HCSTSI President spells out ‘core' reason behind narrow tax base
HYDERABAD: President Hyderabad Chamber of Small Traders & Small Industry (HCSTSI), Muhammad Saleem Memon, has said in a statement that the core reason behind Pakistan's narrow tax net and limited number of taxpayers is the lack of public and business community's trust in the government's utilization of tax revenues.
He emphasized that unless people are assured of transparent and effective use of their paid taxes, there can be no significant improvement in voluntary tax compliance.
He highlighted that despite billions of rupees being collected in taxes annually by various departments, the public and business sectors continue to suffer from a lack of basic civic amenities. Roads remain in poor condition, hospitals and schools are dilapidated, and municipal services are constantly declining. He pointed out that numerous reports, including those from the Auditor General of Pakistan, have consistently revealed massive financial irregularities and mismanagement in public funds, but no meaningful accountability has been ensured.
HCSTSI President stressed that it is impossible to strengthen the tax system without restoring the confidence of the business community. Currently, traders feel that they are being forcefully taxed, yet their issues remain unresolved. He urged the federal and provincial governments to publish detailed annual expenditure reports alongside tax collection data, so that citizens can clearly see how and where their money is being spent.
He said that if the government ensures the transparent use of public money, it would not only boost the confidence of current taxpayers but also motivate non-taxpayers to become part of the formal economy. He noted that Pakistan's tax-to-GDP ratio is lower than other regional countries such as Bangladesh and Sri Lanka, which reflects the public's deep mistrust in how tax revenues are managed.
Drawing comparisons with developed nations, Memon stated that one of the key reasons behind their success is the public's trust in their tax systems. For instance, in Canada, each taxpayer receives an annual breakdown of where their taxes were spent. In Norway, citizens have access to detailed expenditures of any public project. South Korea's 'Taxpayer Bill of Rights' gives people full awareness and holds the government accountable. As a result, people in these countries willingly and confidently pay taxes.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
4 days ago
- Business Recorder
Budget 26: Govt looking to boost export of ‘made in Pakistan' mobile phones, say assemblers
Pakistan's mobile phone assemblers claim the federal and provincial governments will announce a policy in the upcoming budget 2025-26 aiming to boost phone exports. This is to maintain the balance of trade which is likely to widen in the wake of surge in imports from the US in the aftermath of trade talks between Islamabad and Washington, according to several experts that Business Recorder spoke to. One leading domestic mobile phone assembler told Business Recorder on the condition of anonymity that the government is working to announce a rebate on export of mobile phones in the upcoming budget, scheduled to be announced on June 10. More luxury items set to attract sales tax in upcoming Pakistan budget Separately, Muhammad Idrees Memon, a former president of Karachi Electronic Dealers Association (KEDA), told Business Recorder that the federal and provincial governments are designing a policy similar to the Export Facilitation Scheme (EFS) which will incentivise the export of 'made in Pakistan' mobile phones. Both federal and provincial governments were approached to confirm the development. They were yet to reply by the time of filing this story. Memon, who is also a former president of Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KCCI), said the Sindh government and KCCI are currently in talks about removing or reducing the Infrastructure Development Cess (IDC) on the import of mobile parts (CKD/completely knocked down) for those manufacturers who want to export their products. The IDC is being collected in the range of 1.81% to 1.85% on imports at the provincial level. He also said the Sindh government will finish working on the export package for mobile phone exporters 'over the next two to three days (by Wednesday)' and announce it in the budget. 'The Punjab government has already agreed to a similar export package. The ministry of finance, ministry of commerce, Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) and Engineering Development Board (EDB) all are supporting us,' he said. He said Sindh Chief Minister Murad Ali Shah, and PPP ministers and members of the provincial assembly including Mukash Kumar Chawla and Dharejo are working with KCCI leadership to design an EFS-like product to promote and support the phone exports to help partially controlling the likely increase in balance of trade. He added that Pakistan is considering increasing imports of products including cotton and edible oil from the US to avoid President Trump's proposal to double tariff to 29% on imports from Pakistan. Once the provincial government finalizes its tax incentives for exports then the federal government will also join the export package in the making, Memon said. 'There is huge potential and Pakistan can earn a significant amount of foreign exchange through exporting 'made in Pakistan' phones,' Memon said. He said Pakistan is already exporting mobile phones to Middle Eastern countries including Dubai, but the volume of the trade is insignificant. Almost all the Chinese phones - about two dozen brands - available in the country are being assembled locally. Memon said Pakistan is importing 100% raw material (parts/CKD) for mobile assembling in the country at present. The removal of IDC on imports would enable manufacturers to add value to the products and earn a handsome amount on their exports. In addition to this, this would also help create a new employment generation and promote 'made in Pakistan' products across the globe. China looking to move export base to Pakistan Meanwhile, Aamir Allawala, CEO, Transsion Tecno Electronics, said that Chinese companies are interested in moving their export base to Pakistan due to availability of labour at a lower cost and to mitigate its risk associated with global trade war. 