logo
The anti-woke can be as woke as the woke

The anti-woke can be as woke as the woke

Economic Times19-07-2025
NOT YOUR IDEA OF DAVID COPPERFIELD, EH? I consider myself to be slept, not woke. Each time I learn about some school in Britain pulling some book out of their library on account of it being 'regressive' - or, not 'progressive enough' - I chuckle and eyeroll at the same time like a gay John Wayne, thinking of the books they pull out of American school libraries for being 'progressive' - or, 'too progressive,' as my grandma would like to call people who 'live in sin' (unmarried cohabiting couples). But let's just say there are sins far graver than excessive or performative activism - that is, being woke. Sure, finding 'narcissistic behaviour' or 'cultural appropriation' lurking under every lamp post can make a chic virtue out of virtue-signalling. But what was considered woke yesterday (without the word being invented then) - whether it be demanding a 'benign' colonial power to bugger off, or being against 'disciplinary' corporal punishment, or finding 'tough love' domestic violence to be abhorrent - can become SOP good sense today.
But being anti-woke has also emerged as a new form of intelligence-signalling. There are people who can now make a living (read: dinner party conversations and columns) by woke-hunting. This is especially evident whenever traditional depictions in pop culture are stitched to PC culture. Like, say, Disney's depiction of a Black actress as The Little Mermaid in the eponymous 2023 film. 'This is the limit!' scream the anti-wokemeisters. I recently watched Armando Iannucci's The Personal History of David Copperfield, a cinematic adaptation of Charles Dickens' 1850 novel. True, meeting the Victorian hero-narrator and finding him being played by Dev Patel was unexpected, especially for us honed on our Occidentalism via Dickens, Enid Blyton, James Bond, Jeeves, and Britannia biscuit diet. But after the initial 'What the Dickens!' surprise of a Brown Copperfield - and other non-White-as-the-cliffs-of-Dover actors - the film proceeds wonderfully with its modernist wit, charm, and freshness. No shred of DEI-ness creeps in to provide any diversity message on the sly beyond the obviously visual. In fact, very subtly, it brings a new layer of depicting how universal Dickens' Victorian characters are to this day, in any society. When I saw Peter Brook's cinematic version of his and Jean-Claude Carriere's 1985 stage play, Mahabharata, in Kolkata in 1989, the terms 'DEI' and 'woke' would have sounded Jesuit Latin and wrong English, respectively. Almost all the characters were played by (non-Hindu) non-Indians, with only Malika Sarabhai as Draupadi. Senegalese-French actor Mamadou Dioume's performance as Bhima left me with goosebumps all over my nominally Hindu, Bengali brown skin. Brook's superb treatment, part-Shakespeare, part-Kurosawa, was far-removed from the opulent kitschof BR Chopra's immensely more popular 1988-1990 TV series on Doordarshan. It gave out no smoke of woke. Instead, it was 'just' a powerful reinterpretation, the 'visual' deviation from standard ethnic depiction adding to its universal power. A new stage production of Ramayana has been making waves in Karachi this month. Directed by Yogeshwar Karera and produced by Rana Kazmi of Mauj Theatre Group, it's incidental that barring the director and two actors who are (Pakistani) Hindu, all other members of the production team are (Pakistani) Muslim. What holds the Karachi Ramayana's appeal is its interpretation not of a religious epic done with a secular mission, but of a human classic staged for thoughtful entertainment. A particular kind of anti-woke brigade rails out against any form of deviation from the original 'purity' of Western-White-gendered tropes - 'Black James Bond!' 'Woman Hamlet!' 'Chinese woman Dr Watson!' Which is as dogmatic as shouting one's head off about Alauddin Khilji being depicted as a 'depraved Muslim' in a Bollywood movie. And as silly as removing golliwogs from Enid Blyton's Noddy books, or changing language deemed offensive from Roald Dahl's children's books. While the public may never take to a Chinese Superman - after all, immigrants from Planet Krypton have to be White as created by Jerry Siegel (Praise Be Upon Him) - a wok Clark Kent needn't be woke. In the head of a clever writer-director, it could be what Shakespeare in his play, Vishal Bhardwaj in Maqbool, and, more recently, Anirban Bhattacharya in Mandaar, superbly did to Holinshed's Macbeth. Elevate your knowledge and leadership skills at a cost cheaper than your daily tea. Leadership shakeups cloud Ola Electric's revival attempts
Can Indian IT's 'pyramid' survive the GenAI shake-up?
How Safexpress bootstrapped its way to build India's largest PTL Express business
As deposit ground slips under PSU banks' feet, they chase the wealthy
Zee promoters have a new challenge to navigate. And it's not about funding or Sebi probe.
These large- and mid-cap stocks can give more than 27% return in 1 year, according to analysts
Stock Radar: SRF hits record highs in July 2025! Time to book profits or buy the recent dip?
F&O Radar| Deploy Bull Call Spread in Nifty to gain from overall bullish trend in market
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

