
Denbighshire, Conwy, Gwynedd & Anglesey MPs back assisted dying bill
This does not mean the bill has become law, but it allows it to now progress to the House of Lords for further scrutiny.
The majority almost halved since the last vote in November, during the bill's second reading.
If successful, the bill would make assisted suicide legal for terminally ill adults expected to die within six months, and with the mental capacity to make a choice about how to end their life.
Below are comments from MPs Llinos Medi, Liz Saville Roberts, Claire Hughes, Gill German and Becky Gittins on why they all backed the bill.
Llinos Medi (Image: Submitted) "I am assured that the bill has been strengthened during the scrutiny process. For example, I voted in favour of an amendment to prevent health professionals such as doctors from initiating conversations with under-18s about assisted dying, which passed.
"Regardless of today's vote, scrutiny does not end here. As MPs, we have a duty and I remain committed to listening to all voices, including those who oppose the bill.
"Whatever your opinion on today's outcome, I believe that we should show respect to both sides of the debate. Days like today are not easy and we must show compassion to all."
Liz Saville Roberts (Image: Submitted) "I believe that adults who are terminally ill, with a prognosis of six months or less to live, and who have full mental capacity, should have the legal right to make this profoundly personal decision for themselves, free from coercion and with strong safeguards in place.
"I fully understand the concerns many people, including disability rights groups and medical organisations, have raised about protecting individuals.
"That is why I support the inclusion of strict safeguards, involving medical professionals, social workers and judicial oversight, to ensure that each decision is carefully assessed, voluntary, and free from pressure.
"I am also conscious of concerns about the so-called 'slippery slope'. However, the bill is tightly framed, applying only to terminally ill adults and excluding those whose suffering is solely related to mental illness. Any further changes would require full parliamentary scrutiny."
Claire Hughes (Image: Submitted) "Fundamentally, I believe we should all have the right to decide what happens to our bodies and when enough is enough.
"I believe that the status quo - where only terminally ill people with the wealth to enable them to travel to Dignitas are able to exercise control over their final moments - is not good enough.
"This bill has gone through a robust process, making it rigorous, practical and safe, and is rooted in the principles of compassion, justice and human dignity.
"I want, again, to make it abundantly clear that good palliative care and giving terminally ill people the choice to choose an assisted death, are not mutually exclusive."
Gill German (Image: Rick Matthews) "During report stage, I supported New Clause 10, which expands the bill's protection for medical practitioners to ensure they have 'no obligation' to administer an assisted death and provide legal protections for medical professionals to ensure they are not subject to punishment for refusing to carry out an assisted death.
"Further, I voted against New Clause 1 and 2. While I respect the deeply held views on all sides, I believe both amendments introduced unnecessary risks by restricting open, compassionate conversations between clinicians and patients that are often essential to end-of-life care.
"New Clause 1, which was not adopted, would have banned doctors from raising assisted dying with adult patients at all, even when clinically appropriate. This clause would disproportionately harm those with lower health literacy who may not know how to start the conversation.
"New Clause 2, which was passed, prevents doctors from discussing assisted dying with under-18s in any context. I believe this risks isolating terminally ill teenagers or young relatives of dying patients, by preventing doctors from discussing assisted dying with under-18s in any context.
"This may drive vulnerable young people towards unregulated and potentially harmful sources of information."
Becky Gittins (Image: Submitted) "I believe there are as many safeguards as practically possible contained within this bill to ensure free and fair choice for patients to make this decision in an informed way, free from coercion.
"I hope that the high level of parliamentary scrutiny that this bill has received will encourage a more forensic consideration of the role of patient decision-making across the UK and broader society.
"Throughout the legislative process, the attention given to the needs of the most vulnerable people and the importance of ensuring a free choice has brought an essential focus on the role of coercion, domestic abuse, disability, ableism and poverty on people's ability to genuinely make a free decision about their lives – whether on this issue or many others."

