logo
AI in Schools Would ‘Dehumanise' Classroom Interactions, Education Specialist Warns

AI in Schools Would ‘Dehumanise' Classroom Interactions, Education Specialist Warns

Epoch Times23-05-2025

An education specialist has warned the use of artificial intelligence in schools would dehumanise classroom interactions and increase children's digital overload.
Christopher McGovern, chairman of the Campaign for Real Education (CRE), told The Epoch Times that educators tend to embrace technology because they see it as an improvement; however, they have not fully considered the implications of education-enhanced AI.
Some of these concerns involve how it would reduce the elements of human interaction that are integral to the learning experience.
'AI dehumanises the traditional classroom interaction between a teacher and the children, but also between the children themselves. That's all taken away,' McGovern said.
McGovern, a retired head teacher and former adviser to the policy unit at 10 Downing Street, made the comments in the context of the education sector exploring the ways in which AI can aid pupils in the classroom and teachers with administration.
The Ada Lovelace Institute (ALI), a research centre which aims to ensure that technology works for the benefit of society,
Related Stories
5/7/2025
4/28/2025
David Game College, a private school in London,
Children Could Reject AI
Younger generations who have have grown up in a world of technology would reasonably be expected to be the most open to AI taking over the classroom.
But according to the ALI, that is not necessarily going to be the case. In its
'The importance of the pupil-teacher relationship matters as much to the pupil as it does to the teacher,' the think tank observed.
Similarly, teachers who were invited by the DfE to test a proof-of-concept AI marking tool
'[Pupils] want you to read their work. They want you to know and understand who they are as an individual. They want to impress you often. They want to interest you in who they are,' one secondary school teacher said in feedback to the department.
Tech Overload
McGovern said he does recognise that AI can be used constructively in certain situations and has the capacity to match learning tasks to the individual needs of pupils.
However, he said that if schools are going to introduce AI into a classroom, the use of technology needs to be reduced elsewhere.
The educator warned that AI would contribute to the 'massive overload' of technology that is already impacting children, not least since smartphones and social media have become such a prominent part of young peoples' lives.
'It's an overdose of AI which is going to be the problem. As we are going further along the path overdosing our children, they become increasingly addicted to their screens,' he said, adding it could be a further detriment to children's mental health.
Teachers Already Using AI
Despite there being few education-specific AI tools available, teachers are using generic AI products like ChatGPT in administrative tasks.
In 2023, 42 percent of teachers in England
File photo of a maths exam in progress at Pittville High School, Cheltenham, England, on March 2, 2012.
David Davies/PA Wire
ALI has pointed out that using generic products comes with its own problems, including generating content that is not age-appropriate or relevant to the curriculum. AI can also 'hallucinate,' producing inaccurate outputs that it presents as facts.
The DfE has
Schools can also set their own rules on AI use—including whether and how pupils can use it—as long as they follow legal requirements around data protection, child safety, and intellectual property.
The DfE is already supporting
Concerns Over Cheating
Last month, a survey of school support staff who belong to the GMB union
Cheating is not a new phenomenon, but educators have said that generative AI has made it much easier for children to do so, particularly in non-supervised assignments like coursework.
Education specialist Tom Richmond told The Epoch Times, 'Coursework was already recognised as an unreliable form of assessment well before ChatGPT came along, but it is now abundantly clear that unsupervised assignments cannot be treated as a fair and trustworthy form of assessment.'
Richmond, the former director of the EDSK think tank, said that it is not possible to say with certainty how many children are using AI to cheat, as there are no reliable detection tools available to schools and colleges.
He added, 'No form of assessment is immune to cheating, but some assessments are much harder to manipulate than others.'
'The most obvious way to reduce cheating is for schools to change the types of tasks and assessments that they set for pupils. Any task and assessment completed at home without supervision is now wide open to cheating, so schools can switch to more in-class assessments to prevent cheating,' he added.
File photo of Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson, dated Feb. 03, 2025.
Lucy North/PA Wire
An EDSK report from 2023
£1 Million for EdTech
The government has a wider strategy to advance the usage of AI, including in education.
On Monday, Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson
In her speech at the Education World Forum, she confirmed that the department's new Content Store Project will see curriculum guidance, teaching resources, lesson plans, and anonymised pupils' work made available to AI companies to train their tools 'so that they can generate top quality content for use in our classrooms.'
However, she emphasised that EdTech 'can't replace great teachers' and that 'AI isn't a magic wand.'
She also said the DfE will be working closely with international partners in the development of global AI guidelines for generative AI in education, in order to shape 'the global consensus on how generative AI can be deployed safely and effectively to boost education around the world.'
The UK will host an international summit on generative AI in education in 2026.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Is ChatGPT Down for You, Too? Widespread Outage Continues to Grow
Is ChatGPT Down for You, Too? Widespread Outage Continues to Grow

