SC dismisses PIL seeking SIT probe on violent protests in Murshidabad over Waqf Act
A bench led by Justice Surya Kant found no reason to entertain the plea and suggested the petitioner to approach the High Court.
'We see no reason to entertain this petition under Article 32 of the Constitution, as the petitioner has an alternative, efficacious remedy to approach the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution', the top-court bench stated in its order.
The plea was filed by one Satish Kumar Agarwal, who flagged the failure of state authorities in discharging their duties/responsibilities to protect the life and property of Murshidabad residents.
The counsel appearing for the petitioner, advocate Barun Kumar Sinha, began his submissions informing the court of the failure of state authorities to investigate the violence that led to the death of people from the Hindu community.
'Because the Police Administration of the State of West Bengal has miserably failed in discharging its duty/responsibility in protecting the life and property of Hindus. The ghastly incident of murder, arson and loot which took place from April 8, 2025, to April 12, 2025, in Murshidabad, West Bengal has caused an exodus,' the counsel said.
The Court, however strongly suggested the counsel to approach the Calcutta High Court, stating that the matter strictly pertains to West Bengal and there is no reason for the top court to entertain such a plea.
'Tell us who is preventing you from going to the High Court. It is the constitutional court having powers even better than the Supreme Court under Article 32 (of the Constitution). The case pertains to only one state..What message does it give to the High Court?' the Court stated.
The counsel further informed the Court about a report issued by the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) in this regard, alleging that various human rights violations had taken place.
'The NHRC report is very disturbing', the counsel said.
After considering the submissions, the Court dismissed the plea, issuing directions for the petitioner to approach the High Court.
'If the Petitioner perceives any threat to his life and liberty, he may file the petition online. The hearing can also take place through Video Conferencing (VC). We direct the High Court (officials) to extend some specialities (to the petitioner),' the bench said.
The bench also remarked that such petitions are filed before the top court, only to create a scene.
'These are only to create a scene. This is all hype being created, we know all this', Justice Surya Kant stated. (ANI)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
27 minutes ago
- Hans India
Rahul Gandhi kicks off ‘Voter Adhikar Yatra'
Patna/New Delhi: Congress leader Rahul Gandhi on Sunday launched the party's 'Voter Adhikar Yatra' in Bihar, a 16-day march covering more than 1,300 km across over 20 districts. The campaign, aimed at protesting Election Commission's Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of the voter list and what the Congress calls 'vote chori,' began from Sasaram and will culminate with a rally in Patna on 1 September. The yatra began from Bihar's Sasaram, with several leaders such as Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge, Pawan Khera, Kanhaiya Kumar and senior RJD leaders, including Lalu Prasad Yadav and Tejashwi Yadav, joining Gandhi for the launch. Rahul Gandhi, in a post on X, wrote: '16 days, 20+ districts, 1,300+ km. We are coming among the people with the Voter Adhikar Yatra. This is a fight to protect the most basic democratic right – 'one person, one vote'. Join us in Bihar to save the Constitution.' The route will take Gandhi through Aurangabad, Gaya, Nalanda, Sheikhpura, Munger, Bhagalpur, Purnea, Darbhanga, Sitamarhi, Champaran, Siwan, Chapra and Arrah, before concluding in Patna. During the event, the Congress MP vowed to expose 'vote chori' and added that the Special Intensive Revision in Bihar was a 'conspiracy' by the Election Commission. The entire country knows what the Election Commission is doing. Earlier, the country did not know how votes were being stolen. But we made it clear in the press conference how votes are being stolen. Whenever the theft is happening, whether in Bihar, Maharashtra, Assam, Bengal, we will catch the theft and working to show it to the people," said Gandhi. "I am telling you from this stage that Vidhan Sabha and Lok Sabha elections are being stolen in the entire country. Their latest conspiracy is to conduct SIR in Bihar and steal the Bihar elections as well by cutting the new votes and adding fake ones. All of us have come to this stage to tell you that we will not let them steal this election," he said.
Hans India
27 minutes ago
- Hans India
CEC junks ‘vote chori' charges
New Delhi: The Election Commission of India (ECI) on Sunday adopted a self-righteous tone, dismissing 'vote chori' allegations by Congress leader Rahul Gandhi in its first press conference since Bihar's controversial Special Intensive Revision (SIR), stating that they are standing like a rock behind the voters. 'Either give an affidavit under oath or apologise to the nation. If the affidavit is not received within 7 days, it means that all these allegations are baseless,' Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar said in response to allegations made by Rahul Gandhi. The CEC stated that the EC takes every possible step to safeguard the voting rights of every citizen in the country, and a deliberate attempt is being made to discredit them. The Commission's press meet comes 10 days after the Opposition leader in a press conference accused the ECI of facilitating widespread electoral malpractice. Rahul Gandi alleged that over one lakh fake votes were registered to aid in BJP's victory in Bengaluru Central Lok Sabha constituency in the 2024 Parliament elections. He had also accused the election body of attempting to steal Bihar's Assembly elections. Following his press conference, the ECI had accused the Congress leader of using 'dirty phrases' against them. 'The EC is not scared of such allegations, and neither are the voters. I want to make it clear that the EC will without bias stand like a rock with women, poor, young, voters of the country,' he said, adding that the allegations are tantamount to insulting the Constitution. On questions regarding allegations of undue haste in SIR, the ECI said they are misleading. "The law says that such revisions are to be done before the polls," the CEC said. "In Bihar, in 2003 an SIR was done. It was done successfully then, it would be done successfully now," he added. When asked about voter irregularities in Kerala and Karnataka, the CEC said, 'If no candidate had a problem even up till 45 days after the election concluded, then it is clear to all voters what the intent is.' Gyanesh Kumar also said that unlike the special summary revision, the SIR is an attempt to purify the rolls by giving to each voter an enumeration form. Responding to a question on why the ECI is determining eligibility, Gyanesh Kumar said that it was being done to ensure that the Article 326 of the Constitution is not violated.
Indian Express
an hour ago
- Indian Express
August 18, 1985, Forty Years Ago: Punjab election
Punjab will go to the polls on September 22 to enable a popular government to be installed in the state before October 5, when the present term of President's Rule expires. The Punjab Assembly, which was earlier under suspended animation, stood dissolved on June 26 last year. The present term of President's Rule expires on October 5, andto extend it, the Constitution has to be amended. Opposition reacts The announcement of elections in Punjab evoked mixed reactions from political parties. While the Bharatiya Janata Party and the Congress (S) welcomed the announcement, the CPI (M) felt it was not a proper decision and 'unfortunate'. In separate statements, J P Mathur, member of the national executive of the BJP, and K P Unnikrishnan, Congress (S) general secretary, hoped the decision had been taken after careful consideration of all aspects of the situation. Harkishan Singh Surjeet, CPI (M) politburo member, said the elections should not be held immediately. Agitation continues The All-Assam Students Union and the All-Assam Gana Sangram Parishad will continue their non-cooperation with the caretaker government to be formed in Assam after dissolution of the legislative assembly. Sri Lanka massacre Over 200 Tamils were killed in two villages near Trincomalee in Sri Lanka as security men and armed hoodlums went berserk for the second day, violating the ceasefire agreement. According to the Eelam National Liberation Front and the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam spokesmen, the securitymen and armed civilians entered the villages, pulled out the residents of the houses and shot them dead.
