A Triumph of Ideological Elasticity as Chandrababu Naidu Lauds Narendra Modi in Tribute to Narasimha Rao
A lecture on a Congress prime minister, delivered by a regional leader whose party was born in opposition to him, had become a platform to deify a BJP prime minister.
Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister N Chandrababu Naidu during a programme titled "The Life and Legacy of PV Narasimha Rao", in New Delhi on July 15, 2025. Photo: @JaiTDP on X via PTI
New Delhi: On July 15, a peculiar séance was underway at the Prime Minister's Museum and Library at Teen Murti Bhavan. The official purpose was to reflect on the "Life and Legacy of P.V. Narasimha Rao," the accidental prime minister, the architect of liberalisation, and – according to the whispers in the corridors of Indian politics – the "first Bharatiya Janata Party prime minister."
The medium chosen for this communion was N. Chandrababu Naidu, the chief minister of Andhra Pradesh, himself a politician whose career is a testament to ideological elasticity.
As Naidu spoke, it became clear that the tribute was not exactly Rao's. The lecture was a bait-and-switch, a political ritual not of remembrance, but of fealty. In a performance of strategic sycophancy, Naidu used Rao's memory to offer praise to a usual figure: Narendra Modi.
This performance revealed far more about Naidu's own precarious position in the National Democratic Alliance (NDA) coalition and the ideological shifts reshaping India than it did about the man he was ostensibly there to honour.
The evening's partisan flavour was set from the outset. The host, Nripendra Misra, a veteran bureaucrat who served as principal secretary to Narendra Modi, listed the subjects of previous lectures. For the non-Congress prime ministers, there was a reverential "Shri." For the others, a stark mention: "Jawaharlal Nehru, Indira Gandhi and Lal Bahadur Shastri." This was likely no slip but a signal from a Modi-era power broker that a reordering of reverence is fast taking place in the very institution meant to preserve the nation's history.
Naidu took the stage and began with a perfunctory nod to Rao as a "great statesman" before pivoting to his true subject. "I have seen everything over the last five decades in politics," Naidu declared, moving on to framing the last 10 years under Modi as the singular apex of India's journey. With surgical precision, he excised the decade of UPA rule under Manmohan Singh – the very finance minister who was the other and indispensable half of the Rao-Singh reform duo. In Naidu's retelling, Indian history had a 10-year black hole between Vajpayee and Modi.
Naidu peddled the much-debunked claim that the World Bank had ranked India as the "fourth most income-equal country globally." This claim, born of a misread government press release, serves as a crucial myth for a leader whose own "Super Six" welfare promises in Andhra Pradesh remain largely unfulfilled in his first year in power.
The convenient amnesia of history
Naidu choosing Rao as the vessel for his adulation of Modi was ironical.
Naidu's entire political existence is a direct consequence of the Kamma community's historical antagonism towards the Congress government that Rao once led in Andhra Pradesh. Rao's tenure as chief minister in the early 1970s, with his government's land ceilings act and restrictive 'mulki' rules, created considerable alienation among the powerful Kamma caste. This disenchantment directly fuelled the meteoric rise of the Telugu Desam Party (TDP), founded by Naidu's father-in-law, N.T. Rama Rao.
Naidu built his political empire on the foundations of Kamma disaffection with the Congress, a disaffection ignited by policies under Rao.
As Naidu stood and recast Rao as an uncomplicated hero, more glaring was his omission of the sordid realities of Rao's own ascent to power. In his searing 1991 essay ' Meham in Nandyal,' the late civil liberties icon K. Balagopal documented the brutal "gangsterism" and "warlord" tactics that secured Rao's unopposed election, writing of abducted opposition candidates and intimidation sanctioned from the highest echelons of Congress. Naidu's hagiography naturally sought to bury this version.
The saffron price tag
Naidu's performance aligned seamlessly with the Hindutva project of the NDA masters. Mentioning that Rao was fluent in 17 languages, he could not resist a pointed jibe: "Now we are all talking, why should we learn Hindi?". Many will consider this a direct betrayal of the Dravidian political consensus Naidu once claimed to champion.
This capitulation became a grotesque family affair this week. First, his deputy, Pawan Kalyan, called Hindi the tongue of " peddamma" (mother's elder sister). Then, Naidu's son and heir-apparent, Nara Lokesh, while speaking to a national news channel, incorrectly insisted "Hindi is our national language," defiantly doubling down even when corrected.
This is, seemingly, the price of admission to the new NDA. After a vitriolic campaign against Modi before 2019 – which led BJP president Amit Shah to declare the doors to the NDA "permanently closed" for him – Naidu has completely surrendered. He now finds himself on a saffron tightrope, making ample space for a soft-Hindutva narrative – praising yoga, for example even in his speech – something that the BJP has masterfully weaponised as a tool of cultural normalisation.
