Husband suspected wife of poisoning him before toxic mushroom murders
A judge on Friday lifted a gag order on pretrial evidence that triple murderer Erin Patterson, 50, had wanted kept secret while she attempts to overturn her convictions.
The evidence included the suspicions of Patterson's estranged husband, Simon Patterson, that she had previously attempted to kill him.
Mr Patterson gave evidence at a pre-trial hearing that he had declined the lunch invitation out of fear.
'I thought there'd be a risk that she'd poison me if I attended,' he told the court months before the trial in evidence that was not presented to jurors.
Mr Patterson said that while he had stopped eating food prepared by his wife, from whom he had been estranged since 2015, he never thought others would be at risk.
Simon Patterson said he had stopped eating food prepared by his wife (James Ross/AAP/AP)
Erin Patterson was convicted by a Victoria state Supreme Court last month of murdering her parents-in-law, Don and Gail Patterson, and Gail's sister Heather Wilkinson, at her home in Leongatha, with a lunch of beef Wellington pastries containing toxic death cap mushrooms.
She was also found guilty of attempting to murder Ian Wilkinson, Mrs Wilkinson's husband, who survived the meal but spent weeks in hospital.
Erin Patterson was initially charged with attempting to murder her husband by inviting him to the lunch in July 2023. He had accepted the invitation, then cancelled.
She was also initially charged with three counts of attempting to murder him on three occasions around Victoria between November 2021 and September 2022.
Prosecutors dropped all charges relating to the husband before her trial began in April.
Mr Patterson gave evidence before the trial that he suspected his wife had deliberately made him seriously ill with dishes including Bolognese pasta, chicken korma curry and a vegetable curry wrap. No poisons were ever found.
The three alleged poisonings occurred during family camping trips. Mr Patterson told his poisoning suspicions to his doctor, who encouraged him to create a spreadsheet listing what he had eaten around the time he became sick.
The judge, Justice Christopher Beale, ruled for lawyers representing media who sought to overturn the gag order, ordering that the evidence that jurors had not seen would be made public.
Erin Patterson's lawyers wanted all the evidence that was not deemed admissible at her trial kept secret until an appeals court decided whether to overturn her convictions.
Their reasons included that media interest in the case was unprecedented.
Defence lawyer Colin Mandy argued that reporting of the suppressed evidence, as well as references to it in books, podcasts and a planned television mini-series, would 'leave an indelible impression on the minds of potential jurors in the event that there is a retrial'.
A hearing will begin on August 25 to determine what sentence she will get. She faces a potential life sentence for each of the murders and 25 years for attempted murder.
Prosecutor Jane Warren told the judge on Friday 'a lot' of victim impact statements would be presented at that two-day sentencing hearing.
Once Erin Patterson is sentenced, she will have 28 days to lodge an appeal against the sentence, the convictions, or both.
Her lawyers say they will appeal against her convictions.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
28 minutes ago
- Sunday World
‘There's no way he killed himself' Jeffrey Epstein's former butler claims
'LOVED LIFE' | Former employee claims Trump offered disgraced financier a job during first term in White House In an interview that will heap renewed pressure on the Trump administration to make the Epstein files public, one of his closest aides said he spoke to the paedophile financier before he died and insisted he was in good spirits. Valdson Vieira Cotrin, who ran Epstein's Paris home, said he could not accept the official verdict of suicide and feared his own life was in danger. He also said he believed that Epstein victim Virginia Giuffre, who accused Prince Andrew of rape and died by suicide in April, was a victim of foul play. Mr Cotrin also made the extraordinary claim that Epstein told him he had been offered a job by Donald Trump in his first administration in 2016 – but that Epstein had turned it down. Donald Trump claims he fell out with Epstein in 2004. Photo: Reuters There is no evidence that the allegation is true and Mr Trump has maintained that he stopped speaking to Epstein in 2004 after they fell out over a business deal. But Mr Cotrin's recollection of a conversation with his boss will fuel a growing demand for the full Epstein files – the trove of documents from the criminal investigations into Epstein that allegedly name high-profile celebrities and politicians, possibly including Mr Trump – to be released in full. Jeffrey Epstein with his former butler Valdson Cotrin News in 90 Seconds - Aug 9th In his exclusive interview, Mr Cotrin, speaking on the record for the first time, also alleged: Mr Cotrin remains in possession of a number of photographs taken with friends of Epstein, including a photo of himself with Bill Clinton on the so-called Lolita Express, Epstein's private plane that he used to traffic underage girls and women for sex. The existence of the photo showing Mr Clinton on board Epstein's jet will also fuel demands for the former president to reveal his full