Rob Hersov's inflammatory remarks reignite race relations debate in South Africa
Image: Supplied
South African businessman Rob Hersov ignited controversy when he fired a series of inflammatory remarks about the country's black population and the historical figure Zulu king Shaka during a recent episode of the American podcast "Thought Leaders."
His comments drew widespread condemnation but have also reignited discussions about the delicate fabric of race relations in South Africa.
Speaking on a platform associated with the conservative Epoch Times, Hersov referred to black South Africans as "barbaric." He also labelled Shaka a "rapist" known for throwing people off cliffs.
Such statements were seen as promulgating deeply entrenched stereotypes and alarmist narratives regarding violence in South Africa.
Hersov did not shy away from insisting that the country was plagued by two farm attacks each day and two murders of farmers each week. He asserted that farmers were three times more likely to be murdered than police officers, a statement that lacked reliable data or credible sources to back it up.
His utterances aligned with the rhetoric associated with organisations like AfriForum, which faced accusations of misrepresenting the realities of farm violence, even though official statistics for the 2022/23 period told a different story.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Ad loading
While Hersov claimed farm murders were rampant, reports indicate that 111 police officers were killed during that period. This was in contrast to AfriForum's figure of 49 alleged farm murders. Furthermore, a recent assessment by suspended police minister Senzo Mchunu revealed that, out of 12 farm murders in the last quarter of 2024, only one victim was white.
Similar sentiments have been echoed by US President Donald Trump, who recently alleged that a "white genocide" was happening in South Africa. He proposed measures such as cutting US aid to the country and granting expedited citizenship to Afrikaners.
Those assertions were rejected by President Cyril Ramaphosa, who, during a meeting with Trump, stated that the narrative of a white genocide does not reflect the realities of the nation.
Ramaphosa underscored the South African government's dedication to democratic principles and freedom of expression while also stressing that extreme views do not represent state policy.
"What you saw in the speeches made is not government policy. We have a multiparty democracy in South Africa that allows people to express themselves," he stated previously.
Political analyst Siphamandla Zondi denounced Hersov's claims as mere election-style rhetoric lacking substantive evidence.
He noted that the narrative of "white genocide" serves to amplify fears and alarm without addressing the broader context of violence that affects all demographic groups.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
an hour ago
- IOL News
‘SA flag belongs to citizens, not government': Zuma hits back at Minister Lamola over Morocco visit
MK Party leader Jacob Zuma addresses the media in Sandton, defending his use of the national flag during a recent visit to Morocco. Image: Simon Majadibodu/IOL The Umkhonto weSizwe (MK) Party leader, Jacob Zuma, has defended his use of the South African flag during a visit to Morocco, saying it does not belong exclusively to the government but to all citizens. Zuma made the remarks during a press briefing held Friday in Sandton, where he addressed journalists alongside party officials following a meeting of the party's National Officials. Those present included Zuma, national chairperson Nathi Nhleko, MP and national spokesperson Nhlamulo Ndhlela, and other senior leaders. 'The South African flag doesn't belong to the government. Is there anyone who doesn't know that the flag of any country belongs to the citizens of that country? Is there anyone who doesn't know that?' Zuma said, laughing. 'And you,' he added, pointing to journalists, 'come here asking so many questions about the flag. Every country has a flag. Every citizen owns the flag. It's not a government flag.' His comments came after Minister of International Relations and Cooperation Ronald Lamola raised concerns about the use of national symbols during Zuma's visit to Morocco, which included a meeting with Moroccan Foreign Minister Nasser Bourita in Rabat on July 15. Photographs from the meeting showed both South African and Moroccan flags displayed prominently, sparking diplomatic criticism. 'While we recognise and respect Morocco's sovereign right to invite individuals and groups, DIRCO, on behalf of the Government of the Republic of South Africa, strongly protests the use of South African national symbols - in this instance, the South African national flag - during the meeting between Mr Jacob Zuma and the foreign minister of the Kingdom of Morocco,' Lamola said. Zuma was accompanied by the MK Party's Head of Presidency, Magasela Mzobe, during the visit. DIRCO spokesperson Chrispin Phiri said the department viewed the display of the South African flag as a breach of diplomatic norms. 'The use of the South African national flag in a meeting with a member of a political party in opposition, which is a non-state actor, constitutes an abuse of existing protocol and decorum and undermines official bilateral relations between the Republic of South Africa and the Kingdom of Morocco,' Phiri said. He explained that national symbols such as the flag inherently convey official state endorsement. Their use in such contexts, he added, 'elevates the perception of the encounter to that of a state-to-state engagement,' which was not the case. 'This characterisation is inconsistent with established diplomatic protocol, as the participants did not represent the official positions or engagements of the South African state.' Phiri said South Africa had conveyed its concerns to Morocco, asserting that the portrayal of the meeting could not be recognised as an official bilateral engagement. 'The government of the Republic of South Africa holds the firm view that the use of its national symbols in contexts implying official state endorsement of non-governmental engagements is inappropriate, irrespective of the setting,' he said. 'In the spirit of fostering and maintaining cordial and friendly bilateral relations, and consistent with the fundamental principles of mutual respect between sovereign states and non-interference in internal affairs, South Africa respectfully encourages the Government of the Kingdom of Morocco to refrain from such actions.' He said adherence to these principles was essential to preserving positive relations between the two countries. Zuma's visit has sparked widespread criticism from political parties, including the governing African National Congress (ANC). ANC Secretary-General Fikile Mbalula labelled Zuma a 'sellout' for showing support to Morocco, which annexed Western Sahara in 1975 - a region South Africa recognises as occupied territory. 'We, as the ANC, will fight side by side for the self-determination of the Sahrawi people. We are in solidarity with them, and Morocco must stop the occupation of Western Sahara,' Mbalula said.