Unable to fight Hindutva, Naidu is now actively helping to build its kingdom.
The neoliberal gospel of a 'good cat'
Throughout his lecture, Naidu invoked the term "public policy" with the fervour of a televangelist. As Balagopal diagnosed decades ago, this is code for a specific ideology. Naidu's "public policy" is the gospel of neoliberalism, which posits a state not as a provider but a "facilitator" for private capital. It's why he speaks of social responsibilities and public-private partnerships, replacing the language of rights and social justice with the language of corporate-friendly "efficiency" and the "charity" of billionaires like Bill Gates.
The most revealing articulation of this philosophy was his proud mention of the "P4 model" – public private people's partnership. This is a masterstroke of hollow sloganeering. The standard P3 model is already criticised for outsourcing state responsibility to corporations. Adding the fourth 'P' for 'people' is a cynical PR flourish, designed to make the state's retreat sound like democratic empowerment. It diffuses responsibility onto an amorphous "people" who possess none of the institutional power of the state or the financial power of the corporation, rendering them participants in name alone. It allows the government to abdicate its duties while claiming to be more inclusive; a slogan ostensibly suited for a leader who has been slow to implement his own government's welfare schemes.
Rao's famous appropriation of Deng Xiaoping's quote, "It should not matter if a cat is black or white, if it catches a mouse... it is a good cat," which Naidu also cited, finds expression in Naidu himself. For him, ideology is merely the colour of the cat; power is the mouse. Any cat that helps him catch the mouse is, for that moment, a good cat.
As the evening concluded, one was left with a profound sense of political vertigo. A lecture on a Congress prime minister, delivered by a regional leader whose party was born in opposition to him, had become a platform to deify a BJP prime minister, while simultaneously erasing the legacy of another Congress PM who was instrumental to the very reforms being discussed.
Balagopal wrote that Naidu was a man who did not just represent his times but actively latched onto them. Today, the times are defined by Modi's hyper-centralised power and the BJP's Hindutva expansionism. Naidu, the ultimate survivor, is once again latching on, hoping to ride the wave.
The Wire is now on WhatsApp. Follow our channel for sharp analysis and opinions on the latest developments.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Time of India
6 minutes ago
- Time of India
Independence Day 2025 speech: Best long and short Swatantrata Diwas speeches in English for students
Independence Day speech ideas: Independence Day in India is more than a national holiday—it's a heartfelt tribute to the legacy of sacrifice, unity, and patriotism that earned the country its freedom on 15 August 1947. For every Indian, this day marks a pivotal moment in history when colonial shackles were broken, and a new dawn of sovereignty was ushered in. As we are all set to celebrate the 79th Independence Day, special programs are organised in schools and colleges across the country. This is the best time to express your thoughts for the country by giving an Independence Day speech. During the 15 August speech, you need to practice the facts mentioned in your Independence Day English speech. Theme of Independence Day 2025 The Government of India often announces a unique theme each year to guide the nationwide celebrations. For this year, the official theme is yet to be declared. National Celebrations and Events From the grand parade at the Red Fort in New Delhi to flag hoisting ceremonies across schools and institutions, the tricolour flies high with pride and glory. Speeches, patriotic songs, parades, cultural performances, and tributes to freedom fighters are key elements of the day. The Journey to Freedom: A Historical Glimpse From 1857 Revolt to 1947 Independence India's fight for freedom formally began with the First War of Independence in 1857, a valiant uprising against British rule. Over the next 90 years, countless protests, movements, and non-cooperation acts shaped the resistance. Role of Freedom Fighters in India's Liberation Heroes like Mahatma Gandhi, Subhas Chandra Bose, Bhagat Singh, Rani Laxmi Bai, and Sardar Patel dedicated their lives to freeing India. Their strategies—ranging from non-violence to armed revolution—paved the way for independence. Role of Students in Independence Day Celebrations Patriotic Activities in Schools and Colleges Independence Day offers students a chance to actively participate in activities like: Flag hoisting Singing patriotic songs Enacting skits on freedom fighters Delivering speeches and essays Speech Competitions and Cultural Programs Speech competitions are among the most engaging ways students express their understanding of the nation's journey, values, and future. Long Independence Day Speech for Students (Updated for 2025) Good morning to everyone present here. Respected teachers, principal, and my dear friends, Today, I feel honoured to stand before you on the occasion