CNET

time19 minutes ago

  • CNET

Is ChatGPT Down for You, Too? Widespread Outage Continues to Grow

Have you noticed that ChatGPT is a little less chatty this morning? OpenAI is experiencing a widespread outage Tuesday morning that's affecting its ChatGPT AI chatbot service, as well as its Sora tool for AI-generated videos. The number of reported outages has continued to increase throughout the morning. An OpenAI representative responded via email, directing us to its post on X and its status page. Both stated that OpenAI is experiencing "elevated errors and latency" and that it has identified the root cause and is working to mitigate the underlying issue. The technical issues are also affecting OpenAI's APIs, which allow developers to tap into the company's AI models. The troubles been ongoing for seven hours, OpenAI noted, meaning they likely started around midnight PT. The Downdetector service also shows outage reports starting around that time and then spiking several hours later. (Downdetector is owned by Ziff Davis, which is also the parent company of CNET.) Launched in 2022, ChatGPT has become the most popular AI application ever released, with 400 million weekly users. A barrage of generative AI competitors have followed, including Meta AI, Google's Gemini and Microsoft's Copilot, but ChatGPT remains the leader largely because it's easy to use. At its Worldwide Developers Conference 2025, Apple even touted an expansion of its ChatGPT integration. The AI chatbot uses learning algorithms and large language models to process massive amounts of data from books and the internet, which it uses to deliver human-like responses to prompts from users. (Ziff Davis in April filed a lawsuit against OpenAI, alleging it infringed Ziff Davis copyrights in training and operating its AI systems.) This is a developing story. What can you do while OpenAI is down? Although OpenAI's ChatGPT may be among the most popular options, there are plenty of alternatives while it's down -- and many of them are free to use. Chat Claude is our current favorite chatbot we've tested, and Claude even knew all the details about ChatGPT's outage, according to my colleague Jon Reed, CNET senior editor who covers AI. Images If you rely on ChatGPT's Dall-E 3 as your image generator, we'd recommend trying for really creative work and Canva for free, beginner-friendly work. Video If you're looking for an alternative to Sora tool for AI-generated videos, we just checked out Microsoft's Bing Video Creator, which is super easy to use and live on mobile now.

ChatGPT Down: Eight Hours And Counting
ChatGPT Down: Eight Hours And Counting

Forbes

time20 minutes ago

  • Forbes

ChatGPT Down: Eight Hours And Counting

It's been a dark day for ChatGPT ChatGPT is suffering from a prolonged outage, which has seen the service disrupted for more than eight hours. The OpenAI service status page reported that 'some users are experiencing elevated error rates and latency across the listed services.' from around 4am ET. As of 11:15 ET, the service is still struggling, with OpenAI reporting that it's 'still working on implementing the mitigation for this issue." The 'partial outage' is disrupting ChatGPT, the Sora video generation service and the company's APIs. Although the ChatGPT site appears to be functional, responses to queries have been slow or showing error messages for several hours. The 'too many requests'" error appeared when I entered a prompt shortly before this article was published, with the service appearing to slow down further with more of the U.S. entering working hours. This is a breaking news story. More to follow.

ChatGPT Outage: OpenAI Reports ‘Elevated Error Rates'
ChatGPT Outage: OpenAI Reports ‘Elevated Error Rates'

Forbes

timean hour ago

  • Forbes

ChatGPT Outage: OpenAI Reports ‘Elevated Error Rates'

OpenAI on Tuesday said a 'partial outage' was disrupting functionality for ChatGPT, though the company said it identified the 'root cause' of the issue and is implementing a fix, as nearly 2,000 users reported issues with the AI-powered chatbot on OpenAI said it has 'identified the root cause' of the issue and is working on a fix. OpenAI reported issues with the company's application programming interfaces, ChatGPT and its AI-powered image-generating service Sora starting around 3 a.m. EDT, saying users are 'experiencing elevated error rates and latency' across several services. At around 9 a.m., OpenAI said it 'identified the root cause of the issue' and has been 'working on implementing a mitigation' for the outages. More than 1,900 users reported outages across OpenAI's service, with 92% of reports indicating issues with ChatGPT, which has responded to some users with an error message, 'Hmm … something seems to have gone wrong.' OpenAI did not immediately respond to a request for comment. This is a developing story.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store