Stockport slam officials after Leyton Orient playoff draw: ‘Worst decision in 15 years'
The Stockport manager Dave Challinor attacked 'the worst decision I have seen in 15 years of management' after Leyton Orient salvaged a late draw in a pulsating and controversial League One playoff semi-final first leg at Brisbane Road.
Charlie Kelman put the home side ahead on 30 minutes when he slotted home from six yards, with the officials failing to spot he was clearly in an offside position when the ball was flicked on by Omar Beckles. The video assistant referee system will be in use for the final at Wembley but has not been deployed in any of the semi-finals.
Stockport turned it round after the break through a penalty by Ollie Norwood and a Fraser Horsfall header but Kelman struck from the penalty spot late on to leave the tie in the balance going into the second leg at Edgeley Park on Wednesday.
Challinor said. 'Massive kudos to our players for reacting in a positive way to a decision which was the worst I've seen in my 15 years of management in what was the biggest game of my managerial career.
'I've not spoken to the referee or linesman as of yet but the processes are all completely wrong. That was an absolute shocker. When someone is four yards offside that's really worrying. I can understand now why there is a scramble to get robots involved and stop human error because incidents like today cannot happen.
'People are putting tens of millions of pounds into football and things can be dictated by a flag and a whistle and that's not a good place to be.'
Harbottle header gives AFC Wimbledon slender 1-0 lead
Riley Harbottle's second-half goal handed AFC Wimbledon the advantage in their League Two playoff semi-final against Notts County at Meadow Lane.
Harbottle's header gave Johnnie Jackson's men a hard-fought 1-0 victory before next weekend's return at the Cherry Red Records Stadium. County manager Stuart Maynard will feel his side are still in with a chance of reaching Wembley after creating a number of opportunities.
However, Alassana Jatta's dismissal in stoppage time, for a foul on Alistair Smith, could be a damaging blow for the Magpies. PA Media
Challinor's opposite number, Richie Wellens, said he did not have a clear view but 'people have told me it is offside – and if he is offside, just give it offside. We would rather get a genuine goal. I've said it all season that the referees have a huge impact on games at this level. I believe we should have had another penalty, too.'
The visitors had created the better chances in a competitively-fought first period, testing Josh Keeley in the home goal on a number of occasions. Kyle Wootton found himself free in the fifth minute but Keeley raced out to narrow the angle and avert the danger while Will Collar should have done better with a cross when he headed wide.
A powerful drive from Owen Moxon was punched clear by Keeley before Jayden Fevrier, a constant threat down the right, cut inside Brandon Cooper and unleashed a shot which Keeley saved with his feet. But it was Kelman, League One's leading marksman, who opened the scoring on the half-hour mark, converting the flick from Beckles with ease.
Orient were grateful to the crossbar for protecting their lead soon after the interval when a 25-yard thunderbolt by Moxon beat Keeley but Stockport were deservedly back on terms on 60 minutes. Fevrier sent a cross into the box and Rarmani Edmonds-Green handled the ball, although he was being held down by Horsfall. Norwood slammed the resultant penalty into the net. Stockport then took the lead, with Norwood's free-kick headed in by Horsfall in the 65th minute.
The Orient substitute Ollie O'Neill was involved in the leveller on 88 minutes when his shot was adjudged by Ben Speedie to have been handled by Horsfall and Kelman stepped up to send Corey Addai the wrong way. Orient might even have snatched an advantage deep in added time but Beckles volleyed over from four yards.
'As a last game of the season at home I thought it was a great spectacle,' said Wellens. 'It was something the supporters can be proud of, and the players too.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Report: Bobby Madley criticises VAR for removing emotion from football
Report: Referee Bobby Madley Says He 'Hates' VAR's Impact on Football Referee Bobby Madley has delivered a scathing assessment of VAR, stating that he 'hates' the technology and the way it has changed the emotional dynamic of football. Speaking at the Cheltenham Science Festival during an event on technology in sport, Madley expressed frustration at how video assistant referees have affected the in-the-moment joy of goal celebrations. Advertisement 'As a fan, hate it, hate it. Love the Championship, love League One – I'm still a fan,' said Madley. 'I love League One because you score a goal, you look at the referee, you look at the assistant, he hasn't put his flag up, it's a goal. 'It [VAR] takes that emotion away from it and football is a game where there could be one moment in the game, one goal, and that's it. 'To take that emotion away, to have to wait and wait, and what feels like an eternity, as a fan I'm not a huge fan of that experience.' Madley currently officiates in the English Football League and acts as a fourth official in Premier League matches. While VAR is widely used in England's top flight, it has not been introduced to regular EFL fixtures. IMAGO Madley's career and return to English football Madley's career has taken a complicated path. Between 2013 and 2018, he refereed 91 Premier League matches before being dismissed by Professional Game Match Officials Limited (PGMOL) after sending a video that mocked a disabled person. Following that episode, he moved to Norway to officiate in the lower leagues. Advertisement In February 2020, he returned to English football as a National List referee. His return to the top flight has been limited, taking charge of one Premier League game in the 2022-23 season and another in 2023-24. He was not selected for any Premier League refereeing duties during the 2024-25 season. Commercial pressures behind VAR's introduction In his comments, Madley also pointed to the commercial forces driving VAR's implementation. He argued that the technology was introduced not because of fan or referee demand, but due to the financial interests of football's governing bodies and investors. 'There's so much money in football, it's business-driven. So any mistake is perceived to cost people money,' he said. Advertisement 'And I don't think most football fans were clambering over each other to get video technology. 'The players weren't, the referees weren't, but the people who run football, they are multimillion-pound and billion-pound people, and they had issues with referees getting things wrong.' This view brings into focus a larger debate within modern football: whether decisions driven by corporate stakeholders serve the spirit of the game or erode it. Madley's words reflect growing scepticism within the football community about the direction the sport is heading. While VAR was designed to reduce refereeing errors, many argue it has created its own issues by slowing down the game and sapping moments of joy and spontaneity. Advertisement 'I think we've got to the stage where people go, 'Sorry, we're ruining football with this now',' Madley added. 'But we knew the monster that had been created. As referees, we knew what was coming.' His remarks will undoubtedly resonate with many fans, players and even officials who feel the soul of the sport is being sacrificed in the name of technical perfection.
