Clashes and arrests in Turkey over magazine cartoon allegedly depicting prophet Muhammad
The clashes occurred after Istanbul's chief prosecutor ordered the arrest of the editors at LeMan magazine on grounds it had published a cartoon that 'publicly insulted religious values'.
The magazine's editor-in-chief, Tuncay Akgun, said the image had been misinterpreted.
'This cartoon is not a caricature of prophet Muhammad in any way,' he told Agence France-Presse. 'In this work, the name of a Muslim who was killed in the bombardments of Israel is fictionalised as Muhammad. More than 200 million people in the Islamic world are named Muhammad.
'[It] has nothing to do with prophet Muhammad. We would never take such a risk.'
As the news broke, several dozen angry protesters attacked a bar often frequented by LeMan staffers in downtown Istanbul, provoking angry scuffles with police, an AFP correspondent said.
The scuffles quickly became clashes involving between 250 to 300 people, the correspondent said.
Founded in 1991, LeMan is famed for its political satire and has long been the bane of conservatives, especially following its support for France's Charlie Hebdo after its Paris offices were attacked in 2015 by Islamist gunmen who killed 12 following the magazine's publication of caricatures of the prophet Muhammad.
The interior minister, Ali Yerlikaya, said on that X police had arrested the cartoonist responsible for the image as well as LeMan's graphic designer.
'The person named DP who made this vile drawing has been caught and taken into custody,' he wrote, adding: 'These shameless individuals will be held accountable before the law.'
Others named in the arrest warrant were LeMan's editor-in-chief and its managing editor, media reports said.
In a string of posts on X, LeMan defended the cartoon and said it had been deliberately misinterpreted to cause a provocation.
'The cartoonist wanted to portray the righteousness of the oppressed Muslim people by depicting a Muslim killed by Israel, he never intended to belittle religious values,' it said. 'We do not accept the stigma imposed on us because there is no depiction of our prophet. It takes a very malicious person to interpret the cartoon in this way."
'We apologise to our well-intentioned readers who we think were subjected to provocations.'
The justice minister, Yilmaz Tunc, said an investigation had been opened on grounds of 'publicly insulting religious values'.
'Disrespect towards our beliefs is never acceptable,' he wrote on X. 'No freedom grants the right to make the sacred values of a belief the subject of ugly humour. The caricature or any form of visual representation of our prophet not only harms our religious values but also damages societal peace.'
Istanbul's governor, Davut Gul, also lashed out at 'this mentality that seeks to provoke society by attacking our sacred values'.
'We will not remain silent in the face of any vile act targeting our nation's faith,' he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Middle East conflict could force Formula One to move two races
Formula One has acknowledged that both the Qatar and Abu Dhabi end-of-season grands prix could be relocated if conflict in the Middle East intensifies. The likelihood of an emergency switch is being played down but F1 executives are in daily contact with promoters and have a contingency plan. With four races now held in the region, Stefano Domenicali, the F1 chief executive, said the championship is inevitably exposed to 'geopolitical risk'. 'Of course we are monitoring in the area that there are very unfortunate conflicts, and we are exposed on the promotional side, mainly in the Middle East,' he said. 'We are in daily contact with their promoters there.' After air strikes in the past month involving Israel, Iran and the US, Domenicali maintained 'we have a plan'. He said, however, that promoters are 'not worried at all' that the races are currently in danger. When asked to clarify whether there is a genuine risk of the races being moved, he added: 'So far, we don't have this kind of signal, and so we are really hoping not. I don't want to even think about it, mainly for the bigger picture, not for the racing itself.' An F1 spokesman added that contingency plans were always in place for global events, pointing to scheduling changes made during the pandemic. 'It's definitely serious' The latest Foreign Office advice following a ceasefire between Israel and Iran on June 24 states that travellers must 'stay up to date with events in the region'. Domenicali said: 'We're talking about human beings and bombs, so it's definitely serious. But of course, when we consider all the things, we consider the safety devices that are in place. 'Remember, two years ago there was the Houthi attack in Saudi Arabia – we then went there because we were sure about the guarantee that we had in terms of safety. It was guaranteed to the system that we were moving there. So of course, it's a judgment that we will take with the right people, the right knowledge.' Domenicali, who will be part of an F1 delegation at Downing Street on Wednesday, added in a wide-ranging London briefing ahead of the British Grand Prix that the Silverstone race is here to stay. He did, however, say he would ask the Prime Minister about helping the sport with logistical challenges post-Brexit, such as visa difficulties for staff flying in from Europe for the week. 'We need to make sure that all the people related to the ecosystem of F1 can come to perform their duties with no limitation,' he said, 'because they are part of a group of thousands that are moving for the races.' Business is booming for F1 and Domenicali, 59, is contracted as chief executive until 2029. The sport claims to be worth £12 billion to the UK economy annually. Domenicali, who was team principal at Ferrari between 2008 and 2014 before becoming chief executive of Lamborghini in 2016, will make the case to Sir Keir Starmer for Silverstone's need for improved road infrastructure ahead of the record attendances anticipated this week. While cities globally bid to become F1 destinations, the Italian, who succeeded Chase Carey as F1 CEO in 2021, says Silverstone can remain on the calendar 'forever'. 'I do believe that, in that respect, Silverstone has the right characteristics to stay forever in the calendar because there's no other places where you can develop such a huge event in the UK,' he said. 'I don't see any other places.' Ahead of his Government meeting, Domenicali said his intention was 'keep the centricity of UK in our ecosystem' – with 6,000 people directly employed in the UK in the sport. Last year Silverstone produced the largest attendance of any event on the F1 calendar, with 480,000 fans. That number is expected to be beaten by Sunday.