of our nation's 79th Independence Day. On this proud day, we remember and salute the sacrifices made by millions of freedom fighters who brought independence to our land on 15th August 1947. Their dedication, courage, and love for the country should forever inspire us. India was under British rule for nearly two centuries. Our freedom fighters faced inhuman conditions, imprisonment, torture, and even death so that future generations could breathe in free air. From Gandhiji's Dandi March to Subhas Chandra Bose's Azad Hind Fauj, every movement etched new energy into the struggle for independence. Today, India is not just free, but it is growing, thriving, and leading globally in sectors like space technology, defense, agriculture, digital innovation, and education. As students and future leaders, we must cherish this freedom and contribute toward building a stronger India. Let us remember that with freedom comes responsibility. We must promise to uphold peace, respect others, support the underprivileged, and always prioritise our nation's interest. Jai Hind! Jai Bharat! Vande Mataram! Short Independence Day Speech for Students Good morning and Happy Independence Day to all. Today we celebrate 79 years of freedom from British rule. On this day in 1947, India emerged as a sovereign nation after a long struggle filled with sacrifices. Let us take a moment to remember Gandhiji, Nehruji, Bhagat Singh, and countless unnamed heroes. Their bravery has made it possible for us to live in a free nation. Let us vow to become responsible citizens, support each other, and work hard to fulfil our duties to our motherland. Thank you, Jai Hind! Independence Day Speech for Kids Good morning, teachers and friends. Today is 15th August, our Independence Day. It is a very important day for all of us. On this day in 1947, India got its freedom from British rule. Our great leaders like Mahatma Gandhi and Subhas Chandra Bose worked hard for our country. Let us respect them and make India proud by being good students and responsible citizens. Happy Independence Day! Jai Hind! Independence Day Speech for Primary Students Hi everyone and Happy Independence Day! I am proud to be an Indian. Today we remember all the freedom fighters who made India free. Let's always love our country, follow rules, help each other, and make India a better place. Bharat Mata ki Jai! Key Points to Include in Independence Day Speeches Date and significance of 15 August Struggles under British rule Non-violent freedom movements Role of youth in nation-building Importance of unity and diversity Famous freedom fighters and their contributions Inspirational Quotes for Independence Day Speeches "Freedom is not worth having if it does not include the freedom to make mistakes." – Mahatma Gandhi "Swaraj is my birthright, and I shall have it!" – Bal Gangadhar Tilak "Faith is the bird that feels the light when the dawn is still dark." – Rabindranath Tagore "The sanctity of law can be maintained only so long as it is the expression of the will of the people." – Bhagat Singh "Let new India arise out of peasants' cottage, grasping the plow, out of huts, cobbler and sweeper." – Swami Vivekananda Tips to Deliver a Great Independence Day Speech Start with a warm greeting Speak clearly and confidently Use hand gestures to express passion Include a personal touch or story End with patriotic slogans Emotional Connect: Expressing Patriotism in Speech Make your audience feel proud. Remind them of the struggle, the sacrifices, and how far the nation has come. Stir emotions through quotes, real stories, and your own love for the nation. How Teachers Can Help Students Prepare for Speeches Assist in writing drafts Conduct practice sessions Offer constructive feedback Encourage creativity and confidence Role of Technology in Modern Independence Day Celebrations Today, students use digital tools to: Create virtual presentations Share speeches on YouTube Attend online competitions Watch documentaries on India's freedom As we mark the 79th Independence Day of India, let us remember that freedom is not a gift but a hard-earned right. We owe it to our freedom fighters and to future generations to protect this liberty. Let's dream big, act responsibly, and always keep the spirit of unity alive. Vande Mataram! Jai Hind! Bharat Mata Ki Jai! Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) Q. What is the date of Independence Day in India? A: India celebrates Independence Day on 15th August every year. Q. Why is 15 August celebrated? A: It marks the end of British rule and India's emergence as an independent nation in 1947. Q. Who was the first Prime Minister of independent India? A: Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru. Q. What is a good quote to use in a speech? A: 'Swaraj is my birthright and I shall have it' – Bal Gangadhar Tilak. Q. How should I start my speech on Independence Day? A: Start by greeting the audience and stating why the day is important. Q. What should kids say in their speech? A: Simple facts like the date, reason for celebration, and expressing pride in being Indian. For more informative articles on historical and upcoming events from around the world, please visit Indiatimes Events.

