logo
Question before SC: are ‘unopposed' election victories unconstitutional?

Question before SC: are ‘unopposed' election victories unconstitutional?

Indian Express27-04-2025

The Supreme Court suggested last week that in case there is only one candidate in an election, she should be required to obtain a prescribed minimum vote share in order to be declared elected, rather than winning without the election being held.
The court was hearing a petition by legal research think tank Vidhi Centre for Legal Policy questioning the constitutionality of Section 53(2) of The Representation of the People Act, 1951, as far as Lok Sabha and Assembly elections are concerned.
This section ('Procedure in contested and uncontested elections') says that 'if the number of…candidates is equal to the number of seats to be filled, the returning officer shall forthwith declare all such candidates to be duly elected to fill those seats'.
The court has asked the Union government to file its response within four weeks.
Petition and argument
The petition, filed in August 2024, argues that not holding the election in case of a single candidate prevents voters from choosing the 'None of the Above' (NOTA) option, which amounts to a violation of their fundamental right.
The petition cites the Supreme Court's 2013 judgment in People's Union for Civil Liberties vs Union of India, in which the court held that the right to cast a negative vote by choosing NOTA was protected in direct elections under Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution.
It argues that 'this right, by which the voter indicates her disapproval of the entire field of candidates, must be agnostic to the number of candidates in the fray'.
Uncontested elections
Candidates were elected uncontested to Lok Sabha at 26 constituencies between 1951 and 2024, the petition says, citing statistical reports of the Election Commission of India for these years. As such, more than 82 lakh electors had been deprived of the chance to cast their vote in these elections, it says.
Of these 26 no-contests, seven took place during the Lok Sabha election of 1957, five each in the elections of 1951 and 1967, three in 1962, two in 1977, and one each in the elections of 1971, 1980, 1989, and 2024, according to the petition. Last year, the BJP candidate from Surat, Mukeshkumar Dalal, was declared elected 'unopposed' after all other candidates either dropped out or had their nominations rejected.
Uncontested elections are more common in state Assemblies, the petition says.
Response of ECI
In its counter affidavit submitted earlier this month, the Election Commission pointed out that only nine of the 20 Lok Sabha elections held from 1951 to 2024 had seen uncontested elections of MPs. And in the more than three decades since 1989, only one candidate had entered Lok Sabha uncontested.
'With the evolution of democracy, more number of political parties are contesting elections and hence, the number of candidates also increases automatically and the voters have also become more aware and eager to exercise their franchise to right to vote. The chance of an election being uncontested has become a rarity which is proven from the statistical data and hence, in such a scenario, [the] court ought not to entertain the present petition,' the ECI said.
The Commission argued that 'NOTA' cannot be assumed to have automatically contested every election.
It cited the court's NOTA judgment that a button should be added to the electronic voting machine (EVM) to give an option to those who did not wish to vote for any of the candidates in the fray.
'Hence', the ECI said, 'NOTA option can be exercised when the polling takes place where the voters come to the polling booths to cast their votes… Therefore, treating NOTA as a mandatorily contesting candidate in all direct uncontested elections does not find place in the statute and the same would require legislative amendments in the provisions of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 and the Conduct of the Elections Rules, 1961.'
Justice Surya Kant, who presided over the two-judge Bench, said during the hearing on April 24: 'Will it not be a very welcome and progressive step where only one candidate is left in [fray] and still you say that you will be declared [elected] only when you get at least 10%, 15% [votes], whatever…?'
'When we talk of the majority as the foundation stone of the democracy, why not in furtherance of achieving that very goal, we prescribe that even in a default direction, there should be at least some voters who are liking you,' Justice Kant said.
He asked the government to 'please examine' the question, because 'today you don't have a problem…but you can enact something visualising that if tomorrow this problem comes, I have a weapon ready to address it'.
What that weapon can be, 'it's your wisdom, if Parliament will decide', he said. '[But] why should we allow somebody to enter Parliament by default who is unable to get even 5% vote? You may think of that because you are representing the will of the people.'

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

No urgency, will hear TN plea on school funds in due course: SC
No urgency, will hear TN plea on school funds in due course: SC

Time of India

time40 minutes ago

  • Time of India

No urgency, will hear TN plea on school funds in due course: SC

Supreme Court(File photo) NEW DELHI: SC on Monday turned down Tamil Nadu govt's plea for urgent listing of its suit against the Centre for the release of over Rs 2,291 crore under the Samagra Shiksha Scheme (SSS). Appearing before a bench of Justices Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Manmohan, senior advocate P Wilson pleaded that there was urgency in the case and the state should be granting hearing during the vacation. The bench, however, said that there was no urgency and the suit could be listed for hearing in due course. The state sought early hearing alleging that lack of funds was depriving the Right to Education to nearly 48 lakh students and the new academic year had already started on June 3. Tamil Nadu govt filed the original suit under Article 131 of the Constitution, alleging that Union govt was withholding funds under SSS over the non-implementation of the National Education Policy 2020.