IOL News
2 hours ago
- IOL News
Floyd Shivambu expelled from MKP amid financial disputes and R28m debt claims
MK Party and its leader, former president Jacob Zuma, have defended the display of the South African flag during a recent trip to Morocco. Image: MKP The uMkhonto weSizwe Party (MKP) has fired another salvo at its expelled secretary-general Floyd Shivambu after alleging he left the organisation R28 million in debt. Shivambu had accused some MKP leaders of stealing R7m every month. MKP Treasurer-General Mpiyakhe Limba on Friday said Shivambu left the party, led by former president Jacob Zuma, with a debt of R28 million. Announcing his departure from the MKP after being forced to step down as its secretary-general in June, Shivambu said there were withdrawals of R7m monthly from its coffers and that he had raised these concerns internally. However, Limba dismissed the claims, saying the former EFF deputy president had instead left the MKP with a debt of R28m. According to Limba, the MKP has appointed an independent company, Nduma Chartered Accountants, before the annual audit by the Auditor-General SA. He said the findings had more to do with bookkeeping, which was the area that required improvement. The MKP also announced that it had expelled and terminated Shivambu's membership. Shivambu has since started his Mayibuye consultative process towards establishing a new political party, which is now registered with the Electoral Commission of South Africa. The party has appointed Dr Bongani Mncwango as its new secretary-general and Nomsa Dlamini as his deputy. Other changes include moving national organiser Joe Ndhlela to policy coordination and replacing him with one of its MPs Aleck Nkuna. National Chairperson Nathi Nhleko said the party has had some gaps in the national leadership collective, hence it was making the changes. 'Dr Mncwango has 35 years of executive experience, is a former chief executive officer at Sanlam Healthcare, Netcare 911, he was also chair of the Qwabe Traditional Council,' said Nhleko when introducing the new administrative head of the party. The MKP also dismissed concerns about Zuma's visit to Morocco two weeks ago and was pictured displaying the South African flag during public engagements.
The Citizen
2 hours ago
- The Citizen
It costs taxpayers between R800 and R1 000 a month to feed an inmate
Correctional services spent R455.6 million in 2025/26 on food supplies in the 2025/26 quarter compared to R363.6 million from April to June of 2024/25. It costs South African taxpayers R800 to R1 000 a month to feed an inmate in correctional facilities under a new contract system for catering services. Minister of Correctional Services Pieter Groenewald recently acknowledged complaints from the public about supposedly high prices on bread items under the newly awarded contracts. According to parliamentary data provided by Groenewald's office, monthly feeding costs per inmate ranged from R614 to R993 in 2024/25. This increased to between R839 and R1 016 in 2025/26 for the months April to June. The highest monthly cost recorded was R1 015.98 per inmate in April 2025. Inmate food spending breakdown shows varied patterns Correctional services spent R363.6 million on food supplies in the quarter from April to June of 2024/25, compared to R455.6 million in the corresponding 2025/26 period. The spending patterns varied significantly across different food categories. In 2025/26, groceries represented the biggest expenditure at R205 million, followed by meat, poultry and fish, costing R98.9 million. Bread and baked products cost R94.4 million, while fruits and vegetables totalled R49.3 million. Milk and dairy products cost R7.4 million, with baby and speciality foods at R534 262, and eggs at R67 068. The 2024/25 pattern differed notably, with meat, poultry and fish leading at R128.6 million, followed by groceries at R117.9 million. Bread products now cost R71.8 million, fruits and vegetables R37.5 million, milk products R7.2 million, baby foods R329 242 and eggs R256 819. ALSO READ: Two police officers shot dead while transporting prisoner Contract award criteria under scrutiny EFF MP Nontando Nolutshungu raised concerns about the tender process in parliament, questioning whether price competitiveness and value for money were properly assessed. The minister referenced the evaluation criteria outlined in an attached report. Mandatory requirements for tender bidders to be considered include: Delivery vehicle; Business premises; Financial capacity; Delivery commitment letter; and Pricing schedule. Some bidders did not meet these requirements. 'Bidders who did not submit/meet all the above mandatory requirements were disqualified from further evaluation,' Groenewald said. Nolutshungu's parliamentary questions also sought information about internal audits and investigations into pricing discrepancies. The minister confirmed that investigations had been conducted, leading the department to renegotiate certain contract items. ALSO READ: Prisoners and ghosts claim overtime: meet SA's worst-run province Procurement system changes The previous procurement system relied on quotation processes from various suppliers for both perishable and non-perishable food items. This approach was replaced with a centralised tender system involving specific contracted service providers. Monthly costs per inmate showed fluctuations during 2024/25, starting at R992.57 in April, dropping to R729.76 in May and reaching R614.36 in June. Under the new system in 2025/26, costs began at R1 015.98 in April, decreased to R917.99 in May and settled at R838.95 in June. The inmate population remained relatively stable, averaging around 155 000 in 2024/25 and 164 000 in 2025/26. Department response and renegotiations The minister acknowledged that complaints about high bread prices had been brought to his attention. In response to concerns about cost containment, accountability and prevention of procurement irregularities, the department indicated it was renegotiating existing contracts. It did not disclose specific measures for better cost containment and accountability in future procurement processes. READ NEXT: Operation Dudula demands release of members detained at Diepkloof police station
