How SA's old coal mines can offer hope for dying towns
A recent analysis at University of Cape Town (UCT) highlights the potential for abandoned coal mines to serve as platforms for sustainable job creation and economic regeneration.
The study conducted by Nicola Wills, senior economist and an PhD candidate in economics at UCT, revealed that South Africa has almost 6 000 abandoned mines – including more than 300 coal sites – which pose risks such as acid mine drainage, water pollution, land degradation and greenhouse gas emissions.
Risks and opportunities
Wills said the deficient rehabilitation and restoration of abandoned and closed mines 'presents risks, but also opportunities to create jobs'.
Wills said the sites have potential to create sustainable jobs, economic diversity and community resilience in the context of the just energy transition (JET).
She said there were proven innovations in rehabilitation showing that the land where the mining activities took place could be rehabilitated and used for agricultural purposes.
'Mining contamination in Mpumalanga has posed a major challenge for crop cultivation, but innovative rehabilitation techniques are proving that land can be restored for sustainable agriculture – an outcome once thought impossible.
'The Mafube water reuse project [2017– 2020, with phase 2 beginning this year] demonstrated that irrigating virgin land with mine water produced high-quality maize with yields (14.5T/ha) nearly doubling those of dryland crops (8T/ha).'
ALSO READ: Half of SMEs may not survive the next year without urgent help
'Similarly, the Wonderfontein winter wheat project [2021] showed that mineaffected land and water improved crop performance, yielding higher outputs than virgin soil while meeting necessary safety standards,' Wills said.
'Mpumalanga has also partnered with Coaltech and the Mpumalanga Green Cluster Agency to repurpose mining land for biofuels, industrial hemp and renewable energy.'
'Economic collapse'
The Mining Affected Communities United in Action (Macua) welcomed the study.
National coordinator Sabelo Mnguni said the findings reaffirm what mining-affected communities have long advocated for, that JET must be locally grounded, socially just and community-led.
'For decades, mining-affected communities have shouldered the environmental, health and economic burdens of coal extraction with minimal benefit and limited recourse.
'The UCT study rightly notes that Mpumalanga alone houses thousands of households dependent on coal income and with mine closures looming, the spectre of economic collapse is real.
'Yet, these same communities now face exclusion in discussions about rehabilitation, reuse and investment decisions related to JET. This is unacceptable.'
ALSO READ: South Africa gets R8.4 billion loan to help fix and improve its energy sector
Mnguni said the study's evidence, from biofuel farming to mine water reuse for crop cultivation, demonstrates that repurposing mining land can be economically viable.
He, however, said Macua emphasises the interventions must be developed with, not for, communities.
'Local people must be the first beneficiaries of job creation and training. Financing and access remain key barriers as the allocation of R181.9 million for rehabilitation is a step forward, but if coal sites are not prioritised, this funding risks reinforcing historic inequities.'
'Income generating activity'
Mining expert David van Wyk also welcomed the study.
'As long as energy is privately owned, the transition will not be just. The various mining voids are filling up with water.
'This poses a major risk of acid mine water decanting into surface water and eating away the dolomitic substructure of urban areas causing dangerous sinkholes.
'This water can and should be treated to a point where it can be used in industry. This offers another job creating and income generating activity for dying mining towns.'
NOW READ: 'We know it's wrong, but they're trying to make a living,' say families of arrested illegal miners
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
21 hours ago
- The Citizen
How SA's old coal mines can offer hope for dying towns
Rehabilitation projects in Mpumalanga show that former coal mines can be revived for farming, biofuel production and renewable energy initiatives. A recent analysis at University of Cape Town (UCT) highlights the potential for abandoned coal mines to serve as platforms for sustainable job creation and economic regeneration. The study conducted by Nicola Wills, senior economist and an PhD candidate in economics at UCT, revealed that South Africa has almost 6 000 abandoned mines – including more than 300 coal sites – which pose risks such as acid mine drainage, water pollution, land degradation and greenhouse gas emissions. Risks and opportunities Wills said the deficient rehabilitation and restoration of abandoned and closed mines 'presents risks, but also opportunities to create jobs'. Wills said the sites have potential to create sustainable jobs, economic diversity and community resilience in the context of the just energy transition (JET). She said there were proven innovations in rehabilitation showing that the land where the mining activities took place could be rehabilitated and used for agricultural purposes. 'Mining contamination in Mpumalanga has posed a major challenge for crop cultivation, but innovative rehabilitation techniques are proving that land can be restored for sustainable agriculture – an outcome once thought impossible. 'The Mafube water reuse project [2017– 2020, with phase 2 beginning this year] demonstrated that irrigating virgin land with mine water produced high-quality maize with yields (14.5T/ha) nearly doubling those of dryland crops (8T/ha).' ALSO READ: Half of SMEs may not survive the next year without urgent help 'Similarly, the Wonderfontein winter wheat project [2021] showed that mineaffected land and water improved crop performance, yielding higher outputs than virgin soil while meeting necessary safety standards,' Wills said. 'Mpumalanga has also partnered with Coaltech and the Mpumalanga Green Cluster Agency to repurpose mining land for biofuels, industrial hemp and renewable energy.' 