Judicial system needs ‘shake-up' after trader convictions, says Sir David Davis
Tom Hayes and Carlo Palombo were found guilty over benchmark interest rate rigging in 2015 and 2019 respectively, but had their convictions quashed at the Supreme Court on Wednesday.
The former UBS trader and the ex-vice president of euro rates at Barclays bank were said to have manipulated the London Inter-Bank Offered Rate (Libor) and the Euro Interbank Offered Rate (Euribor).
Speaking at a press conference following the Supreme Court judgment, Sir David described the two men as 'scapegoats for the sins that led to the financial crisis'.
He said: 'The implications are far-reaching and of course have been devastating for those caught up in it.
'There were several other people convicted of rate rigging, dozens of others who were either prosecuted, acquitted or not prosecuted. Their lives were upended too.
'This scapegoating exercise happened as a result of collusion between the banks and government agencies, including the SFO (Serious Fraud Office) and FCA (Financial Conduct Authority) and we're not done with that.
'This scandal also highlights the need for urgent reform within our justice system on a range of issues – the handling of expert witnesses right through to the rigidity of the appeals system.'
In an 82-page judgment, with which Supreme Court president Lord Reed, Lords Hodge and Lloyd-Jones and Lady Simler agreed, Lord Leggatt said judges' misdirection to the juries had led to the men's wrongful convictions.
He said: 'The history of these two cases raises concerns about the effectiveness of the criminal appeal system in England and Wales in confronting legal error.'
Sir David said the Supreme Court justices 'did not unpack' why the appeal system fell into error in these cases.
He said: 'I think the judicial system needs a shake-up, and this is the latest demonstrator of it, and we will be returning to it in the future.'
Mr Hayes said he believes the trials of the two men became caught up in the politics of the financial crisis, adding that there was a 'big desire from institutions and politicians, acting in their own interest largely', for traders to go to prison.
Asked about his thoughts on what role juries play in cases like his and Mr Palombo's, he said it was a 'dangerous idea' for complicated fraud and financial cases to be heard only by a judge.
The former trader added: 'The jury is the last defensive barrier that every citizen in this country has between them and a wrongful conviction.
'And are juries perfect? No, they're not. Do they make mistakes? Yes, they do. And you know, it's the best of a whole load of options, none of which is perfect.'
Ben Rose, part of Mr Palombo's legal team, said Wednesday's Supreme Court judgment is 'likely to offer a route' by which others who have been convicted in similar circumstances 'can right the wrong that has been done to them'.
He also said there was a 'fundamental error' in the way the case was prosecuted and that the role of the jury was 'overridden and usurped' by the judges.
The lawyer added: 'That should not happen in a country that abides by the rule of law.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 minutes ago
- Yahoo
The Bonnie Blue documentary on Channel 4 is compelling but dangerous
Bonnie Blue may have slept with over a thousand men in a day as a publicity stunt, but that's not the bit that most sticks with you from her new Channel 4 documentary. 'We're the two most misunderstood people out there at the moment,' she sighs of Andrew Tate, the YouTuber facing charges including rape, actual bodily harm and human trafficking, all of which he denies. Tate is a self-proclaimed misogynist, having said on the platform that he's 'a realist and when you're a realist, you're sexist. There's no way you can be rooted in reality and not be sexist.' Blue, 26, whose real name is Tia Billinger, admits she engages in 'rage bait'. In other words, she says willingly provocative things to drive her engagement. She says she likes having sex with 'barely legal or barely breathing' men, that she'd like to have a disabled gang bang and that 'lazy' women are the reason men seek her out for sex. The new documentary tells the story of the Brit who became one of the most successful porn stars on OnlyFans, and features behind-the-scenes footage from the 'thousand men' stunt. It claims to examine a woman living 'at the edges of modern morality'. But fleeting shots of the hanky-panky and the 'how did she do it' narrative – that she had a doughnut halfway through bonking a small cruise ship's worth of men to keep her sugar levels up – disguise a more sinister narrative. In general the doc is too sympathetic to a dangerous character; it might have been better to have commissioned a multi-voice piece focusing on a broader picture of the sex industry today or for director Victoria SIlver to have appeared more in the piece to share her own views to provide more balance. Bonnie Blue seems plainly out of her depth, as someone who hasn't given much thought to the radicalisation of young men There are endless attempts at trying to justify her. During the piece her mum says 'if you earn a million pounds a month, your morals would change and you'd get your tits out.' But that's the thing: we can't. None of us are Blue. She was earning a reported $1 million a month on OnlyFans before she was banned for posting increasingly outrageous content, because she is an extraordinary character with a troubling ability to climb the porn ranks. The Channel 4 documentary is wrong: she isn't on the fringes of moral society, she's parroting highly irresponsible and dangerous narratives to vulnerable, largely young, people. She says she doesn't agree with everything Andrew Tate says, but by giving him such an over-arching praise and aligning herself with him so directly, she has lost the possibility for any nuance. Someone with Blue's platform, which reaches tens of millions of impressionable people, needs to understand the harmful effect their words can have. Her stunts earned her millions of followers, for obvious reasons. Her fans, many of whom are teenagers, were able to queue up and have sex with her for free. She has brought the fantasy of online porn into the real world. 