'Thunderbolts' Early Reviews Overwhelmingly One-Sided

Newsweek

29-04-2025

Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources.
Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content.
Entertainment gossip and news from Newsweek's network of contributors
The reviews for "Thunderbolts*" are coming out, and everyone seems to be saying the same thing: for fans tired of the same old thing in Marvel movies, this is the one that breaks the mold of recent failures. It's a great flick with a big heart, and most of the credit goes to the cast, who elevate the material above usual superhero movie fare.
Read More: New 'Thunderbolts' Teaser Shows Best Look at Sentry's Powers
One of the main common threads throughout the reviews is that "Thunderbolts*" is, as Liz Shannon Miller of Consequence calls it, "a breath of fresh air." She also writes that it's "a notable step forward for the MCU as a whole, which is pretty remarkable given that this is a cast of characters where the literal point is that they're loose ends left adrift."
From left to right: David Harbour as Red Guardian, Hannah John-Kamen as Ghost, Sebastian Stan as the Winter Soldier, and Wyatt Russell as USAgent in Thunderbolts*
From left to right: David Harbour as Red Guardian, Hannah John-Kamen as Ghost, Sebastian Stan as the Winter Soldier, and Wyatt Russell as USAgent in Thunderbolts*
DISNEY
Likewise, Linda Marric of HeyUGuys calls the film "a gritty, chaotic and sometimes uneven return to the best of the old MCU. It is thrilling and heartfelt and best of all, it proves Marvel can still surprise us when it stops trying to please everyone and leans into the weirdness."
Some critics weren't in love with "Thunderbolts*" as much as others, but still gave it credit for surpassing other recent Marvel films. Empire Magazine's John Nugent, for example, writes that the film "doesn't always land, but it dares to be different, from the title to the team-up. Fresh and thoughtful in a way recent Marvel efforts haven't always managed."
Similarly, Donald Clarke of the Irish Times says, "It is a shame the project feels flimsier than the average TV-show pilot, but, after the catastrophe that was 'Captain America: Brave New World', one can celebrate something that at least has a middle between its beginning and its end."
If nothing else is agreed upon by most critics, it's that the best reason to see "Thunderbolts*" is Florence Pugh's portrayal of Yelena Belova.
"If it ultimately works," writes Radheyan Simonpillai of the Guardian, "it's all due to Pugh, who can wrestle sincerity out of a screenplay (and a franchise) that has so little, capturing a whole emotional arc in just her moments of silence."
Vulture's Alison Willmore agrees, writing, "Pugh, in particular, gives the movie an emotional tangibility that makes it feel realms more solid than the last few years of Marvel product."
If nothing else, we know what the critics have to say about "Thunderbolts*". The film hits theaters this Friday, May 2.
More Comics:
'Avengers: Doomsday' First Look Marks Production Milestone
Blade Reboot Costume Designer Confirms Wildest Theory About Failed Film