'Economic collapse' The Mining Affected Communities United in Action (Macua) welcomed the study. National coordinator Sabelo Mnguni said the findings reaffirm what mining-affected communities have long advocated for, that JET must be locally grounded, socially just and community-led. 'For decades, mining-affected communities have shouldered the environmental, health and economic burdens of coal extraction with minimal benefit and limited recourse. 'The UCT study rightly notes that Mpumalanga alone houses thousands of households dependent on coal income and with mine closures looming, the spectre of economic collapse is real. 'Yet, these same communities now face exclusion in discussions about rehabilitation, reuse and investment decisions related to JET. This is unacceptable.' ALSO READ: South Africa gets R8.4 billion loan to help fix and improve its energy sector Mnguni said the study's evidence, from biofuel farming to mine water reuse for crop cultivation, demonstrates that repurposing mining land can be economically viable. He, however, said Macua emphasises the interventions must be developed with, not for, communities. 'Local people must be the first beneficiaries of job creation and training. Financing and access remain key barriers as the allocation of R181.9 million for rehabilitation is a step forward, but if coal sites are not prioritised, this funding risks reinforcing historic inequities.' 'Income generating activity' Mining expert David van Wyk also welcomed the study. 'As long as energy is privately owned, the transition will not be just. The various mining voids are filling up with water. 'This poses a major risk of acid mine water decanting into surface water and eating away the dolomitic substructure of urban areas causing dangerous sinkholes. 'This water can and should be treated to a point where it can be used in industry. This offers another job creating and income generating activity for dying mining towns.' NOW READ: 'We know it's wrong, but they're trying to make a living,' say families of arrested illegal miners
The Citizen
5 days ago
- The Citizen
Homeowners caught in solar registration grey zone
While City Power encourages voluntary solar registration, homeowners remain confused as Eskom and municipalities apply different rules. There is still uncertainty surrounding registration of home solar systems, with either Eskom or municipalities, as Johannesburg's City Power confirms its meter readers are scouting for the locations of such systems. Randpark residents said this week that meter readers had been asking about solar power systems and had been seen photographing rooftop solar panels on houses. City Power begins checking solar systems City Power spokesperson Isaac Mangena said City Power was in the process of registering small-scale embedded generation systems such as rooftop solar photo-voltaic installations. 'While registration is not yet being enforced, customers are strongly encouraged to begin the process voluntarily to ensure compliance with National Energy Regulator of SA (Nersa) regulations,' he said. Mangena said meter readers visiting households were conducting standard meter audits that may include noting the presence of rooftop solar panels or related infrastructure. 'This is part of routine data collection,' he said. Mangena said City Power was developing measures to identify unregistered systems in the future, including the possible use of satellite and drone-based detection, he said. 'There is currently no official or forced registration drive underway,' he said. An off-grid does not have a connection that ties the generator to the Eskom electricity distribution network. This type of configuration does not need authorisation from Eskom or Nersa registration. Information and graphics: Eskom 'Grid safety' Mangena said Nersa's licensing threshold was 100kVA, which means systems below this capacity are exempt from requiring a generation licence. However, this does not exempt them from the obligation to register with the distributor, in this case, City Power. 'The focus on smaller suburban setups is aligned with national guidelines and City Power's obligation to maintain grid safety, stability and visibility of all systems connected to its network. ALSO READ: South Africa gets R8.4 billion loan to help fix and improve its energy sector 'Even small systems can pose risks such as back feeding, phase imbalances or grid disturbances if not registered and properly integrated,' he said. Mangena said about 1 100 systems have been voluntarily registered. 'City Power is working to simplify the process. Registration requires customers to submit documentation, including a certificate of compliance, single-line diagram and a completed electricity supply application form. 'Once the installation is inspected and approved, the customer may qualify for a smart bi-directional meter, which will allow for both consumption and feedback tracking,' he said. Generation systems already connected to the grid can take advantage of battery storage. This means being able to store solar energy generated during the day and using it at night. Information and graphics: Eskom Eskom and City Power have different registration routes Eskom launched a campaign in April to help residential owners of small-scale embedded generation systems, including photovoltaic installation systems, comply with the National Energy Regulator of South Africa (Nersa) regulations. These regulations require all owners in Eskom-supplied areas to register with Eskom. Eskom has, however, referred owners of solar systems in non-Eskom-supplied areas to their local municipality. Eskom's registration demands rejected While Organisation Undoing Tax Abuse (Outa) CEO Wayne Duvenhage said Outa would challenge Eskom's decision, AfriForum has added fuel to the fire and maintained that Eskom's registration requirements for grid-tied solar power systems have no legal basis. AfriForum local government affairs manager Morné Mostert said Eskom could not threaten or force people to register their systems through statutory requirements, nor fine them. Mostert added that Eskom wants its hands on people's data – potentially for solar tariffs in the future. AfriForum advisor for local government affairs Deidrè Steffens said what frustrates people is that Eskom's underperformance over the past few years has forced people to install solar panels, especially industries and farmers, who had to do it for survival. ALSO READ: Are municipalities failing — or are residents just unable to pay? Why many are turning to off-grid living In this generator network configuration, any surplus generated energy may be exported into the type of grid-tied generator connection requires Eskom authorisation and registration with Eskom or Nersa. Information and graphics: Eskom Concerns over high costs and engineer bottlenecks 'It has already cost them a lot of money. Now they will have to pay an extra R20 000 to R50 000 for the engineer's certificate,' she said. Steffens said it didn't make sense for an engineer to inspect a small solar system, adding that Eskom's requirement that small-scale embedded generation systems customers get an electrical engineer registered with the Engineering Council of SA to sign off on the system was not a prescribed requirement. 