
Opinion Bengaluru's new local governance Act goes against the spirit of decentralisation
The Greater Bengaluru Governance Act, 2024 (GBG Act), meant to replace the Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike Act, 2020 (BBMP Act, 2020), received the Karnataka Governor's assent on April 24. This comes in the aftermath of protest, controversy and walkouts staged against the Act, while it was passed in both the legislative assembly and the legislative council in Karnataka. The GBG Act provides for the creation of the Greater Bengaluru Authority for coordinating and supervising the development of the Greater Bengaluru area. Despite its claims to be 'futuristic', it does little to address Bengaluru's existing problems, which are rooted in lack of coordination among multiple agencies, ineffective decentralisation, and the lack of effective devolution of functions.
While the mayors of the municipal corporations within the Greater Bengaluru Area are designated as ex-officio members of the Greater Bengaluru Authority, the fact that the Chief Minister is the ex-officio chairperson is a cause for concern. As the GBG Act aims to improve the quality of life of all citizens of Bengaluru, the mayor — considered the city's first citizen — must be empowered to preside over the meetings of the Authority to ensure coordination, execution and administration of plans, schemes and major projects. These problems are compounded by the fact that the mayor's term is limited to 30 months — too short to provide stability in governance and to secure a long-term vision for the city.
The Constitution (Seventy-fourth Amendment) Act, 1992, (74th CAA) provides for the establishment of urban local bodies(ULBs) as institutions of local self-government. The objective of the 74th CAA was to devolve key civic functions to ULBs, but in reality, functions such as planning, land use regulation, water supply and others continue to be provided by parastatals in Karnataka/Bengaluru. It is already problematic that these parastatals work directly under the state government and are not accountable to the ULBs. The 1st State Finance Commission, constituted in 1994 had, in fact, recommended that parastatal agencies such as the Bengaluru Development Authority should be brought under the purview of the ULBs. A reading of the composition of the GBA and its functions takes us back to an era that existed before the enactment of the 74th CAA. The Authority essentially brings the operation of the corporations under the control and jurisdiction of the state government, in direct contravention of the intent and purpose of the 74th CAA. The Act perpetuates continued encroachment on the functions and revenues of local governments by the apparently 'specialised agencies' of the state government, thereby weakening the autonomy of local governments and hindering their performance. The fact that the city does not have an elected council only exacerbates the problem, as a ULB without a council cannot be held accountable and responsible by the citizens.
The 74th CAA provides for the creation of ward committees, envisioning them as a bridge between the municipal government and citizens. The GBG Act aims to 'empower Ward Committees to become basic units of urban governance and facilitate community participation'. However, it is important to note that the Act falls short on two fronts when it comes to ward committees. First, although the Act states that decisions of the ward committee shall be made on the basis of a simple majority, by giving a veto power to the chairperson of the ward committee, it renders the idea of voting meaningless, as the chairperson still retains the ultimate decision-making power. Second, Section 103 of the Act clearly states that the recommendations of the ward committee are advisory in nature, thereby rendering the committee toothless. The Act has also done away with Area Sabhas, a body that actually institutionalised community participation and has been instrumental in empowering the residents to suggest development priorities for their areas.
Decentralisation is essential for effective governance, but it cannot be mere lip service. While the Act aims to restructure the BBMP into 'more manageable' corporations, the split will only create coordination problems between the smaller corporations. Some questions remain: What happens to the Bengaluru Metropolitan Land Transport Authority, which has a similar structure to the GBA? Will Bengaluru have to wait for many more years for a mayor and corporators? How long will it be before the GBG Act is struck down by the courts for being contrary to the 74th CAA? When will the city have a new master plan? While states continue to fight over the lack of effective decentralisation and federalism, perhaps it is also time for them to look inwards to address these very concerns to ensure that decision-making power in our democracy effectively trickles down and reaches the cities, towns and villages, as envisioned by our Constitution.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


India Gazette
12 hours ago
- India Gazette
Shivakumar visits urban waste management facilities in Delhi to shape
New Delhi [India], June 9 (ANI): Karnataka Deputy Chief Minister DK Shivakumar and officials from the Greater Bengaluru Authority (GBA) met officials from the Municipal Corporation of Delhi on Monday and visited some facilities to learn how the national capital is dealing with urban challenges such as town planning, waste management and the construction bye-laws. 'Delhi is a very historic, big and planned city. The population is double that of Bangalore. There are three challenges in Delhi: town planning, waste management, and the construction by-laws. Though I visited Hyderabad and Chennai as well, but it was very important to know about the new policies in Delhi. If a city is not planned, it cannot work... I had a brief meeting and they gave their presentation citing new laws and their plans for the coming 25-30 years,' Shivakumar told reporters. He visited the Tehkhand Waste to Electricity Project Limited in Delhi. 'Among all the plants I have visited, this one seems to be the most modern. It was a good learning experience for me. Let me go to Bengaluru and discuss this with my colleagues,' Shivakumar said. According to Tehkhand Waste to Electricity Project Limited website, it is a step towards managing ever increasing Municipal solid Waste and to prevent it going to landfill which is one of the efficient and environmentally friendly solutions for waste management. As part of our efforts to study effective urban waste management, Shivakumar also visited the Okhla SLF site in Delhi today. 'Towards a Cleaner, Smarter Bengaluru! As part of our ongoing efforts to strengthen municipal governance and enhance solid waste management in Bengaluru, I visited the Delhi Municipal Corporation at the SPM Civic Centre on Jawaharlal Nehru Marg today, accompanied by officers from the Greater Bengaluru Authority (GBA). Our delegation was warmly received and engaged in insightful discussions with officials from MCD and DDA. We were briefed on Delhi's Master Plan, town planning strategies, building bye-laws, and the online building sanction system. We also visited the Okhla SLF site to understand the process of bio-mining legacy waste-an important step toward sustainable waste solutions,' he said in a post on X. 'This visit follows earlier study visits to Hyderabad and Chennai, as we continue to explore and learn from successful urban waste management models across India. The aim is clear: to adopt proven, scalable technologies and planning frameworks that will shape a cleaner, more sustainable future for Namma Bengaluru,' he added. To deal with various issues concerning garbage, waste and sewage, the Centre launched the Swachh Bharat Mission -Urban (SBM-U) on October 2, 2014 and the Atal Mission for Rejuvenation and Urban Transformation (AMRUT) in 500 cities on June 25, 2015. To carry forward the work done on ground in Phase-I, Swachh Bharat Mission-Urban (SBM-U) 2.0 has been launched on October 1st, 2021 for a period of five years, up to October 1, 2026, with a vision of achieving safe sanitation and scientific processing of municipal solid waste in all cities. (ANI)


