logo
Question before SC: are ‘unopposed' election victories unconstitutional?

Question before SC: are ‘unopposed' election victories unconstitutional?

Indian Express27-04-2025

The Supreme Court suggested last week that in case there is only one candidate in an election, she should be required to obtain a prescribed minimum vote share in order to be declared elected, rather than winning without the election being held.
The court was hearing a petition by legal research think tank Vidhi Centre for Legal Policy questioning the constitutionality of Section 53(2) of The Representation of the People Act, 1951, as far as Lok Sabha and Assembly elections are concerned.
This section ('Procedure in contested and uncontested elections') says that 'if the number of…candidates is equal to the number of seats to be filled, the returning officer shall forthwith declare all such candidates to be duly elected to fill those seats'.
The court has asked the Union government to file its response within four weeks.
Petition and argument
The petition, filed in August 2024, argues that not holding the election in case of a single candidate prevents voters from choosing the 'None of the Above' (NOTA) option, which amounts to a violation of their fundamental right.
The petition cites the Supreme Court's 2013 judgment in People's Union for Civil Liberties vs Union of India, in which the court held that the right to cast a negative vote by choosing NOTA was protected in direct elections under Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution.
It argues that 'this right, by which the voter indicates her disapproval of the entire field of candidates, must be agnostic to the number of candidates in the fray'.
Uncontested elections
Candidates were elected uncontested to Lok Sabha at 26 constituencies between 1951 and 2024, the petition says, citing statistical reports of the Election Commission of India for these years. As such, more than 82 lakh electors had been deprived of the chance to cast their vote in these elections, it says.
Of these 26 no-contests, seven took place during the Lok Sabha election of 1957, five each in the elections of 1951 and 1967, three in 1962, two in 1977, and one each in the elections of 1971, 1980, 1989, and 2024, according to the petition. Last year, the BJP candidate from Surat, Mukeshkumar Dalal, was declared elected 'unopposed' after all other candidates either dropped out or had their nominations rejected.
Uncontested elections are more common in state Assemblies, the petition says.
Response of ECI
In its counter affidavit submitted earlier this month, the Election Commission pointed out that only nine of the 20 Lok Sabha elections held from 1951 to 2024 had seen uncontested elections of MPs. And in the more than three decades since 1989, only one candidate had entered Lok Sabha uncontested.
'With the evolution of democracy, more number of political parties are contesting elections and hence, the number of candidates also increases automatically and the voters have also become more aware and eager to exercise their franchise to right to vote. The chance of an election being uncontested has become a rarity which is proven from the statistical data and hence, in such a scenario, [the] court ought not to entertain the present petition,' the ECI said.
The Commission argued that 'NOTA' cannot be assumed to have automatically contested every election.
It cited the court's NOTA judgment that a button should be added to the electronic voting machine (EVM) to give an option to those who did not wish to vote for any of the candidates in the fray.
'Hence', the ECI said, 'NOTA option can be exercised when the polling takes place where the voters come to the polling booths to cast their votes… Therefore, treating NOTA as a mandatorily contesting candidate in all direct uncontested elections does not find place in the statute and the same would require legislative amendments in the provisions of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 and the Conduct of the Elections Rules, 1961.'
Justice Surya Kant, who presided over the two-judge Bench, said during the hearing on April 24: 'Will it not be a very welcome and progressive step where only one candidate is left in [fray] and still you say that you will be declared [elected] only when you get at least 10%, 15% [votes], whatever…?'
'When we talk of the majority as the foundation stone of the democracy, why not in furtherance of achieving that very goal, we prescribe that even in a default direction, there should be at least some voters who are liking you,' Justice Kant said.
He asked the government to 'please examine' the question, because 'today you don't have a problem…but you can enact something visualising that if tomorrow this problem comes, I have a weapon ready to address it'.
What that weapon can be, 'it's your wisdom, if Parliament will decide', he said. '[But] why should we allow somebody to enter Parliament by default who is unable to get even 5% vote? You may think of that because you are representing the will of the people.'