'The enforceable National Rational Standards say nothing about the requirement for engineer sign-off; it primarily speaks of an accredited technician who must sign off on the system.' Steffens warned that it could create a bottleneck because only a handful of electrical engineers are available across the country to inspect installations. She said the requirement would cause a big bottleneck in registrations. More confusion as municipalities apply own rules Association for Renewable Energy Practitioners president Carel Ballack said each municipality has its own rules. 'There are 177 municipalities that can sell power. Eskom is just one of the utilities that have its own rules for connection,' he said. Ballack said it depended on the municipality and on how thoroughly an installation has been done. 'If you were to register through Eskom, that will be about R2 500 for the administration fee and then Eskom will send someone to look at the infrastructure. They'll probably change the meter. That's R6 000 and upwards. 'Then you must have other compliances in place. If you don't have an engineer sign-off, that can set you back R4 500 for the line diagrams and sign-off.' NOW READ: Identifying the bugs in SA's long-promised infrastructure boom
The Citizen
5 days ago
- The Citizen
What Eskom's solar registration campaign means
Eskom and City Power insist solar registration is vital for protecting infrastructure and planning the country's future energy mix. In its campaign to get households to register their solar systems, Eskom emphasises that 'unauthorised grid-tied generators can endanger the lives of operating staff, the environment, equipment and the quality of electricity supply'. Association for Renewable Energy Practitioners president Carel Ballack said the registration was a safety function. 'If the municipality shuts down power in the area to maintain the electrical infrastructure, they needed to know whether there was a chance that a generator [tied to the grid] would start up somewhere and the changeover switch wouldn't function and the generator would push power back to the municipal supply line,' he said. Ballack said regulator Nersa utilised generation capacity to determine the energy mix for the power supply going forward. 'They use the growth of solar to determine how the mix is going to affect all the other sources they have,' he said. Nersa's data supports energy planning, not taxation – yet 'We would be able to argue that we could use that data to apply taxes,' Ballack said. 'But to understand that, you would have to look at different municipalities and that each municipal region had its own rates and those rates had to be approved by Nersa. Nersa is not necessarily the entity that would be taxing users for using the electrical infrastructure,' he said. ALSO READ: South Africa gets R8.4 billion loan to help fix and improve its energy sector Ballack said the issue was that electricity has become a human right. 'You have at the bottom of the income chain those who are getting electricity for free because it is a human right, while Eskom has to maintain the infrastructure for the portion,' he said. 'There's a percentage of the population that doesn't pay for electricity at all and the issue is that those who can pay are being burdened to pay for those who can't.' Proper registration stressed City Power spokesperson Isaac Mangena said the organisation had an 'obligation to maintain grid safety, stability and visibility of all systems connected to its network'. 'Even small systems can pose risks such as back feeding, phase imbalances, or grid disturbances if not registered and properly integrated,' he said. Mangena said registration ensured technical compliance and protects both customers and infrastructure. He said everyone with solar – regardless of size – had to register. 'All customers with solar PV systems connected to City Power's grid are required to register their systems, regardless of the size or capacity,' he said. ALSO READ: City Power denies claims its headquarters raided by Hawks 'This applies to grid-tied and hybrid systems. The registration process allows City Power to assess technical specifications, ensure the installation meets safety and regulatory standards and avoid potential risks to the grid. 'Even if a system does not export energy back to the grid, registration is still required to ensure full visibility of energy generation within the network.' Mangena said City Power will not provide bi-directional meters at no charge and customers will be responsible for the cost of the meter and its installation. These would enable customers who had spare generation capacity to feed back into the grid – and be paid for it. Implementation timelines Mangena said the procurement of a service provider to implement the feed-in tariff incentive is still underway, and would take four to six months once the service provider is appointed, after which further implementation timelines will be communicated. City of Tshwane spokesperson Selby Bokaba said: 'Customers who are not interested in back-feeding energy into the grid are still required to register their systems with the municipality by completing the relevant application forms. 'Although the city encourages customers to feed excess energy into the grid, only customers with installed bi-directional meters can export excess energy into the city's grid.' NOW READ: Ekurhuleni mayor to suspend electricity tariff hike after protests in Thembisa
