O'Donovan has ‘no notion' of abolishing TV licence fee or replacing it with tax on tech companies
Patrick O'Donovan
has insisted he has 'no notion' of abolishing the TV licence fee or replacing it with a tax on
big tech
companies.
Mr O'Donovan was responding in the Dáil to
People Before Profit (PBP) TD
Paul Murphy
, who described the licence fee as a 'regressive, unjust tax' where the richest and poorest households pay the same €160 fee.
Mr Murphy said increasing numbers are 'boycotting' the licence as he asked the Minister to instead tax the social media and technology giants to fund public service broadcasting.
'No, I won't, so that's the end of that,' said Mr O'Donovan. 'I have no notion of doing it. This is a fund that's in place to support RTÉ and public service broadcasters.'
READ MORE
It also supports the 'sound and vision' sectors, he said.
'I have no intention of replacing it and I have no intention of going down a cul-de-sac that Deputy Murphy would like us to do, which is a road to nowhere for RTÉ and everybody associated with broadcasting,' the Minister said. 'So the short answer is no.'
Mr Murphy said the 'tax is deeply unpopular and
licence sales have plummeted
'.
He said 950,000 paid in 2022. That figure dropped to 825,000 in 2023 and to 790,000 in 2024.
Mr Murphy said that was a fall of more than 155,000 households 'who are refusing to pay either in protest or because they cannot afford to pay this regressive flat tax, which takes no account of ability to pay'.
[
Why I stopped paying my TV licence fee: 'The whole model is broken'
Opens in new window
]
The Minister replied that 'the licence fee is not a tax. I don't see references to that anywhere in the legislation'.
Describing it as an 'important funding mechanism for RTÉ,' Mr O'Donovan said Mr Murphy seems 'to think that there's a phantom entity out there that can pay for everything'.
Mr Murphy said the licence accounted for just more than a third of funding for public service broadcasting.
He said his party's proposals included a 'radical plan' to increase funding for public service broadcasting by taxing big tech corporations.
Mr Murphy said they had a 'parasitical role' in journalism, not creating content but getting most of the advertising from it and it 'clearly makes sense to allow them to pay'.
'I'll continue to support those who refuse to pay the TV licence, and I warn you that that number is increasing,' he said, adding that the number of prosecutions was also dropping.
'You're entitled to start whatever campaign it is you want to start to undermine another public service,' Mr O'Donovan replied. 'I don't support it… and I don't think most people do either.'
He said if Mr Murphy gets an opportunity to be in government, he will 'actually see that there's more to running a public service than a megaphone'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Letters to the Editor, August 20th: On the long wait for Leaving Cert results, loving bikes, and Maurice for the Áras
Sir, – This week my family, like many others, is nervously awaiting the CAO offers on August 27th. We are trying not to worry about the 6,000 additional applicants, and how this will affect points for our daughter's chosen university programmes. We also know that we can do nothing to address the unfair playing field that is the points race. Leaving Certificate results continue to be artificially inflated, whereas our daughter, who completed the European Baccalaureate examination in Brussels will not benefit from any post-marking adjustment. READ MORE Most of all, we are amazed that Ireland treats its young people so poorly. How can it be acceptable that Leaving Certificate results are only published on August 22nd, offers made five days later, and students and their families are expected to organise themselves to start their studies in just a couple of weeks? All this in a country experiencing a massive housing crisis. Ireland is an outlier in this regard. Our daughter received her European Baccalaureate results in the first week of July. Similarly, across most European countries, students obtain their results in late June or early July. Most of our daughter's friends accepted university places at European universities months ago, and they have had time over the summer to secure accommodation in student residences or in private apartments. Whereas, our daughter and all Irish students are stuck in a limbo all summer and then faced with a stressful mad scramble. Why can we not treat our young people and their families better? – Yours, etc, DR VICTORIA BRUCE, Brussels, Belgium. Connolly and the presidency Sir, – I was baffled to read your reporting on Saturday (August 16th)regarding Catherine Connolly's views on our Defence Forces. Deputy Connolly states: 'They are