Province paid Dr. John Dornan nearly $1.8M in settlement over firing as Horizon CEO
That's 90 per cent of the original record-breaking $2-million payout Dornan was awarded by a labour adjudicator in his unjust dismissal case in 2023, which the province initially appealed.
The amount of the year-old settlement was disclosed for the first time Friday in a written statement from Dornan. Both he and the province had to waive a non-disclosure agreement in order for the amount to be made public.
"As I said during my campaign and now acting as a Minister of the Crown, I am committed to full openness and transparency with the people of New Brunswick regarding the outcome of this case," Dornan said in the emailed statement.
"The total settlement awarded to me was $1,785,000, which was issued on April 18, 2024, with taxes appropriately withheld," he said.
"At the time of my initial dismissal, I received $360,000, which was the equivalent of one year's salary for the position. All associated legal fees and taxes have been fully paid."
The Department of Justice and Public Safety could not immediately say how much money the province spent on its legal fight with Dornan, or whether it's more or less than the $215,000 difference between the settlement amount and his original award.
Dornan now earns $94,523 per year as the MLA for Saint John Portland-Simonds, plus $62,952 per year as the minister of health.
At 'pivotal moment' in career
He filed his grievance under the Public Service Labour Relations Act in the summer of 2022 after then premier Blaine Higgs publicly announced his firing as president and CEO of Horizon during a news conference.
It was part of a larger shakeup of New Brunswick's health-care leadership following the death of a patient in the waiting room of the Dr. Everett Chalmers Regional Hospital's emergency department in Fredericton. Darrell Mesheau, 78, spent about seven hours waiting for care before he was discovered unresponsive by a nurse around 4:30 a.m. on July 12, 2022.
Dorothy Shephard was also replaced as health minister and the boards of both Horizon and Vitalité were removed.
Dornan was only four months into his five-year contract when he was fired. He was "at a pivotal moment in [his] career," he said in his statement.
He had served as interim president and CEO for about seven months when he agreed to take on the role permanently. He gave up his previous position as regional chief of staff for Horizon in Saint John and his endocrinology practice to do so.
"Like any New Brunswicker whose employment is unjustly terminated, I pursued my right to file a claim for unjust dismissal," Dornan said.
"Following due process, the courts determined that my dismissal was indeed without cause, and I was subsequently awarded a settlement for unjust dismissal."
'Mutually satisfactory resolution'
In February 2023, adjudicator George Filliter awarded him special damages of about $1.8 million, representing the value of lost salary, pension contributions and health benefits, plus $200,000 in aggravated damages for "breach of the employer's implied obligation to act in good faith when dismissing him."
It was the largest employment compensation award in the province's history, Dornan's lawyers said at the time.
The province promptly requested a judicial review, seeking to have the award quashed.
But Court of King's Bench Justice Kathryn Gregory upheld the labour arbitrator's decision and awarded Dornan costs of $4,000, plus HST and "reasonable disbursements."
The province subsequently appealed, arguing Gregory "erred in fact and law."
Then in April 2024 — just four days before the case was scheduled to be heard — the province dropped its appeal.
In a statement at the time, then health minister Bruce Fitch said only that the province and Dornan had "reached a mutually satisfactory resolution."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Health Line
3 days ago
- Health Line
When Do You Need to Make an Appointment with a Doctor?