'Pakistan labour cost is only $140 per month compared with $800 in China,' he told Business Recorder. Almost all leading Chinese brands have already set up their factories in Pakistan including Xiaomi, OPPO, Vivo, Tecno, Infinix, Itel, realme, Redmi and ZTE. 'Pakistan can become a hub of export of Chinese brands to markets in Africa, Central Asia and Middle East. 'There is a huge potential on the table. The government should sit together with the local industry and chart a five year forward to take advantage of the changing global trends,' he said. Pakistan is now assembling almost all global brands of mobile phones locally, increasing the 'made in Pakistan' production to 95% of the local demand, while the share of imported phones (finished products) has reduced to merely 5%. The domestic production is saving around 15-20% in foreign exchange, as local assemblers are still importing almost all mobile phone parts from foreign manufacturers. According to Pakistan Bureau of Statistics' (PBS) data, the import of mobile phones (CKD/CBU) dropped 14% to $1.2 5 billion in the first 10 months of FY25 compared to $1.46 billion in the same period of the last year.
Business Recorder
4 days ago
- Business Recorder
Budget 26: Govt looking to boost mobile phone export, say assemblers
Pakistan's mobile phone assemblers claim the federal and provincial governments will announce a policy in the upcoming budget 2025-26 aiming to boost phone exports. This is to maintain the balance of trade which is likely to widen in the wake of surge in imports from the US in the aftermath of trade talks between Islamabad and Washington, according to several experts that Business Recorder spoke to. A leading domestic mobile phone assembler told Business Recorder on the condition of anonymity that the government is working to announce a rebate on export of mobile phones in the upcoming budget, scheduled to be announced on June 10. More luxury items set to attract sales tax in upcoming Pakistan budget Separately, Muhammad Idrees Memon, a former president of Karachi Electronic Dealers Association (KEDA), told Business Recorder that the federal and provincial governments are designing a policy similar to the Export Facilitation Scheme (EFS) which will incentivise the export of 'made in Pakistan' mobile phones. Both federal and provincial governments were approached to confirm the development. They were yet to reply by the time of filing this story. Memon, who is also a former president of Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KCCI), said the Sindh government and KCCI are currently in talks about removing or reducing the Infrastructure Development Cess (IDC) on the import of mobile parts (CKD/completely knocked down) for those manufacturers who want to export their products. The IDC is being collected in the range of 1.81% to 1.85% on imports at the provincial level. He also said the Sindh government will finish working on the export package for mobile phone exporters 'over the next two to three days (by Wednesday)' and announce it in the budget. 'The Punjab government has already agreed to a similar export package. The ministry of finance, ministry of commerce, Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) and Engineering Development Board (EDB) all are supporting us,' he said. He said Sindh Chief Minister Murad Ali Shah, and PPP ministers and members of the provincial assembly including Mukash Kumar Chawla and Dharejo are working with KCCI leadership to design an EFS-like product to promote and support the phone exports to help partially controlling the likely increase in balance of trade. He added that Pakistan is considering increasing imports of products including cotton and edible oil from the US to avoid President Trump's proposal to double tariff to 29% on imports from Pakistan. Once the provincial government finalizes its tax incentives for exports then the federal government will also join the export package in the making, Memon said. 'There is huge potential and Pakistan can earn a significant amount of foreign exchange through exporting 'made in Pakistan' phones,' Memon said. He said Pakistan is already exporting mobile phones to Middle Eastern countries including Dubai, but the volume of the trade is insignificant. Almost all the Chinese phones - about two dozen brands - available in the country are being assembled locally. Memon said Pakistan is importing 100% raw material (parts/CKD) for mobile assembling in the country at present. The removal of IDC on imports would enable manufacturers to add value to the products and earn a handsome amount on their exports. In addition to this, this would also help create a new employment generation and promote 'made in Pakistan' products across the globe. Meanwhile, Aamir Allawala, CEO, Transsion Tecno Electronics, said that Chinese companies are interested in moving their export base to Pakistan due to availability of labour at a lower cost and to mitigate its risk associated with global trade war. 'Pakistan labour cost is only $140 per month compared with $800 in China,' he told Business Recorder. Almost all leading Chinese brands have already set up their factories in Pakistan including Xiaomi, OPPO, Vivo, Tecno, Infinix, Itel, realme, Redmi and ZTE. 'Pakistan can become a hub of export of Chinese brands to markets in Africa, Central Asia and Middle East. 'There is a huge potential on the table. The government should sit together with the local industry and chart a five year forward to take advantage of the changing global trends,' he said. To recall,Pakistan is now assembling almost all global brands of mobile phones locally, increasing the 'Made in Pakistan' production to 95% of the local demand, while the share of imported phones (finished products) has reduced to merely 5%. The domestic production is saving around 15-20% in foreign exchange, as local assemblers are still importing almost all mobile phone parts from foreign manufacturers. According to Pakistan Bureau of Statistics' (PBS) data, the import of mobile phones (CKD/CBU) dropped 14% to $1.2 5 billion in the first 10 months of FY25 compared to $1.46 billion in the same period of the last year.
