South Korea's Supreme Court clears ‘Baby Shark' song of plagiarism
With its catchy lyrics, the 'Baby Shark Dance' video is the most viewed on YouTube, with more than 16 billion views, roughly double those of the runner-up, 'Despacito', and third-place 'Wheels on the Bus'.
At its peak in 2017, the song also climbed as high as number 22 on the Irish Singles Chart.
In 2019, New York composer Johnny Only, whose legal name is Jonathan Wright, filed a lawsuit in Seoul, alleging that the 2015 hit 'Baby Shark' by South Korean education startup SmartStudy copied a song he had released in 2011.
Only demanded 30 million won ($21,700) in compensation, accusing the firm of copying elements of his work, including its bassline and rhythm.
SmartStudy, now known as The Pinkfong Company, argued that its version was an adaptation of a classic North American children's tune that is not protected by copyright.
A South Korean lower court initially cleared the company of the charges at a trial in 2021, finding that there was insufficient evidence of copyright infringement.
Advertisement
That ruling was upheld by an appeal court in 2023.
Only then challenged the 2023 decision, but South Korea's Supreme Court affirmed the lower court rulings today.
'All appeals were dismissed and the lower court's rulings were upheld,' according to court documents seen by AFP.
The Pinkfong Company said in a statement Thursday that the Supreme Court's decision confirmed 'Baby Shark' was 'based on a traditional singalong chant that has entered the public domain'.
The company said it had given 'a fresh twist to the chant by adding an upbeat rhythm and catchy melody, turning it into the pop culture icon it is today'.
Only did not immediately reply to an AFP request for comment.
He told Canadian public broadcaster CBC in 2019 that he had created a toddler-friendly version of 'Baby Shark' in 2011, revising the original song, which was about a gory shark attack.
'I was the first one that did that (rewriting the song), you know? And basically Pinkfong's version does the same thing,' he said in the interview.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
Artist and filmmaker Jenny Brady: ‘My seven-year-old son's train obsession has led us down many YouTube rabbit holes'
Jenny Brady is a Dublin-based artist and filmmaker, exploring ideas around speech, translation and communication. Her newest work The Glass Booth/An Both Gloine is at Project, Dublin.
Irish Examiner
6 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Preparing ahead for back-to-school lunchbox snacks
AFTER the long, lazy, languid holidays, we're coming close to returning to school day structures, timetables — and the oft-dreaded lunchboxes. The coming weeks are an ideal time to plan and get organised, particularly in the back-to-school snack department. There are times when it feels as if children are fuelled by snacks. Even if your kids' school is involved in the hot school meals programme, they will still need to eat at small break, have something to keep them going when they come home from school, and perhaps a grab-and-go bite before sports activities. Caught on the hop, parents can be easily persuaded to part with hard cash for brightly packaged, smartly marketed, ultra-processed foods. This is where Galway-based chef Lou Robbie can help. Published this summer, her book Make & Freeze: The Ultimate Guide to Family-Friendly Meal Prep features many ideas, savoury and sweet, for parents worried about snack time. A professional chef, Robbie is well-practised at feeding people of all ages, with a particular focus on family-friendly options. With a BA in culinary arts from Atlantic Technological University (ATU, formerly GMIT), she started her culinary career in Galway restaurants Cava and Ard Bia@Nimmos, then worked in The Kitchen in Galway City Museum for eight years before it closed during the pandemic. Without a restaurant to work in, Robbie applied her training and skills to the home kitchen, feeding her two children: Maeve, now 10, and Hamish, who is seven. In 2021, she set up her own business —Little Lou Cooks — to teach online cooking classes to adults and children, while sharing recipes and batch-cooking tips on Instagram. A simple Instagram reel of Robbie making and freezing batches of her mini-scones, oat bars, energy balls, and savoury muffins for school lunchboxes went viral in 2023, striking a chord with parents who wanted to add more homemade food to their kids' diets. 'That's when my page blew up,' she says. She gained 77,000 followers from that reel — her total is now 920,000. 'That's what really resonated with people, being able to batch-make snacks, whether they're sweet or savoury, portion them into bags, label, and freeze them,' Robbie says. 'It's what I've always done since my daughter started preschool.' She knows that it's important to make plenty; fresh baking is always irresistible. 'If you like a recipe, then double it up. 