Call an ambulance or go to the emergency room (ER) if symptoms are life threatening or severe. Urgent care is best for mild injuries or illnesses that need same-day attention. Make an appointment with a primary care physician or specialist for all other concerns. Understanding your symptoms or reasons for seeking medical care can help you decide whether to visit a facility that accepts walk-ins or schedule an appointment. The most pressing medical concerns are routed to the ER, which does not accept appointments. During intake, a triage nurse will assess your condition to ensure people are seen in order of medical need. Urgent care facilities are often used as a catch-all for care that can wait a day or two if needed. Although some urgent care facilities accept appointments, they aren't required. You'll likely be seen based on order of arrival. If you have mild symptoms that linger but do not worsen, consider making an appointment with a healthcare professional. This is sometimes known as a 'sick visit.' Follow-up visits for chronic condition management and 'well visits,' which focus on preventive care, are also available by appointment only. Do not make an appointment for emergency medical care In some cases, immediate medical intervention is needed to prevent further harm or fatal complications. ERs are usually open 24/7. Seek emergency medical care if you experience: chest pain difficulty breathing high fever loss of consciousness severe dizziness sudden weakness or numbness uncontrolled bleeding Some of the most common conditions treated at the ER include: accidental overdose alcohol poisoning anaphalaxis burns head injuries large or deep wounds that require stitches seizures stroke suspected fracture or visibly broken bones vaginal bleeding during pregnancy Do not make or wait for an urgent care appointment in severe cases Urgent care facilities have extended hours, accept walk-ins, and are less expensive than the ER. They're ideal for situations that need prompt attention but are not life threatening, such as: Consider making an urgent care appointment for less serious cases You don't have to make an appointment to go to an urgent care center, but it could save you time in the waiting room. You might find it helpful to schedule a same-day or next-day appointment for: burns that do not blister earaches a fever without a rash or other emergency symptoms frequent vomiting or diarrhea painful urination a rash that spreads or becomes painful sore throat Some of the most common conditions treated at urgent care include: ear infections flu food poisoning muscle strains or sprains pink eye sinus infections strep throat urinary tract infections These concerns are typically considered low priority for an ER, but are often too time-sensitive to delay until your usual healthcare professional or specialist has an opening. Make an in-person or telehealth appointment for routine care If you have ongoing symptoms that are not severe, such as joint pain, fatigue, or frequent colds, a primary care physician is the best person to help. Primary care physicians provide comprehensive care, including preventive services and chronic condition management. This includes: Your local health department likely offers free or reduced-fee services. Many community health centers also offer lower cost care, though this may vary depending on the program and location. Telehealth is an increasingly accessible option. You can speak with a healthcare professional via video or phone, wherever you are. This is especially useful for minor illnesses, medication questions, or follow-up visits. If you don't have access to a personal computer or phone, talk with the staff at your local public library. Libraries usually have a computer room or devices that you can check out for free using a library card. Although some online platforms offer discounts for paying out of pocket or advertise rates that are less than a typical copayment or coinsurance cost, it's important to read the fine print. Ensure you understand what your upfront cost is and whether there are recurring charges or membership fees. Ways to take action Seeking medical care should not be overwhelming. Here are some steps you can take to navigate the process more confidently: Track your symptoms: Write down what you're experiencing, when it started, and any patterns you've noticed. This can help you determine when to forgo at-home treatment and seek medical attention. Review your coverage: If you have insurance, it's important to know what your plan covers and what out-of-pocket costs to expect. Many insurers have care navigators who can help you decide where to go. Use online tools wisely: While symptom checkers and search engines can provide basic information, rely on trusted sources like your doctor or established health systems when making decisions. Start small: If you're unsure where to begin, start with a call to a primary care office or a telehealth visit. You can be guided to the right level of care without making unnecessary trips. Consider alternatives: Some pharmacies offer walk-in care for common illnesses like strep throat or minor infections. Ask questions: Do not be afraid to ask your healthcare professional about the necessity of a test, the expected course of your condition, or alternative treatments. Understanding your care can help you feel more in control. Plan ahead: Identify a local urgent care center, find your closest emergency room, and save the name of a telehealth provider. Knowing where to go can save time, reduce stress, and lower your medical bills. The bottom line In some cases, you can choose to wait and see how your symptoms develop before seeking care. For example, a single headache without other symptoms, a sore muscle after exercise, or mild seasonal allergies may not require medical evaluation.
