To avoid worst of Trump tariffs, E.U. accepted a lopsided deal

Yahoo

5 days ago

BRUSSELS - The tariff-and-spending accord announced Sunday by the United States and the European Union stands to avert a damaging trade war between two of the world's largest economies, but it is lopsided in favor of President Donald Trump's protectionist policies, with Brussels swallowing bitter concessions in hopes of stabilizing a relationship that is vital not just economically but also for security interests.
The rough agreement - which allows Washington to raise tariffs on E.U. goods while the Europeans promise to buy more U.S. products - quickly came under sharp criticism in Europe. Despite feisty rhetoric and vows to stand up to Trump, E.U. leaders largely acquiesced to the U.S. leader's ever-changing demands.
Subscribe to The Post Most newsletter for the most important and interesting stories from The Washington Post.
E.U. negotiators insisted the deal was the best way to avoid a highly damaging tit-for-tat trade war that would benefit rivals such as China and Russia. But European officials and analysts said the tentative agreement does not end the uncertainty because so many details must still be worked out.
To the harshest critics, including some in France who spoke of a 'capitulation' and 'humiliation,' the agreement is proof of a deeply unbalanced alliance and the latest example of European appeasement of Trump. At NATO, allies similarly strained to pledge the huge increases in military spending demanded by Trump.
European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, who announced the deal with Trump while sitting next to him at one of his golf resorts in Scotland on Sunday, touted 'a huge deal,' clearly playing to Trump's love of largeness.
But at her news conference soon after, von der Leyen appeared far more sober, declaring the 15 percent tariffs she had accepted on European automobiles to be 'the best we could get.' The E.U., and in particular Germany, its automaking powerhouse, had hoped to eliminate the 25 percent U.S. car tariffs entirely.
'We should not forget where we came from,' von der Leyen said. 'Fifteen percent is certainly a challenge for some, but we should not forget it keeps us the access to the American markets.'
Trump indeed had threatened far worse, including a 30 percent across-the-board tariff that upended months of painstaking negotiations.
Under the new deal, the United States will impose a 15 percent duty on most imports from the E.U. The blanket rate foisted on the E.U. mirrors a U.S. deal announced this month with Japan, another Group of Seven ally, but it is higher than the 10 percent that Britain secured earlier this year and that E.U. officials had grudgingly accepted in recent talks.
Since World War II, trade agreements have largely sought to reduce the cost of buying and selling goods across borders. A 2017 deal the E.U. struck with Canada eliminated tariffs on most goods traded between them. An agreement signed with Vietnam in 2019 aims to phase out nearly all customs duties.
Trump's accord with the E.U. goes in the opposite direction by raising tariffs, with some exceptions. Economists say the tariffs will increase costs for importers, who must pay the duties, and put upward pressure on inflation. Consumers and businesses will probably bear some of the extra costs, experts say.
In France, where President Emmanuel Macron had urged the E.U. to take a harder line, the deal drew sharp backlash. While Macron was quiet Monday, Prime Minister Francois Bayrou said it was 'a dark day when an alliance of free people, brought together to assert their values and defend their interests, resigns itself to submission.'
Von der Leyen's European Commission, the E.U.'s executive body that negotiates trade policy for its 27 member nations, had faced calls from Germany and Italy, two countries that do outsize business with the United States, for an accord that would limit damage to their export-dependent companies.
But even capitals that had urged a conciliatory approach were not exactly celebrating on Monday.
'The agreement successfully averted a trade conflict that would have hit the export-oriented German economy hard,' German Chancellor Friedrich Merz said.
Still, members of the European Parliament from Germany blasted the deal even as it reduced Trump's tariff on cars, one of Germany's central demands. 'My first assessment: not satisfactory; this is a lopsided deal,' said Bernd Lange, who chairs the European Parliament's committee on international trade, in a post on X. 'Concessions have clearly been made that are difficult to accept. Deal with significant imbalance. Furthermore lot of questions still open.'
Dutch Prime Minister Dick Schoof acknowledged that 'no tariffs would have been better' but called the deal 'vital for an open economy like ours.' Belgian Prime Minister Bart De Wever said, 'One thing is clear: This is a moment of relief but not of celebration.'
The talks laid bare the E.U.'s queasiness at using its economic muscle, one of its few areas of leverage against Washington, at a time when allies have had to calibrate repeatedly to keep Trump on board as Russia wages war in Ukraine.
