Appeals court orders new trial for man convicted in 1979 Etan Patz case
Pedro Hernandez has been serving 25 years to life in prison since his 2017 conviction. He had been arrested in 2012 after a decadeslong, haunting search for answers in Etan's disappearance on the first day he was allowed to walk alone to his school bus stop.
The appeals court overturned the conviction because of an issue involving how the trial judge handled a jury note during Hernandez 2017 trial — his second. His first trial ended in a jury deadlock in 2015. The ruling says that the judges concluded that the state trial court's instruction was not only 'clearly wrong' but 'manifestly prejudicial'
The court ordered his release unless the state gives him a new trial within a reasonable period to be set by the lower court judge.
Emily Tuttle, a spokesperson for the Manhattan district attorney, said 'We are reviewing the decision.'
Harvey Fishbein, an attorney for Hernandez, declined to comment when reached Monday by phone.
Hernandez was a teenager working at a convenience shop in Etan's Manhattan neighborhood when the boy vanished.
Hernandez, who's from Maple Shade, New Jersey, later confessed to choking Etan. But his lawyers said he was mentally ill and his confession was false.
Etan was among the first missing children pictured on milk cartons. His case contributed to an era of fear among American families, making anxious parents more protective of kids who many once allowed to roam and play unsupervised in their neighborhoods.
'Through this painful and utterly horrific real-life story, we came to realize how easily our children could disappear,' said Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus R. Vance Jr., a Democrat who made a 2009 campaign promise to revisit the case if elected.
The Patzes' advocacy helped to establish a national missing-children hotline and to make it easier for law enforcement agencies to share information about such cases. The May 25 anniversary of Etan's disappearance became National Missing Children's Day.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
28 minutes ago
- The Independent
Landlord jailed for decades in hate-crime attack on Palestinian American family has died
A landlord jailed for decades after he attacked a Palestinian American boy and his mother has died. Three months ago, Joseph Czuba was sentenced to 53 years behind bars for the attack. He was found guilty in February of murder, attempted murder and hate-crime charges in the death of Wadee Alfayoumi and the wounding of the boy's mother, Hanan Shaheen. The 73-year-old Czuba targeted them in October 2023 because of their Islamic faith and as a response to the war between Israel and Hamas, which started days earlier. Czuba died Thursday in the custody of the Illinois Department of Corrections, the Chicago Sun-Times reported, citing the Will County Sheriff's Office. The law enforcement agency did not return a call seeking comment on the death. Ahmed Rehab, the executive director of Council on American-Islamic Relations' Chicago office, said in a statement on Saturday that 'this depraved killer has died, but the hate is still alive and well.' Evidence at trial included harrowing testimony from Shaheen and her frantic 911 call, along with bloody crime scene photos and police video. Jurors deliberated less than 90 minutes before handing in a verdict. The family had been renting rooms in Czuba's home in Plainfield, about 40 miles (64 kilometers) from Chicago when the attack happened. Central to prosecutors' case was harrowing testimony from the boy's mother, who said Czuba attacked her before moving on to her son, insisting they had to leave because they were Muslim. Prosecutors also played the 911 call and showed police footage. Czuba's wife, Mary, whom he has since divorced, also testified for the prosecution, saying he had become agitated about the Israel-Hamas war, which had erupted days earlier. Police said Czuba pulled a knife from a holder on a belt and stabbed the boy 26 times, leaving the knife in the child's body. Some of the bloody crime scene photos were so explicit that the judge agreed to turn television screens showing them away from the audience, which included Wadee's relatives. The attack renewed fears of anti-Muslim discrimination and hit particularly hard in Plainfield and surrounding suburbs, which have a large and established Palestinian community. Wadee's funeral drew large crowds, and Plainfield officials have dedicated a park playground in his honor.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Lifeguard, 23, arrested at airport over allegation of rape at idyllic summer camp
A foreign lifeguard at a religious summer camp in New York has been arrested over an alleged rape. Manuel Escalera Ibanez, a native of Madrid, Spain, was dramatically apprehended while waiting to board an international flight on Monday night, The Shelter Island Reporter reported. The 23-year-old was on a J-1 work visa with Camp Quintent, a summer camp owned and operated by New York Conference of The United Methodist Church. He was arrested this week after he was accused of rape at the Shelter Island camp. The alleged attack was reported a day before his July 21 arrest. It is unclear who reported the crime to police, but camp officials stressed the alleged victim is not a camper. Escalara Ibanez was taken into custody at 10.22pm at Kennedy Airport as he waited to board an international flight by Shelter Island Police detectives, officers from the Suffolk County District Attorney's office and Homeland Security Investigations. He was charged with Felony Rape in the First Degree, and Criminal Obstruction of Breathing or Blood Circulation, a misdemeanor. Police said an order of protection was issued on behalf of the alleged victim, Newsday reported. He was also ordered by the court to surrender his passport. If released, he must remain in New York State under the further direction of the court. Police said an order of protection was issued on behalf of the alleged victim, Newsday reported. He was also ordered by the court to surrender his passport. If released, he must remain in New York State under the further direction of the court. Currently, he is being held at the Suffolk County Correctional Facility in lieu of $150,000 cash bail, $200,000 bond or a $500,000 partially secured bond. Escalara Ibanez traveled from his native Spain to the United States for work. He was on a J-1 visa, a non-immigrant visa that allows for participation in work- and study-based programs in the country. Other jobs include, a part-time referee for indoor soccer matches in schools throughout the community of Madrid. He is also a senior technician in sales and commercial space Management and transportation and logistics, and works, as per his Linkedin profile. The camp issued a letter to 'Quinipet Families' informing them of the alleged disturbing event. 'We are genuinely saddened about a recent incident. The incident occurred between camp sessions when no children were on-site and did not involve any campers.' 'This matter is the subject of a criminal investigation, and we are cooperating with local law enforcement in this regard.' 'At Quinipet Camp & Retreat Center, the safety, care, and enrichment of every child and staff member are central to our mission. 'We uphold rigorous, longstanding safety protocols and regularly review our policies to ensure that all staff meet or exceed national standards and have met with our staff to once again remind them of our safeguards and compliance practices.' 'We understand that families and members of our community may have questions. However, out of respect for the integrity of the ongoing investigation, we will not be providing further comment at this time. 'We remain firmly committed to providing a safe, nurturing, and enriching environment for all who come to Quinipet. 'Thank you for your continued trust and support as we navigate this difficult time with transparency, compassion, and full resolve.' The camp and retreat center celebrated its 75th anniversary this year. Located on 25-acres in the northwest shore of Shelter Island and is approximately 3.5 hours away from New York City.
