Long road ahead to create a professional SAPS
Image: Siyabulela Duda/GCIS
Prof. Bheki Mngomezulu
On Wednesday 14 May 2025, the Cabinet approved the Draft National Policing Plan (NPP).
This policy aims to create professional and quality policing, provide efficient and effective policing service delivery, improve legitimacy and trust between communities and the police, and build a strong and ethical leadership, management and governance infrastructure architecture within the SAPS. Certainly, the policy is hailed by some but will be questioned by others – especially those who have seen other good policies failing to produce the intended results due to a plethora of reasons.
Addressing the media soon after the approval of this Plan, the Minister in the Presidency, Khumbudzo Ntshavheni stated that the newly approved Plan outlines the government's plans to address shortcomings in the mandate of the South African Police Service (SAPS) to combat crime as a response to previous failures.
The motivating factor behind the drafting and subsequent adoption of the NPP is to address issues such as the small number of police stations across the country which makes it difficult for the SAPS to serve the South African public. The second factor is the capacity issue. It was felt that the SAPS needed serious capacitation if it were to execute its mandate well.
The third and most important issue which necessitated the drafting of the NPP was crime. Both national and provincial police officials constantly present shocking crime statistics. The impact of crime cuts across various spheres of life. These include but are not limited to the tourism sector, investment and economic growth, and South Africa's public and global image.
Presenting its 2023/2024 study report, the UN Office for Drugs and Crime placed South Africa's murder rate at 45 per 100,000. This saw South Africa being ranked the second highest globally when compared to other countries that make their crime statistics available for the public to see. While it is true that these figures fluctuate from one reporting period to another, they are a cause for concern.
Given these issues, it was justifiable to craft and adopt this Draft NPP as the first step towards addressing the challenges enumerated above. There is still a long way to go in dealing with these issues even after the final NPP has been adopted by both the Cabinet and later by parliament.
There are specific issues which have the potential to derail any plans to improve the operation of SAPS. One of them is corruption among law enforcement agencies – including SAPS members and the entire justice system. If officials at different levels within the justice system continue to take bribes from criminal suspects, no initiative – not even the NPP – can change the current situation facing the SAPS and the entire justice system.
Another important factor could be the austerity measures imposed by national government. In each budget speech, the nation is constantly asked to brace itself for the turbulent. The same applies to different government departments – including the SAPS.
Therefore, passing the NPP without an accompanying budget would be a futile exercise. Any plan to increase the number of police stations would be scuttled if there is insufficient or no budget made available to achieve that goal. Even maintaining some of the already existing police stations is currently a challenge.
Even if the number of police stations were to be increased, they would still need well-trained and capacitated police officers. Without sufficient funds, this would be difficult to achieve at best or impossible.
With regards to crime, which was identified as the third important driving factor for the drafting of the NPP, the situation gets even worse. There are various reasons for that.
The first reason is that the same police officers who are supposed to root out crime are also directly involved in the same practice. Every year, no less than 5,500 cases of police criminal offences are reported. This makes a mockery of the entire process of crafting the NPP.
According to the Independent Police Investigative Directorate (IPID), of the 5,500 cases, more than 3,500 of them are for police torture and assault. This points to another problem – lack of proper training. In a worst-case scenario, this could be a deliberate decision by some police officers to disobey the law they already know. In that case, even proper training would not solve the problem.
Building trust between the police and communities is not something that can be achieved overnight. There is a trust deficit between the two parties. Reports of women who are raped at police stations after going there to open cases do not give hope. The cases of witnesses and whistleblowers who are killed by the perpetrators after the police have leaked information about their identities dampen the spirit and discourage others from coming forward with information.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The South African
4 minutes ago
- The South African
Muizenberg mass murders: At least seven killed within three days
Police have launched an investigation following the gruesome discovery of three bodies following a mass shooting in Muizenberg, Western Cape. The bodies of one male and two females, aged between 29 and 32 were discovered at Mike Place, Xakabantu in Muizenberg on Saturday at around 23:30. South African Police Service (SAPS) spokesperson in the Western Cape Colonel Andrè Traut said a fourth victim, a male, survived after sustaining a gunshot wound and managed to escape. Traut said the suspects fled the scene and are yet to be arrested and the motive for the attack remains unclear, and detectives are pursuing all available leads to establish the circumstances surrounding the incident. 'In the meantime, policing in the area has been intensified to prevent any further violence. 'The SAPS appeals to anyone with information that could assist the investigation to contact Crime Stop on 08600 10111, or to submit information anonymously via the MySAPS mobile application,' he said. The mass murder happened just days after a similar incident was reported in Overcome Heights also in Muizenberg. Police confirmed that four men were shot dead in the early hours of Wednesday morning, 13 August, in Overcome Heights. The bodies of the victims – aged between 20 and 37 – were discovered at approximately 05:30 on Mountain Road, each having sustained fatal gunshot wounds. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1. Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X, and Bluesky for the latest news.
