Underground blaze at illegal dumpsite drags on, raising health fears
The area's Ward councillor, Andrew Akkers, wrote to the SA Human Rights Commission (SAHRC), accusing authorities of failing to protect residents' constitutional rights to a safe and healthy environment.
Related story: Toxic smoulder takes over Sea Cow Lake
The fire, burning since early June on private land in Gum Tree Road in Sea Cow Lake, affects multiple communities, including Kenville, Sea Cow Lake, Effingham Heights, Avoca, and Greenwood Park, as well as parts of neighbouring Ward 36.
'The situation constitutes a violation of our constitutional rights,' Akkers wrote in his complaint, citing residents' right to an environment not harmful to health (Section 24 of the Constitution) and the right to access health care services (Section 27).
According to Akkers, illegal dumping has plagued the site for more than a decade, with rubbish now spilling into a protected D'MOSS conservancy area, threatening ecologically sensitive land. Efforts to extinguish the fire have hit multiple roadblocks.
The landfill's towering height, reportedly around 17m, and the unstable terrain, have made it impossible to smother the fire with retardants or to deploy firefighters safely.
'The municipality's inaction constitutes a failure to protect the community from environmental harm,' Akkers said, accusing officials of neglecting their duty to prevent ecological damage and uphold environmental laws.
In his letter, Akkers has urged the SAHRC to investigate the fire, determine whether constitutional rights have been breached, and compel state organs to intervene and rehabilitate the land. He also called for affected residents to be given a platform to voice their concerns.
'I sincerely hope the Commission will intervene in this urgent matter to safeguard the rights, imminently endangered health, and dignity of our affected communities,' Akkers said.
The SAHRC responded to Akkers stating that it would assess the complaint to determine whether it falls within the mandate of the SAHRC; or whether it should be dealt with by another organisation, institution, statutory body or institution created by the Constitution or any applicable legislation.
Health implications
Ward 36 resident Crystal Little, who lives in Acutt Avenue, said she has to sleep with room doors closed in an attempt to keep the toxic smell out.
'It smells like rubber and chemicals burning. The stench gets worse towards early morning, around 02:00, and it wakes me up. I have to close all the doors and windows but the smell still creeps in. I cover my head with blankets when I go to sleep. I suffer nose bleeds and battle with a throat burning. Everyone in this area is hoping the matter will be sorted,' she said.
Little added that she and other residents are aware that a landslide could occur if the fire department tries to douse the smoulder.
'We have had terrible flooding over the recent years and no avalanche has happened. The safe thing to do is to evacuate everyone living at the bottom of the illegal dump site and for the fire department to spray a fine trickle of continuous water, similar to a soaking rain, in order to stop the toxic matter from burning,' said Little.
'I live in Riverside and I have never experienced air pollution like we have at the moment. It is a pungent acrid smell in which you cannot breathe. It is totally unacceptable that we have to live like this,' said Bruce Forrest.
'That is totally unacceptable to us the citizens and ratepayers residing in the area. The officials are not taking this seriously at all and are just fobbing us off,' he added.
eThekwini Municipality spokesperson Gugu Sisilane said the City's Emergency Services, Environmental Health Practitioners, and Air Quality Specialists are working jointly to mitigate the impact of smoke currently emitting from an illegal dumpsite in the Gum Tree Road area.
#GumtreeRoad #ToxicFumesDurban #Ward34 ♬ original sound – caxtonlocalmedia @caxtonlocalmedia Three eThekwini Municipality departments were called out to Gumtree Road in Ward 34 last Thursday after residents raised the alarm over toxic fumes emanating from an old illegal dumpsite. Toxic chemicals had been dumped on this site in previous years until Metro SAPS intervened last year and fined the culprit. These chemicals, now underground, is what is burning and expelling toxic fumes into the air. Anil Beekrum, chairman of the Kenville and Sea Cow Lake Residents and Ratepayers Association and vice-chairman for the Kenville and Sea Cow Lake Community Policing Forum said he has stopped a vehicles from dumping in the area and reported registration numbers to law enforcement and the City's parks and gardens department. Municipal spokesperson Gugu Sisilane said: 'A multi-disciplinary operation is working round the clock to alleviate the impact of pollution and restore air quality in the affected areas as swiftly as possible.' #CaxtonLocalMedia
For more from the Highway Mail, follow us on Facebook , X and Instagram. You can also check out our videos on our YouTube channel or follow us on TikTok.
