'He has only himself to blame': Rishabh Pant's reckless shot sparks debate
NEW DELHI: India's
Rishabh Pant
suffered a foot fracture during the ongoing Manchester Test against England after attempting a reverse sweep on Day 1. The injury occurred when he was on 37, as
Chris Woakes
delivered a yorker that struck Pant's right toe, reportedly causing the fracture.
Despite the setback, Pant resumed his innings on Day 2 and battled through the pain to notch up a gritty half-century before falling to
Jofra Archer
. His injury has now cast doubt over his availability for India's second innings and reignited conversations around the use of injury substitutes in Test cricket.
Go Beyond The Boundary with our YouTube channel.
SUBSCRIBE NOW!
Former England captain Geoffrey Boycott, speaking on The Telegraph Podcast, criticised Pant's shot selection and said the injury was avoidable.
'It is always sad when a player gets hurt and affects his ability to play a part in the game—especially someone as talented as him. But he has only himself to blame,' Boycott said.
Poll
Do you think Rishabh Pant's injury could impact India's performance in the match?
Yes, significantly
Yes, but not too much
No, it won't affect the team
Not sure
'They were nicely in control, batting orthodox—there was no need to try something outrageous. Rishabh tries amazing strokes. When they come off, people are astonished and cheer him, and that is the essence of his batting. But when they don't, it can look silly.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
How Smart Are You Really? This Test Will Surprise You
IQ-Worldwide.org
Try Now
Undo
India were building a strong position. Some might say that's just his nature, but if he can't bat in both innings, it might cost India the match. He's that important,' he added.
Shardul Thakur opens up on being under bowled, gives inside details on Rishabh Pant
The incident has sparked fresh debate over allowing like-for-like substitutions in Tests.
Speaking to TalkSport Cricket, former England batter David Lloyd offered his take: 'I'm probably against runners, but I'm in favour of substitutes for external injuries. It does open a can of worms, but if it's a break and medically he's out for six weeks, then maybe a like-for-like replacement is worth considering. Not something like replacing a batter with a spinner, though.'
For real-time updates, scores, and highlights, follow our live coverage of the
India vs England Test match
here.
Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
18 minutes ago
- Time of India
How barefoot village girl Kranti Goud, daughter of a sacked cop and youngest of six siblings, became India's cricket star
Kranti Goud , a 21-year-old fast bowler from Madhya Pradesh's Chhatarpur district, helped India clinch the women's ODI series against England with a stunning 6/52 in the final match. The performance marked her first five-wicket haul in One Day Internationals and turned the spotlight on her journey from hardship to the national stage. A life shaped by early struggle Goud grew up in Ghuwara, a tribal-majority village in rural Bundelkhand, as the youngest of six siblings. She dropped out after class 8. Her father Munna Singh, a former police constable in Madhya Pradesh, was dismissed from service in 2012 during election duty. The family was forced to leave their official residence and shift into a rented home. Her eldest brother Mayank left school to work. 'We were in a lot of trouble,' he said. 'There were days we didn't have proper meals. People mocked us for letting Kranti pursue cricket, but somehow we held on.' by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Heunghae-eup: Unsold Furniture Liquidation 2024 (Prices May Surprise You) Unsold Furniture | Search Ads Learn More Undo Coaching support despite odds In 2017, Goud joined the Sai Cricket Academy in Chhatarpur under coach Rajiv Bilthare. He recalled her first day at the academy. 'She came in worn-out clothes and regular shoes,' he said. 'Her father was jobless. Her family had nothing. I didn't charge her any fees. I gave her shoes, uniform, and even bought her gear.' Bilthare added: 'I gave her Rs 1,600 to buy cricket spikes. She lit up. Said it felt like a dream.' Live Events First off-field milestone Goud recently signed her first personal sponsorship deal with an international shoe brand. She plans to use the opportunity to support other girls at her academy who come from similar backgrounds. 'It's time for me to give back to society,' she said. 