The Citizen
34 minutes ago
- The Citizen
Hlabisa is a lesson on getting things done behind chaos
While the GNU continues to be chaotic, Cogta Minister Velenkosini Hlabisa has kept calm and done the unthinkable. The GNU presents a laugh a day. In the last month, Andrew Whitfield got axed, setting an awkward precedent for President Cyril Ramaphosa's defence chief. While bus drivers are taking their own lives, having not been paid since January, a dialogue is on the go that increasingly seems to be evolving into a monologue. Gayton McKenzie has been doing his thing, whatever that might be on the day, and team DA is patting themselves on the back for outsourcing state work to the banks. And we all applauded it, such is our disdain of home affairs. Oh, and the ministers appointed to fix load shedding were busted doing what we already knew they were doing; burning diesel as ferociously as Christians burned Beatles albums. Amid all the chaos and lack of time to consider which connected cadre should feast on which deal, some real good has been done; Transnet even seems to be on the rise, Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi's revelations are promising to unlock some gems and South Africa's economic kingpin, Thabo Mbeki, has finally found some guts to start saying some things. Amid the chaos, some things are improving The weather is perfect for sowing the seeds of ideas that may be great for the country and good for the fiscus, even if they aren't politically popular. In a country where a small minority are being squeezed for funding, it's difficult to make financially prudent decisions. But since that money isn't getting to the people it's supposed to, it makes it somewhat easier. Add to that the warring internal factions and it shouldn't be surprising that as the castle of patronage comes down, a couple of things can be improved with the resources. A minister who seemingly gets this and has largely kept a calm demeanor throughout the GNU is Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs (Cogta) Velenkosini Hlabisa. During lockdown, we learned just how much power Cogta has and Hlabisa has been wielding it pretty impressively. ALSO READ: IFP reaffirms GNU role, slams NPA and urges reforms within justice system Halbisa takes on municipal functionality On natural disaster management, he's done the unthinkable in South African terms; enhancing the implementation of a 10-year-old framework. It shouldn't be impressive, but since we tend to have a kink of jumping from one policy to the next, doubling down and anchoring a belief in a policy's execution is quite a brave and functional thing. When last have you heard a minister insistent on implementing the plan of a predecessor and making it work? Hlabisa genuinely seems to want to do what's good for the people and when it comes to preventing them from dying, that's quite nice. I'm not sure if it's because nobody knows how to get in his way or whether it's just not profitable to impose themselves on him, the minister has been given some room to manoeuvre and it appears he knows this. It shouldn't be surprising that he's taken on what is probably going to be the most difficult reform of this administration; municipal functionality. Ten years ago, you wouldn't dream of anybody in Jacob Zuma's cabinet thinking of claiming that the national government is bloated, let alone municipalities. ALSO READ: Cogta warns municipalities against wasting R1.2 billion disaster relief Now, the minister is having a right go at the state of municipal affairs and fairly so. It's not like John Steenhuisen is going to criticise anybody's literacy because it will come off poorly, but the way Hlabisa puts it makes it pragmatic in the eyes of the public. 'You can't monitor billions if you can't read,' he said. Why on earth we're even in a position where he's got to say that is beyond me, but thank goodness somebody has finally said it. What's most exciting about this shake up is that it's clearly a long term investment and he's set milestones allowing him to take his time on the matter. It shows a degree of seriousness rather than politricking and perhaps we don't see the results in his lifetime. It feels so good to hear a minister commit themselves to a long term solution to an issue that nobody has really tried to address in 30 years. There's a saying about great men planting trees and I really hope this one grows. We could do with the shade. READ NEXT: Almost 40 municipalities facing sanctions from Treasury over mismanagement
IOL News
2 hours ago
- IOL News
SA Falls Prey to US Playbook on Human Rights, Regime Change
A worker checks the first copy of "The Star", the biggest and most respected South African daily, hot from the printing press on May 02, 1994 in Johannesburg, South Africa, as it headlines Nelson Mandela as next president of the country following the ANC victory in the first all-race elections. Thirty years of governance have taken their toll on the ANC. This vulnerability created the ideal conditions for a regime change strategy to advance, says the writer. Image: AFP Dr. Reneva Fourie The pattern is well-worn. Regardless of the issue or the president in power, if a country refuses to toe the Washington line, accusations of human rights abuses become the weapon of choice. Cuba and Venezuela were targeted primarily because of their economic policies, which diverged from the model preferred by Washington. Iran and China were labelled for achieving successes that rivalled or surpassed Western capabilities. Now the target is South Africa. The offence is that the country dared to take Israel to the International Court of Justice and lay bare evidence of genocidal acts. When pressure failed to deter the government from this principled course, the United States released a plethora of destabilising interventions, the most recent being a report