Ultimately, after months of mixed signals and threats from Trump, E.U. leaders said they accepted a deal to give their industries a reprieve from the uncertainty that threatened to cripple business.
Officials suggested they had relented out of concern that Trump was prepared to raise tariffs to a level that would effectively halt trade between Europe and the United States.
'Let's pause for a moment and consider the alternative: A trade war may seem appealing to some but it comes with serious consequences,' said the E.U. trade commissioner, Maros Sefcovic, who shuttled to Washington in recent months for difficult talks with Trump officials.
'Our businesses have sent us a unanimous message: Avoid escalation and work toward a solution that brings immediate tariff relief,' Sefcovic told reporters Monday. He said that he and his team had traveled to Washington 10 times for a deal and that the E.U.'s calculations reached beyond trade.
'It's about security, it's about Ukraine, it's about current geopolitical volatility,' Sefcovic said. He said he couldn't go into detail on what was discussed in the room with Trump on Sunday, 'but I can assure it was not just about the trade.'
Now, nearly 70 percent of European goods will face the blanket tariff, a big increase in charges, according to a senior E.U. official who spoke on the condition of anonymity to talk frankly about the details of the deal, which is still under negotiation.
The E.U. had sought carve-outs from the U.S. tariff regime for key sectors including wine and spirits, and aircraft parts. The announced agreement eliminates tariffs on airplane parts, but a decision on wine and spirits was postponed. E.U. officials said talks will continue in the coming weeks.
The two sides appeared to diverge on other details. The White House indicated that a 50 percent tariff on steel would remain in place, while E.U. officials said there would be further negotiations on lowering steel tariffs.
Many officials and experts said it was crucial to sort out the details.
'We need to understand what is included,' said Brando Benifei, an Italian member of the European Parliament and head of its delegation for relations with the United States.
Some questioned if ongoing U.S. trade inquiries by the Trump administration might still result in extra tariffs, such as on European-made pharmaceuticals, though the E.U. said those should remain capped at 15 percent under the new agreement.
At first glance, Benifei said, the deal 'seems very asymmetric.'
'The result is due in my view to the push by some governments to have a deal at any cost, which has weakened our stance,' he added. 'Because the U.S. knew some governments wanted a deal whatever the cost.'
Others noted that Trump's threats managed to shift the view on what constituted relief. Just a few weeks ago, E.U. and U.S. negotiators neared an agreement that involved a blanket tariff of 10 percent, before a Truth Social post by Trump derailed them.
On Monday, some investors saw benefits for Europe's key auto industry, for instance, which would see U.S. car tariffs reduced to 15 percent from 25 percent. The tariffs, however, were at 2.5 percent before Trump's global trade blitz, and some industry groups noted their dismay.
'The U.S. tariff rate of 15 percent, which also applies to automotive products, will cost German automotive companies billions annually and burdens them,' said Hildegard Mueller, president of Germany's main auto industry group, the VDA.
On some issues, the Europeans stood their ground. Trump officials had pressed the E.U. for concessions on tech industry regulations and on food standards, which the bloc insisted were nonnegotiable.
As part of the deal, Trump said Europe had committed to buying more U.S. energy and weapons, and boosting investment in the United States.
But those provisions are mostly aspirational promises without guarantees.
European nations were already poised to buy more U.S. weapons under an arrangement with Trump to continue arming Ukraine, and the bloc was already seeking alternative energy sources, including liquefied natural gas from the United States, as part of its push to phase out Russian energy imports.
More energy purchases and European investments would come from member states and companies that Brussels does not control.
Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, seen as a close Trump ally in the E.U., heralded the deal, while saying details still need to be worked out.
'I obviously welcome the fact that an agreement has been reached,' Meloni told reporters. Still, she added, 'we need to verify the possible exemptions, particularly for certain agricultural products. So there are a number of elements that are missing.'
- - -
Faiola reported from Rome. Beatriz Rios in Brussels and Cat Zakrzewski in Edinburgh, Scotland, contributed to this report.
Related Content
The U.S. military is investing in this Pacific island. So is China.
In a stressful human world, 'mermaiding' gains popularity in D.C. area
'College hazing' or training? Amid shortage, air traffic recruits wash out.