not, and should never become, an army. Armies fight wars. Ireland does not need an army.' This is quite odd, given that our Defence Forces consist of the Army, Navy, Air Corps, and Reserves. While lamenting that they are 'increasingly militarised' Deputy Connolly also states that, 'Our Defence Forces exist to protect our people and our sovereignty.' How is it intended that they will serve this function without being 'militarised' and without being willing to fight a (defensive) war? Lastly, Deputy Connolly lists among countries that we 'cannot trust' France, England (sic) and the United States. Yet she is insistent that these permanent members of the United Nations Security Council should retain a veto over deployment of our Defence Forces. These confused and contradictory views are concerning for a candidate aspiring to be Supreme Commander of our Defence Forces. – Yours, etc, DAVE McGINN, Naas, Co Kildare. Sir, – Congratulations on making a page one story from the fact that Catherine Connolly TD, our only confirmed presidential candidate at this stage, believes Ireland 'cannot trust' the United States, Britain and France when it comes to international law. After witnessing almost two years of the horror in Gaza, which has been armed and funded by the United States, Britain, Germany, France and others, it is hardly shocking that a vocal campaigner for peace is willing to condemn the US in particular, as the country which could have stopped the genocide in an instant. Not only has the US armed, funded, supported and abetted the slaughter of civilians in one of the most crowded places on earth, which is half the size of Co Louth, it has repeatedly used its veto at the United Nations Security Council to block attempts to bring some relief to the traumatised people of Gaza. At the same time, we are seeing protesters in their 70s and 80s in the United Kingdom getting arrested and threatened with imprisonment for the terrible crime of wearing Palestine Action t-shirts at protest marches and demonstrations. Meanwhile, there does not seem to be any consequences at all for the UK-based arms companies who supply weapons to Israel or the UK pilots who fly recognisance flights on behalf of the army which is dropping the bombs on displaced civilians in tents every day. I would be appalled if any candidate for the presidency of Ireland felt that these countries have a 'moral compass' left at this stage, – Yours, etc, CIARAN TIERNEY, Galway city. Maurice for the Áras? Sir, – It was with great joy that I read Maurice Manning's letter on Monday (August 18th). It brought me back to his lectures in UCD, extremely well attended, as he imparted knowledge, a witty raconteur, while, practically as ever, reminding us he did not like correcting exams in August. While his analysis is certainly correct, there is much merit to a quiet life, I also feel that his companions in Smyth's were on to something and 'Maurice for the Áras' would have us all feeling the benefit had he decided on that path instead. – Yours , etc, NIAMH BYRNE, Fairview, Dublin 3. Trump and Mr Magoo Sir, – For some time I have mused over the dominant personality within Donald Trump. I have narrowed it down to two, both of which were on display as he welcomed Volodymyr Zelenskiy and European leaders to the Oval Office. On the one hand we have the daydreaming Walter Mitty, self-mythologising as heroic and admired, the most successful business man, greatest dealmaker and settler of wars. On the other we have Mr Magoo, recklessly oblivious to reality, ignoring facts, stumbling from faux pas to faux pas, miraculously escaping the reproach rightly to be expected after such egregious behaviour. Overall, I think Mr Magoo wins. – Yours, etc, PAT MURPHY, Co Wicklow. Ryanair responses Sir, – Ryanair's response to Pricewatch in relation to their 'minors policy' was unpleasant insofar as it was insulting, abusive and derogatory toward their customers and Mr Pope. If you take out the unpleasant bits, the answer to the questions remains unchanged. I must assume that the insulting, abusive and derogatory bits are also company policy and this is why they were included. One wonders if the unpleasantness policy is mandated by the board of the company or simply its executives? And also, what purpose it serves? – Yours, etc, ROB STRUNZ, Scariff, Co Clare. Sir, – I don't believe it. Ryanair is set to increase the number of seats out of Ireland by 15.5 per cent this winter. ('R yanair adds 600,000 seats to Irish winter schedule ,' August 16th). In the midst of rising temperatures and numerous wildfires in Europe, Ryanair are actually planning to increase the amount of warming greenhouse gas they are pumping into the atmosphere. What kind of insanity is this? – Yours, etc, CELESTINE