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Thousands of 'untainted' schoolteachers in West Bengal wrote to President Droupadi Murmu on Tuesday seeking the restoration of their jobs. 'We should not have to appear for fresh exams when we did not
Thousands of 'untainted' schoolteachers in West Bengal wrote to President Droupadi Murmu on Tuesday seeking the restoration of their jobs. 'We should not have to appear for fresh exams when we did not

The Hindu

timean hour ago

  • The Hindu

Thousands of 'untainted' schoolteachers in West Bengal wrote to President Droupadi Murmu on Tuesday seeking the restoration of their jobs. 'We should not have to appear for fresh exams when we did not

Kolkata Thousands of 'untainted' schoolteachers in West Bengal wrote to President Droupadi Murmu on Tuesday seeking the restoration of their jobs. 'We should not have to appear for fresh exams when we did not take part in any unfair practices or corruption. Why are we being subjected to this ordeal?' said Payel Dutta, an 'untainted' teacher. She and her fellow protesters were seen signing the letters from the footpaths in Salt Lake, Kolkata, where they have been protesting for the past 34 days demanding the restoration of their jobs. The situation follows the April 3 Supreme Court order upholding a Calcutta High Court decision to cancel the recruitment of nearly 26,000 teachers and non-teaching employees in the State-run schools due to irregularities in the 2016 selection process conducted by the West Bengal School Service Commission. The apex court subsequently allowed the 'untainted' teachers to continue working until year-end. On April 24, the State government released lists of 'untainted' teachers. The top court asked the 'untainted' candidates, many of whom have seven to eight years of experience, to appear for fresh exams for reinstatement. 'I earnestly and solemnly appeal to you, the head of the state and the highest constitutional authority... That I be spared from this punishment,' read the common draft of the letter. In the event their request was turned down, the teachers sought permission for 'voluntary euthanasia' for themselves and their family members. The teachers also urged Ms. Murmu to issue a directive 'for a fair reconsideration of the judgment that has deprived us of our rightful livelihood'. Those in distress may contact Sanjivini, Society for Mental Health suicide prevention helpline 011-40769002.

Backwardness only criteria for OBC classification, says Bengal CM Mamata Banerjee
Backwardness only criteria for OBC classification, says Bengal CM Mamata Banerjee

Time of India

time3 hours ago

  • Time of India

Backwardness only criteria for OBC classification, says Bengal CM Mamata Banerjee

West Bengal CM Mamata Banerjee on Tuesday told the assembly that OBC classification hasn't been done on religion, the only benchmark for it being the backwardness of a community. "A high court division bench order led to the exclusion of several groups from the OBC category. The West Bengal government took the matter to the Supreme Court," Banerjee said. In compliance with the HC order, a public notification was issued, she said. All action was taken, abiding by the law, and it has been submitted to court, she said. There were a total of 140 recognised groups among OBCs. Banerjee said out of 140, around 61 are from the majority Hindu community and 79 from the minority community.

Tribals protest municipal limits extension in Jamshedpur
Tribals protest municipal limits extension in Jamshedpur

Time of India

time4 hours ago

  • Time of India

Tribals protest municipal limits extension in Jamshedpur

1 2 3 Jamshedpur: The Scheduled Tribes (STs) community living on the periphery of the Jamshedpur Notified Area Committee (JNAC), Mango Notified Area Committee (MNAC), and Jugsalai Municipal Council (JMC) staged a demonstration at the DC office on Tuesday opposing the govt's proposal to extend the command limits of the three municipal bodies and include the panchayat areas. Representatives of different social and religious outfits, besides panchayat heads and traditional village heads, among others, said that the culture, customs, and rural lifestyle of the adivasis would be compromised with the inclusion of the panchayats in the municipal limits. "Several tribal families in the villages own 10 bighas of ancestral land on average. The holding tax of the municipality will cause a heavy financial burden on the modest earning families," said Mukhiya Sangh general secretary, Kanhu Murmu. Further, the agitating crowd claimed that the whole of Jamshedpur comes under the Fifth Scheduled Area of the Constitution, and in the past, a large part of the land was acquired by the govt for the purpose of setting up industries and developing a planned city without taking into confidence the heads of gram panchayats of that time. "Whatever land we are having in the panchayats will not be parted with the govt for the extension of the municipality," said Majhi Baba Sangh president Ramesh Murmu. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Free P2,000 GCash eGift UnionBank Credit Card Apply Now Undo Notably, the JNAC and JMC completed the satellite survey of the six panchayats earlier in April this year, while MNAC is yet to finish it. Presently, the process of determining the extended boundaries of the municipal areas of Jamshedpur and Jugsalai is ongoing ahead of submitting the report to the urban development department. "The purpose is to provide better municipal facilities to the people living in the areas identified for inclusion in the municipality," said a senior JNAC official, requesting anonymity in the wake of the increasing protest against the proposal. The agencies have identified Moharda, Harlung, and Ghorabandha panchayats for JNAC and Bagbera and Kitadih for the JMC, respectively.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store