'There's no point in making just 12. Make 24, so at least half of them will get to the freezer. Put them into bags, label and freeze to be defrosted as you need them.' While the freezer can be a neglected kitchen appliance, a stopping off place where food is deposited for a time before it heads to the rubbish or composting bin, Robbie uses it in a much more proactive way. It's a lesson that she learned from her grandmother and mother. At the packed Galway launch of Make & Freeze, Robbie spoke of how her granny used to bake, portion, and freeze loaves of homemade bread, making the point that batch cooking frees the cook from being tied to the kitchen every day. 'It's about helping people to save time and money,' says Robbie. 'I want these recipes to be accessible for parents to cook for their kids … with ingredients that are easy to find in supermarkets. My recipes aren't cheffy, and hopefully they'll be recipes that people will make time and time again.' Lou Robbie working in her kitchen at home in Galway focusing on back to school food prep which are illustrated in her cookbook. Photo: Ray Ryan Planning is key Along with chapters on pre-portioned savoury or sweet items that can be frozen for lunchboxes — think mini bacon and cheese quiches, pizza scones, pea mint and feta pancakes, or easy oat bars, apple/banana/carrot muffins, and nut-free energy balls — Robbie includes chapters on breakfasts, slow cooker dinners, air fryer favourites, family pies, and breads. Lots of recipes include nutritious ingredients such as oats — she is a big fan — seeds, vegetables, dried and fresh fruit, and pulses. A section entitled 'sneaky sweet stuff' involves using squash in chocolate mousse, chickpeas in blondies, and energy balls with lentils. All recipes have instructions on storage, freezing, and defrosting, which is where some of us can come unstuck. 'We're often great at filling the freezer,' laughs Robbie, 'we're not always the best at remembering to take things out.' For her, planning is vital: 'We make our lunches the night before and every night we defrost for the next day because it's just too rushed on school mornings. Everything is too hectic, and I don't like going to the freezer in a panic because I'm likely to pull out the wrong thing.' Habit-forming is key, says Robbie, adding, 'It's what sets you up for success.'She has learned this over the last five years of snack-making. 'The first year, I started in September, did it for a few months and stopped after Halloween. The next year I went to Christmas, then Easter, and now it's all year round. Start by making one thing per week, like sausage and egg muffins, or mini sweet scones. Make a big batch, freeze it, and see how that goes. Don't forget to defrost them and put them into the lunchbox. Then add another couple of recipes, like easy oat bars and energy balls, so that's three options that you have in the freezer.' It's also important to spread the workload. 'It's too much for one person to do. Get everybody in the family involved in keeping the freezer stash topped up — it gives them ownership as well. As much as I cater for kids, these are things that are good in everyone's lunchbox.' Don't get discouraged if your children turn up their noses at your lovingly homemade snacks. Robbie has experienced this too. 'Meet them where they're at and don't be disheartened. If they like chocolate, then make something like banana muffins and put three chocolate chips on top. It's mostly good, with a little bit of what they like, and every child is so different.' Parents want to see lunchboxes that come home empty, with all those carefully made, nutritious snacks eaten, and Robbie, through her book and social media, is ready to lend a hand. 'I'll be sharing and re-sharing a lot of recipes,' she says, 'and I'm really excited to see people baking sweet and savoury snacks for the lunchboxes this September.' Lou Robbie's black bean chocolate chip cookies It's safe to say that cookies are always welcome in our house. These are soft and fudgy and delicious as a snack. Servings 12 Preparation Time 20 mins Cooking Time 15 mins Total Time 35 mins Course Baking Ingredients 250g oats 1 x 400g tin of black beans, drained well 125ml maple syrup or honey 2 heaped tablespoons cocoa powder 40g butter, at room temperature 80g chocolate chips TO DECORATE: 70g chocolate, melted Method Preheat the oven to 180°C fan, and line two baking trays with baking parchment. Put half the oats into a blender. Add the drained black beans, maple syrup, cocoa powder and butter and process until fairly smooth. Scoop the mix into a mixing bowl, and stir through the other half of the oats and the chocolate chips. Divide the mix into 12 balls. Place on the baking trays and push down to flatten. If you have a cookie cutter, use it to mould them into nice round shapes if not, do your best to shape them with your hands. Bake for 15 minutes. Let them cool on the trays for a few minutes, then transfer to a wire rack. Melt the chocolate in the microwave in short bursts or in a small pot on a very low heat. Drizzle the cooled cookies with melted chocolate. Serve with cold milk or a hot coffee. STORAGE: These cookies will keep in an airtight container for up to 5 days. TO FREEZE: Freeze in labelled ziplock bags for up to 3 months. TO DEFROST: Defrost in an airtight container overnight. Make & Freeze by Lou Robbie (Michael Joseph, €19.99) is out now. See:
Irish Examiner
6 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Dating and sex: What's love got to do with it?
