'Controlling and coercive' father accused of raping and murdering his ex-fiancé at a luxury five-star hotel had been out dancing with his new girlfriend the night before, court hears
Samantha Mickleburgh, who had ended the relationship two months before, was found dead at Pennyhill Park Hotel in Bagshot, Surrey, in the early hours of April 14 last year.
The 54-year-old mother of two had arranged to stay in a twin room with James Cartwright because she 'didn't want him to feel lonely' on his 60th birthday, his trial heard.
Father of three Cartwright, 61, who prosecutors say was leading a double life, had been out dancing at a ceilidh with Ella Callard the night before allegedly killing his ex 'with his own bare hands', Guildford Crown Court was told.
In a call after the incident, he told her he did not know Ms Mickleburgh would be there, and woke up the next morning to find her dead, the court was told.
Cartwright, of no fixed address, is accused of raping and murdering Ms Mickleburgh between April 12 and April 14 last year.
He also denies one count of controlling and coercive behaviour between May 1 2022 and April 14 2024.
Giving evidence today, Ms Callard said Cartwright had initially been 'very attentive, quiet and reserved' after they met online in February 2024.
Cartwright told her he was being cautious about the relationship because he had been 'hurt before', the trial heard.
After a first date at a garden centre, the couple began spending more time together, with Ms Callard giving him the nickname 'Mr Genuine', the court heard.
As Cartwright's 60th birthday approached, he told her his daughters had been making arrangements, telling him to meet them at the hotel, the court was told.
The night before the trip, Cartwright had joined Ms Callard at a ceilidh dance at a nearby town, and told her later she was the 'loveliest woman in the room that evening', jurors were told.
He 'seemed in a happy mood' when he left for Surrey the following morning, the court heard.
In a call with Ms Callard in the days after the incident, he told her his ex-fiance had a nose bleed during the night but refused medical help, the court was told.
'He told me he woke up in the morning and she was dead', Ms Callard said.
Cartwright assured her nothing intimate had happened between him and Ms Mickleburgh, and said he was not expecting her to be there when he arrived.
'He said he expected the doors of the restaurant to open and his family would be there, but he realised the table was only set for two,' Ms Callard said.
Ms Mickleburgh's colleague and friend Martin Manning said she had been looking for love when she met Cartwright.
She told him her relationship with Cartwright had initially been 'fine', but said he could sometimes lose his temper, jurors heard.
'She caught him reading her emails and then he lost it big time,' Mr Manning told the court.
'He would shout at her and back her into a corner. It frightened her.
'I was concerned for her safety,' he added.
Mr Manning said he offered to let Ms Mickleburgh stay with him and his wife to get away from Cartwright if she felt scared.
He even set up a code phrase for her to say over the phone to let him know if she was in danger, the court heard.
'He was difficult to get rid of, she wanted him out,' Mr Manning continued.
'He told her 'I'm not a real man if I let you throw me out'. I did find that very disturbing.'
Prosecutor Louise Oakley told jurors previously that Cartwright called 999 at about 8.30am on April 14 claiming he had discovered the lifeless body of Ms Mickleburgh lying next to him in bed, jurors were told.
'That was a lie,' Ms Oakley said. 'He had most likely killed her in the early hours of the April 14 2024 with his own bare hands applying manual pressure around her neck, extinguishing her life.'
'There were only two people in this room - and she couldn't have and didn't strangle herself,' Ms Oakley said.
Following their breakup, Cartwright had continued to pursue Ms Mickleburgh, attending her address unexpectedly and uninvited, and 'bombarding her' with messages and calls, Ms Oakley said.
'He had started to lose control of his relationship with Samantha because of his own controlling and coercive ways,' she added.
