
Criminal Justice season 4: Who killed Roshni? Anju, Raj, Ira or someone else? Netizens claim killer may not be who you suspect
Criminal Justice: A Family Matter
dropping on July 3, 2025, fans aren't just waiting—they're investigating. The
courtroom drama
has turned everyday viewers into full-time Reddit detectives, each armed with screenshots, trailer stills, and timelines. As
Pankaj Tripathi
's Madhav Mishra inches closer to uncovering the truth behind nurse Roshni Saluja's murder, the internet is already racing to deliver its verdict.
Season 4 has kept audiences gripped with its layered storytelling. Dr. Raj Nagpal stands accused of murdering his girlfriend, nurse Roshni, while his estranged wife Anju and daughter Ira are slowly pulled into the shadows of suspicion. Every episode has introduced a new piece of evidence—from surveillance gaps to a suspicious lactose-free milk bottle—blurring the lines between guilt and innocence.
Episode 7 ended with fresh twists, forcing fans to reconsider everything they thought they knew. And now, Reddit is brimming with bold, elaborate theories. (Beware, spoiler alert ahead!)
The most convincing theory? The 'other doctor' did it
One Reddit user suggests the killer is not Dr. Nagpal, but a fellow physician. According to their theory, this doctor suspected Roshni of poisoning Nagpal's daughter and, out of concern (and a possible college connection with Anju), tried to intervene. A confrontation allegedly turned fatal, with Anju helping cover it up. The motive? Protection. The fallout? A frightened daughter withholding the truth. The twist? She might just testify in the finale.
Is the murder weapon a red herring—or the key?
The scalpel, found late in the season, sparked intense speculation. Why did Anju hire Madhav Mishra? Was it guilt, or was it to protect someone else, like herself? As more viewers dig deeper, some argue the real killer might be Kamala, based on a woman's hand shown in the trailer's slitting scene. Others lean towards lesser-known characters like Roshni's ex-boyfriend, citing suspiciously little screen time.
Slow burn or genius build-up? Fans are split
While some viewers have dismissed the season as slow or underwhelming, others argue that the real issue is its weekly release format. 'It's not boring—it's suspenseful,' one fan defended. 'There are over 30 different plausible theories circulating. That means the show is doing its job: no one knows what's coming.' Still, many agree on one thing—if the final twist involves Anju, Raj, or Ira as the killer, it better be backed by airtight logic. Anything less could risk making the tension-filled build-up feel unearned.
The final hearing
With just one episode to go, Criminal Justice: A Family Matter has managed to do what few shows can—get everyone guessing, debating, and playing armchair detective. As July 3 approaches, one question looms large: Will the writers outsmart the internet?

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


News18
6 hours ago
- News18
Is Taylor Swift Engaged? Fans Spot Her Flaunting Ring On Travis Kelce's Phone Wallpaper
Last Updated: Taylor Swift fans think she's engaged after spotting a ring on Kelce's phone wallpaper in his new Instagram dump. Is Taylor Swift engaged? That's the burning question Swifties are asking after eagle-eyed fans spotted something very interesting in Travis Kelce's latest Instagram post. The NFL star shared a photo dump on July 24, and while the loved-up pics of him and Taylor were sweet, one image in particular has everyone talking. In one photo taken at a restaurant, both Swift and Kelce's phones are visible on the table and their lock screens feature never-before-seen pictures of them together. But what truly set off engagement rumours was the wallpaper on Kelce's phone, which appears to show Taylor flashing a ring on her left hand. Swifties were quick to connect the dots, wondering if the couple had secretly gotten engaged. 'That looks like an engagement ring," one user wrote on Reddit. 'Did we just soft-launch an engagement?" another chimed in. While fans were buzzing, others noted the image on Kelce's phone seems to be from Swift's July 6 Eras Tour stop in Amsterdam, which Kelce attended. In the snap, Swift is seen in a bodysuit, while Kelce is in a white top—matching paparazzi photos from the concert night. Whether the ring is a prop, a trick of the light, or a real diamond sparkler remains unclear. View this post on Instagram A post shared by Travis Kelce (@killatrav) The photo dump was the first time Kelce posted Taylor on his grid since the two began dating in September 2023. From snowy cuddles and boat rides to matching hats that read 'Captain" and 'First Mate," the photos gave a rare peek into their off-season adventures—Lake Como, Montana, and even an ice rink moment made the cut. Kelce captioned the post: 'Had some adventures this offseason, kept it 💯." Fans also spotted Swift's friend Este Haim and Kelce's close pal Ross Travis tagged in the photos. One cave snap, a snow-filled group cuddle, and Swift lifting her arms gleefully in the snow added to the montage's cozy, couple-goals vibe. While there's no official confirmation of an engagement yet, the buzz is louder than ever. Until Taylor or Travis confirm anything, fans will keep sleuthing and speculating. First Published: July 25, 2025, 23:18 IST Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.


