HSE apologises to teenager (17) for injection of wrong Covid vaccine with already-used needle
Barrister James Cross told Judge Fiona O'Sullivan in the Circuit Civil Court that Ella Mockler Mulhern (17) suffered significantly as a result of the HSE's negligence and breach of duty.
Mr Cross, who appeared with James McSweeney Solicitors, for Ella, said HSE staff administered the wrong vaccine when his client attended a vaccination centre at Citywest Hotel, Saggart, Dublin, in August 2021.
Ella's father, Niall Mulhern, of Beech Park, Lucan, Co Dublin, told the court in written evidence that a second vaccine was administered without discussion or the consent of him or Ella.
READ MORE
He said the nurse involved denied that the first syringe had been used previously. However, he said that after making further inquiry with the clinical lead nurse, an investigation was carried out and it was confirmed the syringe had been used on another person. Nursing staff were unable to identify on which one of three other people it had been used already.
Mr Cross said Ella had to undergo blood tests and be vaccinated against hepatitis B. He said at least one of the possible three people who could have been injected with the syringe had refused to undergo blood tests and Ella had to undergo a post-exposure antiretroviral therapy course for a month as a result.
Judge O'Sullivan heard this caused Ella to feel acutely unwell with symptoms of nausea. She was upset and distressed by what had happened and was unable to attend school for almost a month.
Ella had to undergo tests for hepatitis C and HIV, suffered mental trauma and developed a fear of doctors.
Just under a year later, Ella developed an abscess that ruptured during her school sports day causing her considerable further distress. This had to be treated with antibiotics and it was not known if it was related to the treatment she received in Citywest.
Mr Cross said an initial settlement offer of €11,500 from the HSE was rejected by another judge. This was followed by an offer of €16,500 and then an offer of €20,000, expenses and legal costs which Mr Cross said he was recommending to the court.
Judge O'Sullivan, approving the HSE's final offer, said the episode would have had a serious impact on Ella and she felt €20,000 compensation was acceptable in the circumstances.
Barrister Seamus Breen, for the HSE, read out an apology on behalf of his client during which he said the defendant accepted responsibility for what happened and pointed out that Ella was blameless for what had occurred. He said the HSE wished Ella every success in her life.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
5 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Parents frustrated as child cannot access assessment of need service
The parents of a six-year-old boy have expressed frustration and concern after they received a letter from the HSE stating that the Assessment of Need (AON) service in their area was closed in March due to no psychologists being in post. The Health Service Executive has since confirmed to RTÉ News that AON services in the HSE Dublin and Midlands region "remain active" and is "accepting applications". The mother, who wishes to remain anonymous for the sake of her son, said she was "perplexed" by the letter, seen by RTÉ News, which states that the Parent Social Communication Group was identified as "the most appropriate intervention" and that she had been added to that waitlist. The parent-directed group - which children do not attend - focuses on developing children's social communication and emotion regulation skills. "The idea of been turned away for assessment of need is shocking because we cannot provide what he needs in school, and the school cannot provide it without diagnosis. Also, the Occupational Therapist (OT) requires a diagnosis report, so they know what he needs support with," she said. Demand for AONs has increased significantly in recent years. The Minister for Children has said this is a reflection of both the increase in population and of families "exploring all options" for accessing services for their child. By the end of June, there were 16,593 applications overdue for completion. 13,998 (84%) of those were overdue for longer than three months. The family is based in Dublin 22 (HSE Dublin & Midlands region), which has the longest AON wait time, with 6,243 applications outstanding. A HSE spokesperson said meeting the increasing demand for Assessment of Need (in the Dublin and Midlands Region and nationally) within the required timeframes continues to prove challenging, as the demand outstrips capacity. "Recruitment to fill vacant Assessment Officer posts is currently taking place. The HSE is working with all HSE and HSE funded services in the area and a number of private providers to increase capacity of assessments and decrease wait times," he added. The letter also stated that based on the referral information, the child may also benefit from a referral to the Primary Care Occupational Sensory Service in relation to his sensory needs. Regarding the Primary Care Psychology Service in the Dublin South City and West Integrated Health Area, the HSE confirmed that the service "is limited at present" due to a number of staff vacancies. The spokesperson said resources were being focused on service users waiting over 18 months and as per clinical prioritisation, following receipt of additional wait list initiative funding by Primary Care psychology service. He added that the region is "actively recruiting" to fill vacant psychologist and assistant psychologist posts - both permanent staff and agency staff.
