35 minutes ago
- News18
Secret Service Flies In Troops, Vehicles For Trump-Putin Summit In Alaska: Report
Anchorage's shortage of hotel rooms and rental cars has forced the agency to fly in SUVs from the lower 48 states, Bloomberg said. When Anchorage realtor Beau Disbrow answered the phone, he didn't expect the call to come from the US Secret Service. As reported by Bloomberg, his short-term rentals usually cater to glacier-bound tourists or business travellers, not presidential security teams. But with President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin set to meet in Alaska on Friday, the agency needed housing fast. 'Most of my short-term rentals were booked, but I did manage to put some of them into one home," Disbrow told Bloomberg. The request didn't stop there — soon after, the Russian consulate in New York called with the same query. With no vacancies left, Disbrow referred them to a friend with empty furnished homes. Bloomberg reports that the lone Secret Service agent permanently assigned to Alaska began mobilising hundreds of reinforcements the moment Trump announced the summit last week. The operation, according to four people familiar with the planning, turned into an all-out sprint — condensed into just seven days. Unlike overseas visits, the US location allows the Secret Service to move weapons, communications gear, and medical equipment without foreign restrictions. Still, Alaska's remote geography and limited infrastructure have created logistical hurdles. Anchorage's shortage of hotel rooms and rental cars has forced the agency to fly in SUVs from the lower 48 states, Bloomberg said. The meeting will take place at Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson, Alaska's largest military installation, a Cold War–era listening post located less than 1,000 miles from Russia. The base's controlled airspace, fortified gates, and instant military support make it an ideal — and secure — venue. Alaska Governor Mike Dunleavy told Bloomberg Television that holding the summit on the base eases pressure on the city during peak tourist season. Still, the scale of the operation is immense. Protocol rules require a perfectly mirrored security setup for both leaders — from the number of armed guards to the placement of translators. Neither side will ride in the other's vehicles or open the other's doors, Bloomberg noted. Even the size of secure 'hold rooms" for each leader is under negotiation. With Russian approval for the final security plan still pending, downtown Anchorage is already transformed. Hotels are fully booked, rental car lots emptied for motorcades, and agents are stationed at intersections, coffee shops, and parking garages. Alaska state troopers and local police are integrated into routes mapped down to each turn. Trump has characterised the meeting as a step toward ending Russia's war in Ukraine, hinting that a territorial swap could be part of a deal. Putin, according to Bloomberg, has praised Trump's mediation efforts and floated economic cooperation and a new arms control treaty as possible outcomes. view comments First Published: Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Economic Times
41 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Is anybody fighting back in this trade war?
Synopsis Donald Trump's trade policies, marked by tariffs unseen since the Great Depression, have reshaped global commerce, prompting concerns about economic consequences. While some predicted dire outcomes, the global economy has slowed but not crashed, with limited retaliation from other countries except China. Getty Images India, which has been the subject of some bullish projections as China's economy has slowed, is one of the few economies of significance that hasn't cut a deal with Trump. William Clayton, a businessman who served successive US presidents and became one of the chief architects of the Marshall Plan, was no fan of tariffs. He rated the barriers erected during the Great Depression as one of the great crimes of the century. It's hard to imagine that Clayton, who believed that free trade was as important to prosperity as American aid and security guarantees, would remotely approve of Donald Trump's efforts to reshape White House-engineered upheaval, which pushed tariffs to levels unseen since the Smoot-Hawley law of 1930, will be costly — even if the full price isn't immediately apparent. The global economy hasn't suffered some of the direst consequences that were predicted in April. Demand for US assets has held up, despite the superficial allure of the 'sell America' narrative. The International Monetary Fund doubts growth will suddenly crater, and inflation hasn't taken off. Has a bullet been dodged or is shock delaying the pain? It's notable that countries aren't exactly lining up to fire back. With the exception of China, which has escalated and retreated to match the White House rhythms, there's been little by way of reprisals. 'It's not a war when only one side fights,' JPMorgan Chase & Co. economists said in a recent note. 'The primary drag from the trade war will come from US tariff hikes, but we also looked for broad retaliation by US trading partners.' The counterattack 'has not materialized; in fact, barriers to US exports have been lowered,' they no means does the firm anticipate zero harm. Business confidence is down but not collapsing. Capital spending will be constrained. And while chances of recession are still high, a better outcome remains very sort of guarded optimism — or qualified pessimism — is a break from the dark warnings. Christine Lagarde, head of the European Central Bank, told leaders to prepare for a worst-case scenario in which an antagonistic US drags the world into destructive economic conflict. The prime minister of Singapore, a city-state that thrived during the heyday of free trade, couldn't hide his dismay: Tariffs aren't the actions of friends, Lawrence Wong noted. His Canadian counterpart, Mark Carney, declared that relations with the US would be changed forever. Chinese President Xi Jinping has studiously matched American moves but also toned down his rhetoric and actions when appropriate. Washington and Beijing this week extended a pause on higher tariffs for 90 days, the latest in a series of suspensions. India, which has been the subject of some bullish projections as China's economy has slowed, is one of the few economies of significance that hasn't cut a deal with Trump. But Prime Minister Narendra Modi also hasn't gone measure for measure or shown a desire to get even with American businesses. Yes, there has been indignity and hurt feelings. The governor of the Reserve Bank of India dismissed Trump's claim that commerce was dead there. He touted India's contribution to global growth — about 18% compared to around 11% for the US — and insisted the local economy was doing well. This is in the ballpark, based on IMF projections. It also misses the point that in pure size, America dwarfs India. Brazil, a comer that struggles to make good on its potential, is also refusing to bend. President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva loathes dependence on the US and wants to be treated as an equal. But Trump doesn't like a court case against Lula's predecessor for allegedly plotting a coup. Brazil is trying to develop an alternative to the dollar and places great store in commercial ties to the BRICS group of emerging economies. Many of those nations, and aspiring members of the bloc, have cut deals with Trump, or are likely to do so. Brazil will come to some has Trump got away with it? His aides reckoned that access to the American market is too lucrative to pass up, and they may have been right. It would also be naive to conclude there won't be any cost. The global economy has slowed but hasn't crashed, foreigners still purchase US Treasuries and it's a safe bet that the greenback will be at the center of the financial system for the nations humiliated won't forget this experience. Asia's economies will only get bigger and the siren call of greater integration with China will get louder. Trump's efforts to destroy the existing order may yet prove an own goal. Just not this who became the top economic official at the State Department, believed that robust trade among the shattered nations of Western Europe was as important as physical rebuilding. The economic dislocation wrought by the conflagration had been underestimated; capitalism could revive the continent and prevent the political implosion of key countries. According to Benn Steil's book The Marshall Plan: Dawn of the Cold War, Clayton insisted that the US 'must run this show.'Trump's team brag about reconfiguring the system that grew from the ideals of the postwar era. The hubris may ultimately prove misplaced.