News18
6 hours ago
- News18
Saiyaara Actor Aneet Padda Imitates Alia Bhatt In Viral Clip, Reddit Says 'That Was On Point'
Last Updated: Saiyaara star Aneet Padda's Alia Bhatt impression goes viral on Reddit. Fans call it 'spot on' and praise her charm and talent. Saiyaara breakout star Aneet Padda has been winning hearts all over the internet, not just for her stellar Bollywood debut, but now also for her hilarious and accurate impersonation of Alia Bhatt. A throwback video of the actress mimicking Alia's expressions has gone viral on Reddit, with fans applauding her wit and timing. In the clip, Aneet is seen interacting with a host who jokes, 'She can do a great Alia's face." Aneet then delivers the line, 'I'm sorry, there's no Rishtas for this one," and adds, 'And you know how it would be really disrespectful to make an Alia Bhatt face in front of Pooja Bhatt? So I did just that." The moment drew laughter, and Reddit users couldn't get enough of it. 'She's spot on and such a phenomenally fun and humble person. Love her, love her, love her! And her talent also," read one comment. Another user praised her natural beauty and hoped the industry wouldn't push her into unnecessary cosmetic changes, saying, 'Plz plz plz Bollywood never force her for any unnecessary (downright damaging) plastic surgery." One even pointed out how her 'eyebrow frown was so on point," referring to Alia's signature expression. Saiyaara, directed by Mohit Suri and produced by Yash Raj Films, marks the debut of both Aneet Padda and Ahaan Panday. The film, a romantic drama, revolves around the story of Krish Kapoor, an aspiring musician played by Ahaan, and Vaani Batra, a shy writer portrayed by Aneet. The plot takes a shocking turn that tests their love and decisions. The film's soulful soundtrack and heartfelt storytelling have resonated deeply with the audience. Within just a week of its release, Saiyaara has grossed over Rs 180 crore at the domestic box office, steadily heading toward the Rs 200 crore milestone. The chemistry between the debutants, especially Aneet's screen presence, has been widely praised. First Published: July 25, 2025, 22:46 IST Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.


Pink Villa
7 hours ago
- Pink Villa
'My parents are divorced': Son of Sardaar 2 actor Roshni Walia opens up on her parents separation for first time
Roshni Walia, the actress, has been a part of the telly industry since a very young age. Over the years, the actress gained a huge fan base because of her talent and active social media presence. While her professional life has been like an open book, both many know much about her personal life. Roshni recently opened up about her parents' separation for the first time. Roshni even disclosed that she doesn't have relatives. Roshni Wali opens up on her parents' divorce In conversation with Hauterrfly, Roshni Walia was asked about her father, to which the actress disclosed, "My parents are divorced." She continued, "They don't live together. They are not into each other's lives. Unki apni family hai (He has his own family). I am very happy and respectful. They enjoy." Praising her mother, Roshni shared that her mother has been there for her through tough times, and she is her family. The actress shared, "But mera toh yahi kehna hai ki mere bure waqt mai sabse zyada meri maa ne sath diya hai aur unka sath humne diya hai. Yahi humari family hai. (But I want to just say that during my tough days my mother supported me the most and we stood by her. This is our family)." The Maharana Pratap actress expressed, "I feel kabhi kabhi it's not the blood relation that matters. Kabhi kabhi aapke rishte organically bhi ban sakte hai. Aur voh bohot ache rishte ho sakte hai. Zaruri nahi hai voh aapke khoon ka hi koi ho (I feel sometimes it's not the blood relations that matter. Sometimes your relationships grow organically and that can be good relationships. It is not important that it should be a blood relationship)." Roshni continued, "Sometimes people just come like angels, and then they are in your life." She shared how her mother's friends and her friends are like family to her. She even disclosed, "We don't have any relatives. Humara ek bhi relative humara sagga nahi rha hai (None of our relative have been true to us). None of them have been happy." She disclosed how relatives taunted her mother for coming to Mumbai and cursed her that they wouldn't survive in the city. Walia mentioned how her mother took that step, and so their life is happy. Speaking about her professional life, Roshni Walia will soon be seen in Ajay Devgn and Mrunal Thakur starrer Son of Sardaar 2.