'I want to buy a house for my family. That's first. But I also want girls at our academy to play without worrying about money. My assistance will help them focus on the game.' On-field progress continues Goud made her ODI debut against Sri Lanka on May 11 and earned her T20I cap against England on July 12. She plays domestic cricket for Madhya Pradesh and represents UP Warriorz in the Women's Premier League. Her aim now is to ensure no young cricketer is held back due to lack of resources—one pair of spiked shoes at a time. Kranti shines in just her fourth ODI In only her fourth One Day International match, 21-year-old Kranti Goud delivered a match-winning spell of 6 for 52, helping India secure a 13-run victory and clinch the series against England at Chester-le-Street in Durham. Her performance followed a century by captain Harmanpreet Kaur, who scored 102 off 84 balls. Kaur shared her Player of the Match award with Goud and gave her a signed ball with a personal message. Standout performances at every level Kranti took nine wickets in the three-match series against England, with an average of 15.11. Before her India call-up, she played in all age-group tournaments for Madhya Pradesh and helped the state win the National Women's Championship, taking four wickets in the final, including that of India keeper-batter Richa Ghosh. 'She can bat well too. She's a disciplined player and understands the value of what she has,' Bilthare said. Recognised for her work ethic Madhya Pradesh Cricket Association secretary Sanjeev Rao said, 'This is how dreams are made. She has literally come up from nowhere. Her story should motivate every single girl who aspires to play for India one day.' He also credited the MP Cricket Association's scouting system. 'I must credit our association for sending talent spotters to every small district and village.' Support from top domestic coaches Kranti was also coached by Chandrakant Pandit, who leads both Madhya Pradesh and Kolkata Knight Riders. 'She worked hard day and night and improved her bowling within a year. There's something about her bowling—a fire in her belly, a passion that helped her rise fast,' Pandit said. Pandit spotted her during open trials in Indore when she was 17. 'Her run-up and smooth action stood out. A couple of years ago, she stopped bowling due to back issues, but after I scolded her, she returned to bowling. She's also a brilliant fielder.' Impact of Women's Premier League Kranti was a net bowler for Mumbai Indians for a few years before UP Warriorz picked her up in the WPL auction last year for ₹10 lakh. 'At the time, she hadn't played a senior T20 match, but our scouts saw her potential,' said Kshemal Waingankar, COO of UP Warriorz. 'She could move the ball both ways and had a sharp bouncer. We backed her, and now she's playing for India just months later.' Coach Bilthare added, 'She has received sponsorship from Puma. She's playing for India and in the WPL. She doesn't have to worry about finances now.' (Inputs from TOI)
Indian Express
31 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Washington Sundar, Ben Stokes and a handshake at Old Trafford: Why Test cricket is still beautiful
Washington Sundar is no stranger to extraordinary things. In his first Test with India six down, almost 200 behind Australia, he combined with virtual newbie Shardul Thakur to lay the first step for the now-famous Brisbane heist. But a century is a century, and Washington Sundar's first was even more special because the hero of Brisbane was now among India's saviours at Old Trafford. So, when the English captain offered a handshake, an admission that his tired team had given up trying to win, Washington and his partner Ravindra Jadeja, who was also closing in on a century, were right to deny him any moral high ground. More than an hour of the game was left; why not savour the spoils of hard-earned battle? If the issue was that of the spirit of the game, the question could well be asked who hurt that in the first place – the Indian batsman who chose to carry on, for personal goals, or the English skipper who took their refusal to call it a day as an affront and asked part-timer Harry Brook to serve donkey drops. The last half hour was an anti-climax, the only period when the Old Trafford match wasn't engrossing. Till then, everything that the English and Indian cricketers had done showcased a perfect response to the perennial question asked of Test cricket: Why play a game that goes on for five days – 35 hours, sometimes more – and yet produces no result? Test cricket essentially is a sport in which a team of 11 ideally attempts to beat their competitors, failing which, they try to avoid defeat. The entertainment in a fight to the finish is, of course, unmistakable. The first three Test matches of the India-England series were great examples of such contests. But there is also something spectacular about a team fighting with its back to the wall to come up equal at the end. That's why former England captain Alistair Cook put the hammer on the nail when he said in times to come, the Old Trafford Test will be remembered for, not happened during the closing hours, but for Washington Sundar and Ravindra Jadeja's rearguard action. There was, however, much for the lovers of the