O'REILLY, Foxrock, Dublin. Portiuncula Hospital Sir, – I understand that five separate reviews identified serious concerns with maternity care at Portiuncula Hospital in Co Galway. In these circumstances it seems difficult to understand why people are arranging protests to demand the restoration of such services at the same hospital facility. – Yours, etc, BILLY HANNIGAN, Limekiln, Dublin 12. Older people and large houses Sir, – Lorcan Sirr plays an old record when he posits that 'owning a large house doesn't mean you are wealthy'. ('Older renters are particularly vulnerable amid Ireland's housing crisis,' August 18th) He (or the headline writer) asks 'Who is anybody to tell an older person that their house is too big for their needs?' – a loaded question if ever there was one. Our constitution rightly guarantees property rights; however, the simple fact is that most pensioners are currently receiving benefits (pension and health) far in excess of the contributions they have made to the PRSI system. Asset inflation on the other hand means their housing assets are worth far in excess of what they paid (with no Capital Gains Tax and minuscule property tax). It's instructive that social welfare means testing explicitly excludes the principal private residence, but modest savings of a renter are included. Pity the younger 'generation rent' working and paying high rates of income tax to fund the pensions of the propertied generation. It is also a pathetic reflection on Ireland's banking and legal establishment that bridging finance is absent; my suspicion is that since being stung during the boom, banks are focused on simple lending where they will not be required to bring drawn-out court cases against obstinate 'hard luck cases' when things go awry. – Yours, etc, MATTHEW GLOVER, Lucan, Co Dublin. You, me and my lovely bike Sir, I am writing in response to Sean Mooney (You, me and my lovely SUV, Letters , August 18th)) and to declare my undying and unconditional love for my bicycle. I am unapologetic about its practically non-existent running costs, superfluous health benefits and ability to park almost anywhere. I sit, pedalling past queues of traffic in smug satisfaction that I am not harming the health of the local population with toxic fumes or accelerating climate change with CO2 emissions. I arrive at my destination at a time not dictated by traffic and muse on my most recent journey in an SUV. Sitting sedentary in traffic, watching my bank balance drain as the fuel empties, inhaling toxic chemicals and listening to inane rubbish and endless advertisements on the radio. Sean's claim about tax being applied to whatever is popular is patently wrong – nobody in Amsterdam pays a tax to cycle. His claims of improved safety and lowest ever emissions are conspicuous for their lack of evidence. This answer as to why is simple – there is none. Marginally improved emissions may be applauded, only for the fact the number of cars on Irish roads has almost doubled in the past 25 years, obliterating any benefit in this regard. The sad reality is that the world is burning. We need urgent affirmative action, unity and meaningful discourse. Instead, we get outlandish opinions published in an effort to drive engagement through outrage. I cannot tell who is most at fault in this sorry exchange – Mr Mooney for his views, The Irish Times for promoting them, or me for rising to the bait. – Yours, in hope of a world where we are all better than this. EANNA MULVIHILL, Ashtown, Dublin. Carbon credits and promises Sir, – If last week's opinion article in The Irish Times is to be believed ('A wolf in sheep's clothing, the false promise of carbon credits', Science & Climate, August 14th), carbon markets 'almost always fail' and offer nothing but false promises. That makes for a strong headline, but it's far from the truth. The article's author, Karol Balfe of ActionAid Ireland, calls carbon markets a 'moral failure'. But I've seen them keep forests standing, fund schools, and put food on the table, especially in local communities in the Global South. We can't both be right, so let's look at the evidence. Balfe claims that carbon markets 'almost always fail to provide any real climate benefit,' citing the Guardian newspaper article that claimed 90 per cent of rainforest offsets certified by Verra were 'phantom credits.' However, Nature Climate Change found these projects have a solid scientific basis. Cambridge researchers say REDD+ slows deforestation in high-threat regions. And independent rating agencies call the Guardian's figures 'hugely overstated.' Balfe's most troubling claim is that projects 'have a history of failing to deliver for communities' in the Global South, particularly in Africa. As someone from Africa, and the CEO of