What's love got to do with it? IN a new film about a New York matchmaker, in the glitzy, hollow world of high-end dating, not being rich rules you out as a contender, no matter how hot, charming or clever you are. M aterialists, directed by Korean-American writer and director Celine Song, stars Dakota Fanning, Pedro Pascal, and Chris Evans and is based on Song's experience of working as a matchmaker in her early 20s. She quit to make her first film, 2023's quietly magnificent Past Lives, which was nominated for two Oscars — it's about a South Korean woman, married in the US, who emotionally reconnects with her Korean first love — but has revisited matchmaking in her second film to explore the disconnect between dating and falling in love, and how relationship economics depersonalise. This is a people economy where individuals repeatedly sell themselves to each other, while keeping tight hold of the receipt. People in Song's film have lists, non-negotiables, tick-boxes: 'Nobody with an over 20 BMI'; 'Nobody who likes cats'; 'An income over 500 grand'. Song is deeply invested in love, asking rhetorically in a New York Times interview, 'What's more important?' People, she says, are her 'drug of choice', but she's happily married to a man with whom she shares many connections. She thinks that, unlike dating, love is easy. Especially compared to American dating, where it's not just accepted, but expected, to be transactional and materialistic, to turn falling in love in to a business deal. In her 2011 book Honey Money: The Power Of Erotic Capital, Dr Catherine Hakim — a sociologist at the London School of Economics — urged women to harness their erotic capital, which she defined as a combination of 'beauty, social skills, good dress sense, physical fitness, liveliness, sex appeal, and sexual competence' — to attract a high-quality mate. How very Jane Austen. But had we not left such Mrs Bennett-type activity in the past? Survival of the 'fittest' Today, although women are financially independent, pregnancy requires us to take time off work, which puts us at a financial disadvantage. Even now, in 2025, our careers and incomes continue to suffer when we pause to have children, hence the need to have a partner to share the responsibilities. This has been the basis of human reproductive relationships since the dawn of time. 'Attraction to financial stability in partners does have evolutionary roots,' says psychologist Dr Malie Coyne. 'Historically, financial status was always important in mate selection, because, for our ancestors, a partner's ability to provide resources, like food, shelter, and protection, was directly linked to survival and the wellbeing of offspring. 'This financial stability remains relevant today, as it provides long-term security and stability, but, obviously, it shouldn't overshadow the emotional and interpersonal compatibility. 'In terms of the increase in the cost of living, particularly in areas of housing, education, and healthcare, it has made this financial stability more of an immediate and practical concern in forming relationships — maybe more so than a few years ago. In a world where people are facing rising expenses, economic stability becomes less of a luxury and more of a basic necessity for many, which will then likely contribute to this increased emphasis on financial compatibility in modern relationships…to avoid future stress or financial strain. 'We are looking for compatibility in all areas of life with a prospective partner, and financial stability is just one of those areas.' Dakota Johnson as Lucy and Pedro Pascal as Harry in Materialists. Song highlights how dating, with its lists and its demands, is all about control, even though falling in love with another person is one of the few things over which we have very little control: It just happens. Whether you're rich enough to afford a matchmaker or, like the majority, make do with swipe apps, dating has been reduced to an activity akin to shopping. 'The ease of online dating and the emphasis on shopping lists, which is more the Tinder culture of swiping through profiles based on material attributes, have intensified this focus,' says Coyne. 'Online dating promotes snap judgements, narrowing the scope for proper connection. 'People might overlook potential chemistry due to these surface-level factors, like financial status. 'The rise of individualism and financial independence has also altered how we view financial compatibility. In earlier times, a partner's financial situation would have been more critical because women were dependent on men for their security. 