BJP silent over Vijay Bainsla's open challenge
BJP silent over Vijay Bainsla's open challenge

Time of India

timean hour ago

  • Time of India

BJP silent over Vijay Bainsla's open challenge

1 2 Jaipur: State BJP 's continued silence over Vijay Bainsla, president of Gurjar Arakshan Sangharsh Samiti and a party member, has raised serious questions about internal discipline and leadership authority in the party ranks. Bainsla successfully pressured the BJP-led state govt by threatening a major stir if the demand for 5% reservation for Most Backward Classes (MBC) was not included in the Ninth Schedule of the Constitution. While the govt appeared to soften its stance under pressure, the party leadership neither condemned nor commented on Bainsla's confrontational posture. This move was interpreted by political observers as a crack in the BJP's disciplinary framework. Bainsla, who contested and lost the 2023 Assembly elections from Deoli-Uniara to Congress candidate Harish Meena, was reportedly sidelined within the party since then. Party insiders say he was not given space to raise community demands and was denied a ticket in the Deoli-Uniara bypolls in Nov 2024, fuelling his frustration and pushing him to take an aggressive stance to regain his position in the community. "The party didn't want to open a new front in the form of Bainsla, especially at a time when it is already struggling to manage cabinet minister Kirori Lal Meena," said a senior party leader, on condition of anonymity. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Giao dịch CFD với công nghệ và tốc độ tốt hơn IC Markets Đăng ký Undo Another senior BJP leader acknowledged that Bainsla commands considerable support among the Gujjar community, particularly on the reservation issue. "Being the son of the late Kirori Singh Bainsla, a towering figure in the Gurjar movement, he carries significant influence. During Congress leader Rahul Gandhi's Bharat Jodo Yatra, Bainsla's threat to oppose the march forced the Congress into damage control, resulting in formation of a four-member cabinet committee. That incident clearly established his clout," the leader said. Kirori Singh Bainsla was the leading face of the Gurjar reservation movement in Rajasthan since its inception in 2004. Vijay Bainsla was swiftly inducted into the BJP, with hopes that he would swing the Gurjar vote base, which heavily tilted toward the Congress in the 2018 elections—attracted by speculation over Sachin Pilot's potential elevation to chief minister. However, Bainsla's defeat in the 2023 Assembly elections led to his political marginalisation. However, his recent political revival through the Gurjar Mahapanchayat in Pilupura, which saw participation from Gurjars across Rajasthan, Punjab, Haryana, Madhya Pradesh, and Delhi, has repositioned him at the centre of the community's politics. Speaking to TOI, Bainsla said, "I am very much part of the BJP, but I also carry the responsibility to pursue the long-pending promises made to the Gurjar community by successive govts." Refusing to call his latest moves a rebellion, he added, "This is a 'wait and watch' phase — let's see how the govt responds."

MP CM Mohan Yadav inaugurates 135 development projects worth over Rs 80 crore in Narsinghpur's Gadarwara
MP CM Mohan Yadav inaugurates 135 development projects worth over Rs 80 crore in Narsinghpur's Gadarwara

India Gazette

timean hour ago

  • India Gazette

MP CM Mohan Yadav inaugurates 135 development projects worth over Rs 80 crore in Narsinghpur's Gadarwara

Narsinghpur (Madhya Pradesh) [India], June 9 (ANI): Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister Mohan Yadav on Monday performed bhoomi-pujan and inauguration of 135 development projects worth Rs 80.46 crore at Gadarwara in Narsinghpur district. According to an official release, inauguration of 67 projects worth Rs 56.58 crore and foundation stone of 68 projects worth Rs 23.88 crore was performed. CM Yadav also announced the construction of a Gaushala in Gadarwara and the provision of smooth public transport services across the state. Addressing the occasion, CM Yadav said, 'The government shares a strong relationship of development and trust with the people of Gadarwara. Farmers in Madhya Pradesh will be encouraged to establish agro-based industries. Agricultural trade fairs are being organized to promote this initiative. Farmers who set up such industries will receive a subsidy of up to 50%. Employment-generating units connected to agriculture will also be established, offering workers a monthly remuneration of Rs 5,000.' The CM also highlighted that under the leadership of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, India has reached new heights of development and gained global recognition. As Prime Minister completed 11 years of service and good governance, the achievements are evident to all. During his tenure, the Triple Talaq law was passed peacefully, Article 370 was abrogated creating national unity, and a strong response was given to the Pahalgam attack. PM Modi also elevated Sanatan culture by presiding over the Pran Pratishtha of Lord Ram Lalla in Ayodhya. Under his leadership, significant progress is being made in empowering the poor, youth, farmers and women, he added. Additionally, CM Yadav welcomed newly enrolled schoolchildren with a traditional 'Tilak' and distributed books to them. He said that efforts are being made to provide quality education so that children can understand the values of democracy, culture, and civilization and realise their dreams. The Chief Minister further emphasised that the state government is implementing various welfare initiatives for women's empowerment. Under the 'Ladli Behna Yojana', the monthly amount will be increased to Rs 3,000 within five years. He remarked that now, due to this scheme, every month feels like a festive occasion for women. Furthermore, 33% reservation for women will be implemented in Lok Sabha and Assembly elections following delimitation. CM Yadav announced the upcoming launch of the Mukhyamantri Sugam Bus Yojana across the state for passenger convenience. The State Transport Corporation will resume bus operations throughout Madhya Pradesh. A 132 kV power substation will be set up in Saikheda, a town in Narsinghpur district. He also declared construction of a 20 km road from Chichli to Salichouka at a cost of Rs 60 crores and construction of a 17.5 km road from Arjungaon to Gadarwara at a cost of Rs 27 crores. (ANI)

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store