the world's leading carbon standards body, I can tell you this is simply not true. Yes, like in any market, there have been missteps in some carbon projects. Yes, like in any market, there have been bad actors and even lawbreakers. That's true of every sector in the world. But to dismiss the entire mechanism as something that 'simply does not work' is an oversimplification that does more harm than good. I can't help but wonder if critics of this 'failed' system have visited carbon projects. Like the TIST programme in Kenya, where farmers have planted 26 million trees and funded food, schools, and resilience. Or Pakistan's Delta Blue Carbon project, restoring 600,000 hectares of mangroves, creating 15,000 jobs, and sequestering 142 million tonnes of CO2? These aren't failures. They are real projects, delivering measurable climate benefits and life-changing community impacts every day. Here's where we can agree with Balfe though: carbon markets must keep improving. They must be transparent, deliver tangible benefits, and have mechanisms in place that weed out bad actors. On that, there's no disagreement. But her proposed 'alternatives' (rapid decarbonisation, progressive taxation, vast increases in public climate finance, and fully funded just transitions) read more like a wish list than a workable plan. Of course we need all of those things. The question is when and how? These measures are politically stalled, chronically underfunded, and often decades away from they ever arrive. Meanwhile, communities facing climate impacts today cannot eat promises of future taxation reform. They cannot replace lost livelihoods with unfulfilled finance pledges. And they cannot wait for the 'perfect' system while their forests are being cut down right now. The hard truth is this: we don't have the luxury of pitting one solution against another. We need rapid decarbonisation and high-integrity carbon markets. We need public finance and private capital flowing through proven mechanisms that already deliver results on the ground. Balfe wants to throw away one of the few functioning tools we have . Well-run carbon projects deliver every single day. The alternative isn't just worse. It's unthinkable. Yours, etc. MANDY RAMBHAROS, CEO, Verra, Washington. Not a record Sir, – Mairéad Cashman spotted an open ham sandwich on a menu in a restaurant in Co Clare last week, priced at €22.50 and wonders if this is a record ? ( Letters, August 19th ). No, this is a rip off. €7.50 would be a record. – Yours, etc, PATRICK O'BYRNE, Dublin 7.
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on Ireland's economic position: not as good as it looks
The decision by The Economist magazine to exclude Ireland from its annual ranking of the world's richest countries is not the first time comparisons of this kind have sidelined the State's economy, Even official EU statistics now sometimes leave out Ireland, particularly when looking at trends in trade. And private sector analysts often exclude Ireland when looking at Europe-wide indicators. Should we be upset? Not really. The problem, as the Economist puts it, is that Ireland's economic data is 'polluted by tax arbitrage.' Multinationals organise their tax affairs to declare as much profit as possible in Ireland, helped by accountants who are , as the magazine said , 'as versed in the arts of surreal creativity as James Joyce.' Ireland argues, with some justification, that these companies have ' substance' here – in other words they employ people and produce goods or services from Ireland. However, the extent of the profit declared here is well in excess of what would be justified by this activity. And so, on a range of estimates, as much as half of Ireland's corporate tax take may be 'windfall' – not directly related to activity here – and our Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is very significantly inflated. Does this matter? It complicates analysis of Ireland's economy and more meaningful assessments now use other modified aggregates. Had the Economist included Ireland in its list of GDP per head, it would have been somewhere in the top half dozen countries. A more realistic measure would put Ireland in the middle of the European pack. READ MORE Unfortunately, Ireland's out-of-kilter data has created another problem. It has put the State in the spotlight internationally, including in the White House, where there has been focus on Ireland's trade surplus with the US, due almost entirely to pharma exports. The Irish GDP and trade figures may not reflect the scale of real activity here, but they do show major pharma production in Ireland for the US market and the impact of the associated aggressive tax planning. In that way, Ireland's mangled figures do still tell a real story.