Irish Times
7 hours ago
- Irish Times
Novo Nordisk freezes hiring in push to rein in costs
Novo Nordisk is to freeze hiring in an effort to control costs at the drug maker. The halt will apply across all markets and departments, with the exception of business-critical roles, a company spokeswoman said on Wednesday. Novo's new chief executive officer, Maziar Mike Doustdar, has signaled that job cuts may be part of a promised revamp, telling reporters last month that Novo needs to exercise greater discipline and prudence on spending. He said he plans to review the company's cost base. The maker of Wegovy and Ozempic, which employs close to 500 people in Ireland, is fighting to claw back ground after losing its lead in the US obesity market to rival Eli Lilly & Co. Lilly's weight-loss franchise is poised to overtake Novo's this year and may hold more than half of a $100 billion global obesity market by 2030, Bloomberg Intelligence analyst Michael Shah said. Novo ousted its longtime CEO in the second quarter as the foundation that controls the company pushed for an overhaul, and Doustdar took over earlier this month. Novo's workforce mushroomed to more than 78,000 people in recent years as the drugmaker rushed to boost production of its blockbusters Ozempic and Wegovy. On Wednesday, the company's website had just over 400 jobs posted globally, most of them in China and the U.S. Only eight positions were open in its home market of Denmark. --Bloomberg
The Journal
20 hours ago
- The Journal
HSE has helped just 104 younger people move out of nursing homes for the elderly
THE HSE'S PROGRAMME to help younger people transition out of nursing homes has helped just 104 people move into alternative settings, with hundreds more left languishing in care homes designed for older people. Efforts to reduce the cohort of people aged under 65 living in nursing homes are facing obstacles as the HSE has said that after an initial decrease, the numbers have now 'plateaued'. There are still 1,227 people aged under 65 living in nursing homes for older people according to HSE figures given in July of this year. The programme to help younger people move out of nursing homes was set up in response to the 2021 Wasted Lives report by the Ombudsman, which found serious problems in how they were being treated. A team that tracked the issue within the HSE in 2023 found the main reason for people under 65 entering nursing homes that year was due to referrals from acute healthcare settings, typically a hospital. This led to 136 people being placed in nursing homes that year. The next biggest reason was the lack of an alternative appropriate placement (135 cases). Family circumstances, referral from community services, and a lack of a primary carer were other factors that the team found. For 32 cases that year, the reason for the younger being entered into the care of a nursing home was only recorded as 'unknown'. Acquired brain injury is the primary diagnosis for more than one quarter (26%) of all younger people living in a nursing home, according to data provided by an operational tracker which looks at younger people in nursing homes. This is followed by acquired neurological conditions, such as multiple sclerosis, which account for 24% of people in this group. Other people have conditions including cerebral palsy and spina bifida, or in some cases an intellectual disability. Social Democrats TD Liam Quaide, who requested these figures from the HSE, said that the process of transferring younger people out of inappropriate nursing home settings is 'frustratingly slow'. 'This is a desperately sad and indefensible situation. It is another example of how much distance is opening up between our economic prosperity, on the one hand, and the vindication of disabled people's basic rights, on the other. 'Perpetuating younger people's reliance on nursing homes is an affront to their dignity and right to independence,' Quaide said. The Social Democrats TD said that nursing homes are also being used for temporary care for people awaiting a placement in the National Rehabilitation Hospital. Advertisement He pointed out that four years have now passed since the publication of the Wasted Lives report. That initial report was sparked by the Ombudsman receiving a number of complaints from people under 65 who were living in nursing homes at that time. The office carried out 28 visits to people affected by the issue. It found that Ireland has a long way to go in terms of moving from a medical to a social model of disability. As of 30 June 2020 there were some 1,320 people under 65 being supported by the Nursing Homes Support Scheme (the Fair Deal scheme) according to HSE figures. Slow pace of transition In response to the report the HSE set up its U65 Programme Office and an Implementation Project Team. There is an 'U65′ lead in each Community Healthcare Organisation who is responsible for people transitioning to other care settings. Since this work began there have been a total of 104 transitions. The majority of these people have moved to community residential placements including sheltered living, specialised and residential placements, to their own home or family home, or to a new home. It is expected that 17 other people will transfer out of nursing homes before the end of 2025. The HSE said that people who need to stay in nursing homes can avail of enhanced quality of life supports funded by the U65 programme which include access to personal devices, transport, social care, and vocational and therapeutic services, as well as personal assistant hours. However the number of people availing of these supports are very low. In 2024 just 154 of the people who are under 65 living in nursing homes availed of the supports package. The HSE said that there was a decrease in this age group residing in nursing homes between 2021 and 2023, when there was a decrease of around 100 people, but since then the average number of under-65s in nursing homes per month has 'plateaued' to an average of 1,250 people. The HSE's programme provides funding to help people in this cohort transfer to other settings, and the average cost of these transfers is €207,926. The HSE has said that the primary reason why younger people are staying in nursing homes is due to their personal will and preference. 'Disability services recognise that the issue of will and preference is changeable and that there needs to be planned engagements with individuals to better understand their reasons why they may wish to stay,' a spokesperson said. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