Time of India
13 hours ago
- Time of India
Govt targeting 2034 to hold 1st 'one nation, one election'
NEW DELHI: As the govt is expecting to hold the first countrywide simultaneous polls by 2034 after passage of the constitutional amendment bill for 'one nation, one election', all state assemblies to be elected after 2029 will be for a shorter duration to align their tenure with the 2034 general elections. Head of the joint parliamentary committee (JPC) on the 'one nation, one election' bill (The Constitution (129th Amendment) Bill, 2024) PP Choudhary explained to TOI that after 2027, the assembly due to be elected in 2032 may have a tenure of only two years to ensure the synchronisation of the next elections in Uttar Pradesh-India's largest state electorally -with the Lok Sabha polls which may be held in 2034. The Constitution (129th Amendment) Bill, 2024, and the Union Territories Laws (Amendment Bill), 2024, have provisions for simultaneous elections to the Lok Sabha and state assemblies. As per provisions of the constitution amendment bill, the President may issue a notification on the date of the first sitting of Lok Sabha after a general election, in all probability the one to be held in 2029, to spell when the next general elections will be due. The terms of all state assemblies constituted after this date will expire with the end of that Lok Sabha's five-year term. If Lok Sabha or a state assembly is dissolved earlier than its five-year term, an election for it will be held for a term equal to the remainder of the five-year term. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 전체임플란트 간단 뼈이식포함 300만원에 kimplant 더 알아보기 Undo This will synchronise its next election with the simultaneous elections cycle. Even in states, where polls will be due, elections for assemblies will be held only to align with the Lok Sabha polls. However, the bill states that if the Election Commission is of the opinion that election to a state assembly cannot be held along with the rest of the country, it may make a recommendation to the President in this regard. The President may issue an order to conduct an election for that assembly at a later date. The BJP MP from Pali in Rajasthan, Choudhary, said going by the JPC's working, its tenure may be extended as there was a consensus amongst panel members to visit states and UTs before making the final recommendations. So far, JPC members have visited Maharashtra and Uttarakhand. The bills had been introduced in LS in Dec last year and were referred to the Chaudhary-led panel which has been holding consultations with stakeholders for feedback.


Indian Express
a day ago
- Indian Express
Proposal to include Tumakuru under Greater Bengaluru Authority soon: Karnataka Home Minister
Karnataka Home Minister G Parameshwara said Monday that a proposal will be submitted soon to the government to include Tumakuru under the Greater Bengaluru Authority (GBA). While speaking to reporters, Parameshwara pointed out that Tumakuru, which is around 70 km from Bengaluru, was growing rapidly. 'There is an industrial hub (at Tumakuru) in an area of 20,000 acre. Many are demanding that Tumakuru be expanded like Bengaluru. A study is being conducted on the issue,' he said. 'In the manner in which Ramanagar is renamed Bengaluru South, if Tumakuru is included in Greater Bengaluru, it will benefit us in terms of development. We will submit a proposal regarding the same,' Parameshwara, who is also in-charge minister for the Tumakuru district, said. The proposal came amidst demands to extend the Bengaluru Metro services to Tumakuru to boost connectivity between the two cities. The minister said the Karnataka government will take a call on extending Metro services to Tumakuru. 'Union Minister V Somanna has said that Tumakuru requires metro connectivity. Let there be both Metro and suburban rail connectivity,' he said. The Greater Bengaluru Authority was notified by the Karnataka Government last month after the GBA Act was passed in the Budget Session of the Assembly. The Act provided for the expansion of Bengaluru by including panchayats from areas neighbouring the Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike (BBMP). Multiple city corporations under GBA are also possible under the provisions of the Bill. Responding to a question on reports that he had asked for a change in portfolio, Parameshwara lashed out at media outlets for defaming him by publishing unverified reports. 'There were reports that I had asked for a change of portfolio with the chief minister (following the stampede at M Chinnaswamy stadium). Who told this to you (the media)? Please verify facts before publishing any news,' he said.