George Lucas tells Comic-Con crowd his new museum will be 'a temple to the people's art'
George Lucas tells Comic-Con crowd his new museum will be 'a temple to the people's art'

First Post

time9 minutes ago

  • First Post

George Lucas tells Comic-Con crowd his new museum will be 'a temple to the people's art'

The museum designed by Ma Yansong resembles a giant space cruiser, and at 300,000 square feet it's about the size of an average IKEA store read more George Lucas finally came to the stage at Comic-Con Sunday to an ovation from thousands, some holding light sabers in the air, with soaring 'Star Wars' music filling the room. The 81-year-old, appearing for the first time at San Diego's pop cultural extravaganza, looked decidedly earthbound in his jeans and flannel shirt, and a bit embarrassed by the attention. The quiet, thoughtful discussion that followed about the art museum he's building stood in contrast to the sci-fi and superhero bombast that came from Comic-Con's huge Hall H in the previous three days of the convention. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD He's quietly passionate, though, about the Lucas Museum of Narrative Art, co-founded with his wife, businesswoman Mellody Hobson. Long in the works, the project was first announced in 2017 and is set to open its doors in Los Angeles' Exposition Park next year. 'This is sort of a temple to the people's art,' Lucas told the crowd. The museum designed by Ma Yansong resembles a giant space cruiser, and at 300,000 square feet it's about the size of an average IKEA store. 'Star Wars' art and artifacts will be well-represented as shown in an introductory video narrated by Samuel L. Jackson. But Lucas' focus on the comic art and populist paintings are just as central to its aims. He's is one of the main collectors of the paintings of Norman Rockwell and Maxfield Parrish, and Hobson has made a specialty of collecting the work of Black painters including Norman Lewis and Kara Walker. The panel discussion also included director Guillermo del Toro and production designer Doug Chiang, who has worked on Star Wars films since the Lucas-directed 'Star Wars' prequels in the 1990s. Rapper, singer and actor Queen Latifah, a friend of Lucas and Hobson who called herself a 'sci-fi nerd,' served as moderator and chief energizer of the panel. 'Are y'all pumped up for this museum now or what?' she shouted to the crowd at the end. The project began in part just to have a place for everything Lucas has collected since he was in college in the 1960s, when he learned original drawings from comic books and comic strips were surprisingly affordable. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD 'I could get an 'Alley-Oop' for $30,' Lucas said. 'I've been collecting narrative art ever since.' He owns the first drawing of Flash Gordon, original panels of 'Peanuts' comic strips complete with notes from artist Charles Schulz, and early drawings of Iron Man and Black Panther, along with original artwork for political cartoons and alternative comics. He would later move on to paintings and art from films, after the 'Star Wars' money began pouring in. 'What am I going to do with it all?' Lucas said. 'I refuse to sell it. I could never do that.' Del Toro, himself a famous hoarder of pop culture artifacts and a museum board member, said the Los Angeles wildfires earlier this year came 'frighteningly close' to the collection he keeps at home. 'Now that the museum exists, a lot of it may go there,' Del Toro said. He emphasized throughout the panel the political importance of comics since their beginnings. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD 'Comics were the first one to punch Nazis,' Del Toro said. 'Before movies.' While unusual for the big room, the discussion was very close to the kind of talks that have constantly happened in the less flashy corners of Comic-Con for more than 50 years. Lucas is easily on the Mount Rushmore of figures whose work has had the greatest inspiration on the kind of films and other pop cultural celebrated annually in Hall H. But the convention wasn't a common showcase for blockbuster films when he was directing them himself. And he sold 'Star Wars' and Lucasfilm to The Walt Disney Co. in 2012. The Lucas museum's 11-acre campus sits right next to the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum and near several other major museums and the University of Southern California. An exact date for its opening has not been announced.