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Herald Scotland
an hour ago
- The Herald Scotland
Cancer deaths up although risk of dying from disease falls to new low
Cancer deaths in Scotland have risen over a 10-year period, despite figures showing the risk of dying from the disease is at the lowest on record. New data showed that the European Age Standardised Rate (EASR) for cancer deaths – which set out the risk of dying from the disease – fell to 296.8 per 100,000 population for 2022. That is down by 2.9% on the previous year, with a decrease of 11.1% compared to 2013, with the EASR now at the lowest it has been in data that goes back to 1998. However, figures published by Public Health Scotland showed that between 2013 and 2022 cancer deaths rose by 3.2%, from 15,764 to 16,265. This increase 'largely reflects an increase in the proportion of older age groups within the population, and the fact that cancer is more common among older people', the report from Public Health Scotland said. READ MORE: In 2022, more than two-thirds (69%) of all cancer deaths were in people aged seventy and over, the figures showed. Meanwhile four cancers – lung, bowel, breast and prostate – accounted for almost half (46%) of cancer deaths in that year, the report added. Lung cancer remained as the most common cause of cancer deaths, with a total of 3,925 people dying as a result of this in 2022 – almost a quarter (24.1%) of all cancer deaths that year. The report also found that in 2022 cases of cancer were almost a quarter (23.9%) higher in the most deprived parts of Scotland than they were in the least deprived communities – and mortality rates were 78% higher in the poorest areas. Public Health Scotland said that 'mortality reflects the combined effects of increased risk and poorer survival from cancer in more deprived areas'. The report also noted that while overall cancer death rates have declined for both men and women since 2012, there had been 'notable increases' for some forms of the disease. Liver cancer deaths have risen by 15% amongst men and by 20% amongst women over the period 2013 to 2022. However, Public Health Scotland said; 'Nearly half (49%) of liver cancer cases are preventable through lifestyle changes such as reducing obesity, smoking, alcohol consumption, and preventing viral liver infections.' Labour health spokesperson, Dame Jackie Baillie, said it was 'deeply worrying that the number of cancer deaths in Scotland has risen over the course of a decade'. She added that these deaths include 'an alarming increase in the number of men dying from cancer, with a rise of 5% between 2013 and 2022.' Dame Jackie said the Scottish Government was 'moving too slowly on its commitment to introduce lung cancer screening'. She further insisted: 'SNP ministers must also act urgently to improve waiting times for cancer treatment as almost a third of patients referred to the NHS in Scotland are waiting longer than the 62-day target to start treatment.' Scottish Liberal Democrat leader Alex Cole-Hamilton said the figures showed that 'cancer patients cannot depend on this SNP Government'. Hitting out at SNP ministers the Liberal Democrat said: 'In Scotland, more people die of lung cancer than any other form of disease. Survival rates aren't much better than what they were in the 1970s. 'International studies show Scotland falling behind with cancer care. The SNP's failure to roll out a national lung cancer screening programme is another example of that.' He added: 'My party wants to see the government ending their dithering and making a full rollout of this screening programme a top priority. 'We know there isn't a moment to lose when it comes to getting cancer patients life-saving interventions.' However Health Secretary Neil Gray said: 'It is encouraging to see the risk of dying from cancer in Scotland is at a record low. 'This is down to the hard work of NHS staff, improved treatment options, and people reporting their symptoms at an earlier stage.' He added: 'We are determined to further improve cancer survival, reduce waiting times and provide excellent, equitably accessible care right across Scotland.' The Health Secretary said the Scottish Government is 'taking action to improve the awareness and earlier diagnosis of cancers, including expanding our Rapid Cancer Diagnostic Services and our investment of more than £14 million towards cancer waiting times this year'. He also stated: 'Reducing health inequalities is a clear ambition for this government. 'Cutting smoking rates is key to tackling lung cancer incidence in areas of deprivation – our world-leading tobacco control measures are helping us in our goal of a Tobacco-Free Scotland by 2034.'


