HCSTSI President spells out ‘core' reason behind narrow tax base
He emphasized that unless people are assured of transparent and effective use of their paid taxes, there can be no significant improvement in voluntary tax compliance.
He highlighted that despite billions of rupees being collected in taxes annually by various departments, the public and business sectors continue to suffer from a lack of basic civic amenities. Roads remain in poor condition, hospitals and schools are dilapidated, and municipal services are constantly declining. He pointed out that numerous reports, including those from the Auditor General of Pakistan, have consistently revealed massive financial irregularities and mismanagement in public funds, but no meaningful accountability has been ensured.
HCSTSI President stressed that it is impossible to strengthen the tax system without restoring the confidence of the business community. Currently, traders feel that they are being forcefully taxed, yet their issues remain unresolved. He urged the federal and provincial governments to publish detailed annual expenditure reports alongside tax collection data, so that citizens can clearly see how and where their money is being spent.
He said that if the government ensures the transparent use of public money, it would not only boost the confidence of current taxpayers but also motivate non-taxpayers to become part of the formal economy. He noted that Pakistan's tax-to-GDP ratio is lower than other regional countries such as Bangladesh and Sri Lanka, which reflects the public's deep mistrust in how tax revenues are managed.
Drawing comparisons with developed nations, Memon stated that one of the key reasons behind their success is the public's trust in their tax systems. For instance, in Canada, each taxpayer receives an annual breakdown of where their taxes were spent. In Norway, citizens have access to detailed expenditures of any public project. South Korea's 'Taxpayer Bill of Rights' gives people full awareness and holds the government accountable. As a result, people in these countries willingly and confidently pay taxes.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
9 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Neglected and overlooked: Pakistan's livestock sector seeks government support
Livestock farmers say their sector has a lot of potential but has been severely neglected by the government. It has highlighted the need for a comprehensive policy to export animals and their meat, and said it needs help to scale down energy costs and get proper water supply to pens,. They said if farmers in Sindh and Punjab are encouraged with proper facilities, it will be a game changer in terms of meat export. Talking to Business Recorder, veteran livestock farmer and Memon Dairy Cooperative Farming Society President Jamil Memon said Saudi Arabia procures over 3 million sacrificial animals, including mostly lambs and sheep, during Hajj from Australia and New Zealand as the animals in Pakistan cost 30% to 40% more. Australia produces more and more lambs when it faces drought and farmers are unable to feed them. These lambs weigh between 60kg to 200kg and are disease-free. In order for Pakistan to compete, policymakers must reduce energy costs including gas, electricity and fuel, ensure proper water supply and water connections to pens, remove encroachments and announce incentives for farmers with a view to promoting animal farming and the export of both live animals and meat. Water issues and property rights Memon said local livestock farmers are facing numerous problems. When it comes to a host of pens on the Superhighway (the M-9 motor from Karachi to Hyderabad), 200,000 to 250,000 big animals including cows and buffaloes are present at a number of pens from Sohrab Goth to Kathore, Gadap Town, Malir District in Karachi. However, not a single sweet water connection is allotted to any pen there and farmers have to use groundwater. The 30-year land lease of the Superhighway areas from 1992 to 2022 has expired and farmers are distraught that they have no property rights. Then there is the Bhains /Cattle Colony in Landhi, which spreads to 3,000 acres and has 400,000 animals. Half of the colony is supplied water by Karachi Water and Sewerage Corporation and the rest of the colony farmers have to use groundwater, according to Memon. He added that its 30-year land lease from 1965 to 1995 has also expired, which means farmers have had no property rights for around 30 years. Due to this, commercial farmers and new investors fall prey to confusion which dents confidence. Sindh's potential Meanwhile Sindh Livestock / Animal Husbandry deputy director Dr Mazhar Ali Rind said Sindh small animals and their breeds such as goats, lambs, sheep and others. These exist in large numbers in Shaheed Benazirabad, Matiari, Tando Allahyar, Tando Mohammad Khan, Hyderabad and other districts, while big animals are available in Tharparkar, Badin, Thatta and others. He said Pakistan can produce and export disease-free and healthy animals if certain policies are implemented. For instance, there is a dire need to establish disease-free zones in areas such as Gilgit-Baltistan, Azad Kashmir, Rahim Yar Khan and Tharparkar. Types of livestock farming When it comes to types of animal farming, livestock experts and commercial farmers said there are three types of farming: range farming, intensive farming, and semi-intensive farming. In range animal farming, animals are raised on open land like pastures and various ranges. In intensive farming, animals are raised under proper shades or pens in a confined area while in semi-intensive farming, animals are reared on open land for some hundred meters and enclosed with metal fences to protect them from predators.
