Newly qualified doctors face ‘recurring cycle of debt', BMA warns
Students in their final undergraduate year, along with those in the later years of a post-graduate medical degree, get a reduced student loan alongside an NHS bursary.
This leads to a £3,674 drop in funding on average, according to the BMA.
Sophie Mitchell, deputy co-chair (finance) of the BMA's medical students' committee, told the PA news agency: 'A lot of people are using these loans in previous years to either pay their rent and to live off.
'Losing out on a significant portion of that is meaning that students are struggling.
'We've got people maxing out overdrafts, we've got people maxing out credit cards.
'We've got people going into very significant debt just to actually finish this degree.'
The average medical student faces 12 months of this reduced funding.
However, some post-graduate students, along with those on six-year degree programmes, face up to three years, Ms Mitchell said.
Some are them are also faced with relocation expenses ahead of starting their first job in the NHS.
'The issue with that is most academic years or final years start in around the middle of August,' Ms Mitchell said.
'You are then having this reduced rate of funding until you then get paid at the end of August the following year.
'I know that a lot of my colleagues have had to get loans to pay their rent, or they've had to get credit agreements so that they can pay their rent.
'Also then having to relocate to a new place where you're getting this reduced rate of funding has been a struggle for a lot of people.
'A lot of my friends were already graduating, maxing out their overdrafts, and then they've had to get overdraft extensions to help them live until they get paid at the end of August.
'It's creating this recurrent cycle of debt that people are really struggling to get out of until that first paycheck.'
Ms Mitchell said she knows of new graduates stewarding football matches or taking zero hours bar work to get by.
She added: 'We have people working behind bars.
'We have people stewarding.
'One of my friends is actually working for Uber at the moment, because it was the only work that she could get that meant that she could get some employment in the area that she's in.'
Ms Mitchell is heading the BMA's Fix Our Finance campaign alongside co-chair Henry Budden.
'Quite a common thing that we've heard about the campaign is 'every student gets a job, why are you guys complaining so much?',' she told PA.
'But I think what people maybe aren't so aware of is actually how intense our course is.
'You're training for that role that you're about to start.
'You're in hospital Monday to Friday, nine to five.
'Some universities make their students do night shifts.
'Some universities make their students also do weekends on top of this.
'And then on top of that placement, where you're learning to be a doctor, you're also having to revise for your exams.'
The BMA is calling on the Government to ensure medical students receive full student finance maintenance for the entirety of their course.
The union claims this would cost the Treasury £24 million and just 0.12% of Student Finance England annual lending.
Ms Mitchell and Mr Budden warned the 'situation isn't sustainable' and 'does nothing to help those from poorer backgrounds or improve participation in medicine'.
'Medicine is longer than many other degrees for good reason; because we want to ensure doctors working in the NHS have the best possible training,' they added.
'It is only right then that they should receive the appropriate funding to see them through the entirety of their course.'
A Government spokesperson said: 'NHS bursary grants were uplifted from last September for the first time since 2015 and will increase again by forecast inflation this year, but we know there is more to do to support future NHS doctors.
'The 10-Year Health Plan explicitly acknowledges that the cost of studying medicine is a barrier for working-class students.
