logo
The Triple Tap Raid On the Engels Bomber Base Cost Russia $9.6 Billion

The Triple Tap Raid On the Engels Bomber Base Cost Russia $9.6 Billion

Forbes27-03-2025
The result of a Ukrainian deep strike.
Ukrainian defense ministry photo
On the morning of March 20, Ukrainian drones targeted the Russian air force bomber base at Engels for the third time in 10 weeks. According to the Ukrainian general staff, the resulting blast destroyed 96 Kh-101 cruise missiles—some of Russia's best munitions for striking Ukrainian cities.
Launched by Tupolev Tu-95 and Tu-160 heavy bombers, each Kh-101 travels as far as 560 miles with a 1,000-pound warhead. The general staff in Kyiv claimed planners in Moscow had designated the targeted Kh-101s for raids on Ukrainian cities this month and next.
Those 96 destroyed missiles accounted for two months of production at the Raduga Design Bureau munitions factory near Moscow. Each Kh-101 costs at least $10 million. That means the strike on Engels may have carried a price tag of $9.6 billion—not counting the additional damage to fuel storage and other facilities at the base.
As explosions rocked the base and smoke billowed into the sky on March 20, Engels was 'facing serious difficulties,' the Ukrainian Center for Strategic Communication quipped. Indeed, the difficulties began two months ago.
On Jan. 8, Ukrainian drones flew at least 400 miles to strike in Saratov near Engels. The blasts triggered a blaze at a sprawling depot containing as much as 800,000 tons of fuel. The fire finally burned itself out, or firefighters extinguished it, after six days. Hours later on Jan. 14, drones struck a second time. 'There will be no rest for the wicked,' Stratcom warned.
Maybe. In fact, the damage at Engels can be repaired. Raduga might be able to ramp up production of new Kh-101s. And Ukraine may struggle to acquire enough deep-strike munitions to sustain repeated strikes on Engels.
Saratov burns following a Ukrainian deep strike.
Via Supernova
Ukraine has developed a dizzying array of long-range unmanned aerial vehicles, including some based on modified sport planes that can range 800 miles with hundreds of pounds of explosives. It has also developed a 600-mile version of its iconic Neptune cruise missile—and recently deployed it for the first time.
Kyiv has devoted a significant portion of this deep-strike arsenal to attacks on Russian munitions depots such as the one at Engels. But the raids, which often produce towering fireballs that lend themselves to dramatic social media posts, may be more gratifying to the Ukrainians than they are militarily effective.
According to Ukrainian analysis group Frontelligence Insight, more than half of the observed Ukrainian strikes between September and February—many of them aimed at munitions stocks—'had limited impact' as crews rushed to fix the afflicted facilities and Russian industry adapted to compensate for lost production.
Attacking more often, and with heavier munitions than lightweight attack drones, might inflict lasting damage, Frontelligence Insight concluded.
But Ukraine doesn't get enough of the best foreign-made deep-strike munitions—British-made Storm Shadow cruise missiles, similar French-made SCALP missiles and American-made ATACMS rockets—to mount an intensive campaign targeting Russian logistics. And it doesn't yet build enough similar munitions, including Neptunes, on its own.
It's not for no reason that, in recent months, Ukrainian strike planners have shifted their aim—and are now launching more drone attacks on Russia's delicate, and economically vital, oil infrastructure. They're hoping the damage to the oil industry will ultimately have greater impact than the damage to weapons depots.
Even if the depot strikes look better on camera.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Top Armed Services Democrat calls Trump-Putin summit ‘very disappointing'
Top Armed Services Democrat calls Trump-Putin summit ‘very disappointing'

The Hill

time10 minutes ago

  • The Hill

Top Armed Services Democrat calls Trump-Putin summit ‘very disappointing'

