Adviser to KP CM accuses federal govt of manipulating data, misleading public
ISLAMABAD: The adviser to the chief minister of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa on finance, Muzzammil Aslam, on Monday accused the federal government of manipulating the data presented in the Economic Survey for 2024-25 and misleading the public about the state of the economy.
In a video message released to the media shortly after the government unveiled its Economic Survey for 2024-25, Aslam accused Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif's administration of misleading the nation through manipulated figures in an effort to sustain its narrative and hold on to power.
He said that the government had used the so-called 'Form 47 approach' – a reference to alleged electoral manipulation – not only to form its administration but also to manage public perception, including during the recent release of the Economic Survey. He rejected government claims of economic stability and recovery, saying that inflation, unemployment and international isolation had worsened.
Citing the government's own economic indicators, he said the country's GDP growth had fallen short of targets. 'This year's GDP stands at 2.7%, well below the 3.6% target set last year. I told the prime minister directly last week that this is not something to boast about – it's figure fudging,' he said, recalling a meeting with Sharif. 'Instead of misleading the nation, the government should face economic realities.'
Referring to the World Bank, he said 110 million Pakistanis – out of a population of 240 million – were now living below the poverty line, arguing that the government had 'completely crushed the poor.'
He also challenged the government's assertion of growth in the livestock and industrial sectors. Further citing official reports, he said agriculture had shrunk by 13.5%, with major crop yields in decline. 'There is no truth in the government's claims of recovery when key sectors are underperforming.'
He added that core inflation stood at 11.6%, challenging the government's assertion that inflation had eased. 'Does this look like inflation is going down? Clearly not,' he said.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
4 hours ago
- Express Tribune
An untenable budget
Listen to article The federal government has laid out an ambitious budget of Rs17.573 trillion for FY26 while pinning its hopes on an exalted growth rate of 4.2%. This euphoric document has come a day after the Economic Survey posted a dismal picture of the economy — all targets were missed for the third consecutive year amid a growth rate of mere 2.7%. The budget proposes a cut in overall spending and banks heavily on tightening tax measures while estimating inflation at 7.5%. The lion's share from the deficit-laden economy goes to debt-servicing, at Rs8.207 trillion. And as foreseen, the defence takes a major share from revenue collection with a 20% rise — at Rs2,550 billion or 1.97% of GDP. The hope-line seems to be an estimated $71 billion in cash flows, $7 billion in taxes and $8 billion in royalties, apart from $5 billion from Reko Diq as well as privatisation of the national flag carrier, PIA, and Roosevelt Hotel in New York. The government is also expecting $25 billion from IT exports over the next five years. Moreover, a surplus in the current account, rise in remittances to the tune of $32 billion and the stability of the rupee are other hallmarks that posits a yearning of the economy's turnaround amidst positive ratings from Moody's and Fitch. The budget has set a tax collection target of Rs14,131 billion, an 8.95% increase from previous year, wherein expenditure of civil administration would be Rs0.97 trillion, pensions Rs1.06 billion, and power and other sectors Rs1.19 billion. The finance minister, while delivering the budget speech, pointed out that 390,000 high-value non-filers of tax were identified and Rs300 million recovered from them, and at the same time the revenue machinery has been able to post a 100% increase in the number of tax filers, taking the revenues to Rs105 billion. A 10% raise in salaries from grade 1-20 employees, a 7% hike in pensions and Rs6,000 allowance for the disabled constitute the only voluble theme of the budget speech. The government also promised to reduce the income tax slabs by balancing inflation and take-home income. An 18% tax on imported solar panels and imposition of taxes on online businesses and digital marketplaces are among the features making the budget anti-growth. However, no new tax on fertiliser and pesticides has been proposed. Similarly, the proposition to reduce the super tax to 5% on corporate sector earning from Rs200 million to Rs500 raises eyebrows given that all other sectors are reeling under pressure. Last but not least, the restive province of Balochistan as well as the merged districts in Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa, which had a leeway with taxes in the past years, will now have to pay sales tax starting from 10% for five years — and that is not a sound economic initiative. The most startling revelation is the confession from the finance wizard that the revenue machinery lacks the muscle to achieve the tax targets. This means reforms and not statistics or book-keeping should be the focus of the economy.
