American Idol fans outraged over Carrie Underwood's weird comments to contestant Jamal Roberts as the Top 3 is revealed
The 42-year-old singer joined the judge's panel this season, replacing Katy Perry, 20 years after the Idol win that launched her career.
Only five singers remained - Slater Nalley, John Foster, Thunderstorm Artis, Breanna Nix and Jamal Roberts - after Gabby Samone and Mattie Pruitt were sent home on Sunday.
All five singers performed twice once again, with two singers being sent home via America's vote when it was all said and done - Slater Nalley and Thunderstorm Artis.
While fans were outraged by Sunday night's results, that wasn't necessarily the case on Monday's episode, though many did take Underwood to task.
Many were furious after she told the 27-year-old Roberts, now the last Black singer left in the field, to 'move around and entertain.'
Roberts chose Marvin Gaye and Tammi Terrell's Ain't No Mountain High Enough from the 2000 Disney sports film Remember the Titans, with Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie giving him a standing ovation while Carrie Underwood remained seated.
His performance elicited a huge response from the crowd, with judge Luke Bryan saying, 'You deserve every bit of this.'
Lionel Richie was floored by his ability to transform certain songs, which he called the singer's ability to, 'Jamalerize' a song, adding the performance was, 'amazing' while encouraging fans to vote.
While Carrie Underwood admitted that Jamal's, 'voice is incredible,' she surprised many fans by saying, 'I feel like you missed such an opportunity to move around and entertain.'
She added, 'We are getting close to the end here, it is time to pull out all the stops. And we know you have that in you. So like pull us all in not just with your voice but everything else going on. Put 100% of yourself into it. Let's go.'
After his second performance - a soulful rendition of the title song from Disney's Beauty and the Beast, Carrie was seemingly speechless, telling the other judges to speak.
Lionel said that only Jamal could pull off turning Beauty and the Beast into an R&B song while Luke simply said, 'Let's win this thing, baby! Let's win this thing!'
Jamal was voted through to the Top 3 and will have a chance to win the competition on Sunday night's finale, though many found Carrie's comments quite off-putting.
In fact, some even went so far as to say that they didn't want to see her return to the judge's table for Season 24.
A fan named Brianna (@lakenbriannaxo) said, 'What kills me is Carrie telling Jamal he needs to move around but these others are staying in the same spot and not moving.'
Another fan dubbed @topfloordes said, 'Something about Carrie…….i can't put my finger on it but she's not genuine and doesn't like soulful singers, she doesn't care for runs etc. she thinks country is the only genre out there.'
LaDawna (@LaDawna_writes) said, '#AmericanIdol folks have stood still all season and Carrie decides to tell Jamal to move around and dance. Annoying!'
Lady Kaija (@LadyKaija) insisted, 'Carrie DEFINITELY DOES NOT LIKE JAMAL AT ALL, and she'll do ANYTHING TO SABOTAGE his win! I pray GOD shuts her down once n for all! Jamal is God's Property!'
The same user added, 'It's pretty pathetic that Carrie would criticize Jamal - but to be fair... She gritted on him during his entire performance! She OBVIOUSLY DOES NOT LIKE JAMAL, and she's BLATANTLY OBVIOUS! WATCH.'
Katherine Lind (@katherinelind92), added, 'Carrie have no rights to use that attitude with Jamal.'
Another user dubbed @Gawjussraeee said, 'Carrie can go ahead & sit next season out. Im not feeling her.'
A fan named Brianna (@lakenbriannaxo) said, 'What kills me is Carrie telling Jamal he needs to move around but these others are staying in the same spot and not moving.'
Another fan dubbed @topfloordes said, 'Something about Carrie…….i can't put my finger on it but she's not genuine and doesn't like soulful singers, she doesn't care for runs etc. she thinks country is the only genre out there'
LaDawna (@LaDawna_writes) said, '#AmericanIdol folks have stood still all season and Carrie decides to tell Jamal to move around and dance. Annoying!'
The same user added, 'It's pretty pathetic that Carrie would criticize Jamal - but to be fair... She gritted on him during his entire performance! She OBVIOUSLY DOES NOT LIKE JAMAL, and she's BLATANTLY OBVIOUS! WATCH.'
The same user added, 'It's pretty pathetic that Carrie would criticize Jamal - but to be fair... She gritted on him during his entire performance! She OBVIOUSLY DOES NOT LIKE JAMAL, and she's BLATANTLY OBVIOUS! WATCH.'
Katherine Lind (@katherinelind92), added, 'Carrie have no rights to use that attitude with Jamal'
Another user dubbed @Gawjussraeee said, 'Carrie can go ahead & sit next season out. Im not feeling her.'