Express Tribune
23-05-2025
- Express Tribune
Exporters face double tax blow
Listen to article A senior tax official said on Thursday that 18% sales tax will be imposed on imported raw materials being used in exportable goods, amid a bizarre contradiction in the International Monetary Fund (IMF)'s policy to 'compel' Pakistan to simultaneously charge minimum and standard income tax rates from exporters. The Member Tax Policy of the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR), Dr Najeeb Memon, disclosed on Thursday that the IMF had asked the FBR to retain 1% minimum income tax on exporters while introducing the standard 29% income tax due to a lack of certainty about the revenues from the new measure. Before the last budget, the exporters were subject to only 1% income tax under the final tax regime, which the government changed to the standard 29% rate. The member policy made the disclosure in a meeting of the National Assembly Standing Committee on Finance that discussed the issue of charging double taxes from the exporters. Such double taxation was also contrary to international best practices. The committee members and the Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KCCI) proposed that the FBR should withdraw the 1% minimum income tax after it had already started charging 29% income tax. However, Memon disclosed that the minimum tax on the gross receipts of the exporters cannot be withdrawn because the IMF had asked to retain it for at least two to three years. "It is highly unfair to simultaneously retain both the regimes of minimum and standard income tax," remarked Chairman of the Standing Committee, Syed Naveed Qamar of the PPP. He went on to say that the FBR did not want to work and was comfortable collecting taxes by sitting in their rooms. There was no immediate independent verification of the FBR's claim about the IMF. There have been incidents in the past where the FBR used the name of the IMF to impose certain taxes for the sake of its own revenues. Memon said that it was the IMF that asked, in order to remain certain, the government should retain both the minimum income tax and introduce the standard rate too. He explained that the minimum tax was not refundable and the exporter has to pay both levies. Qamar also expressed displeasure about the absence of FBR Chairman, Rashid Langrial, from the committee meeting. Memon said that Langrial was in the IMF meeting. However, the Standing Committee chairman replied that he was coming from the IMF-PM luncheon meeting and the FBR chairman was not there. Due to the absence of the FBR chairman, Qamar refused to take up the government's tax-related bill for approval. He deferred the discussion on the Income Tax Second Amendment Bill, which the government has proposed to restore 25% income tax credit for the teachers. According to the proposed amendment, the tax payable by a full-time teacher or a researcher employed in a non-profit education or research institution duly recognised by the Higher Education Commission (HEC), a Board of Education or a university recognised by the HEC, including government research institutions, shall be reduced by an amount equal to 25% of tax payable on his income from salary. However, this exemption will not be available to teachers of the medical profession who derive income from private medical practice or who receive a share of consideration received from patients. The rebate has been proposed to be restored with effect from the first day of July 2022 and shall cease to have effect after tax year 2025. The committee also discussed the issue of the imposition of 18% sales tax on local raw materials meant for use in exports. The tax had been imposed in the last budget. There is a likelihood that imported raw material will also be taxed at the rate of 18% in the budget after the government imposed such tax on the local supplies for exportable goods, said the member tax policy. His comments came after the members of the committee and the KCCI demanded withdrawal of the 18% sales tax that had been levied on the local supplies of exporters in the last budget. MNA Arshad Abdullah Vohra said that the local manufacturers of raw materials were facing a big crisis after the government imposed the 18% tax in the last budget but did not impose such tax at the import stage. Last time, the IMF might have overlooked it, but this time the 18% tax will be imposed on imports too, said Memon.