Business Recorder
2 days ago
- Business Recorder
Sharjeel reviews arrangements of grand musical show
KARACHI: Sindh Senior Minister and Provincial Minister for Information, Transport and Mass Transit Sharjeel Inam Memon, Provincial Minister for Local Government Saeed Ghani, and Karachi Mayor Murtaza Wahab visited the National Stadium Karachi to review arrangements for the grand musical show the Sindh government will organise on August 13 to mark Independence Day. On the occasion, Sharjeel Inam Memon was given a detailed briefing on the arrangements and preparations. Speaking to the media alongside Provincial Minister for Local Government Saeed Ghani and Karachi Mayor Murtaza Wahab, Memon said the Sindh government is organising grand Independence Day celebrations at the district and tehsil levels across the province. He said the resolution for the creation of Pakistan was first moved in the Sindh Assembly and that the Sindh chief minister had formed a ministerial committee comprising representatives of various religious and political parties. Memon clarified that the event was neither the government's nor the PPP's programme, but rather a programme for the entire Pakistan. He said a historic programme had been held in Hyderabad, while a ceremony was scheduled to be held in Sukkur today. He added that the National Stadium has a capacity of 27,000, and all seats had been registered. Sharjeel said only those who had been registered would be allowed to attend the programme, while live broadcasts had been arranged for those unable to register. The Karachi concert, he added, would be shown live on screens in all districts of Sindh. Lauding the poetry recital held the previous night, he said the event in Karachi was historic, adding that the entire city has been decorated like a bride for Independence Day. Memon urged citizens to show discipline and help make the programme a success. He said a large contingent of police and Rangers would be deployed at the stadium for security, while separate entry arrangements would be made for women and families. A comprehensive traffic plan and a shuttle service would also be in place for the musical concert. He said the entire nation had inflicted a crushing defeat on India, adding that the Indian Air Chief had made false claims the previous day about shooting down Pakistani planes, whereas the whole world recognised Pakistan's victory. In response to a question Inam Memon said the PTI had chosen August 5, observed as Yaom-e-Istehsaal Kashmir, to stage a protest in order to create chaos. He said people were no longer willing to come out for Imran Khan, though expensive advertisements were being placed in The New York Times for this purpose. He added that the government wanted the PTI to participate in the Independence Day celebrations. In response to another question, he said mischievous elements attempting to disturb the megacity's peace would not be tolerated under any circumstances, and the designs of a few conspirators would be foiled. He added that the government would not be intimidated by such actions. Inam Memon said both 'Sahib' and 'Bhai' are respectable terms, adding that the old era would not return and the government would not allow it to. He said action would be taken against anyone involved in wrongdoing, and if someone burnt a vehicle in anger, a case would be registered against them under Section 7 of the Anti-Terrorism Act (ATA). He added that anyone spreading a wrong message would be stopped firmly, and the politics of hatred would not be allowed to take root in the city. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
2 days ago
- Business Recorder
Transporters call off strike after successful talks
KARACHI: The talks between the Sindh government and the transporters went successful, after which the transporters decided to end their protest. A delegation of transporters, led by Haji Yousaf and Jan Alam, leaders of the Dumper Association, called on Sindh Senior Minister and Provincial Minister for Information, Transport, and Mass Transit Sharjeel Inam Memon at the Commissioner House in Karachi. Karachi Commissioner Syed Hassan Naqvi, Secretary Transport Asad Zamin, Karachi Police Chief Javed Alam Odho, and other officials were also present. During the meeting, Memon expressed deep sorrow and grief over the loss of lives in a recent dumper accident and strongly condemned the violent incidents that followed. He said that the Sindh government will prioritise resolving the legitimate issues of the transporters; however, violence and vandalism are not the solution to any problem. He assured that steps will be taken, in coordination with all parties, to prevent such incidents in the future. He clarified that cases will be registered under the Anti-Terrorism Act against those who took the law into their own hands and incited riots. On this occasion, Memon directed dumper owners to ensure that cameras, trackers, insurance, and driver's licenses are mandatory in all dumpers. Additionally, a committee is being formed to assess the losses suffered by the transporters. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