'They sit at home wanking wondering what it's like to fuck me. So just come fuck me,' she says. But as the documentary also examines, she is sexist, suggesting in reductive generalised statements that it's women's fault that men aren't sexually satisfied. On stage during a press event for the documentary she spoke flippantly about 'fat' women. As she puts it: 'I'm happy to piss off the women because they're not my target audience.' Bonnie Blue isn't likeable or unlikable – just incredibly frustrating She worked for five years as a successful recruitment consultant, and through her porn persona you can see how she brings the bullishness of her former job into new territory. Bonnie Blue says in the doc that 'if you don't like it, stop wanking to it' and is firm on the notion that it's up to parents to teach their children about sex, not her (she also notes that Tate is a 'marketing genius'). But Blue isn't selling jobs in the NHS anymore, she's potentially damaging the mental health and confidence of millions of young people, and teaching a whole generation of young men that women's bodies are disposable. It comes amid worrying data: more sexual crimes than ever against under-18s are being committed by other under-18s. I'm not here to moralise about whether or not having sex with a thousand men in a day is wrong. It doesn't sound great to have under one minute with a sexual partner, and surely that's going to get in the heads of some of those men. But Blue's careless messaging and inability to take any responsibility is deeply troubling. I understand why they made it: Blue is someone we need to be having conversations about. The mainstreamisation of porn is going nowhere as the proliferation of online creators continues, but Channel 4's documentary may end up bolstering her toxic narratives. At the media Q+A, even director Victoria Silver seemed uncomfortable being asked how she felt personally about her subject. Blue does seem to have a deep-rooted love for men She comes across as someone plainly out of their depth, who hasn't given much thought to mental health or the radicalisation of young men. She seems content to bulldoze her way to another million, unwilling or unable to take responsibility for her actions. She isn't likeable or unlikable, more just incredibly frustrating. There are glimmers of a distinctive form of compassion: she is perhaps most believable and truly herself when she says how much she enjoys pleasuring men. Interestingly, the only man she had thrown out of the thousand men stunt was someone penis size-shaming other men. I do think she probably has a deep-rooted care for men. The documentary is also utterly compelling, you cannot take your eyes off her and the outrageous things she says. It's just a shame that her love might also be deeply damaging. airs on Channel 4 on Tuesday 29 July at 10pm
CNN
4 minutes ago
- CNN
Swirling Crises Follow Trump to Scotland on Pivotal Week - Inside Politics with Dana Bash and Manu Raju - Podcast on CNN Podcasts
Swirling Crises Follow Trump to Scotland on Pivotal Week CNN Inside Politics 40 mins First: In the rough. As President Trump tees off overseas, he faces urgent questions about a major tariff deadline and deepening starvation in Gaza. Will he make any progress? Plus: No end in sight. As Trump tries to put miles between him and the Epstein saga, could a new tactic by his team backfire? A conservative congressman who's pushing for more information, Eric Burlison joins me live. And: Shake-up. A big win for Democrats as they try to take back Congress. Can they overcome the odds?
Yahoo
16 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Plans for 62-bed care home and assisted living village at former garden centre
PLANS have been lodged to build a 62-bed care home with 48 assisted care properties at an abandoned garden centre. Care South, a not-for-profit care provider, has applied to BCP Council to approve a full planning application seeking the redevelopment of the former Oaks Garden Centre as a care village. Located off Queen Anne Drive in Merley, the plans include older persons accommodation with specialist residential care and dementia care facilities. A design and access statement prepared by Corstorphine & Wright, on behalf of Care South, said: 'The redevelopment would make the best use of a brownfield site within the green belt to help fulfil the urgent need for specialised older persons' accommodation in the local area. 'The site would also meet the definition of a 'grey belt' site as defined in the latest version of the National Planning Policy Framework." Care South acquired the former Oaks Garden centre site in 2023 with the purpose of redeveloping it to provide a range of accommodation for older people with care to serve the local area. The care provider has an existing portfolio of 15 care homes, eight of which are located in the Bournemouth, Poole and the Ringwood area. The site is located on the southern side of Queen Anne Drive adjacent to the urban area of Merley. It connects to Gravel Hill to the west and Ringwood Road to the east. The site covers 1.64ha hectares and is categorised as previously developed land within the green belt The site has two existing vehicular accesses from Queen Anne Drive, which previously served the garden centre. The site has a lengthy planning history, with past permissions for uses including retail, business, scaffolding storage, and various structures now deemed lawful through long-term use. In recent years, unauthorised activities such as car sales, coach repairs and vehicle washing led to complaints and enforcement action. Care South purchased the site in 2023, and it is now vacant. The applicant says the proposed redevelopment offers a chance to meet local need and improve the appearance of the area. Adding: 'The proposal will provide much needed accommodation and will improving the aesthetic approach to Merley.'