Rep. Adam Smith (D-Wash.), the ranking Democrat on the House Armed Services Committee, said he was very disappointed by the historic summit between President Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin in Alaska on Friday. In an interview on NewsNation's 'The Hill Sunday,' Smith criticized the U.S. president for appearing to emerge from his meeting more aligned with Putin in pushing for an end to the war in Ukraine without first agreeing to a ceasefire. 'The summit in Alaska was very disappointing,' Smith said in the interview. 'We took the demand for a ceasefire off the table in exchange for nothing.' Smith also criticized Trump's 'deference' to the Russian leader, contrasting that approach with the antagonism on display during the explosive Oval Office meeting with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky in February. 'The deference that President Trump showed to Putin—never once just stating the basic notion that Ukraine has a right to exist as a sovereign, democratic country and that the invasion was illegal, unlawful,' Smith said. 'And you contrast that with the way President Trump and Vice President Vance treated Zelensky when he was in the West Wing back in February — it sends the wrong signal if we're trying to force Putin to the table and get a negotiated end to this war,' he continued. Smith said it 'makes sense' for Trump to be trying to get Putin and Zelensky in a room together, saying, 'I applaud that effort, but you have to understand what Putin wants out of this.' 'Putin wants all of Ukraine, and he's just trying to play President Trump and buy time to get in a better position to do that,' he continued. 'That's the calculation of Putin that has to be changed.'

Meeting locations, a statue for Putin: Details of Alaska summit were left on hotel printer
Meeting locations, a statue for Putin: Details of Alaska summit were left on hotel printer

USA Today

time40 minutes ago

  • USA Today

Meeting locations, a statue for Putin: Details of Alaska summit were left on hotel printer

Government documents with details about meeting schedules and seating charts − as well as an extravagant menu and reminder to pronounce President Vladimir Putin's name "POO-tihn," were accidentally left in a hotel printer in Alaska amid President Donald Trump's meeting with the Russian leader. The documents with State Department markings, reported by NPR, were discovered in the printer in an Anchorage hotel around 9 a.m., hours before Trump's summit with Putin at a nearby military base. Hotel guests shared the pages with NPR. The documents laid out the precise locations and meeting times of the summit at Joint Base Elmendorf–Richardson, as well as phone numbers of government employees and the menu for a planned three course lunch that did not occur, including which chairs the presidents would use. The documents appear to have been produced by federal government staff and were left behind. Some of the information, including plans for a lunch and a news conference, was made public before the meeting took place. But much of it was the type of information the White House wouldn't usually share until after an event, such as whether a gift was exchanged. Some of the details verged into sensitive information that wouldn't typically be made public at all, such as what times Trump would be in what room. Security incidents Planned movements of the president and meetings with world leaders, such as which seat they will take during a meeting, are often kept secret until they take place for security reasons. When such security breaches have happened before they are normally considered international incidents and are investigated. In 2023, a police document detailing President Joe Biden's movements, including which streets would be closed and other security measures, were found on a Belfast street while the president was in Ireland. The White House did not immediately return a USA TODAY request for comment Aug. 17. But Deputy White House Press Secretary Anna Kelly told NPR Aug. 16 that the papers were a "multi-page lunch menu" and suggested leaving the information on a public printer was not a security breach. Kelly also dismissed the article in a statement to NewsNation. 'It's hilarious that NPR is publishing a multi-page lunch menu and calling it a 'security breach,'' Kelly said. 'This type of self-proclaimed 'investigative journalism' is why no one takes them seriously and they are no longer taxpayer-funded thanks to President Trump.' Lunch menu Two of the pages seen by NPR included a menu for the canceled lunch, which was to include filet mignon with brandy peppercorn sauce and halibut olympia, a green salad and crème brûlée. The other pages included which seats Trump, Putin and their aides would take during the lunch and which rooms they would be in at what time. The remaining pages include contact information for staff members as well as the names of the 13 U.S. and Russian state leaders who attended, including phonetic pronounciation of the Russian names. Among the details was a gift from Trump to Putin, an "American Bald Eagle Desk Statue." Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and leaders of several European countries are scheduled to meet with Trump at the White House August 18.