Yahoo
12-08-2025
- Yahoo
Woman Went to Use the Bathroom. What She Found in the Toilet Landed Her in the ER for a Rabies Shot (Exclusive)
'I had like 100 people telling me that I should get a rabies shot,' Alison Doyle tells PEOPLENEED TO KNOW A quick bathroom break for Alison Doyle became a medical emergency She documented the experience on TikTok, prompting viral concern from viewers Her ER visit for rabies shots highlighted the importance of autism accommodations in healthcareWhen Alison Doyle flushed her downstairs toilet one afternoon, she expected the usual swirl of water — not the lifeless body of a tiny bat. The discovery would send her from a quiet laundry day to a Canadian emergency room, and eventually into the center of a viral TikTok moment. 'I went downstairs to do laundry after literally a month of living in this new place,' Alison tells PEOPLE. 'I looked down and it was a baby bat, it was deceased.' Doyle says she rarely uses that bathroom and wasn't sure how long the animal had been there. Still, she pulled out her phone and hit record before flushing the unexpected guest away. Posting the clip to TikTok felt natural for Alison, who has been documenting her daily life online for two years. The response was immediate and urgent. Hundreds of viewers filled her comments, warning her to seek medical attention in case of rabies exposure. 'I had like 100 people telling me that I should get a rabies shot,' Alison says. Surprised by the concern, she called paramedics for advice. They told her she needed to head straight to the ER. 'The likelihood of me contracting rabies is extremely low,' she recalls being told, 'but the percentage of you dying if you do contract rabies and don't actually get help is wildly high.' That warning was enough to push her through the hospital doors, despite the sensory challenges she faces as an autistic person. 'If you don't think I need to be here, I would rather just go home,' she remembers telling a nurse. Navigating a busy emergency room is never easy for her. The bright lights, close quarters and constant chatter can make the experience overwhelming. The nurse's reassurance made a difference. 'She told me that it was good that I came in,' Alison says, adding that the validation helped ease some of her anxiety. Medical staff determined she should start rabies post-exposure prophylaxis immediately. 'The first day you get five shots… then a few days ago I got another shot,' Alison says. Her treatment would require multiple visits, but in Canada, she had an option that worked better for her needs. 'A paramedic can come to my house, and it's free,' she says. 'That's the best thing that's ever happened to me.' Despite feeling sick after the shots, Alison focused on the positives. 'I'm very grateful for the level of care,' she says. 'I can't honestly believe how beautifully accommodated I was.' Alison is autistic level one, meaning she has lower support needs — but, she says, that doesn't mean no support needs. 'I wanted the takeaway for people to be… lower support needs doesn't mean no support needs,' she explains. Her transparency about her needs led to accommodations she calls 'the best I've ever gotten.' Staff placed her in a private family room, where she could wait in a calm environment away from the crowd. 'There was a sofa, an armchair, and I just chilled in there for five hours in the dark,' she says. 'It was the best level of care I've ever received in my entire life.' Before leaving, she was handed a gluten-free banana popsicle — a small but thoughtful touch for someone with celiac disease. The kindness stuck with her long after she got home. She also noticed the support pouring in online, particularly from other autistic people. Still, she points out that the most visible representation in the community tends to be white, like her, and she believes more Black, brown, and Indigenous voices need to be heard. 'Some visibility is better than no visibility,' she says, 'but I think there needs to be a lot more representation within the autistic community.' Her viral moment, she hopes, can spark more awareness. 'Autism is a spectrum,' she says. 'It looks different on everybody and it doesn't have a look.' Her experience reinforced the value of self-advocacy, especially in healthcare settings. 'Advocating for [myself] ended up being the best possible thing I could have done,' Alison says. Never miss a story — sign up for to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. Looking back, she wants others to take rabies concerns seriously. 'If there is a deceased bat in your household, it got in there because it was alive,' she says. 'They have very small teeth… they can bite in a very undetectable way,' she adds. 'If you value your life, go get rabies shots.' Alison's strange afternoon could have ended with nothing more than an odd TikTok upload. Instead, it became a story about health, advocacy and the ways kindness can transform an overwhelming experience. 'Disabilities are disabling, that's why it's called a disability,' she says. 'It means that I have a harder time doing things than the average person based off of how the disability affects me — and that's it.' Read the original article on People
Yahoo
11-08-2025
- Yahoo
I Went To The ER. I Ended Up Handcuffed In The Back Of A Cop Car.