The Hindu
6 minutes ago
- The Hindu
India calls for ceasefire in Gaza, says intermittent pauses ‘not enough'
Voicing concern over the persisting humanitarian crisis in Gaza, India asserted that a ceasefire must be put in place, emphasising that 'intermittent pauses in hostilities' are "not enough" to address the scale of challenges facing the region's people. 'Today's meeting takes place against the backdrop of a persisting humanitarian crisis in Gaza," said India's Permanent Representative to the U.N. Ambassador Parvathaneni Harish, addressing an open debate in the UN Security Council on Wednesday (July 23, 2025). "Intermittent pauses in hostilities are not enough to address the scale of humanitarian challenges confronting the people, who grapple daily with acute shortages of food and fuel, inadequate medical services and lack of access to education,' said at the open debate on the 'Situation in the Middle East, including the Palestinian question'. Underlining that the way ahead is clear, and highlighting India's consistent position in this regard, Mr. Harish said the ongoing human suffering must not be allowed to continue. 'Humanitarian assistance needs to be facilitated in a safe, sustained and timely manner. There is no substitute to peace. A ceasefire must be put in place. All hostages must be released. Dialogue and diplomacy remain the only viable paths to achieving these objectives. There are no other fixes or solutions,' he said. He also expressed hope that an upcoming UN conference on the Israel-Palestine conflict would pave the way for 'concrete steps" towards achieving a two-State solution. Mr. Harish told the Council debate, held under Pakistan's presidency of the Security Council for the month of July, that India shares historic and strong ties with its Palestinian brothers and sisters. 'We have always stood by them and our commitment towards the Palestinian cause is unwavering,' he said, noting that India was the first non-Arab country to recognise the State of Palestine. Describing the health and education situation in Gaza as 'particularly troubling', Harish said the World Health Organisation estimates that around 95 per cent of all hospitals in Gaza are damaged or destroyed. The Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights reports that more than 650,000 children have had no schooling for over 20 months, he said. Mr. Harish said that India takes note of the High-Level International Conference on the implementation of a two-State solution scheduled for July 28-30. 'While engaging in a forward-leaning and constructive manner, it is our hope that this conference would pave the way for concrete steps towards achieving a two-State solution,' Mr. Harish said. He said India underscores its readiness to contribute to efforts aimed at shaping a political horizon that restores hope for the Palestinians and achieving sustained peace in the Middle East. The high-level conference, co-chaired by Saudi Arabia and France, was scheduled to take place from June 17-20 but was postponed due to escalating tensions in the region. U.N. Secretary General Antonio Guterres has stressed that it is essential to keep alive the two-State solution perspective 'with all the terrible things we are witnessing in Gaza and the West Bank. 'And for those that doubt about the two-state solution, I ask: What is the alternative? Is it a one-state solution in which either the Palestinians are expelled or the Palestinians will be forced to live in their land without rights? That would be totally unacceptable. I firmly believe that it is the duty of the international community to keep the two-State solution alive and then to materialise the conditions to make it happen,' he had said. President of the General Assembly Philemon Yang has described the international conference as a crucial opportunity that 'we must seize to chart an irreversible path towards the implementation of the two-State solution. It is imperative that this conference succeeds.' India reiterated that the pathway to enduring peace is rooted in a two-State solution — one that establishes a sovereign, viable and independent State of Palestine within recognised and mutually agreed borders, living side by side with Israel in peace. India's endeavour is to make a 'tangible impact' on the daily lives of the Palestinians by implementing projects in diverse sectors, and the country is currently implementing projects valued at more than $40 million, Harish said.

New Indian Express
6 minutes ago
- New Indian Express
'World sleeps; while it is awake, its conscience is buried': Chidambaram on Gaza humanitarian crisis
NEW DELHI: Senior Congress leader and former Finance Minister P Chidambaram on Thursday raised concerns on the humanitarian crisis in Gaza and said that every day, the number of killings in the region is in the double digits, with many of them being women and children. In a post on X, Chidambaram said, "Humanity is shamed in Gaza every day, the number of killings in Gaza is in the double-digits. Many of them are women and children who had nothing to do with starting the conflict." He said that 1000 Palestinians have been killed in Gaza while trying to get food. "According to the UN, over 1000 Palestinians have been killed since May while trying to get food in the Gaza Strip Look at the pictures of hungry children at refugee camps. It is obvious they are starving -- and dying," Chidambaram said. "The world sleeps; while it is awake, its conscience is buried," he said. Earlier, India called for immediate ceasefire in Gaza, uninterrupted humanitarian aid and release of hostages to address the deepening crisis in the region. Speaking at the United Nations Security Council's quarterly open debate on the Middle East, India's Permanent Representative to the United Nations, Ambassador Parvathaneni Harish, said that mere pauses in hostilities are not enough to address the worsening humanitarian situation. "Intermittent pauses in hostilities are not enough to address the scale of humanitarian challenges confronting the people, who grapple daily with acute shortages of food and fuel, inadequate medical services and lack of access to education," he said. Harish expressed concern over the collapsing healthcare and education systems in Gaza. "WHO estimates that around 95 percent of all hospitals in Gaza are damaged or destroyed. The Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights reports that more than 6,50,000 children have had no schooling for over 20 months," he said. Israel's war on Gaza, since Oct. 7, 2023, has now killed at least 58,386 people and wounded 139,077, mostly women and children, according to the Gaza Health Ministry's data.