European leaders to join Ukraine's Zelensky for meeting with Trump
European leaders to join Ukraine's Zelensky for meeting with Trump

Los Angeles Times

time40 minutes ago

  • Los Angeles Times

European leaders to join Ukraine's Zelensky for meeting with Trump

KYIV, Ukraine — European and NATO leaders announced Sunday they will join President Volodymyr Zelensky in Washington for talks with President Trump on ending Russia's war in Ukraine, with the possibility of U.S. security guarantees now on the negotiating table. European leaders, including heavyweights France, Britain and Germany, are rallying around the Ukrainian leader after his exclusion from Trump's summit on Friday with Russian President Vladimir Putin. Their pledge to be at Zelensky's side at the White House on Monday is an apparent effort to ensure the meeting goes better than the Ukrainian leader's last one in February, when Trump berated him in a heated Oval Office encounter. 'The Europeans are very afraid of the Oval Office scene being repeated, and so they want to support Mr. Zelensky to the hilt,' said retired French Gen. Dominique Trinquand, a former head of France's military mission at the United Nations. 'It's a power struggle and a position of strength that might work with Trump,' he said. Special U.S. envoy Steve Witkoff said Sunday that Putin agreed at the meeting in Alaska with Trump to allow the U.S. and European allies to offer Ukraine a security guarantee resembling NATO's collective defense mandate as part of an eventual deal to end the 3½-year war. European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, speaking at a news conference in Brussels with Zelensky, said, 'We welcome President Trump's willingness to contribute to Article 5-like security guarantees for Ukraine. And the 'coalition of the willing' — including the European Union -- is ready to do its share.' Von der Leyen was joined Sunday by French President Emmanuel Macron, British Prime Minister Keir Starmer, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz and Finnish President Alexander Stubb in saying they will take part in Monday's talks at the White House, as will the secretary general of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, Mark Rutte. The European leaders' demonstration of support could help ease concerns in Kyiv and other European capitals that Ukraine risks being railroaded into a peace deal that Trump says he wants to broker with Russia. Neil Melvin, director of international security at the London-based Royal United Services Institute, said European leaders are trying to 'shape this fast-evolving agenda.' After the Alaska summit, the idea of a ceasefire appears all but abandoned, with the narrative shifting toward Putin's agenda of ensuring Ukraine does not join NATO or even the EU. U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio said on NBC's 'Meet the Press' on Sunday that a possible ceasefire is 'not off the table' but that the best way to end the war would be through a 'full peace deal.' Putin has implied that he sees Europe as a hindrance to negotiations. He has also resisted meeting Zelensky in person, saying that such a meeting can only take place once the groundwork for a peace deal has been laid. Speaking to reporters after his meeting with Trump, the Russian leader raised the idea that Kyiv and other European capitals could 'create obstacles' to derail potential progress with 'behind-the-scenes intrigue.' For now, the Zelensky meeting offers the Europeans the 'only way' to get into the discussions about the future of Ukraine and European security, Melvin said. But the sheer number of European leaders potentially in attendance means the group will have to be 'mindful' not to give 'contradictory' messages, he said. 'The risk is they look heavy-handed and are ganging up on Trump,' he added. 'Trump won't want to be put in a corner.' Although details remain hazy on what Article 5-like security guarantees from the U.S. and Europe would entail for Ukraine, it could mirror NATO membership terms, in which an attack on one member of the alliance is seen as an attack on all. In remarks made on CNN's 'State of the Union,' Witkoff said Friday's meeting with Trump was the first time Putin has been had heard to agree to such an arrangement. Zelensky continues to stress the importance of both U.S. and European involvement in any negotiations. 'A security guarantee is a strong army. Only Ukraine can provide that. Only Europe can finance this army, and weapons for this army can be provided by our domestic production and European production. But there are certain things that are in short supply and are only available in the United States,' he said at the news conference Sunday alongside Von der Leyen. Zelensky also countered Trump's assertion — which aligned with Putin's preference — that the two sides should negotiate a complete end to the war rather than first securing a ceasefire. Zelensky said a ceasefire would provide breathing room to review Putin's demands. 'It's impossible to do this under the pressure of weapons,' he said. 'Putin does not want to stop the killing, but he must do it.' Kullab and Leicester write for the Associated Press and reported from Kyiv and Le Pecq, France, respectively. AP writers Pan Pylas in London and Katie Marie Davies in Manchester, England, contributed to this report.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store