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
With a guilty verdict overturned, will Etan Patz's murderer ever be punished?
Decades after six-year-old Etan Patz disappeared while walking to school in New York City, stirring widespread public fear in the US about leaving children unattended, his family felt they got some justice when Pedro Hernandez was convicted of murder in 2017. Now that closure has also vanished. On 21 July, a federal appeals court overturned the guilty verdict. The court stated that the judge in the murder trial was 'clearly wrong' and 'manifestly prejudicial' in his response to a jury note concerning Hernandez's alleged confessions. Hernandez should either face a new trial or be released, the court ruled. And so, it is again an open question of whether there will ever be a resolution to Etan's case, which was a seminal event in US criminal history as it started a movement to help find missing children and caused many Americans parents to watch their kids more closely. 'This case has endured for so many decades, it's almost like there are generations of people that learn about it all over again,' said Lisa R Cohen, a journalist who wrote After Etan: The Missing Child Case That Held America Captive. 'It's going to have an effect on any young parent,' Cohen added. On 25 May 1979, Etan's mother, Julie, allowed him, for the first time, to walk to a bus stop just a couple of blocks away in Manhattan's SoHo neighborhood. After he didn't come home at 3.30pm, Julie learned he never made it to school and reported him missing. Police spent weeks searching for him. His body has never been found. 'I'm not sitting around doing nothing but mourning and thinking of revenge,' Etan's father, Stan, said, according to an excerpt from Cohen's 2009 book. 'But I've also waited 30 years to get justice for Etan. I'll wait as long as it takes.' The stories of Etan and another child, Adam Walsh, inspired a movement to prevent the abduction and murder of adolescents, according to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children. In 1983, then president Ronald Reagan marked the anniversary of Etan's disappearance by declaring the date National Missing Children's Day. Etan's face also appeared on billboards and milk cartons. Before Etan's disappearance, 'kids played after school and came home for supper and no one was tracking every move', Cohen said. 'And then there is the time after Etan, when everything changed. It was a zeitgeist moment.' A suspect, Jose Antonio Ramos, emerged a few years after Etan went missing, but law enforcement officials initially declared that he was not connected to the crime. A federal prosecutor later treated him as a prime suspect and pursued him. A convicted pedophile, Ramos admitted that he tried to molest the child but said he did not kill him. He was never charged with Etan's disappearance, but his parents won a $2m wrongful death lawsuit against Ramos in 2004. Then, in 2012, Hernandez, who worked at a bodega near the Patz's home, confessed that he lured Etan to his store by promising him a soft drink and took him to the basement and strangled him. His parents became convinced that Hernandez, not Ramos, was the killer, A jury deadlocked on the Hernandez murder trial in 2015, but in a 2017 retrial, the jury found him guilty. 'The Patz family has waited a long time, but we've finally found some measure of justice for our wonderful little boy, Etan,' Stan Patz said at the time. 'I'm really grateful that this jury finally came back with which I have known for a long time that this man, Pedro Hernandez, is guilty of doing something really terrible so many years ago.' But during the investigation, Hernandez had initially confessed after seven hours of questioning from police, who did not read him his Miranda rights against self-incrimination, according to court documents. Only afterwards did police issue them, and he then repeated his confession. During the second trial, the jury asked the judge to explain whether, if the jury found that Hernandez's first confession was not voluntary, it must disregard the later confessions. The judge said no. Sign up to Headlines US Get the most important US headlines and highlights emailed direct to you every morning after newsletter promotion The appeals court ruled that the directive was wrong. David Schwartz, a former prosecutor in New York, said the judge's answer 'was certainly not harmless error' and 'really is contrary to the law of confessions'. 'You certainly want justice to be done for this tragic case, but on the other hand, we have to uphold the integrity of the criminal justice system and fair trials,' he said. Etan's parents have not commented on the case since Hernandez's conviction, the New York Post reported, and it does not appear that they have responded publicly to the appeals court ruling. Louis K Meisel owned an art gallery on the block between the Patz's home and the bus stop and knew the family 'very well', he said. 'It's one of the biggest mysteries, and we're never going to know the end and the answers,' Meisel said. Cyrus Vance Jr, the former Manhattan district attorney who oversaw the two trials, told the New York Times after the ruling that he was 'surprised and saddened for the Patz family'. 'I was certainly convinced myself that Pedro Hernandez killed Etan Patz, and I think that today,' Vance said. Emily Tuttle, a spokesperson for the Manhattan district attorney said: 'We are reviewing the decision.' Schwartz, the former prosecutor, thinks the district attorney would have a difficult time retrying Hernandez. 'The confession was really at the heart of the case,' Schwartz said. 'Unless there is new evidence somehow, which is very unlikely, I'm not sure they are going to be able to retry.'