Click to subscribe to our newsletter here
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
4 hours ago
- The Citizen
Struggle veterans in Endumeni call on municipalities to respect constitutional rights
ANC struggle veterans and members of the ANC Women's League gathered in Dundee last week to honour the legacy of Nelson Mandela and reflect on the sacrifices made during South Africa's liberation struggle. The joint engagement also served as a platform for raising urgent concerns around governance, service delivery and constitutional rights. Addressing the gathering, local struggle veteran Mzwakhe Sithebe said: 'The exorbitant billing by Umzinyathi, along with misleading estimates, continues to frustrate residents. There is a serious lack of public participation within both Umzinyathi and Endumeni municipalities. This is unacceptable.' Sithebe expressed full support for the community's pending legal action against the municipality for its failure to provide water. 'An increasing number of areas in Endumeni are experiencing dry taps. This is a clear violation of Sections 24 and 27 of the Constitution. The constitutional mandate is not being honoured.' He added that the 'renewed ANC is not inward-looking but responsive to people's needs', stressing that members are committed to building a party that remains a servant of the people. Other key concerns raised during the meeting included: The slow progress on land restitution, which members said must be prioritised to build a responsive state; Allegations of nepotism in municipal appointments, with preference reportedly given to relatives of officials; Councillors failing to hold regular constituency meetings; The absence of genuine public participation in local government despite it being a cornerstone of democracy outlined in the Freedom Charter and Section 152 of the Constitution. Sithebe concluded: 'The call that 'the people shall govern' must be more than just words. Our municipalities must reflect the will and needs of our communities.' HAVE YOUR SAY: Like our Facebook page, follow us on Twitter and Instagram or email us at [email protected]. Add us on WhatsApp 071 277 1394.
The Citizen
5 hours ago
- The Citizen
EFF calls on Madlanga to ensure ‘every cent' of inquiry is accounted for
The commission is expected to cost taxpayers an estimated R147.9 million. The EFF has called on former Deputy Chief Justice Mbuyiseli Madlanga to ensure that every cent of the cost of the venue where the inquiry into KwaZulu-Natal (KZN) police chief Lieutenant General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi's allegations of criminal infiltration into the South African justice system takes place is accounted for. Secretary-general Marshall Dlamini wrote to Madlanga in his capacity as chairperson of the Judicial Commission. Venue cost The commission is expected to cost taxpayers an estimated R147.9 million. In the letter, Dlamini outlined the commencement of the commission's work, with particular focus on the venue to be used and the overall costs associated with its operations. 'The EFF's concern arises from the costly precedent set by the Judicial Commission of Inquiry into Allegations of State Capture ('the Zondo Commission'). The Zondo Commission cost the nation nearly R1 billion, with a significant portion of the expenditure linked directly to the lease of its venue at Hill on Empire in Parktown, Johannesburg. ALSO READ: Madlanga inquiry: How much probe into Mkhwanazi's allegations will cost 'This expense was not incidental; it was one of the single largest cost drivers over the Commission's lifespan,' Dlamini said. Not about expenditure Dlamini said the EFF's letter is not just a question of high expenditure. 'The EFF has repeatedly raised concerns about inflated pricing in such lease agreements, lack of transparent and competitive procurement processes, the use of elitist venues that are inaccessible to ordinary members of the public, undermining the constitutional principle of openness in such inquiries,' Dlamini said. 'As the EFF, we believe that the public has a right to expect that every cent spent on this commission is used in the most prudent and transparent manner possible. The commission of inquiry must not become a conduit for the enrichment of private landlords and politically connected service providers at the expense of the people. 'It is our view that for this Commission, the Chairperson must insist on the use of a municipal hall or another publicly owned facility for the entire duration of its operations,' he said. Dlamini said in the case of the Zondo Commission, the awarding of contracts to Tiso Black Star and Redefine Properties raised doubts about whether 'due process was followed at all.' Credibility Dlamini warned that should the commission proceed to lease a privately-owned venue under terms similar to those of the Zondo Commission, it will be making a choice that is both 'financially reckless and contrary to the public interest. It would also risk undermining the credibility of the inquiry before a single witness is heard.' 