The trial continues.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
25 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Dentist used lewd affair email to have chemical used to poison his wife fast-tracked delivered, murder trial hears
The Colorado dentist accused of fatally poisoning his wife tried to have potassium cyanide overnighted to him, telling the company selling it that he'd be using the lethal substance for a fictional presentation, jurors heard on Thursday. James Craig, 47, is charged with first-degree murder in connection with the March 2023 death of his wife, Angela, who'd repeatedly visited the hospital with mystery symptoms in the weeks before she died. Prosecutors say Craig used poisons - including cyanide, arsenic and a chemical found in eyedrops - to taint protein shakes he prepared for her, even administering a fatal dose in her hospital room. Cassie Rodriquez, a customer service representative for Midland Scientific, told jurors on Thursday how she first began dealing with Craig's order via email on March 9, 2023. He wrote to her from the same personal address he'd used for extramarital relationships – jimandwaffles@ – and such Gmail accounts usually raise a flag at her employer, Rodriquez testified. Craig filled out and returned a 'usage statement,' she said, 'saying he was using it for some type of seminar he was presenting.' The dentist had originally noted he wanted the order for 'pick up,' but that wasn't allowed for such chemicals, she said. She worked on 'trying to get the product to him as soon as possible … he wanted it overnighted.' Craig was so desperate to get his hands on the chemical that he attempted to call Rodriquez, though they were never connected and continued correspondence via email, she testified. He repeated his urgency and kept checking on delayed delivery, writing on March 11: 'Wow - it's 7.30 at night and I've been waiting at my office all day for the shipment. 'Looks like it didn't come. I wish they would've just told me they wouldn't be able to get it to me overnight,' Craig wrote to Rodriquez. He later followed that with: 'It's not your fault I was just feeling frustrated and needed somebody to vent to.' Craig listed his billing address for the order as the Aurora home he shared with Angela and their children – but listed his dental practice as the shipping address. Craig also marked the order 'personal.' Craig physically turned up at Midland Scientific's Aurora location, the warehouse supervisor testified on Thursday, asking about a storefront customers could use - but it closed during COVID. Witness Ashley Donohue testified that Craig turned up on the afternoon of March 13 in 'blue scrubs' in the parking lot - something he'd never seen happen during his five years of working there. Donohue alerted the company's HR department 11 days later after recognizing Craig on the news, he testified. Earlier on Thursday, jurors heard testimony from the lead detective in Craig's case - whom he allegedly tried to arrange a hit on from behind bars. Aurora Police Det. Bobbi Jo Olson told the court that she and other officers served a search warrant at 8.30am the day after first hearing allegations of Craig's cyanide purchase. Olson will be recalled to testify further later in the trial, the court heard. A forensics digital expert also testified on Thursday about the process used to extract data from the Craigs' devices. Upon cross examination on Thursday and since the beginning of the trial, defense lawyers questioned witnesses' credentials and repeatedly noted that receipts, texts and emails did not prove who, in fact, had used the cards and addresses. Correspondence may have come from Craig's number and jimandwaffles@ they argued, but witnesses couldn't verify he'd personally written it, they argued. Defense lawyers have tried to paint Angela as 'manipulative' and suicidal. They have explained away Craig's behavior from behind bars as 'not great.' After his arrest, Craig allegedly tried to arrange assassinations and get his daughter to plant evidence, in addition to offering free dental work in exchange for fabricating cover stories to clear him, prosecutors have argued. 'He just lost his wife because law enforcement looks at this case with blinders,' defense attorney Ashley Witham said during opening arguments. 'He's been arrested, which means he's also lost his children ... he's anxious and he does some not great things from jail.' Jurors also heard testimony this week from the office manager at Craig's dental practice - who told the court how she'd seen him mysteriously using an exam room computer in the dark late at night. After that, she said, he texted her that he'd be receiving a personal package at work, and she should put it on his desk and not open it. A front desk employee opened the package when it arrived a week later, however - the same day Craig emailed Rodriquez to say the cyanide was out for delivery, he'd noted by tracking it. Romero saw the invoice listing the package's contents as 'potassium cyanide' before she re-boxed it up and put the delivery on his desk as instructed. She googled potassium cyanide, however - and, after learning its symptoms, comparing them with Angela's mystery illness and noting two unusual statements Craig made to her that his wife might not 'make it through the night - alerted her bosses. The wife of Craig's dental partner, Michelle Redfearn - a longtime friend of Angela's with a PhD in nursing - testified on Wednesday how she and her husband confronted Craig about the cyanide. They did so on a phone call on March 15 as the Redfearns sat in their car outside the hospital after learning that Angela had been declared brain dead. First Craig claimed the package had contained a ring for his wife; when the Redfearns countered that they knew he was lying, he said Angela had asked him to buy the cyanide for her. He said she was suicidal and lacked the necessary credentials to purchase the chemical. When Ryan Redfearn pressed him as to why, still, Craig would agree to order the cyanide, he said it was like 'a game of chicken.'