'The cultural shifts towards more transactional relationships, where qualities like financial status are weighed more heavily, are partly a response to the modern pressures we face. But it's important to note that relationships have always involved exchanges: Emotional, social, financial. Relationships involve exchanges, which sounds less romantic.' Unless, of course, you're only interested in sexual connection, in which case someone's financial status isn't important. It all depends on your priorities. Love not a set of criteria Rather than writing lists of your ideal partner's qualities and attributes, actual dating is the best way to find out if they are suitable. I went out with someone who didn't have the price of a cinema ticket, followed by someone who owned five houses; neither relationship worked long-term. We were out of sync. Financial values extend beyond how much you have in the bank; they are about attitudes to work, use of time, and how you want to live. 'Face-to-face interactions allow for a fuller, more authentic connection, like humour and warmth, which may not be captured online,' says Coyne. 'To counter the transactional, surface-level nature of online dating, meeting in person allows for an organic discovery of compatibility. The goal is to embrace vulnerability and make space for unexpected emotional connection, which might transcend the shopping-list mentality. I'd suggest becoming friends with your partner beforehand and seeing if your values align. Finances will not be the main thing.' Or, as Song reminds us, if we are too hung up on someone's bank balance or height, what happens if they change their job, or grow old and shrink? However, there's a big difference between expecting a prospective partner to be a 6'4' fintech squillionaire with a six-pack and a penthouse and disempowering yourself by partnering with someone to whom you cede financial control. 'Who holds the purse strings often holds the power in the relationship, even when it comes to booking and paying for couples therapy,' says Orlagh Reid, a psychotherapist and Gottman method couples therapist. 'Traditionally — and sadly still the case across Ireland — we know that women earn far less than their male counterparts as they tend to dedicate time to raising families, caring for elders, and are less financially secure. 'As a result, money can become a bargaining tool when things begin to decline in relationships and marriages. For women, in a world of gender inequality, it should be high on their priority list to be financially stable, secure, and compatible when it comes to money matters.' Money is one of the top-five causes of relationship breakdown. 'Finances — including attitudes and values towards money and wealth, which may include work ethic and education — should be relatively high on the list of priorities when choosing a life partner,' Reid says. 'I have seen first-hand in my practice how many men resort to financial, coercive control of their partners. I believe it's probably the most prevalent form of abuse and control in modern-day relationships. 'Sadly, money does still equal power and freedom, so I would encourage younger women and men to become financially independent and focus on their professional lives first, before investing in any long-term relationship, to ensure equality and stability later in life.' Like Coyne, she urges us to remember that while compatible financial attitudes are important — even if you earn the same, if you're a saver and your partner's a splurger, or vice versa, this can be tricky — long-term compatibility extends far beyond money. 'Healthy, sustainable relationships depend on different aspects of compatibility,' Reid says. 'Communication styles, emotional compatibility and intelligence, values, equality, respect, family values, gender roles and fundamental similarities rather than differences. 'Money may not be initially an important topic, while chemistry and desire are running high, but it should be a non-negotiable topic to discuss at length to establish compatibility for long-term relationship success. Attitudes and values towards money, saving, spending, investing, planning, and making life dreams come true are all important.' So, while you may find the idea of an American-style shopping list ridiculous, do yourself and your prospective life partner a favour and have the money talk before you make any big decisions together. 'Materialists' opens in cinemas today
