
Sugar, power and patronage
Listen to article
Pakistan's recurring sugar crises have become a telling reflection of how entrenched elite interests continue to manipulate the economy under the guise of policy. The latest surge in sugar prices, now hitting between Rs180 and Rs210 per kilogramme despite official claims of intervention, shows just how far removed state actions are from public welfare. What is unfolding isn't simply mismanagement. It's a system that protects the powerful and punishes the public.
In July 2024, the federal government announced with much fanfare that it had reached an agreement with sugar mills to sell sugar to wholesalers at Rs165 per kg. This was framed as a breakthrough deal. But within days, the mills began violating the agreed price, resuming supply at Rs175, not Rs165. Even at inflated rates, sugar remains scarce in wholesale markets. The public, meanwhile, continues to pay well over Rs200 per kg in major cities like Karachi and Lahore. This was not just a policy failure. It was the illusion of reform – an orchestrated move to deflect public outrage without touching the roots of the problem. And at the root lies one uncomfortable fact: the sugar sector is not regulated by the government. It is effectively governed by itself.
The concentration of political and economic power is stark. The Sharif family, which sits at the core of the current ruling coalition, owns major sugar mills. That the same actors who draft economic policies also control production and pricing of sugar reveals a conflict of interests so blatant that it no longer shocks. This overlap turns policy into patronage, and governance into a tool for private gain.
Earlier this year, the government allowed sugar exports even as domestic stocks were under pressure. Predictably, local prices soared. Then came the tax-free import of 500,000 metric tons of sugar; a move that drew criticism from the International Monetary Fund, which questioned both its timing and its lack of transparency.
No one has explained who received import licences, under what conditions, or how the decision was justified while government revenues continue to bleed. What the country witnessed was a two-way windfall: profits made on the export side and further gains through duty-free imports. Also there is an issue of price collapse when the shipments arrive in November; around the time sugar mills will be buying from growers, giving them leverage to manipulate buying prices.
Throughout all this, regulators have remained silent. The Competition Commission has issued no inquiry into possible cartelisation. The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has not released any audits on sugar mill compliance or tax contribution. No action has been taken against mills for openly breaching their agreement with the government. When institutions with legal mandates refuse to act, the market ceases to be a marketplace. It becomes a racket.
This isn't new. But it's become more brazen. The previous PTI-led government also faced sugar price hike in 2020. However, its response was markedly different. Then prime minister Imran Khan ordered a wide-ranging inquiry, involving the FIA, SECP, FBR, and other agencies. The investigation looked into hoarding, tax fraud, price manipulation, and the misuse of subsidies.
Importantly, it didn't shy away from naming allies or investigating politically connected individuals within PTI itself like Jahangir Tareen. The inquiry report was published in full. While it triggered backlash, it also marked a rare moment where the state asserted its regulatory role over an entrenched industrial elite. The investigation was abandoned and charges dropped when the PTI government was removed.
What we are seeing now is the opposite. Instead of confronting the sugar mafia, the current government has aligned itself with it. Instead of enforcing transparency, it has shielded its members from scrutiny. At every step, decisions have served the interests of the few at the expense of many.
This has real human costs. Sugar is not just a luxury good. It is a daily essential for households and a critical input for small businesses. Rising sugar prices drive up food inflation, burden already stretched family budgets, and hurt bakeries, tea stalls, and street vendors across the country. When a government facilitates price spiral through weak enforcement and preferential trade decisions, it doesn't just fail the economy. It abandons its moral claim to serve the people.
To fix this, Pakistan must first acknowledge that the sugar crisis is not a temporary market blip. It is a symptom of a deeper structural disease: the collusion between political elites and monopolistic interests. The solution begins with cutting these links.
Public officeholders, and their immediate families, must be barred from owning or profiting from industries they are in a position to regulate. This principle is basic in any functioning democracy. Without it, policy becomes an instrument of personal enrichment, not public service.
Next, regulatory institutions must be depoliticised and empowered. Agencies like the CCP, FBR, and SECP should have independent boards, professional leadership, and the authority to publish findings without seeking ministerial approval. If sugar mills are in violation of tax laws or pricing agreements, the public has a right to know.
Trade policy must also be demystified. Export and import decisions, especially for essentials like sugar, should not be made behind closed doors. They must be based on evidence, presented in parliament, and subjected to public scrutiny. Import licences should be granted through open bidding, and their recipients disclosed proactively.
In the digital age, there's no excuse for opacity. A transparent digital dashboard that tracks sugar from mills to wholesalers to retailers would make it harder for hoarders and profiteers to operate undetected. It would also empower consumers and watchdog groups with real-time data.
Finally, subsidies and tax exemptions must be subjected to rigorous review. No tax waiver or import concession should be granted without a clear, documented public interest rationale. Otherwise, they will continue to be used as vehicles for elite enrichment.