Business Recorder
10 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Wall Street mixed as US-China trade talks grab focus
Wall Street's main indexes were mixed on Tuesday as investors awaited the outcome of ongoing trade talks between the United States and China aimed at cooling a tariff dispute that has bruised global markets this year. U.S. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said trade talks with China were going well as officials from the two sides met for a second day in London. Investors are hoping for an improvement in ties after the relief around a preliminary deal struck last month gave way to fresh doubts when Washington accused Beijing of blocking exports critical to sectors such as aerospace, semiconductors and defense. White House economic adviser Kevin Hassett said on Monday the U.S. was likely to agree to lift export controls on some semiconductors in return for China speeding up the delivery of rare earths. 'I think these issues will be resolved, but I think it's still early days … but the fact that they're talking certainly is positive,' said Mark Malek, chief investment officer at Siebert Financial. 'We're not making progress yards at a time, but inches at a time.' At 10:03 a.m. ET, the Dow Jones Industrial Average fell 20.22 points, or 0.05%, to 42,742.88, the S&P 500 gained 10.30 points, or 0.17%, to 6,016.18 and the Nasdaq Composite gained 53.92 points, or 0.28%, to 19,645.16. Seven of the 11 major S&P 500 sub-sectors rose, led by energy with a 1.7% gain, tracking strength in oil prices. Communication services stocks added 0.9%. Wall Street mixed with focus on US-China trade talks U.S. equities rallied sharply in May, with the S&P 500 index and the tech-heavy Nasdaq marking their best monthly gains since November 2023, helped by upbeat earnings reports and a softening of President Donald Trump's harsh trade stance. The S&P 500 remains about 2% below all-time highs touched in February, while the Nasdaq is about 2.6% below its record peaks reached in December. Investors are awaiting U.S. consumer prices data on Wednesday for clues on the Federal Reserve's rate trajectory. The World Bank slashed its global growth forecast for 2025 by 0.4 percentage point to 2.3%, saying higher tariffs and heightened uncertainty posed a 'significant headwind' for nearly all economies. Shares of McDonald's fell 1.4%, weighing on the blue-chip Dow Index, after a report Redburn Atlantic downgraded the fast-food giant to 'sell' from 'buy'. Most megacap and growth stocks were mixed. Tesla shares advanced 2.6%. Insmed shares jumped 27.7% after the drugmaker said its experimental drug significantly reduced blood pressure in the lungs and improved exercise capacity in patients in a mid-stage study. U.S.-listed shares of Tencent Music Entertainment Group advanced 2.2% after the Chinese company said it would buy domestic long-form audio platform Ximalaya for about $2.4 billion in cash and stock. Advancing issues outnumbered decliners by a 2.52-to-1 ratio on the NYSE and by a 1.76-to-1 ratio on the Nasdaq. The S&P 500 posted 7 new 52-week highs and one new low while the Nasdaq Composite recorded 42 new highs and 29 new lows.