Butta J (@ButtaKupJ) said, 'Dear Carrie, this is flat foot singing! He don't have to do flips! Shiiid you didn't do any when you was on the show. This man is sanging! Vote for Team Jamal Roberts #AmericanIdol.'
ForeverInFantasyLand (@WhittyWhit86) said, 'I feel like Carrie Underwood should have dressed up as the Evil Queen with the mean faces she's making #AmericanIdol.'
Penny Pumpkin (@pennypumpkin33) said, 'Was waiting for Carrie to tell Jamal he should have done a handstand during his performance.'
Butta J (@ButtaKupJ) said, 'Dear Carrie, this is flat foot singing! He don't have to do flips! Shiiid you didn't do any when you was on the show. This man is sanging! Vote for Team Jamal Roberts #AmericanIdol.'
ForeverInFantasyLand (@WhittyWhit86) said, 'I feel like Carrie Underwood should have dressed up as the Evil Queen with the mean faces she's making #AmericanIdol.'
Penny Pumpkin (@pennypumpkin33) said, 'Was waiting for Carrie to tell Jamal he should have done a handstand during his performance.'
American Idol closes out Season 23 with the epic finale Sunday, May 18 at 8 PM ET on ABC.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
17 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Has Leo DiCaprio FINALLY settled down? Actor, 50, reveals how his mother has inspired him to change his dating rules since finding love with model, 27 - after he was mocked for romancing under 25 year olds
Leonardo DiCaprio has hinted he has finally settled down with his model girlfriend Vittoria Ceretti after making some changes in his life since entering his fifties. The Hollywood heartthrob, 50, known for his lothario lifestyle, has always hit headlines with his relationships with model women all under the age of 25. Ever since he burst onto the big screen in the early 1990s, Leonardo has dated a never-ending conveyor belt of glamorous models and actresses, including Gigi Hadid, Gisele Bündchen and Bar Refaeli. Vittoria has seemingly broke Leo's rule of strictly dating women under the age of 25, as the pair's relationship continues to blossom. In a rare new interview with Esquire UK, Leonardo declared he is living by the new rules of always being 'honest' and more 'upfront' because he has 'no time to waste' at his age. Leonardo reflected on how there is 'much more life behind him now' than there is ahead of him as he discussed is expectations for the coming decades. Speaking in the unfiltered interview, Leo said: 'Turning 50 creates a feeling like you have a desire to just be more honest and not waste your time. 'I can only imagine how the next few decades are going to progress. I look at my mother, for example, and she just says exactly what she thinks and wastes no time. She spends no time trying to fake it.' Before Vittoria, he famously split from Camila Morrone after five years together in 2022, just a month after she turned 25. Detailing the importance of saying exactly how you feel, he explained: 'Being more upfront and risking having things fall apart or risking the disagreements or risking going your separate ways from any type of relationship in life. 'The personal, the professional — it's that you don't want to waste your time any more. 'You have to just be much more upfront. It's almost a responsibility, because much more of your life is behind you than it is ahead of you.' Leonardo famously dated model Gisele for five years starting when she was 18, to a five-year romance with Bar Refaeli that ended when she turned 25. The Hollywood star had also been linked to model Gigi after they fueled romance speculation in September 2022. In a rare new interview with Esquire UK, Leonardo declared he is living by the new rules of always being 'honest' and more 'upfront' because he has 'no time to waste' at his age He was first linked to the model just weeks after his split from then-girlfriend Camila Morrone. But rumours were quickly squashed in February 2023, as a source told 'Leo is very single right now and he is not keen on the hype suggesting that he is seeking out these very young women.' The insider continued: 'He is looking for something more mature in the relationship department. It is just ridiculous because he cannot go anywhere without being linked to the youngest beautiful woman there.' 'He wants to ditch this image once and for all and he is really bothered that this continues to follow him,' they added. For years now, Leo has found himself the butt of many a dating joke - as well as facing furious backlash over his apparent refusal to woo a woman who was over the age of 25. The furious speculation about his dating habits has been given much fuel over the years; Leo split with Camila just weeks after she hit the 25 milestone - and was then photographed with a bevy of young models, including 25-year-old Victoria Lamas and 19-year-old Eden Polani. Leo faced bitter backlash over the alleged romance with Eden - who is 29 years his junior - prompting an insider to issue a vehement denial that there was anything romantic between them. 'They were seated next to each other at a music-listening party,' the insider told at the time. 