The sugar industry has become a symbol of how deeply elite capture runs in Pakistan. But it can also become a turning point. If the state can confront the sugar mafia – not with hollow deals but with real accountability – it can begin to rebuild public trust and economic fairness. If it cannot, the crisis will return. Prices may dip briefly, but the profiteering will continue. This is not just about sugar. It is about who the system is designed to serve and who it leaves behind.
The writer is a graduate of the University of British Columbia
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Business Recorder
12 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Bridging governance gap for economic growth
Governance plays a central role in shaping a country's developmental outcomes. It determines how public resources are managed, how decisions are made and how institutions deliver services to the citizens. It is not revealing that Pakistan's economic problems are underpinned by governance issues. Attempts, supported by the International Monetary Fund (IMF), have been aplenty to address the core of the economic and fiscal crises that are deemed to be rooted in chronic budgetary and trade deficits. The fiscal crises in turn largely draw from persistent governance deficits. The recent evidence is clear — both in Sri Lanka and Bangladesh, it was the lack of transparent, accountable, and rules-based public institutions which undermined the state's ability to deliver, enforce the rule of law, and manage public resources effectively. In other words, governance issues – lax rules and corruption – compromise the effective implementation of policies; howsoever, cogent they may be. In case of Pakistan, the country needs structural reforms which can restore macroeconomic stability, address fiscal and external imbalances, and ensure long-term economic sustainability. What is crucially important is that the ongoing reforms must place parallel emphasis on governance, transparency, and anti-corruption. In 2024, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) approved a $7-billion Extended Fund Facility (EFF) for Pakistan, but this time it has signaled a broader approach, one that emphasizes that without tackling governance deficits, structural reforms cannot deliver lasting results. As part of the programme, the IMF is preparing a Governance and Corruption Diagnostic Assessment on Pakistan. Governance Diagnostic Assessments (GDAs) are in-depth reviews carried out by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) to assess corruption risks in a country. In 2023, Sri Lanka underwent a formal GDA following the country's 2022 economic collapse. The assessment, conducted with technical assistance of the IMF, uncovered serious governance failures – particularly the absence of key anti-corruption legislation such as a public procurement law in the country. Pakistan has showcased the importance of governance reform for meaningful recovery. There are numerous success stories and cases in Pakistan where putting together a sound legal and administrative system has rendered a service largely efficient, harassment-free and corruption-free. However, there are key governance gaps that, if remain unaddressed, can continue to undermine progress towards reform and keep Pakistan in a cycle of economic crisis. First and foremost, addressing revenue shortfalls and fiscal imbalances requires fundamental reforms in revenue administration and expenditure management. Pakistan's narrow tax base, distorted by weak enforcement, and large informal sectors, continues to undermine the state's fiscal capacity. Bridging gaps in tax collection, particularly in agriculture, real estate, and imports, is critical to improving equity and compliance. At the same time, more effective deficit management through expenditure controls is necessary to reduce the recurring cycle of fiscal crises. Reinforcing fiscal governance also depends on building our public sector capacity through digitization. Pakistan has made significant strides in this direction and initiatives such as NADRA's digital identity system, the Pakistan Single Window, and the Punjab and KP e-governance platforms demonstrate the feasibility of large-scale digital reforms. However, systemic integration across ministries and levels of government remains limited. A more coordinated, whole-of-government approach is essential to scale up digitization, expand use of digital systems in public offices including in public procurement. This can reduce discretionary power and corruption while improving efficiency and accountability. Secondly, accountability across all tiers of governance is fundamental to achieving good governance. To strengthen the integrity and effectiveness of financial oversight, there is a need for statutory provision, mandating that the Chairperson of the Public Accounts Committee, at both the national and provincial levels, be the Leader of the Opposition. This legal mandate would institutionalise the principle of impartiality in financial scrutiny, ensuring that the oversight function is not compromised by political interests. Such reforms will align Pakistan with international best practices in public financial management. Finally, our anti-corruption framework faces significant challenges, and there is a need to pivot from punitive approaches toward preventive systems that emphasize institutional integrity, civic awareness, and independent scrutiny. Transparency laws such as the Right to Information must go beyond legislation to become functional instruments of public empowerment, supported by digital tools, proactive disclosure, and impartial implementation bodies. Recently, Transparency International Pakistan published a Civil Society Governance Diagnostic Assessment. The report identifies a total of 54 practical recommendations for governance reform, to be integrated into the IMF's lending conditions. Such recommendations include complete digitization of procurement procedures for uniformity and tracking, wider parliamentary oversight and robust transparency laws for greater accountability. These principles remain essential to restoring trust in public institutions, encouraging investor confidence, strengthening ease of doing business and citizens' confidence in the effective service delivery rendered by the state. However, turning recommendations into real reform will depend on sustained political will. If backed by strong political will, the IMF's governance diagnostic assessment will be an opportunity for Pakistan to ensure that reforms are not only adopted but implemented in ways that truly transform lives of the citizens of Pakistan. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025