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
Whitehaven to Wembley via Widnes - Wire's route to the Challenge Cup Final
FROM freezing in February to sizzling in spring – Warrington Wolves' run to the Challenge Cup Final has been one for all seasons. There have been quagmires, artificial pitches and the dry tracks speedsters dream of. Routine blow-outs, edge-of-your-seat thrillers and a huge scare survived. Advertisement And after all of that, another Wembley final to savour as Warrington booked their eighth trip to the national stadium in 17 years. Hull KR await but first, let's take a look back at how The Wire set up this mouth-watering final… THIRD ROUND Whitehaven 4-44 Warrington Wolves February 9, 2025 As a result of a change in the competition's format, Super League sides were brought into the fray in a very different way. Third-round ties would be the first competitive action of the year for top-flight clubs, who were also guaranteed to be drawn as the away side against lower-ranked opposition. The Wire's trip to Cumbria to face League One side Whitehaven was probably everything the powers that be were looking for when they made that change as a huge crowd packed into Haven's Ortus Rec to see the big boys come to town. Advertisement As expected, it was a routine victory for Sam Burgess' side on an extremely heavy playing surface. Even if star names like George Williams, Matt Dufty and Paul Vaughan were kept in reserve, Burgess still paid their hosts the respect of naming a strong side including Danny Walker, who was one of four players to score braces. Debutant Oli Leyland was another, with Jake Thewlis and Cai Taylor-Wray also running in two tries each. Haven got their big moment when Jay Weatherill crossed to ensure they were not 'nilled,' but Wire's road to Wembley started serenely. Danny Walker touches down for a try against Whitehaven (Image: Joe Richardson) Advertisement FOURTH ROUND Widnes Vikings 16 Warrington Wolves 26 March 15, 2025 Another trip to lower-league opponents but this one had a completely different feel to it. A first competitive clash with fierce rivals Widnes was a stand-out tie in the fourth round – and Warrington had to survive a huge scare in order to seal their progress. With Burgess' boys struggling to shake off a Las Vegas humbling, the Vikings clearly sensed blood and put in an inspired display, striking first to go 6-0 up early doors and despite Adam Holroyd and Josh Thewlis touching down to edge Wire into a half-time lead, the hosts surged back after the break. Advertisement With 20 minutes to go, Wire were 16-10 down and staring a huge embarrassment in the face but final-quarter tries from Max Wood, Ben Currie and Zane Musgrove spared their blushes. They had just about dodged a bullet, but now they were into the business end of the competition. Wire struggled against neighbours Widnes but eventually ran out as winners (Image: Olly Hassell/ QUARTER-FINALS Warrington Wolves 20 St Helens 12 April 6, 2025 No more messing about, time to get serious… This was the second of three games against St Helens within 34 days either side of two Super League meetings, but it emerged as the most important. Advertisement With both sides struggling to keep pace at the top of Super League, the Challenge Cup emerged as the most realistic chance of the silverware demanded by both fanbases. And after Matt Dufty and Tristan Sailor swapped early tries, a Marc Sneyd penalty plus Ben Currie's try jumped The Wire into a lead they would never relinquish. Things got nervy when Daryl Clark touched down on his old stomping ground to narrow the lead to just two points, but then a moment of genius from George Williams ended the contest as he dummied through the Saints line and sprinted home from his own half. It would be the skipper's last major contribution to the side before being struck down by an ankle injury, but he had brought Wembley into view. Advertisement George Williams finishes off his superb solo try during the quarter-final win over St Helens (Image: Richard Walker) SEMI-FINALS Warrington Wolves 21 Leigh Leopards 14 May 11, 2025 Since the quarter-final, Warrington had experienced an unprecedented run of injuries – one that they are, of course, still feeling the effects of. George Williams, Danny Walker, Marc Sneyd, Matty Ashton and Toby King all went down with injuries of varying levels of seriousness and while the latter three were able to take the field for the semi-final – Sneyd having miraculously recovered from having surgery on a fractured eye socket just 16 days prior – Williams and Walker remained absent. Advertisement Against a Leigh side that had won five games in a row in all competitions who took the lead through a freak Edwin Ipape try inside the first minute, many feared for them. In truth, that was as bad as it got as Wire first dominated and then controlled their way to Wembley. Rodrick Tai and Paul Vaughan crossed in quick succession to put them in command, with Sneyd's boot keeping them at arm's length as Tesi Niu's brace led Leigh's fightback. King – playing on the wing as part of a reshuffle after Ashton, Josh Thewlis and Lachlan Fitzgibbon had all been forced off – touched down to seal victory and leave the primrose and blue army plotting their way to London once again. Paul Vaughan celebrates his semi-final try against Leigh Leopards (Image: Alex Whitehead/