dealings with Epstein. Mr Clinton was issued with a subpoena on Tuesday, demanding he give evidence to a congressional committee investigating the financier. Bill Clinton and his wife Hillary have both been subpoenaed to appear before the house oversight committee. Photo: AP Mr Cotrin also shared a photograph of himself with Epstein that was taken in January 2019 on his private jet, which may be one of the last taken of the financier. He looks puffy but is smiling and relaxed and notably wearing an Israel Defence Forces sweatshirt. Epstein has long been accused of being an operative for Mossad, Israel's intelligence service, although last month his former lawyer said that Epstein used to laugh off the claim. Mr Cotrin, who acted as Epstein's butler, chauffeur and cook in Paris, recalled driving his boss to Le Bourget Airport in Paris to catch a flight to New York, where he was arrested upon landing on July 6, 2019. I don't believe this was suicide. He loved life too much Epstein (66) was charged with sex trafficking underage girls and remanded in custody. He was found hanged in his cell on August 10. But Mr Cotrin is insistent Epstein would never have killed himself. Epstein had told him he was planning to negotiate with the judge in the case to secure bail, having been held in custody as a possible flight risk. 'I am like his brother [Mark Epstein]. I don't believe this was suicide. He loved life too much,' said Mr Cotrin. Mr Cotrin recalled seeing Epstein for the last time. Epstein, he said, was relaxed and had been talking about making more investments in his islands – he had discreetly bought a second, which Mr Cotrin visited – as well as spending more time in Paris. 'I drove him to Le Bourget Airport. It was a Saturday, because on Monday he was supposed to appear before the judge regarding all these accusations. 'When I got home, two young women rang, his main girlfriend who had been with him officially for several years, Karyna [Shuliak] and another who worked for him. And then they told me, 'Mr Epstein has gone to prison. He arrived in New York. The police were waiting for him'.' Mr Cotrin's partner, Maria Gomes de Melo, who also knew Epstein well, recalled that in Paris, Epstein had said goodbye to her and added: 'I'll be back next week', Ms de Melo told him: 'Sir, don't go.' She also questioned the official conclusion that he had killed himself. Epstein's brother, Mark, has suggested the financier may have been murdered, ordering a second post-mortem examination that tended to back up that assertion. 'On the Saturday late, we got the news that he had hanged himself, and honestly, he loved life too much to float away like that,' she said. The US department of justice has released nearly 11 hours of surveillance video from outside Epstein's cell in the Manhattan Metropolitan Correctional Centre, but a crucial minute from 11:58:58pm to midnight was missing. That has further fuelled conspiracy theories that Epstein was murdered to silence him. Mr Cotrin remains fiercely loyal to Epstein and insists he never saw his boss cavorting – let alone having sex – with underage girls. He said young women were hired to give Epstein massages and to cut his nails. 'The girls did that to him, but it stopped there,' he said. He gave an extraordinary insight into Epstein's world – and the rich and famous who would stop by for his guidance and hospitality. Mr Cotrin, who has joint French and Brazilian nationalities, worked for Epstein for 18 years, managing his sumptuous eight-bedroom Paris apartment on Avenue Foch overlooking the Arc de Triomphe. He lived in a garret flat on the sixth floor. But he also worked dozens of times at Epstein's properties in New York, Palm Beach, Florida and on Little St James, Epstein's private Caribbean island – dubbed 'paedophile island' – where he is said to have trapped and raped often underage victims. 'He trusted me completely,' said Mr Cotrin, who has not worked since his boss's death six years ago. 'I was his chauffeur, his cook, his housekeeper. I did everything in Paris, I was his only full-time, paid-up employee and worked for him from 2001 until his death. If someone could have seen something, it's Valdson, there's no one else,' he said. His interview took place in his French home over a beer and Brazilian bread and cheese balls that he says were a hit with Bill Gates. Upstairs, a large photo of Mr Cotrin and Epstein taken on the 'Lolita Express' hung on one wall, alongside another with the butler and Mr Clinton. Mr Cotrin reeled off a list of dignitaries who came to visit Epstein over two decades, including Prince Andrew, who he cooked for and chauffeured 'five or six times' in Paris and New York; Mr Clinton, whom he met once in Epstein's jet during a stopover in Paris; Peter Mandelson, now the UK's ambassador to Washington DC; Woody Allen; and Israeli ex-prime minister Ehud Barak, along with other Middle Eastern dignitaries. A photograph of Mr Mandelson with Epstein and Mr Cotrin taken at the Paris apartment on Epstein's birthday has been widely circulated, causing Mr Mandelson, the former Labour cabinet minister, huge embarrassment. Mr Cotrin has refused countless requests for interviews since Epstein was found hanged in his prison cell, but said he was breaking his silence to 'tell my truth' about Epstein, whom he refers to as 'Monsieur' or 'Patron'. Ms Giuffre killed herself at her home in Australia in April, aged 41. 