10 years after offence: European Court of Justice rules in Seraing's favour in dispute with FIFA
The problems stem from 2015, when Seraing transferred the economic rights for several players to the Maltese company Doyen Sports. However, according to FIFA, this violated the ban on Third Party Ownership (TPO).
The Belgian news outlet explains that. 'this means that a party other than a football club owns part of the economic rights to a player and can thus profit from transfer fees, loan fees, and image rights.'
FIFA imposed a transfer ban on the club for four transfer windows and a fine of 150,000 Swiss francs (over 136,000 euros). These sanctions were upheld by the International Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) and the Swiss Federal Court, with FIFA being based in Switzerland.
The case was also brought before the Belgian court, but it declared itself incompetent in the matter. Belgian law recognises the authority of rulings by the CAS. An appeal was subsequently filed, and the Court of Cassation referred the matter to the European Court of Justice.
The Advocate General of the Court had already issued an opinion in the case in January. Now the European Court agree, ruling that 'it is essential that arbitration does not undermine the rights and freedoms that athletes, clubs, and the like derive from the fundamental rules of EU law.'
According to the Court, 'national courts must therefore have the power to thoroughly review the compatibility of arbitration awards from the CAS. Furthermore, if a national regulation or a sports federation's regulation prevents national courts from exercising their jurisdiction, the courts are obligated to disapply the regulation.'
GBeNeFN | Max Bradfield
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
7 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Beşiktaş 'reach agreement' with Leicester for Wilfred Ndidi
Turkish football powerhouse Beşiktaş have reached an agreement with Leicester City to sign Nigerian midfielder Wilfred Ndidi, marking the conclusion of a prolonged transfer saga. Outlet Fanatik have confirmed that Ndidi has been invited to Istanbul to complete his medical examinations and finalise personal terms, with a 3+1-year contract on the table. The transfer fee is reportedly set at €9.5 million (£8.3 million), a figure Leicester City have accepted despite Ndidi's release clause being higher. The 28-year-old is in the final year of his contract with the English club and has chosen not to renew following Leicester's relegation from the Premier League. Ndidi has been a key figure for Leicester since his arrival in 2017, making over 240 appearances and earning a reputation as one of the Premier League's most effective ball-winning midfielders. In the 2024–25 season, he featured in 30 matches, scoring once and assisting five times. His consistent performances over the years have attracted interest from several European clubs, but it is Beşiktaş who have made the decisive move. The transfer is seen as a major boost for Beşiktaş ahead of the new season, especially with the added demands of domestic competition and potential European fixtures. Manager Ole Gunnar Solskjær, newly installed at the helm, reportedly played a key role in pushing for the transfer, having admired Ndidi's abilities during his time in England. For Ndidi, the move represents an opportunity to compete at a high level and play an influential role in a club with strong ambitions. The Turkish Super Lig offers a fresh challenge, and Beşiktaş are hopeful that his arrival will bring much-needed stability and strength to the centre of the pitch. Both clubs appear satisfied with the outcome of the negotiations, with Turkish media describing the deal as a 'happy ending.' Supporters have already begun to celebrate what they believe is one of the most significant signings of the summer for the club. Ndidi is expected to arrive in Istanbul within days to complete the final formalities before being officially unveiled as a Beşiktaş player. 📸 Michael Regan - 2025 Getty Images
Yahoo
7 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Inter Milan Will Only Sign A Defender If They Sell One – Genoa Star Tops Shortlist
Inter Milan will only sign a defender this summer if they sell one, with Genoa's Koni De Winter at the top of their shortlist. This according to today's print edition of Milan-based newspaper Gazzetta dello Sport, via FCInterNews. It has long seemed as though Inter would move for a defender this summer. After all, the Nerazzurri's current backline isn't getting any younger. The likes of Stefan de Vrij and Francesco Acerbi will turn 34 and 38 respectively next season. Therefore, Inter have been targeting defenders who are much younger than that for months. And in the meantime, Inter have taken steps to lower the average age of the squad. They've signed young players like Petar Sucic, Luis Henrique, and Ange-Yoan Bonny. As well as bringing Francesco Pio Esposito into the first-team fold. Inter Will Only Sign A Defender If They Sell One – De Winter Tops Shortlist RIYADH, SAUDI ARABIA – JANUARY 06: Yann Aurel Bisseck of FC Internazionale passes the ball during the Italian Super Cup Final between FC Internazionale and AC Milan at Kingdom Arena on January 06, 2025 in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. (Photo by) According to the Gazzetta dello Sport, though, Inter are not going to sign a defender without selling one first. The likeliest candidate would probably be Yann Bisseck, the newspaper notes. However, the Nerazzurri are in no hurry to sell the German international. Meanwhile, Bisseck himself is also more than happy to say. He reportedly gave the cold shoulder to Crystal Palace after the Premier League club made an offer for him. If Inter were to sell a defender this summer, however, the Gazzetta name Genoa's Koni De Winter as the player they would be most inclined to move for as a replacement.
Yahoo
7 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Tottenham Hotspur have made enquiry for Barcelona midfielder
Barcelona continue to make it known in public that they are open to departures this summer, despite their claims that they can register all three of their new signings without any. One of the names that has been floated as a potential exit is midfielder Marc Casado. The 21-year-old was a surprise revelation last season in the Barcelona side, with injuries taking him from a potential summer exit on loan to a starter against Bayern Munich and Real Madrid. Within three months of his first start, Casado was in the Spain squad. Chelsea and Atletico Madrid have been credited with interest in Casado, and Sport say he has a €30m price tag. Tottenham Hotspur enquire about Casado The Catalan daily go on to say that Tottenham Hotspur have also enquired about a move for Casado this summer, as they look to add a midfield alternative. They are seeking to add one or two holding midfielders this summer, and Barcelona have plenty of options in midfield, with Gavi, Frenkie de Jong and Marc Casado all competing for minutes in the deeper role at Barcelona. Image viaMove unlikely on both ends However with Spurs bringing in Joao Palhinha from Bayern Munich, their need for more options in the position has been dramatically reduced. At the other end of the equation, Casado is said to be completely focused on earning minutes at Barcelona, and is not listening to any offers to leave the club. Can Casado get enough minutes in this Barcelona side? Whether Casado might be forced to reconsider next summer is another matter. As mentioned, four players are competing for his position, while Gavi can play elsewhere in midfield, and Bernal is recovering from a cruciate ligament injury. Earlier on in the season Casado could have more opportunities, but by the end of the season, someone will likely be left with less minutes than they hoped for.