'He married you for green card': American woman living in India shares a 'sample' of racist comments she faced from trolls
'He married you for green card': American woman living in India shares a 'sample' of racist comments she faced from trolls

Time of India

timean hour ago

  • Time of India

'He married you for green card': American woman living in India shares a 'sample' of racist comments she faced from trolls

An American woman named Jessica, who has made India her home for nearly two decades, recently went viral on Instagram after she posted a video shedding light on the discrimination faced by foreigners, particularly white women, married to Indian men. Through her post, she revealed the kind of cruel, baseless remarks often thrown at women like her, prompting widespread reactions from users across the the video, Jessica walks through a bustling Indian bazaar, calmly going about her day. But the peace in her video contrasts with the hostile comments she says she often receives. Some of these include accusations that her husband married her only to gain access to a green card, that she ruined her life by settling in India, or that her children are unfortunate not to have inherited her white skin tone. She even recounted being pitied for marrying someone with a darker complexion. Jessica pointed out that this is just a glimpse of the colorism, racism, and obsession with Western identity she endures reel quickly gained traction, racking up over 210,000 views. It opened a floodgate of comments, many from individuals who related to the hateful stereotypes or who were disturbed by how deeply rooted such prejudices users chimed in with their own stories. One person highlighted how the green card accusation seems to be the most frequent insult aimed at interracial couples. Another expressed disbelief at how people make such outrageous assumptions, sharing how they too had faced similar criticism. Someone else noted that aside from the expected offensive remarks, there's often an unhealthy fascination with the appearance of children in mixed-race families, particularly when they have fairer reactions didn't stop with India. Others shared that this form of judgment and stereotyping is rampant in several countries outside the Western world—including parts of Africa, Asia, and Latin America—suggesting the issue is global rather than the negativity, some followers encouraged Jessica to continue turning these unpleasant experiences into teachable moments, offering strength and perspective to others in similar from social media, Jessica contributes positively by teaching Hindi through her podcast, Learn Hindi With Me, and her online Hindi learning app, Learn Hindi Anywhere, which have helped countless learners appreciate Indian culture and language more is married to a local man and has a son and a daughter.

Oops! Jennifer Lopez faces outfit mishap mid-performance: ‘Glad I had underwear on'; netizens ask 'Is that on purpose'
Oops! Jennifer Lopez faces outfit mishap mid-performance: ‘Glad I had underwear on'; netizens ask 'Is that on purpose'

Mint

time2 hours ago

  • Mint

Oops! Jennifer Lopez faces outfit mishap mid-performance: ‘Glad I had underwear on'; netizens ask 'Is that on purpose'

Jennifer Lopez took a lighthearted approach to a wardrobe mishap during her performance in Warsaw, Poland, on Friday. After her silver fringe skirt slipped down, she said she was glad to have underwear on. The 'On the Floor' singer laughed off the incident and carried on with the show like a pro. Netizens ask whether it was done on purpose. The pop star let out a surprised gasp as she tried to catch her skirt before it fell to the floor. She quickly regained her composure, confidently continuing her performance in just green high-waisted briefs, a sparkling green bra, long matching gloves, and sheer tights. She quipped to the audience, stating, 'I'm here in my underwear". As the band began singing 'Happy Birthday' to celebrate Jennifer Lopez turning 56 on Thursday, one of her backup dancers stepped in to help reattach her skirt. When the skirt refused to stay on, Lopez decided to take it off completely and playfully tossed it into the crowd. Laughing about the moment, she told the audience, "I'm glad that they reinforced that costume. And I'm glad I had underwear on. I don't usually wear underwear.' One of the users said, 'I used to like her so much 25 years ago.' Another remarked, 'Seems like it was on purpose'. 'Even after a successful career in entertainment, she craves attention so badly that she is empty inside when she doesn't have it', 'She is better looking than Madonna but still it's getting creepy', 'Is that on purpose' were some other comments made. Others reacted saying, 'Damn she presents much younger and firmer than 56", "I don't like her politics. But she looks GOOD', 'Looks rehearsed and intentional', 'That was all planned. Please', 'Not a malfunction. Seriously cringe, though'. Jennifer Lopez, often referred to as is a multi-talented American singer, actress, dancer, and businesswoman. She first became popular as a dancer on the TV show 'In Living Color' before transitioning into acting, where she earned acclaim for her breakout role in the biopic Selena. Lopez later became a global music star with chart-topping hits like 'If You Had My Love,' 'Jenny from the Block". Beyond entertainment, she has built a fashion and beauty empire with her brand JLo Beauty and also leads a production company, Nuyorican Productions. In her personal life, she has been in the spotlight for high-profile relationships. She got divorced to Ben Affleck after two years of marriage.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store