Couple lose legal challenge of winter fuel payment cuts
Pensioners Peter and Flo Fanning, from Coatbridge in North Lanarkshire, took their case to the Court of Session in Edinburgh in March, alleging that both governments failed to adequately consult with those of pension age and did not release an equality impact assessment on the changes.
The Court of Session ruled to refuse the petition on Friday.
The couple's lawyers have said they have no doubt the Fanning's litigation had been influential in securing U-turns by both governments.
Couple's bid to sue governments over winter fuel payment
A big difference or missing out again? Reactions to winter fuel payment U-turn
Better-off pensioners able to opt-out of Scottish fuel payment
A spokesperson from the Govan Law Centre told BBC Scotland News: "While our clients have lost their case at first instance, we have no doubt that this litigation has been influential in securing the partial U-turn made by the Scottish government last November and the major policy U-turn confirmed by the UK government earlier this week.
"We hope that the Scottish government will now follow suit and restore the winter fuel payment in full for people such as our clients."
Earlier this week, the UK government abandoned plans to withdraw the payments from all but the poorest pensioners after the scheme drew widespread criticism.
The Scottish government had already launched its own winter fuel benefit in response to the original cuts which included extra support for those less well-off, but also a universal payment which is unaffected by income.
The Govan Law Centre added the legal challenge "was always one of process" and the fact the UK government has already reconsidered the cuts "vindicates" their clients.
It said that an appeal would have "reasonable prospects of success" but added it is unlikely that legal aid would be provided for this.
About 10 million pensioners in England and Wales lost their allowance under new measures announced by chancellor Rachel Reeves in July last year.
Those on pension credit or certain other means-tested benefits retained the annual payments, worth between £100 and £300.
In Scotland, the payment was devolved to Holyrood in April 2024, but the Scottish government followed the actions of their counterparts in Westminster in terminating it in August 2024, arguing £160m had been taken from its budget.
A new alternative, called the Pension Age Winter Heating Payment (PAWHP), was due to be introduced the following month, but that has since been pushed back to winter 2025.
It will also be means-tested, despite ministers claiming it would not be.
Social Justice Secretary Shirley-Anne Somerville recently said the universal approach of the devolved Scottish scheme was important - but that wealthier pensioners would be made aware that they could opt out.
The current plan is for all pensioner households to receive at least £100 regardless of income, while those on pension credit will receive up to £305 depending on age.
Meanwhile, the devolved government in Northern Ireland also followed suit, but affected pensioners were given a one-off £100 payment from Stormont in November.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
8 hours ago
- New York Post
Gavin Newsom and Zohran Mamdani can bring about the ruin of California and New York
It was in December 1777 that the great Scottish economist Adam Smith learned of General Burgoyne's defeat at Saratoga. Smith's correspondent said that he feared Smith's own nation of Great Britain, was ruined. The economist's reply was: 'There is a great deal of ruin in a nation.' Ever since that quote became famous, it has been both consoling and misleading. Consoling because it is true that while some people always claim the sky is falling down, more often than not, it stays up perfectly nicely. Adam Smith's own nation more than survived the defeat at Saratoga. Advertisement At the same time, the quote is misleading. Nations cannot cope with an infinite amount of ruin. Cities and states can tolerate even less. In our own country, there are many politicians who think that US cities in particular can put up with almost anything. Take Governor Gavin Newsom of California. In recent days, he has been trying to 'win' the internet. That's because, having failed at his job of governing an actual state, he seems to have decided to become chief troll online. Democrat pundits are 'LOLing' all over the place at Newsom's alleged brilliance in aping the internet manners of President Trump. Advertisement It would be a lot more fun if the situation in Gavin's own state were sunnier. As it is, while Newsom plays cute online, California is in a disastrous state. Just this year, it has suffered ruinous wildfires, causing billions of dollars worth of damage. And even if the areas of Los Angeles that burned to the ground are rebuilt, good luck to anyone trying to get home insurance. Then there are the riots — stoked along by Democrat politicians, who seem to think that it is the natural-born right of every illegal alien to riot against ICE and other law-enforcement officers and wave the flags of Mexico and other countries to demonstrate just how many rights they think they should get in America. Advertisement All this comes as the state of California still struggles to recover from the disastrous COVID-19 lockdown policies that Newsom tried to install in his state. For everyone but himself, naturally. Perhaps Newsom and the sycophants in his party think that some winsome online behavior will bring back the 2.1 million registered Democrats who seem to have been lost by the party in the years between 2020 and 2024. But the reality is that Newsom's policies — from taxation to homelessness and law and order — have seen a great exodus of the people the state needs most. In recent years, California has lost even more wealthy millennials than New York has. Some 10,000 millennial households bringing in more than $200,000 a year fled California in a single year. A figure almost twice the size of the exodus from New York of the same demographic in the same year. Of course, in part, that is because of the genius of the federal system in this country that makes moving between states so relatively easy. Advertisement A British person afflicted by high taxes and high crime cannot just up sticks and move to a different jurisdiction in their country. It's all going to be the same. Get opinions and commentary from our columnists Subscribe to our daily Post Opinion newsletter! Thanks for signing up! Enter your email address Please provide a valid email address. By clicking above you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Never miss a story. Check out more newsletters But if California or New York decides to tax the successful beyond their endurance and fails to give them a decent quality of life in return, then Florida or Texas will never look so appealing. That is a fact that Democrats in New York, as much as in California, should keep at the top of their minds. Even as New York is considering the possibility of electing a high-taxing, radical socialist mayor, there are people who say that it is an empty threat that people will actually leave this city. These are the same people who seemed to think that the Golden State would be endlessly attractive, even if there were syringes all over the sidewalks and the place was on fire. The same people seem to think that you can test and test New York as much as you like, and it doesn't matter because people will still want to live here. Tell that to the people who had to live through the city's downturn in the 1970s. In fact, tell that to the citizens of the numerous cities in this country that have managed to fall through the floor. Advertisement There was a time when Detroit seemed like the city of the future. There was a time when St. Louis seemed like a good bet. But these places should be reminders that what seems enduring can in fact be stress-tested to death in front of your eyes. I mentioned the country of Adam Smith, and it is still worth looking to it for a lesson in what could happen here. The left-wing Labour government in the UK came into power last year, promising to tax the rich to fill its fiscal deficits. Of course, it hasn't worked. But the threat has certainly chased money out of the country. The UK is expected to lose some 16,500 millionaires this year alone. An uptick of over 50% just in the year before. All driven away by the brilliant tax policies of a government that doesn't even say it is socialist. Advertisement What Zohran Mamdani and Co. would do to this city is orders of magnitude worse than anything Labour has achieved in the UK. But there is another lesson still to learn. Which is that, having chased the wealthy out of the UK, the Labour government is now suddenly hoping to woo them back. They are learning in real time the old conservative lesson that it is much easier to destroy than it is to build. Easier to chase people away than to give them the long-term confidence that would be needed to encourage them back. Which returns me to Adam Smith. There may be a great deal of ruin in a nation. But there isn't an endless amount of ruin in a state. Much less of a city. Come November, New Yorkers should remember that.