'We are determined to break down these barriers and ensure the NHS workforce reflects the communities it serves, which is why we're exploring options to improve financial support to students from the lowest socio-economic background so that they are able to thrive at medical school.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
24 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Pensioner, 77, died during heart surgery when hospital suffered a ten-minute power cut during a crucial stage, inquest hears
A pensioner died during heart surgery at an NHS hospital after the operating theatre she was in suffered a ten-minute-long power cut, an inquest heard. Jean Dye, 77, was at the crucial stage of the procedure when the electricity went down - meaning doctors had to delay the process as they couldn't see vital X rays. Five years after her death, a coroner has now issued a report saying that the delay in restoring power was a 'critical factor in her death'. It was found that an engineer was required to reset the system because it was in another part of the hospital. In a Prevention of Future Deaths Report, Paul Smith, Senior Coroner for Greater Lincolnshire, has now raised concerns about the lack of power controls within the operating theatre and that medical professionals weren't trained in how to understand when electricity has been restored. Mrs Dye, from Grimsby, Lincolnshire, suffered an underlying cardiac disease and attended Scunthorpe General Hospital to have it treated, the inquest was told. At the time of her death in September, 2020, she was having stents implanted to treat narrowed blood vessels. The operation only has a limited window to deploy the devices, the hearing was told. However, at exactly this moment there was a 'sudden and unexpected' power cut, which lasted for 10 minutes. It meant that medics could not see X-rays they needed for the procedure. No clear cause for the power cut has been identified, other than it overrode the back-up electrical supply, Mr Smith said. It was confirmed that power cuts have occasionally happened at hospitals across the country but the staff in Scunthorpe had not had this happen before. There was no manual re-activation of the circuit meaning that an engineer had to come to fix the issue. Once the power had returned, the stenting was completed but Mrs Dye failed to recover and she later passed away, the inquest heard. The hearing concluded that 'on the balance of probabilities, Mrs Dye would have survived but for the loss of electrical power'. It gave her cause of death as an iatrogenic artery dissection during a percutaneous coronary intervention. Mr Smith raised concerns about the lack of an indicator within the lab to confirm that the power had re-activated. There were also issues with the reset button being elsewhere in the hospital. Mr Smith said: 'The delay whilst power was restored was a critical factor in this death. 'The loss of power arose as a result of the Emergency Power Off (EPO) circuit activating. It overrode the emergency power back up system. 'All staff at the scene were unaware of the cause of the loss of power, never having experienced such a situation previously, and an engineer was summoned to attend to reinstate the power, which he did. 'There was no light or other indicator within the lab to confirm to those present that the EPO circuit had activated. Likewise there was no restart button within the lab to permit the EPO circuit to be reset. That lay within the plant room elsewhere within the hospital. 'Had staff been aware of the exact cause of the loss of power on this occasion and had they had the opportunity to reset the circuit without the need to await the arrival of an engineer, who in turn had to attend a separate plant room, the downtime would likely have been significantly reduced. 'Whilst it was not possible to say that the additional time spent on this occasion made a difference between the patient surviving or not, there may well be future cases within which such fine margins are time critical. 'I received evidence that there is no current guidance in relation to the siting of such controls remote from the affected room. I invite review of that guidance and of the need for any consequential training.' Mr Smith sent the report to NHS England and the Health Service Executive, who have until August 28 to respond.
BBC News
24 minutes ago
- BBC News
Tributes as former Birmingham doctor dies aged 95
Tributes have been paid to a "trailblazer" former doctor who has died at the age of Pauline Manfield became one of the first female consultants in UK paediatrics, helping establish a department at the Good Hope Hospital in Sutton Coldfield, with her colleague, staff nurse Eileen leaving the NHS in her 60s, devout Christian Dr Manfield became a lay reader and chaplain at Birmingham Cathedral where she served until she reached her late Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust said she "leaves behind a legacy defined by compassion, dedication, and an unwavering commitment to service". Dr Manfield was born in Worcester in 1929 and her early years were shaped by World War Two, especially the vivid memories of bombings during her time in Preston as a family eventually settled in Chelmsford where she attended Chelmsford Girls' High an aspiration to become a doctor, she studied medicine at The Royal Free Hospital. She then went on to earn membership of the Royal College of Physicians in the 1960s before joining Good addition to her work with the NHS and Birmingham Cathedral, she was a member of Sutton Sisters, a local multi-faith group promoting understanding and unity. She was involved with a range of local groups, such as the Sutton Coldfield Archaeological and Gardening Societies, and the Lichfield Science and Engineering also ran in the Sutton Coldfield Fun Run, enjoyed photography and travel, and was a regular at ballet shows and Birmingham Symphony Orchestra Manfield also led efforts through the Sutton Coldfield Association of Women Graduates to sponsor young women in Malawi. 