'And what about Virginia [Giuffre] Roberts?' Mr Cotrin said, adding: 'I'm scared because after what happened to them, poor Valdson, who knows?' Mr Cotrin never met Mr Trump – Mr Trump and Epstein had fallen out over the sale of a property in Palm Beach in 2004. However, Mr Cotrin said that Epstein had boasted of being offered a job by Mr Trump after his surprise first presidential election win in November 2016. The claim – if true – would be dynamite, although there is no evidence to back it up. Sources inside Trump's first administration have told The Telegraph that Mr Cotrin's recollection appeared fanciful. Activists put up a poster showing Donald Trump and Jeffrey Epstein near the US Embassy in London. Photo: AP Mr Cotrin said: 'I can tell you one thing [regarding Mr Trump]. A few days after Trump's [2016] election, Mr Epstein arrived in Paris on Monday or Tuesday, and I went to pick him up at the airport. 'He said: 'Valdson, you saw that Trump is the new US president?' ''Yes,' I replied, 'I saw it on the news in Paris'. ''Well, Trump asked me to work for him in the new government'. 'I said: 'Congratulations. I'm happy for you,' in my bad English. 'He said: 'No I didn't accept.'' I asked no more questions as it wasn't my place Mr Cotrin insisted Epstein was not in the habit of trumpeting false claims in such a confidential setting. He said his boss made no mention of what position that might be. 'I was surprised because I would have thought such a position could be interesting, but I asked no more questions as it wasn't my place,' Mr Cotrin said. 'In my job, one waits to be spoken to. 'But in my opinion, if he did turn it down, it was because he liked his freedom, I think he didn't want to be controlled by anyone.' Mr Trump has not been accused of any wrongdoing in the case.
Irish Independent
4 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Mushroom murderer tried to poison husband with rat poison and anti-freeze in meals, suppressed evidence alleges
Erin Patterson (50) was found guilty last month of murdering her husband's parents and aunt in 2023 by lacing their lunch with lethal death cap mushrooms. Prosecutors initially sought to present evidence that she may have put rat poison in a meal prepared for Simon Patterson, the father of her two children. Mr Patterson had also discussed with his doctor the possibility that radiator antifreeze had been added to biscuits his ex-wife had baked for him in February 2023, five months before his parents and aunt died at Erin Patterson's home in Leongatha, south-east of Melbourne. Police initially charged Erin Patterson with four counts of attempting to murder her husband, which she denied. Eventually, police dropped those charges. In pre-trial hearings, the court heard how Mr Patterson had become so concerned of falling ill from meals prepared by his estranged wife that he kept an Excel spreadsheet on his computer to document them. 'I had the idea I got sick from Erin's food. I did not give it too much thought,' he told police in a statement read out to the court. In November 2021, he ate a portion of Bolognese penne pasta from a Tupperware container. Afterwards, he began suffering from vomiting and diarrhoea, and spent a night in hospital. Six months later, in May 2022, he fell into a coma days after eating a chicken korma curry prepared by Erin Patterson on a camping trip in the mountains of Victoria's High Country region. Surgeons were forced to remove a large part of his bowel to save his life. In September 2022, while visiting a stretch of Victoria's coastline, he would become unwell again after eating a vegetable wrap. At first, he felt nausea and diarrhoea coming on, the court heard, before his symptoms escalated. He started slurring his speech, gradually lost control of his muscles and began 'fitting'. ADVERTISEMENT 'By the end of the journey [to hospital], all I could move was my neck, my tongue and lips,' he told the court. The prosecution argued that his symptoms could be consistent with barium carbonate ingestion, a chemical compound that is used in rat poison. Dr Chris Ford, Mr Patterson's GP, told the court that he had asked him to record his symptoms because he 'couldn't understand why' he had had three 'near-death experiences'. 'It didn't fit into any of my medical models that would account for all three of those things,' Dr Ford told the court. 'There was no other reasons that could fit all the different admissions, so it seemed feasible it [the food he was served] could be a possible reason.' The allegations were revealed yesterday after the Supreme Court of Victoria lifted a suppression order that had kept the details secret until the conclusion of one of the most high-profile murder trials in Australian history. Erin Patterson was found guilty of murdering Gail and Don Patterson, and Gail's sister, Heather Wilkinson. She was also convicted of the attempted murder of Ian Wilkinson, the fourth lunch guest, who survived after undergoing a liver transplant. Police yesterday released a 21-minute video of Erin Patterson's interview with detectives a week after the lunch, in which she portrayed herself as a loving daughter-in-law who was committed to helping with the investigation. Simon Patterson's family were 'good, decent people that have never done anything wrong by me, ever', she told police. 