Business Recorder
15 hours ago
- Business Recorder
PM to open ‘PortVerse' next month
ISLAMABAD: Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif will launch 'PortVerse' maritime one-window system during the first week of August in Karachi. Port Community System (PCS) is a digital platform that facilitates information exchange and collaboration among stakeholders in a port community. Addressing a press conference on Wednesday, CEO PSW Aftab Haider on Wednesday said that the 'PortVerse' acts as a central hub, enabling efficient and secure data sharing between various entities like customs, port authorities, shipping lines, and freight forwarders. By streamlining communication and automating processes, PCS aims to improve efficiency, transparency, and security in port operations and global trade. PSW CEO explains trade facilitation, regional connectivity agenda The CEO said that we are optimistic that this PCS will help in reducing clearance of containers time at ports from 52 hours to just 12 hours. He said that the government will perform a system audit of the WeBOC (Web-Based Computerised Clearance System) application and the Pakistan Single Window (PSW) to evaluate glitches and issues that have occurred over the past two to three years. Haider also confirmed that some technical glitches in system occurred before the start of this year; however, he ruled out any revenue losses from these technical glitches. The system had lacked proper validation since 2015, allowing some users to manipulate WeBOC system, the CEO added. He also clarified that there were no technical glitches involved in the recently surfaced high-end smuggled vehicle scam; rather, someone had misused a user's login credentials. The CEO PSW also informed that the Federal Board of Revenue is working on integrating scanners, which will help consolidate data in a centralized system. Haider also said that PSW has been established to facilitate the cross border trade, by streamlining and reducing the movement time through digitalisation and eliminating human interaction to the maximum limit. Currently, around 23 government departments and 29 banks were in the PSW system and all were interlinked at the single platform, facilitating stakeholders including the traders and the truckers who have to wait for hours to load containers at the ports. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025


Business Recorder
15 hours ago
- Business Recorder
FBR tells PM: Tax-to-GDP ratio jumps 1.5pc to 10.6pc
ISLAMABAD: The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) on Wednesday said the country's tax-to-GDP ratio rose by 1.5 percentage points in FY2025, reaching 10.6 percent compared to FY2024 – a notable advance towards the government's goal of 13 percent under its three-year reform agreement with the International Monetary Fund (IMF). In a briefing to Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif, who chaired a high-level meeting to review the FBR's reform agenda, officials said that the number of tax filers had increased from 4.5 million in 2024 to more than 7.2 million by the end of June 2025. Sharif welcomed the gains, calling the rise in tax compliance encouraging, but cautioned that continued progress would depend on deep and sustained reforms at the FBR, the country's primary tax authority. FBR seeks 18pc tax-to-GDP ratio by 2027-28 He praised the improvements in revenue collection – particularly what he described as a 'historic' increase in the tax-to-GDP ratio – but stressed that further modernisation was needed to align the tax system with international norms. 'Meeting targets is commendable, but our real challenge is building a sustainable and contemporary tax system,' Sharif said, according to a statement issued by the Prime Minister's Office. 'Reforms must be implemented within a fixed timeline, with the input of all relevant stakeholders.' Officials said that recent efforts to formalise the retail sector – including integration through the FBR's Point of Sale (POS) system and enhanced enforcement – had yielded an additional Rs45.5 billion in tax revenue compared with the previous financial year. They also highlighted early successes of the FBR's new 'faceless' customs clearance platform, a digitisation initiative designed to curb corruption and improve efficiency. The system has already bolstered revenue, officials said, and is expected to cut average clearance times from 52 hours to just 12 hours within three months. To further streamline operations, the agency has launched remote case hearings via video link – a move aimed at expediting decisions and minimising in-person interactions. Additional measures, officials added, have reduced the weighted average tariff on imports by 2.16 percent – a change expected to lower input costs for manufacturers and support industrial growth. Tax collection in the retail sector rose by Rs455 billion on the previous year, driven by the integration of point-of-sale systems and tighter enforcement. Officials also told the meeting that recent reforms had reduced the weighted average tariff on imports by 2.16 per cent, lowering raw material costs and supporting domestic industry. Sharif directed the FBR officials to deliver a comprehensive implementation plan for the next phase of reforms within a week. That plan, he added, should include restructuring the agency's digital wing and actionable timelines for execution. He also emphasised the importance of expanding the tax base – especially into the informal sector – while easing the burden on compliant taxpayers. 'The convenience of businesspeople, traders, and taxpayers must be ensured as we move forward,' he said, underscoring that the reform process should remain people-centric. Officials also noted that better use of economic data would help track production across industrial sectors and improve coordination with relevant government agencies. Recommendations from international consultants – particularly in digital taxation and compliance – will be incorporated as part of the FBR's ongoing modernisation drive. The prime minister concluded the meeting by commending FBR personnel for their efforts but warned that real reform would require discipline, transparency, and sustained commitment. The meeting was attended by senior government officials, including Information Minister Ataullah Tarar, Economic Affairs Minister Ahad Cheema, Law Minister Azam Nazir Tarar, the FBR chairman Rashid Langrial, and other senior officials. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025