Martin Lewis' report into major UK health food saving scheme finds customers losing money
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info
Martin Lewis' Money Saving Expert (MSE)team has been investigating Holland & Barrett's 'Subscribe & Save' scheme, finding that in the majority of cases it failed to offer customers "the best value".
Due to their report which looked at trends over the past five months, the chain has now promised to review the scheme.
As stated on the Holland & Barrett website, the scheme is a service that "means you will never be without your favourite wellness products, you control the frequency of deliveries, perhaps it's shampoo you need every month, or vitamins you need every 3 months.
Read more: Martin Lewis issues 'flawed' warning over Labour u-turn on Winter Fuel Payment cut
"To make sure you get the best price, you'll get up to 45% off* every time, we also offer free delivery on every subscribe & save order over £10."
The scheme also offers free delivery.
The asterisk notes that the fixed percentage off can range between 20% and the capped limit of 45%.
The MSE team checked the prices of 10 products over 100 separate days between 29 July 2024 and 17 January 2025.
Ultimately, the investigation came away with two major findings:
MSE stated: "In over half of cases (59%), it was therefore cheaper to buy the product as a one-off – rather than through the subscription.
"Shoppers would've lost out on savings of 75p to £3.50 in most cases – but in the worst instances, they could have overpaid by as much as £39.99."
A major reason for this is that the scheme doesn't factor in other savings the company is offering, such as 'buy one get one free'.
Essentially, "the subscription discount doesn't stack with most other promotions," according to the MSE team.
In response to the MSE, Holland & Barrett defended Subscribe & Save, saying that it offers "consistently great prices over the course of a year", along with "the convenience of an automated order".
Yet, it admitted that "on rare occasions", customers "may have paid more".
The chain also said it would "carry out a detailed review," of the scheme following the MES's detailed report.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
16 hours ago
- The National
Ian Murray 'does not understand how devolution works', minister says
The Scottish Secretary attempted to defend not informing the Government at Holyrood about alterations to the payment by suggesting Westminster would 'never' consult devolved governments on devolved policy. But Scotland's Social Justice Secretary Shirley-Anne Somerville has said Murray "doesn't seem to understand the system", as she laid out how the Labour Government had made it "almost impossible" for the Scottish Government to know how to proceed with its own devolved winter payment. After making the Winter Fuel Payment means-tested last year – meaning only those on pension credit or other benefits would receive it – Chancellor Rachel Reeves announced a major policy U-turn last week, with pensioners south of the Border earning up to £35,000 a year now set to get £200 for those aged up to 80 and £300 for those aged over 80. READ MORE: SNP Government rule out Scottish independence convention The current plan in Scotland – which has its own devolved Pension Age Winter Heating Payment – is for all pensioner households to receive £100 regardless of income, while those on pension credit will receive up to £305 depending on age. That was announced on the back of the initial cut made to the UK payment, but Reeves's latest announcement will mean – as things stand – pensioners in England and Wales earning less than £35,000 will get a larger payment than those in Scotland. Scotland will receive more money as a result of the UK change via Barnett consequentials, but Somerville told the Sunday National exact funding implications have not yet been made clear by the UK Government, making it 'almost impossible' for the Scottish Government to decide whether it can alter its own devolved payment. (Image: PA) Murray (above) said that if Labour had consulted the Scottish Government on the policy, it would 'be screaming blue murder at the fact that we're encroaching on the devolution settlement'. But Somerville said: 'If Ian Murray actually understood how the system works, he would know that changes in aspects that are devolved to Scotland, changes that happen down in England, have an implication for a Scottish budget,' she said. 'I don't think it's surprising, and I wouldn't have thought it was asking too much, for the UK Government to therefore talk to the Scottish Government when a decision they're going to make has major funding implications for the Scottish Government. 'I'm afraid Ian Murray, deliberately or otherwise, doesn't seem to understand the system.' Somerville insisted the only way Scotland will only ever be able to escape continued wranglings with the UK Government over social security is through gaining independence. She said she had 'long lost patience' with the Labour UK Government having "no respect" for Scotland after she found out through social media about the fresh changes to the Winter Fuel Payment. Somerville insisted Scotland must have full powers over social security. READ MORE: UK Government must 'urgently engage' with Scotland over migration 'I read about it [the Winter Fuel Payment change] first on social media before a meeting with the Treasury, where they couldn't tell me what the financial implications for Scotland were, and we are still trying to work out the details of how their scheme works and impacts on Scotland,' she said. 'So, there is deep disappointment. But when you have a system as we do, that is so reliant on the UK Government both in terms of its policy decisions and the finances, we are always going to be in this position. 