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
Birmingham aim to reach Premier League next year
Birmingham City chairman Tom Wagner says the club are targeting successive promotions and reaching the Premier League next year "is certainly the goal". The League One champions broke the EFL record for most points in a season in 2024-25, and the American businessman told BBC Sport he wants the club to return to the top flight "as quickly as we can". Advertisement With plans for a new stadium handed a major boost on Tuesday, after the government confirmed investment in local transport links, Wagner believes the Blues will be "highly competitive" in the Championship. And he says that is because the club's commercial revenues will be "very close to, if not in line with" those of rivals in receipt of parachute payments. Leicester City, Southampton and Ipswich Town will each benefit from almost £50m next season, having been relegated from the Premier League. Birmingham spent £25m after dropping down from the Championship last year, and Wagner vowed to be "very active in the transfer market" this summer in a bid to build on the progress under "exceptional" manager Chris Davies. Advertisement He added he is open to the idea of clubs playing some cup matches overseas as a means of growing an international fanbase. 'Unique opportunity' A "thrilled" Wagner was speaking after his hopes for a new 62,000-seat stadium to replace St Andrews took a significant step forward, with government funding for a new tramline to a planned £3bn 'Sports Quarter' in the east of the city. The club's owners, US investment firm Knighthead Capital - which Wagner founded - wants to build a 125-acre sports and leisure complex on abandoned land in Bordesley Green, and have been trying to persuade ministers to grant the West Midlands billions of pounds to fund new transport links for the regeneration project. Advertisement Now that has been achieved, he says the aim is for the "transformative" Sports Quarter - which will also include a 20,000-seat arena, hotel and training complex for the club's men's, women's and academy teams - to be open by 2030. "We needed the transport links to ensure the site was viable," said Wagner. "This will be an entertainment venue unlike many others in the world." "We have a unique opportunity. If you look across western Europe you'd be hard pressed to find another city with that much land available... where a project of this magnitude could be created. Advertisement "This will be a venue that is used 365 days a year, we'll create 8,500 jobs... the goal would be to host a whole range of international events, not solely football but American football, rugby." Seven-time Super Bowl champion Tom Brady is a minority owner of Birmingham City. When asked if there was a risk that the new stadium would result in higher ticket prices for supporters, Wagner said: "If you price out the fans that are here you have different people sitting in the stands, you lose the singing, you lose the passion and then you've lost your product. "We have to remember this is a club of the people and that means the solution for growing commercial revenue is not solved through ticket prices, it's solved through making a better product." Advertisement Last year, Birmingham City's former chief executive Garry Cook said it would be "a great idea" if they played a league match against fellow US-owned club Wrexham on American soil. "I don't think that it makes sense to do it necessarily with regular-season matches," said Wagner. When asked what he thought about potentially playing some domestic cup matches in the US, he said: "It's something that has to be thought of. "When you think about the top-tier clubs in the Premier League, they're competing globally, which means that they have to have global fans and global-scale revenue, and if that means playing some matches overseas to create more following and revenue for the club I think that's a good thing. Advertisement "You have to find a way to do it that doesn't take away from your local community, so it's very much a balancing act. There's a very fine line that needs to be walked there, but I think for the top clubs it's something that has to be seriously considered. "Perhaps there's a different tournament, or something that happens that allows for that, maybe at a different point in time in the season. There's a whole series of ways that could be pursued beyond simply the pre-season tours." When asked what assurances he could give to fans concerned about the number of English clubs now controlled by US investors, Wagner said: "The reason Americans are drawn to investing here is because it's English football. "If we 'Americanise' it, then it's lost everything that drew people here in the first place."
