Dentist criticised for 'supervised neglect' of some patients
Photo:
123rf.com
A dentist working in sole practice for three decades has been criticised for sloppy record-keeping and "supervised neglect" of some patients.
Deputy Health and Disability Commissioner Dr Vanessa Caldwell has just issued her findings in relation to seven patients of the dentist 'Dr C'.
The problems came to light in November 2021, when Dr C had a break from practice and two other dentists treated his patients.
Dr Angela McKeefry, an expert advisor to the HDC, described his care of one patient - Ms D - as a case of "supervised neglect" over a period of 25 years.
She had about 18 appointments in that time, but never had any X-rays taken, even before having teeth removed.
Another dentist who saw her in February 2022 because her front teeth were sore said she was "in complete shock" to learn she had severe periodontal disease, as she had been seeing Dr C for regular cleaning.
An X-ray showed dead gum tissue, abscess and "severe bone loss" around some teeth.
Dr McKeefry admitted that even with specialist treatment, the patient could still have lost all her upper teeth, but she was "effectively given no opportunity to try and prevent this from happening".
"The lack of radiographs, periodontal pocket depth charting, diagnosis, offer of specialist referral or satisfactory clinical notes would be found to be shocking by most dentists."
Dr C told the commission that after providing dental care to the community for 30 years "this complaint has been a source of shame and stress for him".
He acknowledged his record-keeping was significantly below standard for all these patients and that there were deficiencies in the care provided, and said that he was sorry for this.
For many of these patients, the treatment he provided allowed them to keep their teeth for longer than they otherwise would have, he said.
He maintained he discussed treatment plans with his patients, but accepted his poor record-keeping meant this could not be confirmed.
"Dr C also acknowledged that he should have been more assertive with some patients, setting out holistic, permanent options for treatment as opposed to quick-fix solutions that would only prolong the inevitable."
The dentist said he had taken various steps to improve his practice, and has had no complaints since 2021, including doing extra training, working with a supervisor and hiring more staff to do administration.
Dr Caldwell said due to the severity of the breaches and number of patients affected, she had considered prosecution.
"However, given the measures that have since been put in place by the Dental Council, the time that has elapsed since these events, and that some of the consumers did not support a referral, I have decided not to proceed with a referral to the Director of Proceedings in this instance."
Instead, she has recommended Dr C do some additional training, an audit of his records, and apologise to the patients involved.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter
curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Aged Care Association says ward for medically discharged shows need for funding
The 20-bed ward was created in May for people who were effectively medically discharged but did not have anywhere to go for lower level care. Photo: rafaelbenari/123RF The Aged Care Association says the the additional ward at North Shore Hospital demonstrates a need for Te Whatu Ora Health New Zealand (HNZ) to start paying care homes to support people who are not yet ready to return home. The 20-bed ward, known as ward six, was created in May for people who were effectively medically discharged but did not have anywhere to go for lower level care, because of their specific needs. RNZ understands they are not under the direct care of doctors, but being looked after by nurses and allied health staff such as physiotherapists and social workers. HNZ's Waitematā operations director Brad Healey said they had started the dedicated ward to help boost capacity in the busy winter period. But Aged Care Association chief executive Tracey Martin told Checkpoint there had been an underfunding of the residential care sector for some time, and the government needed to work out a way to compensate aged care facilities for taking in people in similar situations to those in ward six. "The shortage is not new. The fact that we've got an ageing population and so more people will need residential care, or somewhere secondary to recover ... rather than taking up an acute bed in a hospital is not new," she said. Care homes had the facilities to support people in their rehabilitation and transition out of hospital, but HNZ needed to review how those beds were paid for, she said. "Our sector has got registered nurses, enrolled nurses, nurse practitioners, we have GPs ... they have healthcare assistance ... Those with hospital level care have got all of the equipment. "They're there and they are capable of actually taking in individuals ... and working with them so that they are ready to go home, and are unlikely to then have to be readmitted to hospital because they have been released too soon." The challenge was that there was not a proper funding model to pay for a person receiving that kind of care, she said. "Because that person is not entering residential care it will require a contract between Health New Zealand and the facility, and the provider, to pay a certain price per day to actually provide the care and the support that person needs." Currently the model provided by HNZ put forward had "no evidence base" and did not match the cost of providing that care, she said. There was a shortage of some 12,000 beds compared to what was needed now and what would be needed in the future, and businesses needed to be compensated by the government for any work they did to pick up the slack, she said. "Te Whatu Ora themselves said that these individuals need a very high level of care. And if they're not prepared to pay a private business for them, then that business is going to make a loss. "Really, it's the government's responsibility to look after its citizens if they need clinical care," Martin said. Despite the wide capabilities of care homes in New Zealand, Martin said she was unsure whether the individuals in ward six could be placed under the care of an aged care facility as she did not know their conditions. HNZ apparently thought there was no aged care home in the country that could look after them for them, she said. "I guess they'll just have to stay in hospital if that's the case. "I think it's unusual," she said. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
4 hours ago
- RNZ News
Hospital ward full of patients with no medical need to be there
A ward of people at Northshore Hospital that have no medical reason to be there, but can't be discharged because they have nowhere to go for further care is the tip of the iceberg, according the Aged Care Association. The 20-bed ward was created in May for patients and RNZ understands the people there were not under the direct care of doctors, but were looked after by nurses and allied health staff such as physiotherapists and social workers. There is effectively nowhere for them to be discharged to further care, like an aged care facility. Chief executive of the Aged Care Association, Tracey Martin. To embed this content on your own webpage, cut and paste the following: See terms of use.
RNZ News
12 hours ago
- RNZ News
The Governments' latest health and safety announcements
A health and safety expert says extensive consultation last year with the sector, has largely been ignored in favour of isolated comments and anecdotes. Last week the Minister for Workplace Relations and Safety Brooke van Velden made five announcements related to reducing red tape across various workplaces. This included proposals to change when scaffolding might be required, rules for children working and being on farms, exposure to dust and fumes, and reducing red tape for adventure activity and amusement ride operators. The Health and Safety at Work Act 2015 is 10 years old, and the promise to reform New Zealand's health and safety laws was an agreement in the ACT - National Coalition Agreement. Mike Cosman has almost 50 years' experience in occupational safety and health and risk management in New Zealand and internationally. He was Chair of the NZ Institute of Safety Management Board for 9 years, and runs the health and safety consultancy form CosmanParkes. To embed this content on your own webpage, cut and paste the following: See terms of use.