When I finally told someone I was afraid I might hurt myself, I thought I was doing what everyone says to do: 'Ask for help. Tell someone. Don't suffer in silence.' I didn't expect to end up handcuffed in the back of a police cruiser, stripped of my clothes, my rights, and any remaining dignity. I had been struggling. Sleep-deprived and in the throes of a bipolar mixed episode, physically wrecked by chronic illness, and stressed to the max. I didn't want to die, living had just become too painful. When I finally said it out loud, honestly and clearly to a psychiatrist in the ER, I wasn't in any immediate danger. I was asking for help early, while I still could. The plan was agreed on with the consulting psychiatrist: a voluntary admission to a reputable hospital with a decent psychiatric unit. We even made a list of hospitals I was OK with, and two I absolutely was not. I knew from personal experience as a peer support volunteer that one was poorly managed, unsafe and chaotic. The other was underfunded and more like a holding pen for people. I wasn't asking for five stars; I just wanted to avoid any more trauma. But when it came time to transfer me, none of the hospitals we had agreed to had a bed. Guess who did. I refused. Calmly, clearly. I offered to remain in the ER on suicide precautions until a bed opened elsewhere. I was told that was unreasonable because I was 'stable' and the ER is for emergencies. I asked to be discharged to go directly to another hospital, with my partner. I was told that would put me at risk of harm. I was in crisis, yes — but I was asking for help. I did not understand that by self-reporting that I was at risk, I had given away my control. Their solution was to issue a 72-hour Temporary Detention Order (TDO) and force me to go. Two police officers showed up. Quiet. Professional. Still cops. They took my clothes, my phone, my belongings and my autonomy. Strip search. Handcuffs. I was paraded through the hospital in front of patients and staff like I was being arrested ― because I told the truth about being in pain. I have no criminal history. The only time I've been inside a 'correctional' facility was as a peer support volunteer, working with others who were also detained against their will. But now I was being treated like something dangerous, just because I'd admitted I was vulnerable. What followed was one of the worst weeks of my life. The conditions in the psych unit were worse than anything I ever saw in jails. I was locked in my room nearly the entire time. No TV. No books. The food was inedible, and I barely ate. My bed was a wooden plank. My blanket? ONE hand towel. Two hand towels are apparently highly dangerous. I was not permitted to shower unobserved. Related: My roommate, deep in psychosis, spent most of the time arguing with ghosts and screaming at Jesus. He wasn't violent, just suffering. During his brief lucid moments, he was sweet and apologized profusely. It was heartbreaking. There was no therapy. No individual counseling. No structured treatment of any kind. There was an hour of crafts run by a warm and caring volunteer, which was one of the few times I was allowed out of my room. I wasn't consulted about my treatment plan or offered options or alternatives. Just crafts and lithium. Lithium can be incredibly effective for many people in crisis, but has a long list of side effects and risks. Also, in some cases — like mine ― it is simply ineffective. Which, if anyone had cared to listen to me, I could have told them. There is no better historian about me than me. At the conclusion of the 10 minutes I had with my doctor, he was annoyed that I had been TDO'ed there. He agreed that I was experiencing a crisis, but far from an urgent one, and definitely not worth being on his ward for psychotic and violent patients. He knew I didn't belong there, and he wanted me out as much as I did. He also didn't want to medicate me unnecessarily. But he knew how the judge operated. The bipolar TDO checklist was in play. If my lithium levels weren't in the therapeutic range, my clinical status wouldn't matter. Seventy-two hours would then become 30 days. So he said, gently: 'Just take it. Two days. It'll suck, but it's the only way out.' I was less than 24 hours in, and it was already unbearable. So, I agreed, reluctantly. My court-appointed lawyer showed up five minutes before the hearing, also trying to help. He advised me to surrender my Second Amendment rights, not because I posed any