'There were a number of people at that event.' The intrigue around Leo's dating habits dates back decades after he was catapulted to stardom following a string of leading man roles in movies like 1996's Romeo + Juliet and 1997's Titanic. Two years after the release of Titanic, the actor - who was 24 at the time - began dating then-18-year-old supermodel Gisele Bundchen, future ex-wife of NFL legend Tom Brady. Being in the under 25 club himself, at the time, it was not really an issue. DiCaprio flaunted his love for Bundchen on countless red carpets during their five-year relationship and they seemed like the perfect pairing. In 2004, when Bundchen was 23 years old, the two broke up. In 2005, DiCaprio jumped into another five-year romance with supermodel Bar Refaeli, who was 20 when they started seeing each other. Every detail of their long relationship was extensively covered, and many believed, at the time, that DiCaprio had met his soulmate. However, when Refaeli turned 25 years old in 2010, the two broke up - thus beginning an apparent dating pattern that would follow Leo for the next 13 years. After spending a decade in two long-term romances, DiCaprio had a series of short flings with famous women who were all under 25. In 2011, DiCaprio dated Gossip Girl beauty Blake Lively, who was 23 at the time. The following year, in 2012, DiCaprio got together with 22-year-old model Erin Heatherton, which only lasted a few months. DiCaprio then moved on with another 22-year-old - German model Toni Garrn - who he split with after she turned 24 in 2014. In 2015, he romanced Baywatch beauty Kelly Rohrbach, who was 25 at the time. That ended before she turned 26 years old. After his relationship with Rohrbach ended, DiCaprio jumped into another romance in 2016 with 24-year-old actress Nina Agdal. That ended two years later, in 2018, when Agdal was 25 years old. In 2018, DiCaprio fell hard for model Camila. At the start of their relationship, Leonardo was 43, while she was just 20. However, the age gap did not appear to be an issue - and for a while it seemed as though Leo had finally found the woman of his dreams. Then, just one month after Camila turned 25, the pair's fairytale romance came to an end. After his five-year relationship with the actress ended, Leo finally broke his 'under 25' pattern when he started seeing supermodel Gigi Hadid, who was 27 at the time. But their widely publicized fling ended a few months later, in December 2022. Although it did not workout, the source says that they are 'still friends.' Vittoria and Leo are said to have met at the 2023 Cannes Film Festival, where his Martin Scorsese movie Killers Of The Flower Moon was premiering. They were first linked in the August of that year, after a flurry of rumors that had connected Leo to Vittoria's fellow supermodel Gigi. Over the course of their time together, Vittoria has been seen on occasion with a ring on her wedding finger, but sources have insisted she and Leo are not engaged. Vittoria was previously married from 2020 until 2023 to the Italian DJ Matteo Milleri, who is part of the Berlin-based duo Tale of Us. The Autumn issue of Esquire UK is out on 14 August Leonardo DiCaprio's Dating History The Django Unchained star has famously made a habit of never dating any woman over the age of 25. GISELE BUNDCHEN (1999-2004) Leo's first high-profile relationship was with the Brazilian model, who was 20 when the pair hooked up. She broke off the relationship five years later at the age of 25. BAR REFAELI (2005-2010) The actor's relationship with Bar Refaeli ended after 5 years of dating - coincidentally the same time the Israeli model turned 25. BLAKE LIVELY (2011) The current wife of Ryan Reynolds dated Leo for just one year - when she was 23. ERIN HEATHERTON (2012) The Victoria's Secret Angel alum was just 22 when she dated DiCaprio in 2012. TONI GARRN (2013-2014) German-born model Garrn was just 21 when she and Leo broke up after two years of dating. KELLY ROHRBACH (2015) The Baywatch reboot star was 25 when she and DiCaprio dated from June until around December of 2015, with the break alleged to be a mutual decision NINA AGDAL (2016-2017) Things ended between Leo and the Danish swimsuit model after she hit 25 in 2017. CAMILA MORRONE (2017–2022) Leo and the model-turned-actress began dating just months after his split from Nina Agdal. The were reported to be more serious than ever at the start of the coronavirus pandemic, but the two reportedly split over the summer of 2022. GIGI HADID (SEPTEMBER 2022 - DECEMBER 2022) Following his August split from Morrone, it was reported that Leo had his eyes on model Gigi Hadid. The pair were seen hanging at NYC hotspots but the romance seemingly fizzled out in December. VICTORIA LAMAS (DECEMBER 2022) Leo was previously romantically linked to model/actress Victoria Lamas, who happens to be the daughter of actor Lorenzo Lamas. The pair were spotted hanging in Hollywood in late December and reportedly rang in the New Year together. VITTORIA CERETTI (MAY 2023) Leonardo was first reported to have met Italian model Vittoria at the Cannes Film Festival back in May, and in August they were first romantically linked when they were spotted on an ice cream date in August. In November, 'crazy about' Ceretti and has fully committed to their relationship.