'Deep compassion' "Her intelligence and warmth earned her early praise as 'clever, pretty and kind' – a description that would remain true throughout her long life," a spokesperson for the NHS Trust said."Pauline was known not only for her clinical excellence but also for the deep compassion she showed to patients and their families."Her impact was so significant that many former patients contributed to a special birthday book in her honour, filled with notes of gratitude and stories of lives touched by her care."While she never married or had children, the spokesperson said "Pauline nurtured deep friendships and maintained connections with her schoolmates and colleagues"."She was godmother to 12 children, and her home in Sutton Coldfield was a hub of hospitality, known for its garden parties, home-cooked meals, and walls lined with decades of photographs," the spokesperson continued."Pauline will be remembered as a trailblazer, a mentor, and a kind-hearted physician who gave her all to the people and causes she believed in." Follow BBC Birmingham on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Scots receive a record £2,669 more public spending each than UK average
Scots receive nearly £2,700 more public spending each than the UK average, according to official figures revealing that the gap has widened to record levels. A major report, published by SNP ministers, showed total spending by the UK and Scottish Governments equated to £21,192 per person in Scotland in the 2024/25 financial year. This compared with an average £18,523 of public spending per person across the UK as a whole – £2,669 lower than the figure for Scotland. The cross-border spending gap was by far the largest on record, £2,311 up on the previous year and having nearly doubled over the previous decade. The Scottish Government's annual Government Expenditure and Revenue Scotland report also found public spending accounted for a record 52 per cent of the country's GDP, compared with 44.4 per cent of the UK as a whole. This was more than five points higher than before the pandemic. And Scotland's deficit – the difference between total revenue and expenditure – has surged to 11.7 per cent of GDP. This was more than double the UK figure of 5.1 per cent and higher than anywhere else in Europe. The report was published after SNP ministers recently confirmed they backed full fiscal autonomy, with Scotland getting control over all taxes and the abolition of the Barnett formula that provides the higher spending from Westminster. But Ian Murray, the UK Government's Scottish Secretary, said that would mean a funding gap of more than £14bn, resulting in 'turbo-charged austerity and economic chaos for Scotland'. He said: 'These figures underline the collective economic strength of the United Kingdom and how Scotland benefits from the redistribution of wealth inside the UK. 'By sharing resources with each other across the UK, Scots benefit by £2,669 more per head in public spending than the UK average. It also means that devolved governments have the financial heft of the wider UK behind them when taking decisions.' Mr Murray added that Scots want to see 'better outcomes' from the extra money the SNP has to spend on schools, hospitals and policing. Craig Hoy, the Scottish Tories' shadow finance secretary, said: 'The SNP Government's own figures highlight the huge, and rising, Union dividend that Scots enjoy thanks to being in a strong United Kingdom. 'Every single person in the country is almost £2,600 better off because we are part of the UK. If we lost that – as we would if the SNP achieved their goal of Scottish independence – it would have a catastrophic impact on the nation's finances.' He said the figures also demonstrated the 'economic lunacy' of Sir Keir Starmer's opposition to allowing new exploration licences to be issued for the North Sea. Oil and gas revenues in Scotland's geographic share of the UK's waters fell by £800m last year to £4.1bn. The Government Expenditure and Revenue Scotland report is produced by Scottish Government economists and calculates public spending on devolved services, such as health and education, by SNP ministers and local authorities. Scotland is also allocated a population share of spending by the UK Government on reserved policy areas such as defence and debt interest. The report said the main reason for Scotland's deficit increasing from 9.7 per cent to 11.7 per cent was 'Scottish revenue growing more slowly and Scottish expenditure growing more quickly than the UK'. Oil and gas raise tax revenue total Public spending in Scotland rose by £6.2bn to £117.6bn last year, the report said, with the cost of benefits rising more quickly than across the UK. This was partly thanks to the Scottish Government's more generous welfare system. Tax revenues north of the border totalled nearly £91.4bn, £91 per person higher than the UK average. However, they were £578 per person lower when oil and gas were excluded. Scotland's 11. per cent notional deficit amounted to £26.5bn, a rise of more than £5bn compared to the previous year. The next highest deficits in the EU were recorded in Romania (9.3 per cent of GDP), Poland (6.6 per cent) and France (5.8 per cent). Shona Robison, the Scottish finance secretary, said: 'The decisions we have taken here in Scotland are helping support sustainable public finances. For the fourth year in a row, devolved revenues have grown faster than devolved expenditure. 'Scotland's public finances are better than many other parts of the UK, with the third highest revenue per person in the UK, behind only London and the South East.' But Struan Stevenson, the chief executive of the pro-Union Scottish Business UK group, said: 'The sharp rise of the 'Union dividend' once again in the Government Expenditure and Revenue Scotland figures show that independence would be a disastrous calamity for Scotland, costing us tens of billions and almost bankrupting the nation at a stroke.'