'This is an inevitable consequence of having a Union and having a Union with a government which seems to take decisions with no thought to the implications for Scotland. 'There's clearly only one way we get past that and that's for the Scottish Parliament to have full control of our social security.' It is not the first time this year the Labour Government has left its Scottish counterpart in limbo when it comes to social security. (Image: PA) Earlier this year, the UK Government announced that from 2028/29 onwards, people would only be able to prove their eligibility for the health element of Universal Credit (UC) via the assessment for Personal Independence Payments (PIP). PIP has been replaced in Scotland by the devolved Adult Disability Payment, but the UK Government has still not confirmed whether Scots looking to obtain the UC health element can prove their eligibility via this new system. Somerville (above) told The National in March she had been seeking clarity on this matter from the previous UK Government and never got answers – a trend which she says is continuing under Labour. She said the Labour Government's failure to communicate effectively with Scotland should prove to people a switch in power at Westminster will never result in vulnerable people being better protected. 'Understandably some people thought one of the answers to further protecting vulnerable people in society – or indeed people who just have a right to support like disabled people and carers – was to elect a Labour government,' she said. 'So, we've had a Labour government elected, and the first thing they did was cut the Winter Fuel Payment from pensioners. They followed that with cuts to disabled benefits in the rest of the UK. 'If anyone needed further proof that the answer isn't a change of government in Westminster, we've unfortunately seen that. 'The only way we can protect people from those types of changes is we have those decisions being made up here by a Scottish Government through independence.' Somerville said she wanted to reassure Scottish pensioners they 'will have a winter heating payment this year' while the Government in Edinburgh continues to seek answers on the funding implications of Labour's latest U-turn. A UK Government spokesperson said: "Decisions on Scotland's Pension Age Winter Heating Payment are a matter for the Scottish Government. The Scottish Government will mechanically receive additional funding to reflect the increase in spending in England and Wales through a Block Grant Adjustment, as agreed in the Scottish Government's Fiscal Framework. "Regarding the comments about the Scottish Secretary, Ian Murray joined an HMT briefing with the Cabinet Secretary for Finance on Wednesday where she was informed ahead of publication of the Spending Review that it would mean an extra £9.1 billion for the Scottish Government over the next three years. That's more money than ever before for them to invest in Scottish public services."
Wales Online
a day ago
- Wales Online
DWP confirms exact date of birth you need to receive 2025 winter fuel payment
DWP confirms exact date of birth you need to receive 2025 winter fuel payment Chancellor Rachel Reeves confirmed that millions of people who had the benefit axed last winter will get it this year Chancellor Rachel Reeves has confirmed more people will get the winter fuel payment (Image: Carl Court, Getty Images ) The Department for Work and Pensions has confirmed that individuals born before a specific date will be eligible for the winter fuel payment this year. The website has been updated with preliminary details following Chancellor Rachel Reeves' announcement that nine million people who lost the £200-300 benefit last winter will receive it this year. Those earning over £35,000 will also receive the payment, but it will subsequently be reclaimed through the tax system. Sir Keir Starmer has maintained that the decision to restore most winter fuel payments was not a reaction to political backlash against the policy. Following the announcement, the DWP has updated its information and confirmed who will be eligible for the payment. DWP officials stated that only those born before a certain date would receive the money. They said: "The Winter Fuel Payment for 2025 to 2026 will be made to everyone in England and Wales born before 22 September 1959, unless you choose not to get it. "You could get either £200 or £300 to help you pay your heating bills for winter. You do not need to do anything - payments will be made automatically," reports Teesside Live. Officials confirmed that everyone will receive the money, but cautioned those earning above a certain threshold that it would be recouped through HMRC, though they did not provide specifics on how this would occur. Article continues below It stated: "If your income is over £35,000, your Winter Fuel Payment will be recovered later through HMRC. Details of the 2025 to 2026 payment will be available by the end of June 2025." Warnings have been issued this week about "fiscal drag" resulting from the £35,000 earnings threshold, which could see numerous individuals lose their winter fuel payment during this parliament. This follows confirmation from Ms Reeves that the £35,000 limit will not adjust in line with inflation, potentially affecting an additional 500,000 people before the parliament concludes. BBC Moneybox expert Paul Lewis commented: "The £35,000 income limit for keeping the winter fuel payment will be frozen Ministers confirm, leading to more pensioners repaying the money year by year it will join frozen bereavement payments, capital limits, child benefit limits, and tax thresholds." The Prime Minister highlighted recent growth figures and declining interest rates as evidence that "the economy has stabilised". Ms Reeves recognised that working individuals might not yet perceive the signs of economic progress, as she aimed to shift focus from the winter fuel controversy by asserting that her forthcoming spending review would promote growth. "This government is going for growth because that is the best way to create jobs, boost wages, lift people out of poverty and sustainably fund our schools and our hospitals and all the public services we rely on," she declared at the GMB Union Congress conference. While highlighting that the government was "making progress", Ms Reeves commented: "I know that not enough working people are yet feeling that progress, and that's what [last week's] spending review is all about - making working people better off, investing in our security, investing in our health, investing in our economy." Rachel Reeves did not dismiss the possibility of additional tax hikes come autumn. This comes as new data indicated the economy contracted more sharply than forecasted in April. The Chancellor has consistently asserted that her last year's tax increases have sufficiently funded the spending review outcome, emphasising that departments must now "live within their means". Economists are cautioning that due to a potential economic downturn, coupled with new obligations such as partially reversing reductions to winter fuel payments, further tax rises seem probable this coming autumn. Queried about the likelihood of more tax increments, Ms Reeves told LBC: "I think it would be very risky for a Chancellor to try and write future budgets in a world as uncertain as ours." Nonetheless, she restated her pledge that any tax changes wouldn't mirror last year's steep £40 billion increase. For our free daily briefing on the biggest issues facing the nation, sign up to the Wales Matters newsletter here . Article continues below
Wales Online
a day ago
- Wales Online
DWP offers payment worth £812 but warns you must repay it by cut-off date
DWP offers payment worth £812 but warns you must repay it by cut-off date The payment is usually sent out in November or December to help with fuel costs during the colder months The government will vote on making the Winter Fuel Payment means tested (Image: Gareth Fuller/PA Wire ) Previously, Winter Fuel Payments were universally distributed to everyone over state pension age. However, following its election victory last year the new Labour-led UK government declared it would begin means-testing these payments, limiting them to those on benefits and Pension Credit as a cost-saving measure. This decision was widely condemned for targeting some of the most vulnerable individuals and was believed to have contributed to the party's poor performance in the local elections. In recent weeks the government has partially reversed its stance, with Chancellor Rachel Reeves confirming that more pensioners will receive the Winter Fuel Allowance this year although it will not be universal. For money-saving tips, sign up to our Money newsletter here At a press conference, Ms Reeves told reporters that 'more people will get Winter Fuel Payment this winter' adding that further details would be announced 'as soon as we possibly can.' What changes are being implemented under the new rules? The modifications, officially announced on Monday, June 9, will enable all pensioners in England and Wales earning £35,000 a year or less to receive a Winter Fuel Payment. This expands eligibility to the vast majority of pensioners, with approximately nine million or over three-quarters benefitting according to ministers. Article continues below This change will cost around £1.25 billion in England and Wales and the Winter Fuel Payment is expected to save around £450 million compared to a universal system, subject to certification by the Office for Budget Responsibility. These figures will be reflected in the next Budget and OBR forecast. The payment of £200 per household, or £300 for households with someone over 80, will be automatically made this winter. Over 12 million pensioners across the UK will also benefit from the Triple Lock, with their State Pension set to increase by up to £1,900 during this parliament. Chancellor Rachel Reeves said: 'Targeting Winter Fuel Payments was a tough decision but the right decision because of the inheritance we had been left by the previous government. It is also right that we continue to means-test this payment so that it is targeted and fair rather than restoring eligibility to everyone including the wealthiest. 'But we have now acted to expand the eligibility of the Winter Fuel Payment so no pensioner on a lower income will miss out. This will mean over three-quarters of pensioners receiving the payment in England and Wales later this winter.' Reeves elaborated further, stating that pensioners earning above the £35,000 threshold, about two million individuals, will automatically repay the Winter Fuel Payment through PAYE or their self-assessment tax return. They will not need to take any action unless they choose to opt out of receiving the payment altogether, which will be possible later this year. Budgeting Loans If you're applying for a Budgeting Loan, separate from the Winter Fuel Payment, this must be repaid, though it is interest-free so you only pay back what you borrow. The repayments are automatically taken from your benefits and the amount you repay depends on your income including any benefits and what you can afford. After you apply, you'll get an email, text or letter telling you if you've been offered a loan and this will explain how much your weekly repayments will be if you accept it. You normally have to repay the loan within two years (104 weeks). The maximum loan amount is £812 for a couple with children. Article continues below
