War of words over GST carve-up as states butt heads
Queensland Treasurer David Janetzki accused his southern counterparts of receiving $800 million out of the Sunshine State's GST share to reimburse "COVID-19 failures, five years after the fact".
"The GST distribution should not compensate states for any economic or financial mismanagement," he said in his maiden post-budget speech to a Committee for Economic Development of Australia event in Brisbane.
"In practice, this doesn't always occur."
Queensland's revenue has been hit hard by a $2.3 billion reduction of GST revenue in 2025/26 and more than $5.3 billion over the following three years.
The share is 28 per cent higher than a decade ago but significantly lower than a 58 per cent jump for NSW, Victoria's 118 per cent rise and Western Australia's whopping 317 per cent.
"Queensland's unprecedented GST reduction ... has punched a hole in revenue forecasts," Mr Janetzki said.
The state budget revealed a record $205 billion debt blackhole by 2028/29 and an $8 billion deficit in the next financial year.
Mr Janetzki also claimed Melbourne received twice as much funding for ferries as Brisbane, which was a reflection on the Commonwealth Grants Commission's "fundamental misunderstanding" of transport infrastructure in a decentralised state.
"They effectively assume the cost of serving a resident in Ballarat, 113 kilometres from Melbourne, is the same as the cost of serving a resident in Mackay, 968 kilometres from Brisbane," he said.
But Victorian Premier Jacinta Allan refuted Mr Janetzki's claims, using choice words to condemn the Queensland treasurer's allegations.
"Perhaps, let me put it in language in a way that the Queensland treasurer can understand - it's just bullshit," she said.
"Because when you look at the history of GST, Victoria has been a net contributor to the tune of $31 billion.
"And the Queensland budget's blackhole, their $8 billion-plus black hole, has got nothing to do with the circumstances here in Victoria."
Ms Allan said she does not want to quibble with another state over "nonsense" instead focusing on Victoria receiving its "fair share".
But the quibble continued when Mr Janetzki rebuffed that "the facts speak for themselves".
"The facts couldn't be any clearer," he told reporters.
"Canberra's carver has sold Queensland down the river to keep Victoria afloat."
It is not the first time a war of words has escalated over the GST carve-up after former Victorian Treasurer Tim Pallas called NSW Premier Chris Minns "mathematically challenged".
"He might not be the sharpest tool in the shed but he is a tool," Mr Pallas said last year.
It occurred over the 2024/25 distribution that saw NSW and Queensland's share fall while Victoria received a boost.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sydney Morning Herald
4 minutes ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
This should be a prime slice of the city. But it's dark, noisy and unsafe
Page says the pocket provides crucial riverside open space for the growing number of apartment buildings popping up nearby. He says the kiosks are well-intentioned but don't work because they look temporary and sporadically placed. 'This part of the city has evolved to need a more permanent structural investment,' he says. 'It's such a little gem for the city ... and we need to unlock it. It just shouldn't feel unsafe.' Far East Consortium executive director Craig Williams says the company still manages public car parking and the sheds, via a lease with the Victorian government, but says the railway and lack of sunlight have been a challenge for the area. Williams says Far East would be willing to help finance a new, commercially viable plan. 'Would we like to see something better there? Yes,' Williams says. 'If anyone could think of something clever to do there, I'm all ears.' Property investor Joe Cairns is taking ownership of the office building at 525 Flinders Street in November after purchasing it for $33 million. 'I can see the value in it long term, it's overlooking the Yarra … and you've got Southern Cross and Flinders Street Station up the road.' Cairns is motivated to see the Rebecca Walk 'dead zone' transformed and is willing to contribute financially with leadership at a local or state level. 'The area's got so much potential, it's just never been done properly,' he says. Architect Rob Adams, who led urban design at the City of Melbourne for 40 years until he left the council in 2023, says building under the rail bridge is particularly tough. He recalls in the '80s looking at ways to reduce its impact by embedding it within the structure of a building – like the Sea Life Aquarium did in 1999. 'You might need to sacrifice some of [Batman Park] to create a high amenity, but the result is better parkland and a nicer edge,' Adams says. 'Generally viaducts have dark areas underneath that are not pleasant places to be.' Adams says the commercial sheds have been on the site for too long, and it's time to reimagine the precinct. 'Temporary containers are just not doing it,' he says. 'The nature of it is no one has spent any money on it, nobody's curated it and it's therefore failing, and in failing, it becomes even more of a distraction.' The Rebecca Walk and Batman Park area is on Crown land with a mix of responsibility arrangements, including management by City of Melbourne, Metro and Far East Consortium. A spokeswoman for Metro, which is responsible for the bridge, says 4000 square metres of graffiti had been removed from the structure so far this year. 'The illegal graffiti on our train network is an ongoing frustration we share with the community,' she says.