Spectator
an hour ago
- Spectator
Scottish Labour faces councillor crisis as Reform eyes up seats
It's not a good time to be in Scottish Labour. With nine months to go until the 2025 Holyrood election, the party is still trailing behind the SNP and, at times, Reform UK. And things aren't going well at a local level either: in recent months the party has suspended five councillors over inappropriate conduct and today one of these, Fife council's David Graham, has been jailed for 27 months after the 43-year-old was found guilty for sexually abusing a vulnerable teenager. Good heavens… A by-election will be held in Fife's Buckhaven, Methil and Wemyss Villages ward in due course – with opposition parties keeping tabs on a number of council seats after the suspension of more Labour councillors in Scotland. North Lanarkshire Labour councillor Andrew Duffy-Lawson was suspended last month over sexually inappropriate messaging. The former leader of Glasgow City council, Labour's Frank McAveety, was arrested and charged in April this year over fraud offences. Labour's Philip Braat has also been suspended from Glasgow City council, pleading guilty to a charge of stalking in May this year. And one of Scottish Labour's most prominent local authority leaders, Edinburgh City council's Cammy Day, was suspended – and resigned as council leader – in December 2024 amid allegations he had sent sexually explicit messages to Ukrainian refugees. (A subsequent police investigation cleared him of criminal wrongdoing and Day has since blasted the allegations as 'an orchestrated political campaign against me'.) Reform UK is keeping a close eye on these cases in the event of by-election being called. The party has fared well in Scottish council polls before – taking a quarter of the vote in both the Glasgow North East (23.6 per cent) and Clydebank Waterfront (26.2 per cent) elections this year. It hopes to translate this success to Holyrood: while both the SNP and the Scottish Tories are projected to lose seats at next year's Scottish parliament election, Reform is rather excited about its prospects. Some polls have predicted Nigel Farage's party could gain around 15 MSPs from a standing start at the expense of Scotland's unionist groups. 'The Tories are frightened,' a senior Reform source confided to Mr S, adding that Farage's group expected the Scottish Conservatives to fall from being the largest opposition party to 'single figures' next year. 'To put it mildly: they are s****ing themselves.' While senior Tories have suggested they could form an electoral pact with Reform next year, Farage's crowd say they are 'not interested in shackling ourselves to a Tory corpse'. Crikey. It's certainly quite the image… Labour's recent woes have instilled confidence in Farage's Scottish group – 'they are in a doom loop' – while current polling suggests the SNP won't win enough support to form a majority government. 'It'll prompt talks of a Labour-SNP coalition,' the Reform insider added, 'with some grand title, to have the purpose of effectively keeping Reform out.' Indeed, as Lucy Dunn wrote earlier this month, the bravado of some politicians is already starting to wear off. More pragmatic proposals to retain power are being floated, with some Nats are in favour of a 'grand coalition' with Scottish Labour in a bid to keep the party in government. Well, desperate times call for desperate measures…


Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Finnish MP ‘takes own life' in Helsinki parliament
A Finnish MP has died inside the national parliament, the country's prime minister has said. Following reports that a politician had taken their own life, Petteri Orpo confirmed that the body of a member of his National Coalition parliamentary group had been found on the premises without naming the MP. 'Some time ago, we received truly shocking news from parliament, our common workplace,' he said. 'One of our colleagues has passed away on parliament premises. This is truly sad news.' He added that political discussions would be suspended in mourning for the MP's death. 'At the same time, we wish strength to his family, loved ones and colleagues. This deeply touches all of us, we send greetings and strength to everyone,' he said. The Finnish parliament is on summer recess, with MPs due to return to work on Sept 2. According to Finnish media, the MP's body was found at about 11am local time. There was a large police presence inside the building on Tuesday afternoon. Finnish media outlets are refraining from identifying the MP until their next of kin have been notified. In front of the parliament building, Finnish flags were lowered to half-mast. Päivi Räsänen, a Finnish MP, said it was 'shocking, heartbreaking news about the loss of a colleague', adding: 'I assume that the sad news will be conveyed to the family before the person is publicly announced. I deeply share the great sorrow of the family and remember them with prayers.' She told the Ilta Sanomat newspaper: 'I believe that this will mark the beginning of autumn in parliament. Despite the political tensions, it is a close-knit working community.' Ms Räsänen said a memorial service will be held at the beginning of the session, adding: 'There will be tears.'