The Independent
26 minutes ago
- The Independent
Ten more years of injustice: Figures lay bare scale of IPP scandal
It will take a decade to free 2,544 prisoners trapped on 'inhumane' indefinite jail terms, damning new figures suggest, as campaigners warn the government 'must go further and faster' to end the scandal. The number of Imprisonment for Public Protection (IPP) prisoners being released for the first time has hit an all-time low, according to the Ministry of Justice data, with just 172 freed for the first time last year. At current rates, the overall population is decreasing by less than 10 per cent a year – despite some prisoners having served up to 22 times longer than their original sentence. This excludes a further 233 people on IPP sentences who are being held in secure hospitals after their mental health has deteriorated in prison. The figures, released on Thursday in an annual report, lay bare the toxic legacy of the open-ended jail terms as pressure mounts on the government to take up fresh proposals to help those languishing without a release date. The jail term – described as 'psychological torture' by the UN – was outlawed in 2012, but not retrospectively, leaving those already jailed incarcerated indefinitely. Victims of the scandal, whose tragic cases have been highlighted by The Independent, include: Leroy Douglas, who has served almost 20 years for robbing a mobile phone; Thomas White, 42, who set himself alight in his cell and has served 13 years for stealing a phone; and Abdullahi Suleman, 41, who is still inside 19 years after he was jailed for a laptop robbery. At least 94 prisoners have taken their own lives in custody after losing hope of ever getting out. A further 37 self-inflicted deaths have taken place in the community under strict licence conditions which leave offenders in fear of being hauled back to prison indefinitely for minor breaches. Successive governments have refused justice committee recommendations to resentence IPP prisoners, claiming it will lead to dangerous prisoners being released without supervision. However an expert panel, convened by the Howard League for Penal Reform and former top judge Lord John Thomas, last month urged the government to end the injustice by giving prisoners a release date at their next review by the Parole Board within a two-year window. Other measures being considered by ministers include reducing numbers recalled to prison and providing a package of mental health support for IPP prisoners on release. The Howard League's director of campaigns, Andrew Neilson, said the data in the annual report 'underlines how much further and faster ministers will have to go to end a scandal that leaves thousands of people still in prison without an end date in sight'. "The government must provide hope for those still serving this unjust sentence, and the best way to do this would be to accept the carefully considered proposals put forward by the working group chaired by Lord Thomas,' he added. Campaigner Shirley Debono, who co-founded IPP Committee in Action, told The Independent: 'It's a travesty. This has been devastating for families. 'It's going to take a decade to clear the backlog of IPPs. In that time people are going to die and family members are going to die.' She claims the government's IPP Action Plan, designed to help support prisoners to progress towards release by the Parole Board, is only working to keep prisoners in jail for longer as her son Shaun Lloyd languishes in prison. Mr Lloyd, who was handed a two and a half year IPP sentence in 2005 after stealing a mobile phone, has served a total of 14 years after being recalled four times. He has been held for 17 months on his latest recall, despite facing no further police action, and told he must complete a five-month course before the Parole Board will consider him for release. The latest figures show prisoners serve a further 25 months on average before they are re-released, even if they are not convicted of a further offence. A spokesperson for The United Group for Reform of IPP (UNGRIPP) said the latest report shows the government's plan 'misses the mark in the urgency that is needed to put an end to this 20 year long injustice'. 'By sticking with this approach the government are committing themselves to a slow change scenario,' they added. 'UNGRIPP do not believe that this or any action plan can fix the IPP sentence, the only true way to fix it is through parliamentary policy and the politicians know this but are choosing to ignore it.' Last week former justice secretary Alex Chalk said the jail terms are 'overbearing' and 'unfair' as he urged his successor Shabana Mahmood to look carefully at the Howard League's proposals to end the historic wrong. Prisons minister James Timpson admitted there is more work to do to help IPP prisoners. "It is absolutely right that the IPP sentence was abolished,' he added. "As this report shows, we have significantly improved support for these offenders, with greater access to rehabilitation and mental health support. 'There is more work to do as we reduce the number of IPP offenders in custody, but will only do so in a way that protects the public.'