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
Protesters demand action to ensure entry to Ireland for Palestinian students
Dublin college students staged a protest outside the Department of Foreign Affairs on Tuesday, demanding the Government facilitate the evacuation of students from Gaza to take up places in Irish universities. The Representative Office of Ireland, in Ramallah, provides 30 scholarships to Palestinian students to pursue one-year master's degrees in Ireland through a programme with Irish Aid . Others receive supports from individual Irish universities, called 'sanctuary scholarships', which often include waived fees and a monthly stipend. Students from Trinity College, University College Dublin, Dublin City University and the National College of Art and Design gathered at Iveagh House where they called on the Government to 'make good on its promise to Palestinian students, both current and future'. READ MORE In July, nine Palestinians arrived in Ireland to begin their studies this September; however, protesters claim more than 40 others remain trapped in Gaza with no clear path to Ireland. 'With few safe passages out of Gaza, these students are being left cruelly stranded by the Government that invited them here in the first place,' the coalition of students' unions said in a joint statement. Ibtisam Abuhassira, who has called on the Irish Government to evacuate her son and husband from Gaza, at the protest in Dublin. Photograph: Bryan Meade Speaking on the steps of Iveagh House, Harry Johnston, chair of Trinity College Dublin's boycott, divestment and sanctions group – a student-led pro-Palestinian organisation with no affiliation with the university's administration – said Minister for Foreign Affairs Simon Harris and his department were failing those due to arrive on campuses. 'We're here today to demand that sanctuary scholarship students, people who have been promised places in Irish universities, will be allowed to take up those places,' he said. 'We have to do better as a nation that has experienced forced famine and the same displacement that is affecting Palestinians right now.' Hazen Griffin, from UCD's students' union, accused the Government of 'playing games' with the lives of affected students by not evacuating them immediately. 'To grant a student fleeing war and genocide a place at a university in another country with no extra support or financial help is nothing short of despicable,' he said. Mr Griffin read from correspondence the UCD union received from a Gazan student due to begin studying in Dublin. 'On August 18th, 2024, an Israeli air strike destroyed my family's home while we were inside. My father and brother were injured. It was the hardest night of the war,' the letter read. 'My dream is to study biomedical engineering. Growing up in Gaza, I witnessed hospitals without electricity, life-saving equipment broken and a lack of spare parts, and patients dying while awaiting basic treatment.' The student said he had witnessed his father suffering in hospital with no way to receive the correct treatment. 'That experience strengthened my commitment to pursue biomedical engineering, not just for myself, but for anyone going through similar tragedies.' [ Student with place on UCD master's course still awaiting evacuation from Gaza Opens in new window ] Independent Senator Alice-Mary Higgins told the demonstrators that the Gazan students 'have done the impossible work of earning scholarships, of being accepted to universities, of continuing to envisage a future when they are living in a place moment by moment, when all they are surrounded with is death'. She said she took issue with being told by the Department of Foreign Affairs that she should appreciate that the embassy has limited resources to support non-Irish citizens. 'We don't appreciate that and we don't accept it. 'The idea that the workload of an embassy and a few staff is so difficult that they can organise evacuation for nine students but not for 40 is outrageous. What really that language is hiding is a rollback on decency,' she said. In response, the department said it was aware of the 40 Palestinian students and was providing consular assistance. A spokeswoman said individuals must be in possession of valid visas and travel documents in order to travel to Ireland. 'Exit from Gaza is dependent on receipt of permission from the relevant local authorities, both in Israel and, in certain circumstances, neighbouring jurisdictions. Such permissions are outside the control of the Government of Ireland.'