The Independent
19 minutes ago
- The Independent
Where to pre-order Taylor Swift's new album – as release date and cover are revealed
Less than a year since her blockbuster Eras tour concluded, Taylor Swift has unveiled her latest album: The Life of A Showgirl. After announcing the new record on her boyfriend Travis Kelce 's podcast New Heights, the singer has now unveiled the album artwork and the official release date. No stranger to dropping Easter eggs for her fans, a countdown to 12.12am EST on 12 August appeared on her website, which transformed into a glittering orange facade. Early on Monday, Swift's marketing team posted a carousel of 12 photos with the caption "Thinking about when she said 'See you next era…". Then, Kelce revealed that his girlfriend would be a guest on the new episode of New Heights, posting a silhouette of Swift taken from a photoshoot on 12 December 2022. The Life of a Showgirl will be her 12th album, and in keeping with the theme, it will be released in October. The artist's 11th studio album, The Tortured Poets Department, broke the Spotify record for being the most-streamed album in a day. Allegedly picking apart the end of her relationship with actor Joe Alwyn, it also appeared to skewer The 1975 singer Matty Healy after a brief romantic liaison in the wry song The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived. After the success of her last album, and the record-breaking Eras tour, the highest-grossing tour in history and the first to break $1bn, The Life of A Showgirl is set to be one of the biggest music launches of 2025. Here's how to pre-order the new record – plus the official release date. 'The Life of a Showgirl' vinyl: £29.99, Taylor Swift has unveiled the cover artwork for The Life of a Showgirl, which is an image of her half immersed in water, broken up into pieces of glass. This could be a reference to the record's opening track, 'The Fate of Ophelia', with Swift taking inspiration from John Everett Millais's paining of Hamlet 's famous character singing in a river before she drowns. A nod to it being her 12th album, there are 12 tracks on the record, including a cover of George Michael's 1987 song 'Father Figure' – plus, a collaboration with Sabrina Carpenter in the title track. Fans don't have long to wait until the new album, with the release date set for 3 October 2025. In the lengthy podcast interview to coincide with the announcement, Swift said she recorded the album in Europe while she was on the Era's tour. Inspired by her two years spent on road, the album promises to take you behind the scenes. 'This album is about what was going on behind the scenes in my inner life during this tour, which was so exuberant and electric and vibrant,' she said. 'I'm so proud of it. And it comes from the most infectiously joyful, wild, dramatic place I was in in my life, so that effervescence has come through on this record.' Swift has reunited with Swedish producers Max Martin and Shellback, who worked on her albums Red, 1989 and Reputation, including the songs 'Shake It Off' and 'Blank Space'.
Daily Mail
19 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Machine Gun Kelly buys daughter Casie a sensible car for her 16th birthday
proved to be a doting dad as he celebrated his daughter Casie's 16th birthday, by buying her 'dream car'. The 35-year-old rapper spoiled his eldest daughter during her special day in July, as the teen was seen gushing over a black Acura TLX in a viral video. As he surprised her with the new wheels, the rapper had one rule for his girl: 'Don't drive like your dad.' The star said about the moderately priced vehicle: 'I don't know why it's her dream car, but it's her dream car.' According to Business Insider, the sleek sedan ranges from $45,400-$62,000 - a small price for the artist, whose net worth is an estimated $25million. Speaking of Casie getting her driver's permit, MGK said in the clip: 'It runs in the family, dude. We can't get a license to save our lives.' This comes as Machine Gun Kelly made wild claims he might have an extraterrestrial background during his appearance on What Happens Live with Andy Cohen. The rapper, 35, revealed he has considered the possibility that he may have alien lineage thanks to several mysteries in his life, including his body's ability to quickly recover from injuries. Adding fuel to the theory, MGK says his mother suspects she may have been abducted by a UFO at one point - which may explain for the rapper's quirks. He opened the can of worms as he admitted he didn't know how old he was, saying: 'It's a weird thing, dude, I don't know if my age, I don't know if it exists'. He said: 'I don't know many facts about my life, so I don't know, I'm starting to just be like, like my skin, like if it rips open, it heals really quick.' 'How?' an intrigued Andy asked. MGK continued: 'There's just things where I'm starting to be like, "Who's my dad?" 'Do you think that you could be like otherworld?' Andy asked. 'I've asked my mom, I said, "Any period of time you went like missing, off Earth?... Ever a tall, slender creature?"' he said. 'She told me she felt like she got abducted at one point.' 'So there may be something to this!' Andy said. 'No, there really is!' he said. 'I'm bad at talking, I shouldn't have came on a talk show.' The speculation about his heritage wasn't all MGK discussed on the show. The rapper also had a dramatic three-word response to rumors he may have struck up a romance with Sydney Sweeney. Viewer 'Kyle P.' submitted a question asking MGK about the matter, and the actor did not shy away from telling the curious fan exactly how he felt about the topic. 'MGK, Kyle P. wants to know if there's any truth you and Sydney Sweeney were more than just friends?' Host Andy Cohen, 57, asked, reading the viewer-submitted question. 'Kyle P., shut up dude,' MGK said, garnering laughter from the studio.