'We trust that you will receive this letter in the constructive spirit in which it is intended: to safeguard the financial sustainability of the Commission, preserve its credibility, and ensure that it remains open and accessible to all South Africans.' President Cyril Ramaphosa announced his decision to establish a commission of inquiry to investigate the serious allegations of political interference in police operations made by Mkhwanazi earlier in July. The commission is expected to deliver a preliminary report in three months and a final report within six months of its formation. ALSO READ: Madlanga inquiry: Mkhwanazi first to be consulted [VIDEO]
The Citizen
15 hours ago
- The Citizen
Ramaphosa seeks apartheid damages case delay, but victims' families argue perpetrators are dying
The court was told that the government's interest lies in uncovering the truth. President Cyril Ramaphosa has asked the Gauteng High Court in Pretoria to stay a damages case brought by families of victims of apartheid-era crimes. However, lawyers for the applicants have warned that the alleged perpetrators are old and dying. The legal action, initiated by 25 families and survivors of apartheid victims – including relatives of the Cradock Four – seeks R167 million in constitutional damages. ALSO READ: Ramaphosa launches commission of inquiry into apartheid-era justice delays The applicants accuse the government of blocking the investigation and prosecution of murder cases referred by the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC). Ramaphosa has since established a commission of inquiry chaired by retired judge Sisi Khampepe to investigate the lack of prosecutions. Ramaphosa urges court to delay apartheid damages case On Wednesday, Advocate Timothy Bruinders, representing Ramaphosa and government, argued in court that the commission should be allowed to complete its work before the damages case proceeds. 'There was notice put out by judge Khampepe in which she set out what the progress will be over the next month. 'I think she has just started work on it so it's settled that there is a commission,' he told the court. Bruinders pointed out that both the TRC and the families had previously called for the establishment of such a commission to investigate the apartheid-era crimes. 'The reason for the commission of inquiry is because the facts are as yet unknown,' he said. ALSO READ: Mbeki accused of trying to save his reputation by intervening in apartheid lawsuit Judge Nicolene Janse van Nieuwenhuizen, however, raised a concern about whether it was not the applicants' prerogative to go ahead or withdraw their case. Bruinders responded that the case relied on the commission's findings in order for the court to make a ruling on damages. He argued that former National Director of Public Prosecutions Vusi Pikoli did not provide enough detail to conclude that interference occurred in one of the TRC cases. 'One could conclude from that there was an attempted interference.' Watch the case below: Bruinders added that the government and president sympathise with the families. 'They don't have closure. As they say, the prosecutions haven't happened. 'This is of concern to any government who cares about its citizens and those who died in fighting for what he ultimately sees now in the Constitution.' He emphasised that the government's interest lies in uncovering the truth. 'It is not to fight the families on procedural matters. One can imagine how that would go down politically. I do not think it would go down very well.' Victims' families demand justice Later, Advocate Matthew Chaskalson – representing the families – criticised the government's request to the court to delay the damages case, particularly as it had years to establish the commission. 'The applicants are seeking justice for crimes that were committed 30 and 35 years ago. That's the period we are dealing with. 'The perpetrators of these crimes have either already died or are dying at a rapid rate,' he said, pointing out that most suspects are now likely in their 70s. Chaskalson told the court that the applicants themselves are aging and that some have already died. 'They do not have time to wait indefinitely for the commission of inquiry to report and for relief to be recommended,' the lawyer said, adding that the applicants are entitled to their day in court while they are still alive. He further argued that commissions of inquiry have a tendency to 'drag on and on'. 'It is an extraordinarily optimistic proposition to put forward the idea that this commission will be able to do a thorough job on its investigation and report in four months' time, which is all it has left of the originally six months.' The court has reserved the judgment. NOW READ: Khampepe Commission is the right platform for Mbeki, Mabandla to tell their story, court rules