Yahoo
12 hours ago
- Yahoo
Police Scotland forked out £500,000 in compensation last month as officers missed time off during Trump visit
Police Scotland paid officers £500,000 in compensation for not being able to get time off last month. With US President Donald Trump visiting Scotland in July, and his Vice President JD Vance also holidaying in the country in August, Deputy Chief Constable Jane Connors said it has been a "very busy summer for policing in Scotland". She said Police , together with others, including police forces across the UK, had "ensured safety and security across a range of events", most notably Mr Trump and Mr Vance's visits. DCC Connors claimed that at the same time as such events, "day-to-day policing continued for our communities". She told a Scottish Police Authority (SPA) meeting in Glasgow on Thursday: "It does put pressure on our resources and our staff who we know are very tired after a long summer." Deputy Chief Constable Alan Speirs said that in July alone the force spent £500,000 to "buy back" time off in lieu (toil) from officers who had been unable to take this time due to the demands on the police. Police Scotland mounted a major operation when Mr Trump spent several days in Scotland in July, in which he held talks with both UK Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer and Scottish First Minister John Swinney as he visited his golf resorts in South Ayrshire and Aberdeenshire. Less than a month later, officers were needed to help with security arrangements when Mr Vance and his family flew in as part of their holiday. Read more: DCC Speirs explained police can either receive overtime payments, or if given toil have three months to take this before the force buys the time back from them. He said: "Regrettably, the spend for us in the month of July alone was £0.5m because officers weren't able to get the time back, which to me demonstrates there is a real demand on the service and it is largely through events. "The trend around toil is quite significant, so we will continue to look at that on a monthly basis. It is a growing challenge for us, to manage that element of the budget. "We don't want officers at work when they should be off, so it is regrettable that we're in that position of having to compensate them through payment for things like toil." His comments came as DCC Connors told the SPA board about the pressures on the force, saying police are dealing with an "increase in the volume of challenging protests and counter-protests". In addition, she said there are now more football matches that require to be policed. She said: "Games that would be police-free, we are now having to police."
Yahoo
13 hours ago
- Yahoo
Popular airline announces six new destinations from major Scottish airport
JET2 have announced six new destinations from Glasgow Airport in a bid to give Scottish holidaymakers more choice for a winter getaway. As part of its winter 2026/2027 city break programme, the popular airliner has unveiled six new destinations across Europe. The destinations, which went on sale on Wednesday for the winter months of 2026 and 2027, include Berlin, Budapest, Krakow, Prague, Rome, and Vienna. Jet2 said it will offer twice-weekly services to Rome, Krakow, and Prague and will also operate a mini-series of dedicated Christmas market trips to Berlin, Budapest, and Vienna. READ MORE: 'Widespread' use of AI generated reviews at Fringe Festival, performers claim Two weekly services will operate to Berlin, Budapest, and Vienna during the winter period, giving Jet2 customers the chance to visit some of the most 'dazzling Christmas markets' Europe has to offer. Chris Tibbett, aero director at AGS Airports, who owns Glasgow Airport, welcomed the six new routes as he said they will give Scottish holidaymakers more choice over winter. He said: 'This announcement marks another exciting milestone in our long-standing partnership with and Jet2CityBreaks. 'The addition of six fantastic city break destinations, including dedicated Christmas market trips, gives Scottish travellers even more choice and flexibility when planning their winter getaways. 'We're proud to support this expansion and look forward to welcoming thousands of passengers through Glasgow Airport as they set off to explore some of Europe's most iconic cities next winter.' (Image: Archives) Steve Heapy, CEO of and Jet2holidays, said the new routes have been announced due to the growing demand for Christmas getaways. He said: 'We are delighted to be putting our Winter 2026/2027 city break programme on sale from Glasgow Airport with a fantastic choice of flights to popular winter destinations. 'Whether it is a magical city break or winter wonderland escape, we are offering something for everyone, and customers need look no further when it comes to getting away next winter. 'With local holidaymakers continuing to look to get away on their well-deserved holidays, particularly during the long Scottish winter, we are stepping in to meet that demand by providing lots of choice and flexibility to some of the most popular city and Christmas market destinations.'