game's longer version before India's best all-rounder and the man touted to be his successor came together. The team lost the services of Rishabh Pant in the first few hours, a turn of events that only the free-spirited wicketkeeper could have scripted. Batting with nonchalant ease, he decided to reverse sweep Chris Woakes, who can occasionally make the ball talk even in the evening of his career. The shot boomeranged onto Pant's feet, leaving it with a gash the size of a table tennis ball – it turned out to be a fracture. But the Indian wicket keeper, who seems to have made it a habit to push the pain barrier higher, delayed putting his injured limb in a cast. He came back to bat, scored a 50, helped his team add runs and spent precious time at the crease. This was much more than heroics. It may not have been apparent then, but the battle of attrition, which the match turned out to be, actually began with Pant's defiance. These seemingly small moments are also why its devotees savour Test cricket. There was also Washington Sundar, even before he had made his mark with the bat. Two drifters, that would have made the classicists among off-spinners proud, snapped out the centurion Joe Root and England's newest prodigy Harry Brook, and made sure that the poms had to fight extra hard for the lead. Of course, what happened after India were 0 for 2 in the first over of their second innings, 311 runs behind in the first innings, is sure to be part of cricket's lore. Reams have already been written on Shubman Gill's coming of age as a batsman, and consistency, at last, seems to be making friends with K L Rahul. Spare a thought for the English team, though. The ifs and buts are another reason that make test cricket beautiful. What may have happened had Liam Dawson held on to a difficult chance when Gill had not passed 50 or the chance offered by Jadeja, first ball, had struck in Joe Root's hands? Or what may have happened had the pitch, that had begun to play tricks, not gone for a lunchtime nap on the fifth day, from which it would never wake up. And, spare a thought for Ben Stokes. It would be a pity if the English captain's petulance in the last half hour is even a footnote in the annals of the match. He was the only bowler that batsmen could never be sure against, often willing his body to come up with sharply swerving induckers or wickedly climbing bouncers. And, bat with the tail to score a wonderful century and extend England's lead to a point that a draw was the only option for India's batters. Stokes was rightly the Man of the Match. But even one of the greatest ambassador's of the modern day game would admit – perhaps grudgingly – a draw was a victory for the Indian team.
India.com
31 minutes ago
- India.com
Shubman Gill goes past Virat Kohli and Steve Smith with century, equals Sachin and Don Bradman's record of...
Shubman Gill goes past Virat Kohli and Steve Smith with century, equals Sachin and Don Bradman's record of... New Delhi: Shubman Gill scored his ninth Test century and fourth century of this series in the ongoing Test series against England. 25-year-old Gill has become only the third captain in Test history to score four centuries in a single series. Earlier this feat was achieved by Don Bradman and Sunil Gavaskar. First Indian to score a century in Manchester after 35 years Gill has become the first Indian batsman to score a century in Manchester in 35 years. Before him, this feat was achieved by Sachin Tendulkar at the age of 17. He has also become only the third Indian after Gavaskar and Virat Kohli to score four centuries in a series. Unique record in the first series as captain Gill has become the first player to score four centuries in his first series after becoming captain. Earlier, Don Bradman, Virat Kohli, Steven Smith, Greg Chappell and Warrick Armstrong had scored three centuries each. Gill has scored more than 700 runs in this series so far. Gill took control of the innings after 0/2 in the first over Gill scored a century with great restraint. He came to bat when the team was 0/2 in the first over itself. He stopped his natural aggressive play and completed his century with the help of 12 fours in 228 balls. During this, he pulled the team out of trouble. Rahul and Gill gave strength, England got a lead of 311 runs KL Rahul shared a partnership of 188 runs with Gill. Rahul was out LBW on Ben Stokes' ball after scoring 90 runs in 230 balls. Gill also returned to the pavilion after scoring 103 runs just before lunch. India was trailing by 311 runs in the first innings and was on the verge of defeat. England dominated, Stokes did wonders with bat and ball England scored 669 runs in the first innings. Ben Stokes played a brilliant innings of 141 runs after taking five wickets. His performance helped England take a massive 311-run lead in the first innings, putting India in danger of an innings defeat.