alleging that the human rights situation in South Africa had worsened significantly. In the past, millions accepted the official story told about countries placed on Washington's list of offenders. They defended sanctions that crippled economies and harmed civilians. Those who challenged the propaganda were branded as conspiracy theorists or apologists for despots. South Africans are now watching this process unfold in real time. Narratives are created and disseminated through a system of media, think tanks, and lobbying networks, until repetition renders them true. This is not a new phenomenon. Noam Chomsky and Edward Herman's Manufacturing Consent detailed how media and political elites shape public perception to align with imperial interests. The same playbook is being used against South Africa. The US government, alongside its allies in the corporate media and right-wing NGOs, is constructing a narrative of a 'failing state' to justify intervention. Several sources, including Dale McKinley's The ANC and the Liberation Struggle: A Critical Political Biography, indicate that the seeds of regime-change had been planted well before the democratic transition. Knowing that the fall of apartheid was imminent, and that the vast socio-economic disparities due to apartheid policies would compel some form of social protection, deliberate efforts were made to secure capital control of the economy and progressively erode the highly popular power of South Africa's liberation movement. Thirty years of governance have taken their toll on the ANC. Internal disputes, corruption scandals, and declining service delivery have eroded public trust. This vulnerability created the ideal conditions for a regime change strategy to advance. In the run-up to the 2024 general election, large sums were poured into a coordinated effort to remove the ANC from power. One significant step was a meeting held in Gdańsk, Poland, in 2023. Out of this gathering came plans for a political coalition to challenge the ANC, then known as the Moonshot Pact. The return of the Trump administration to power in the United States gave impetus to the regime-change agenda. Backed strongly by the Zionist lobby, the administration re-established links with figures and groups rooted in the apartheid era. It embraced false claims promoted by AfriForum and Solidarity about state-sponsored genocide, land seizures, and restrictions on cultural rights. These are being weaponised to discredit progressive forces inside the South African government. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad Loading The United States' 2024 Country Reports on Human Rights Practices in South Africa presents itself as objective but is a work of distortion. It accuses the government of complicity in extra-judicial killings, repression of free expression, and antisemitism. It claims the state had failed to take credible action against officials responsible for human rights abuses and included allegations of inflammatory racial rhetoric and violence against racial minorities. The Ministry of International Relations and Cooperation rejected the report outright. It described it as inaccurate and deeply flawed, and said it ignored the reality of South Africa's constitutional democracy. Despite this, Solidarity announced plans to travel to the United States in September. Its stated purpose is to propose ways for Washington and other foreign actors to improve human rights in South Africa. There is no moral or political justification for such an appeal. The United States is a country that fails to address its own deep racial and economic inequalities and that has fuelled human rights abuses globally through war, sanctions, and covert operations. South Africa already has the National Dialogue, which provides a platform for honest discussion and collective problem-solving. Solidarity's actions are treasonous. They seek to restore the racial hierarchy of the past and place South Africa under a form of minority rule that would guarantee elite privilege. What Solidarity and its allies may not realise is that they are not the architects of this agenda but the instruments of it. The real prize for Washington and its corporate backers is a government that will embrace neoliberal policies without question. That role fits the Democratic Alliance perfectly. The United States is becoming more open in its regime change tactics, confident that the same methods used in Latin America, the Middle East, and Eastern Europe can work in Southern Africa. It is aggressively forging ahead to undermine South Africa's ability to determine its policies, protect its resources, and shape its future free from foreign control. The answer is not to retreat into denial or partisanship. It is to recognise that the struggle for sovereignty is a shared one. External actors can exploit the divisions that exist within South African society unless they are addressed honestly and directly. That is why the National Dialogue process is critical. It provides a forum where competing visions can be debated without the interference of those whose only interest is to control outcomes for their gain. South Africa has faced powerful adversaries before. The defeat of apartheid was not a gift. It was the result of unity, sacrifice, and a refusal to accept the idea that the powerful always win. The same spirit is needed now. We need to be united on the principle that the people of South Africa, and no one else, must decide the country's future. If South Africans adhere to that principle, the current campaign of manipulation and pressure will fail, just as previous attempts to crush the people's will have failed. * Dr Reneva Fourie is a policy analyst specialising in governance, development, and security. ** The views expressed do not necessarily reflect the views of IOL, Independent Media or The African.