The Sun
27 minutes ago
- The Sun
Protesters clash with cops outside migrant hotel after asylum seeker appears in court over ‘sexually assaulting' girl
VIOLENT protesters were seen clashing with police outside a migrant hotel on Thursday evening. The tense demonstration outside The Bell Hotel in Epping, Essex, came after an asylum seeker appeared in court charged with sexually assaulting a 14-year-old girl. 9 9 9 Masked protesters could be seen attacking police vehicles outside the building - which has been operating as an asylum hotel for the past five years. Children in balaclavas were seen alongside men and women as they blocked the road to the hotel. The protest had reportedly started peacefully before a group of hardcore agitators stopped three Essex Police riot vans from driving past the hotel to support their colleagues. Shortly before 8pm, masked protesters launched their attack - repeatedly punching and kicking the police vehicles. One man could be overheard shouting "smash it, smash it" as officers sat trapped inside. A number of thugs then clambered onto the roof of the vans, before jumping up and down. The van was eventually forced to flee the scene with its back doors wide open. Violent protesters also threw fireworks and bottles at police, who were protecting anti-racism counter-protesters. Other footage shows thugs attacking a police van by kicking and punching it. The masked protesters even try to open the van's doors before one jumps on the front bumper, slapping the bonnet of the vehicle as it backs up. Hundreds of asylum seekers living in tax-funded hotels have been charged with crimes such as rape, robbery & GBH A broken wing mirror could also be seen on the floor next to the riot van before it was picked up and launched by one of the demonstrators. The unrest began after asylum seeker Hadush Gerberslasie Kebatu, 38, was arrested and later charged with three counts of sexual assault, one count of inciting a girl to engage in sexual activity and one count of harassment without violence. He appeared at Colchester Magistrates' Court on Thursday, July 10, and denied all the alleged offences before being charged yesterday. His arrest, however, led to multiple protests in the region, culminating in this Thursday's violence. One man was arrested yesterday on suspicion of affray, following reports of an assault during Sunday's protest, police said. On Sunday, two security guards were seriously assaulted by a group of men at a bus stop in the town. 9 9 9 "We have closed a section of High Road, Epping, for the safety of the public and those protesting," Essex Police said. "We will not tolerate any criminality on our streets, whether linked to protesting or not," the force added. "One man has already been arrested at today's protest on suspicion of affray following reports of an assault near The Bell Hotel in Epping on Sunday July 13. "He will be taken into custody while our inquiries continue." Chief Superintendent Simon Anslow said: "Disruption and offending is never an appropriate response, no matter the strength of feeling in this case, and on this issue. "People protesting peacefully, lawfully and responsibly cause us - and the wider public - no concern. "However, we can never, and will never, tolerate criminal behaviour of any sort and anyone identified as committing crime will be dealt with robustly." 9 9 9