Business Recorder
11 hours ago
- Business Recorder
World Bank slashes global growth forecast as trade tensions bite
WASHINGTON: The World Bank on Tuesday slashed its global growth forecast for 2025 by 0.4 percentage point to 2.3%, saying that higher tariffs and heightened uncertainty posed a 'significant headwind' for nearly all economies. In its twice-yearly Global Economic Prospects report, the bank lowered its forecasts for nearly 70% of all economies - including the United States, China and Europe, as well as six emerging market regions - from the levels it projected just six months ago before U.S. President Donald Trump took office. Trump has upended global trade with a series of on-again, off-again tariff hikes that have increased the effective U.S. tariff rate from below 3% to the mid-teens - its highest level in almost a century - and triggered retaliation by China and other countries. The World Bank is the latest body to cut its growth forecast as a result of Trump's erratic trade policies, although U.S. officials insist the negative consequences will be offset by a surge in investment and still-to-be approved tax cuts. The bank stopped short of forecasting a recession, but said global economic growth this year would be its weakest outside of a recession since 2008. By 2027, global gross domestic product growth was expected to average just 2.5%, the slowest pace of any decade since the 1960s. World Bank warns that US tariffs could reduce global growth outlook The report forecast that global trade would grow by 1.8% in 2025, down from 3.4% in 2024 and roughly a third of its 5.9% level in the 2000s. The forecast is based on tariffs in effect as of late May, including a 10% U.S. tariff on imports from most countries. It excludes increases announced by Trump in April and then postponed until July 9 to allow for negotiations. The bank said global inflation was expected to reach 2.9% in 2025, remaining above pre-COVID levels, given tariff increases and tight labor markets. 'Risks to the global outlook remain tilted decidedly to the downside,' the bank wrote. It said its models showed that a further 10-percentage point increase in average U.S. tariffs, on top of the 10% rate already implemented, and proportional retaliation by other countries, could shave another 0.5 percentage point off the outlook for 2025. Such an escalation in trade barriers would result 'in global trade seizing up in the second half of this year … accompanied by a widespread collapse in confidence, surging uncertainty and turmoil in financial markets,' the report said. Nonetheless, it said the risk of a global recession was less than 10%. World Bank cuts Pakistan growth projection to 2.7% 'Fog on a runway' Top officials from the United States and China are meeting in London this week to try to defuse a trade dispute that has widened from tariffs to restrictions over rare earth minerals, threatening a global supply chain shock and slower growth. 'Uncertainty remains a powerful drag, like fog on a runway. It slows investment and clouds the outlook,' World Bank Deputy Chief Economist Ayhan Kose told Reuters in an interview. But he said there were signs of increased dialogue on trade that could help dispel uncertainty, and supply chains were adapting to a new global trade map, not collapsing. Global trade growth could see a modest rebound in 2026 to 2.4%, and developments in artificial intelligence could also boost growth, he said. 'We think that eventually the uncertainty will decline,' he said. 'Once the type of fog we have lifts, the trade engine may start running again, but at a slower pace.' Kose said while things could get worse, trade was continuing and China, India and others were still delivering robust growth. Many countries were also discussing new trade partnerships that could pay dividends later, he said. IMF lowers Pakistan's FY25 GDP growth forecast to 2.6% US growth forecast cut sharply The World Bank said the global outlook had 'deteriorated substantially' since January, mainly due to advanced economies, now seen growing by just 1.2%, down half a point, after expanding 1.7% in 2024. The U.S. forecast was slashed by 0.9 percentage point from its January forecast to 1.4%, and the 2026 outlook was lowered by 0.4 percentage point to 1.6%. Rising trade barriers, 'record-high uncertainty' and a spike in financial market volatility were expected to weigh on private consumption, trade and investment, it said. Growth estimates in the euro area were cut by 0.3 percentage point to 0.7% and in Japan by 0.5 percentage point to 0.7%. It said emerging markets and developing economies were expected to grow by 3.8% in 2025 versus 4.1% in January's forecast. Poor countries would suffer the most, the report said. By 2027 developing economies' per capita GDP would be 6% below pre-pandemic levels, and it could take these countries – minus China - two decades to recoup the economic losses of the 2020s. Mexico, heavily dependent on trade with the U.S., saw its growth forecast cut by 1.3 percentage points to 0.2% in 2025. The World Bank left its forecast for China unchanged at 4.5% from January, saying Beijing still had monetary and fiscal space to support its economy and stimulate growth.