The Age
4 minutes ago
- The Age
This should be a prime slice of the city. But it's dark, noisy and unsafe
Page says the pocket provides crucial riverside open space for the growing number of apartment buildings popping up nearby. He says the kiosks are well-intentioned but don't work because they look temporary and sporadically placed. 'This part of the city has evolved to need a more permanent structural investment,' he says. 'It's such a little gem for the city ... and we need to unlock it. It just shouldn't feel unsafe.' Far East Consortium executive director Craig Williams says the company still manages public car parking and the sheds, via a lease with the Victorian government, but says the railway and lack of sunlight have been a challenge for the area. Williams says Far East would be willing to help finance a new, commercially viable plan. 'Would we like to see something better there? Yes,' Williams says. 'If anyone could think of something clever to do there, I'm all ears.' Property investor Joe Cairns is taking ownership of the office building at 525 Flinders Street in November after purchasing it for $33 million. 'I can see the value in it long term, it's overlooking the Yarra … and you've got Southern Cross and Flinders Street Station up the road.' Cairns is motivated to see the Rebecca Walk 'dead zone' transformed and is willing to contribute financially with leadership at a local or state level. 'The area's got so much potential, it's just never been done properly,' he says. Architect Rob Adams, who led urban design at the City of Melbourne for 40 years until he left the council in 2023, says building under the rail bridge is particularly tough. He recalls in the '80s looking at ways to reduce its impact by embedding it within the structure of a building – like the Sea Life Aquarium did in 1999. 'You might need to sacrifice some of [Batman Park] to create a high amenity, but the result is better parkland and a nicer edge,' Adams says. 'Generally viaducts have dark areas underneath that are not pleasant places to be.' Adams says the commercial sheds have been on the site for too long, and it's time to reimagine the precinct. 'Temporary containers are just not doing it,' he says. 'The nature of it is no one has spent any money on it, nobody's curated it and it's therefore failing, and in failing, it becomes even more of a distraction.' The Rebecca Walk and Batman Park area is on Crown land with a mix of responsibility arrangements, including management by City of Melbourne, Metro and Far East Consortium. A spokeswoman for Metro, which is responsible for the bridge, says 4000 square metres of graffiti had been removed from the structure so far this year. 'The illegal graffiti on our train network is an ongoing frustration we share with the community,' she says.