Telegraph
2 hours ago
- Telegraph
Labour's pick for equalities chair backs gender-critical feminists
Labour's choice to be the next chairman of the equalities watchdog has championed the right of women who oppose gender ideology to speak out. Dr Mary-Ann Stephenson said 'freedom of expression' was very important to her, as she spoke out against women being 'harassed or sacked from their jobs for peaceful expression of legally protected beliefs'. Appearing before MPs and peers, she criticised trans rights activists' attempts to 'no platform' women's rights groups as part of their 'attempts to close down debate'. Dr Stephenson, the director of the Women's Budget Group, is the Government's pick to lead the Equality and Human Rights Commission when Baroness Falkner, the incumbent, steps down later this year. 'Attempts to close down debate' But supporters of trans rights have criticised the choice, accusing her of having attended women's rights conferences at which gender-critical views were aired. On Tuesday she was challenged at a joint meeting of the Lords and Commons' equalities committees over her decision to sign a letter calling for open, non-violent discussion on gender issues, a letter which some activists have described as transphobic. 'They were about my opposition to practices of no platforming and attempts to close down debate,' she said. 'I started my professional career at Article 19 which is an international human rights organisation which focuses on freedom of expression. It's a really important value to me. 'I don't think freedom of expression should be an absolute value but it should be restricted in very limited circumstances, and I think that attempts to close down debate in any area is generally a mistake. 'To be honest I think that had we been able to have better dialogue on some of these issues 10 years ago we might be in a better position than we are in now.' Employment tribunal Dr Stephenson defended her decision to donate to a lawyer who was discriminated against at work for opposing trans self-ID. She also donated £25 to the legal fund of Allison Bailey, a barrister who took her chambers to court after they asked her to remove two gender-critical tweets. An employment tribunal found she had been discriminated against after clerks gave her less work to do. 'The donation was very specifically because I was upset at seeing women being harassed or sacked from their jobs for peaceful expression of legally protected beliefs,' she said. Dr Stephenson added: 'The debate has been so toxic that people just stepped away… so you end up with discussions taking place on social media.'
Telegraph
3 hours ago
- Telegraph
The IDF is not just Israel's army: it is a symbol of Jewish self-defence
Anti-Zionists are the edgiest cowards around. Leftists revelled in Bob Vylan's Glastonbury hate rally as a dramatic shifting of the Overton Window in their favour. A throng of middle-class festival-goers led in a chant of 'death to the IDF' by a performer who demanded that Palestine is free 'from the river to the sea' and recalled working for 'f***ing Zionists' – all carried live on the BBC iPlayer, no less. But now Jews are fighting back. Chief Rabbi Sir Ephraim Mirvis has blasted 'toxic Jew-hatred' posing as 'edgy political commentary'. The Jewish Leadership Council declaimed an 'obscene display of extremist hatred'. The anti-Zionists, meanwhile, have argued that Vylan's chant was nothing more than criticism of Israel and its military operation in Gaza. In fact, they say, it is Vylan's detractors who are the real anti-Semites for conflating Israel with Jews. If the Palestinians must be patronised by grandstanding Westerners, they deserve better than these faint-hearted crybullies. Not that the feelings of the Chief Rabbi or communal organisations have any impact on anti-Zionists. Lived experience is sacrosanct for every minority apart from Jews. For a movement that appears to glory in violent rhetoric, when consequences rear their head they fold like a Hamas command centre paid a visit by the Israeli Air Force. They embrace nuance and complexity and all those other traits of the snivelling liberals they scorn. Their anti-Zionism retreats from banner slogans to multi-page footnotes. Yes, they cavil, the IDF is a conscript army made up almost exclusively of Jews, but that doesn't mean calling for its 'death' is a call for death to Jews. (Disparate impact is another doctrine of the Left that applies to every minority except the Jews.) Why do they cry ' death to the IDF'? The Israeli army is civilian led. Why not death to the Israeli prime minister, or the defence minister, or the security cabinet? It is not just a matter of what rhymes. The IDF is not just Israel's army; it is the symbol and the substance of Jewish self-defence and Jewish sovereignty. Without the IDF, there would be no Israel, and this is exactly what they want. Across 2,000 years of exile from their homeland, Jews were reviled, calumnied, excluded, expelled, pogrommed, and exterminated. As the Passover Haggadah observes: 'Not only one has risen up against us to destroy us, but in every generation they rise up to destroy us.' The restoration of Jewish sovereignty in the Land of Israel was about ensuring that future generations had a means of defending themselves. More would come to destroy them, but this time they'd be prepared. Strong Jews, sovereign Jews, Jews you can't push around. For two millennia, these were concepts not merely revolutionary but fantastical. But now they are lived out every day in Israel. Political anti-Zionism is a project to separate the Jewish people from the theory and practice of Jewish self-determination. The Israeli army is all that stands between 'death to the IDF' and 'death to the Jews'.