danger, but because the judge would require it. If I declined: 30 days. I didn't own a gun and have no intention of ever buying one. I'm something of a pacifist and abhor tools of violence. The lawyer explained that I could later apply to have my rights restored and that it was technically voluntary ... but it might still show up on legal forms, indefinitely. An administrative scarlet letter. A permanent mark from a temporary hold. Related: I reluctantly agreed. But the best time to make consequential legal decisions is NOT during involuntary detainment with only five minutes of legal counsel. And if I was too unwell to make medical decisions, how was I somehow competent enough to waive constitutional rights? If I was well enough to make those decisions, maybe I didn't belong there at all. The judge, barely looking at me or my file, asked if my lithium levels were therapeutic. He asked if I'd surrendered my gun rights. He checked the boxes on his list. He still extended the TDO to 30 days, but allowed a provision for my doctor to override it, which he immediately did. And just like that, I was discharged. No therapy. No plan. No follow-up. Just out. Still in crisis, but now disoriented, sick from the lithium, humiliated, and traumatized on top of it. I left worse than when I entered. Now, when things get bad, when I'm sleep-deprived, when my body isn't working right, when my thoughts start to splinter, I instinctively hesitate to tell anyone. Because now I know that honesty isn't always safe. What happened to me wasn't an outlier. It wasn't a rare failure inside a system that usually works. This IS how the system works. A system that responds to pain and suffering with containment instead of care. A system that substitutes police for therapists, and compliance for healing. So, I'm cautious. If I end up in crisis again, the ER is the last place I would turn. Not unless someone I trust can promise me that I won't be punished for trying to stay alive. That I won't be criminalized for being sick. That the words I say won't be used to take away my voice. I didn't end up in that facility by accident. I ended up there because I'm publicly insured, because I have a chronic illness, because I live in the wrong zip code and asked for the wrong kind of help on the wrong day of the week. Many people, especially those already marginalized, have no trusted provider, no family support, no safety net. And for people in that position, ERs are often the only option, but also the most expensive and the least likely to provide care. And if you're poor, disabled, incarcerated, uninsured, a person of color, an immigrant, identify as a woman or LGBT+, or as part of any marginalized group? The chances that you'll receive actual care drop even further. Yet my story is not a message to stay silent, or to avoid seeking help. It's a message to demand better helpn— and to ask for it in ways that protect your dignity. Start with someone you trust. A partner, a close friend, a spiritual adviser. Someone who truly cares and can walk with you, literally or figuratively. If you have an established relationship with a family doctor or a mental health professional, built on trust, start there. Ask them to help you navigate, to advocate, to hold space. Don't be afraid to ask how providers handle mental health emergencies. Tell your loved ones and providers your wishes if you are ever in crisis. Create a 'Psychiatric Advance Directive.' Put your wishes in writing. Identify who should speak for you, what medications you will or won't accept, what facilities are off-limits. A crisis is not the time to start setting boundaries. Do it now. There are some organizations doing it differently. If you're struggling, The Trevor Project offers 24/7 crisis support and can help you figure out the safest route forward. Or try searching for 'crisis warm lines.' These are peer-run resources — people who've been there, who can help you figure out where to start. No judgment. No police. I can't promise that your experience will be better than mine. But I can say this: You deserve for it to be. We all do. If you or someone you know needs help, call or text 988 or chat for mental health support. Additionally, you can find local mental health and crisis resources at Outside of the U.S., please visit the International Association for Suicide Prevention. This article originally appeared on HuffPost in June 2025. Also in Goodful: Also in Goodful: Also in Goodful: Solve the daily Crossword