'I think Simon hated that I had a relationship with his parents,' she added. She also told police she did not own a food dehydrator − a lie that would later be found out by CCTV showing her dumping one at a rubbish tip. Forensic testing revealed the dehydrator contained traces of the Amanita phalloides fungi, commonly known as the death cap. By the time police arrested Patterson, they had also raided her home and seized phones and computers at the property. On them, they found several pieces of evidence − allegedly including an article about barium carbonate. They also found a social media post she allegedly made asking for advice on how to treat her cat after it ate poisonous mushrooms − even though she did not own a cat. Police included the post in their brief of evidence, but it was ruled as inadmissible. Mr Patterson told the court that his estranged wife had invited him to the July 2023 lunch, but he declined because 'I thought there'd be a risk that she'd poison me if I attended'. He had previously told relatives that he feared his estranged wife was trying to kill him after the series of unexplained medical crises between 2021 and 2022. But he did not warn them against eating at her house because he never thought she would set out to harm them. The pair had remained on friendly terms despite their separation, but had started to argue over finances including child support payments. Patterson's defence lawyer told the court, however, that a medical expert who had analysed Mr Patterson's medical records had concluded his symptoms were consistent with low potassium levels. Several possible explanations for his illnesses were raised, including gastrointestinal conditions, and doctors did not find poison in his system. The allegations were never presented to the jury as the court-ordered prosecutors would need to pursue a separate trial to address claims Erin Patterson had tried to kill husband Simon. She will face a two-day pre-sentence hearing on August 25, when relatives and friends of the Pattersons and Wilkinsons will have an opportunity to read victim-impact statements. Erin Patterson faces a maximum penalty of life in prison without parole. She is expected to appeal her convictions.
The Irish Sun
13 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Crypto bro begged ‘call my mom' & ratted out pal after he ‘tortured Italian millionaire in luxury pad with chainsaw'
A CRYPTO bro charged with torturing an Italian millionaire with a chainsaw ratted out his partner and begged to speak to his mother shortly after being arrested. John Woeltz, 37, was dragged out of his luxury New York apartment by cops back in May. 6 New York police officers arrest John Woeltz Credit: AP 6 John Woeltz appears for arraignment in Manhattan Criminal Court Credit: Reuters 6 He quickly gave up the name of his associate William Duplessie that afternoon Credit: ABC 7 6 Woeltz had allegedly been sadistically torturing the captive Credit: ABC 7 It came after the victim was reportedly able to escape the $40,000-a-month apartment on Prince Street. The victim had told investigators he was Woeltz's former partner, but their relationship had soured and he had gone back to Italy. But new court papers have revealed the staggering aftermath of the crypto bro's arrest - which saw him dragged barefoot and in a bathrobe out of his home. Woeltz, originally from Kentucky, quickly gave up the name of his associate William Duplessie that afternoon, the New York Post has reported. He told a detective: "My partner is William Duplessie. We have attorneys but I don't know them." According to Manhattan Supreme Court papers, Woeltz added: "He's from here, he's from New York. "We live in the same house. Yes, he wasn't there this morning." The documents further show him turning down officers' offer of free pizza and bragging that he had "detective friends". The crypto bro repeatedly asked to speak to his lawyer, and then asked to talk to his mother. While being interviewed by a detective, he said: "I'd love a lawyer, or phone call, or something, but thank you, no pizza. Inside France's brutal crypto crime wave with chopped off fingers, delivery van street kidnaps & £10million ransoms "I'd love to understand why I'm here. "I've been here so many hours, I haven't been able to call a lawyer or my detective friends, I've been able to call nobody." A few minutes after his, he revealed the name of his partner and asked for an attorney. He reportedly begged: "Can I get a phone call? Call my mom, and she can write it down. His arrest came after the Italian millionaire managed to escape from the apartment. Woeltz had allegedly been sadistically torturing the captive. According to investigators, he tied up the victim with electrical cords and used electrocutions to torture him. He also allegedly tased him with his feet in water and threatened to cut his limbs off with a chainsaw. Woeltz even reportedly took Polaroids of the victim being tortured, according to cops. He was charged with two counts of assault, kidnapping, unlawful imprisonment and criminal possession of a firearm. The court records further show that Woeltz told officers he was confused why he had been taken in. He said: "I don't know what triggered you all coming out here but I know it sucks." Woeltz further said he had been sleeping when cops stormed his apartment and that he worked in "cybersecurity". 6 The crypto investor allegedly tortured a captive Italian with a chainsaw Credit: ABC 7