The Advertiser
8 minutes ago
- The Advertiser
Embattled airline Qantas adds another woe to its list
RECENT QANTAS SCANDALS: * Qantas outsourced more than 1800 ground staff jobs in 2020 during the COVID-19 pandemic, in a move ruled illegal and an attempt to curb union bargaining power in wage negotiations by courts. It was fined $90 million, on top of a $120 million compensation payment * The consumer watchdog successfully sued Qantas for selling tickets to thousands of flights that had already been cancelled between 2021 and 2023. The 'ghost flights' saga cost the airline a $100 million fine and $20 million more in compensation * Qantas was dragged into controversy surrounding Qatar Airways' request for more flights into Australia in 2023. After the federal government rejected the request, it was accused of protecting Qantas from competition * Complaints about customer service, including cancellations, delays and lost luggage, spiked following the pandemic * Despite the numerous negative headlines, Qantas executives received hefty pay packets with at-the-time CEO Alan Joyce initially set to be paid $21.4 million for the 2022/23 financial year. The airline eventually cut his package by $9 million * Mr Joyce resigned as CEO in September 2023, two months earlier than scheduled. He acknowledged the numerous recent scandals and said "the company needs to move ahead with its renewal as a priority" RECENT QANTAS SCANDALS: * Qantas outsourced more than 1800 ground staff jobs in 2020 during the COVID-19 pandemic, in a move ruled illegal and an attempt to curb union bargaining power in wage negotiations by courts. It was fined $90 million, on top of a $120 million compensation payment * The consumer watchdog successfully sued Qantas for selling tickets to thousands of flights that had already been cancelled between 2021 and 2023. The 'ghost flights' saga cost the airline a $100 million fine and $20 million more in compensation * Qantas was dragged into controversy surrounding Qatar Airways' request for more flights into Australia in 2023. After the federal government rejected the request, it was accused of protecting Qantas from competition * Complaints about customer service, including cancellations, delays and lost luggage, spiked following the pandemic * Despite the numerous negative headlines, Qantas executives received hefty pay packets with at-the-time CEO Alan Joyce initially set to be paid $21.4 million for the 2022/23 financial year. The airline eventually cut his package by $9 million * Mr Joyce resigned as CEO in September 2023, two months earlier than scheduled. He acknowledged the numerous recent scandals and said "the company needs to move ahead with its renewal as a priority" RECENT QANTAS SCANDALS: * Qantas outsourced more than 1800 ground staff jobs in 2020 during the COVID-19 pandemic, in a move ruled illegal and an attempt to curb union bargaining power in wage negotiations by courts. It was fined $90 million, on top of a $120 million compensation payment * The consumer watchdog successfully sued Qantas for selling tickets to thousands of flights that had already been cancelled between 2021 and 2023. The 'ghost flights' saga cost the airline a $100 million fine and $20 million more in compensation * Qantas was dragged into controversy surrounding Qatar Airways' request for more flights into Australia in 2023. After the federal government rejected the request, it was accused of protecting Qantas from competition * Complaints about customer service, including cancellations, delays and lost luggage, spiked following the pandemic * Despite the numerous negative headlines, Qantas executives received hefty pay packets with at-the-time CEO Alan Joyce initially set to be paid $21.4 million for the 2022/23 financial year. The airline eventually cut his package by $9 million * Mr Joyce resigned as CEO in September 2023, two months earlier than scheduled. He acknowledged the numerous recent scandals and said "the company needs to move ahead with its renewal as a priority" RECENT QANTAS SCANDALS: * Qantas outsourced more than 1800 ground staff jobs in 2020 during the COVID-19 pandemic, in a move ruled illegal and an attempt to curb union bargaining power in wage negotiations by courts. It was fined $90 million, on top of a $120 million compensation payment * The consumer watchdog successfully sued Qantas for selling tickets to thousands of flights that had already been cancelled between 2021 and 2023. The 'ghost flights' saga cost the airline a $100 million fine and $20 million more in compensation * Qantas was dragged into controversy surrounding Qatar Airways' request for more flights into Australia in 2023. After the federal government rejected the request, it was accused of protecting Qantas from competition * Complaints about customer service, including cancellations, delays and lost luggage, spiked following the pandemic * Despite the numerous negative headlines, Qantas executives received hefty pay packets with at-the-time CEO Alan Joyce initially set to be paid $21.4 million for the 2022/23 financial year. The airline eventually cut his package by $9 million * Mr Joyce resigned as CEO in September 2023, two months earlier than scheduled. He acknowledged the numerous recent scandals and said "the company needs to move ahead with its renewal as a priority"
