India Supreme Court reverses content takedown order against Wikipedia operator
NEW DELHI, May 9 (Reuters) - India's Supreme Court on Friday quashed a lower court ruling ordering online encyclopedia operator Wikimedia Foundation, which runs Wikipedia, to remove a page describing its legal dispute with an Indian news agency.
Indian news agency ANI last year sued Wikimedia for defamation in the Delhi High Court over the way a Wikipedia page described the news agency. ANI said in its lawsuit it was being described on its Wikipedia page as an agency facing criticism for being a "propaganda tool" for the government.
Wikimedia, which has denied wrongdoing, was ordered by the High Court to take down another page describing the lawsuit.
The Supreme Court judges backed a legal challenge by Wikimedia, which had called that takedown order as one which would have a "chilling effect on free speech".
The Supreme Court said the takedown order was the result of the high court reacting "disproportionately."
"Courts, as a public and open institution, must always remain open to public observations, debates and criticisms," the 37-page Supreme Court order said.
ANI in a statement said it welcomes the court's "affirmation of the press's right to report on legal proceedings, while also noting that litigants may seek reporting restrictions in exceptional cases to avoid prejudice."
Wikimedia Foundation did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the Friday's verdict.
Reuters, which owns a 26% stake in ANI, also did not immediately respond to a request for comment. It has previously said it was not involved in ANI's business practices or operations.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Revealed: Winston Churchill's generosity towards the man his glamorous 'first great love' chose to marry instead
A fascinating letter showing Winston Churchill's good nature towards the man who his 'first great love' chose to marry instead of him has emerged 124 years later. The future British wartime prime minister would have been within his rights to feel aggrieved at Victor Bulwer-Lytton who had won the affection of Pamela Plowden. But he instead showed admirable strength of character by going out of his way to give Lytton a helping hand in entering politics. In the 1901 letter, he tells 'My dear Lytton' that he would use his connections to give him an opening and invited him to the House of Commons to further discuss his aspirations. Lytton, who later served as Under-Secretary of India, Governor of Bengal and Acting Viceroy of India, married Plowden in April 1902, two years after she turned down Churchill's marriage proposal. The letter begins by Churchill, who had been elected Conservative MP for Oldham in the October 1900 General Election, informing Lytton of a soon to be vacant municipal chairman role 'closely connected with local and national politics'. He then discloses that 'my friend Goulding, to whom I introduced you the other day in the Lobby... would be a most powerful, if not an all powerful ally in the matter'. He ends the letter by stating: 'I was speaking to G. Wyndham the other day of you and your wish to enter politics. 'He tells me your father showed him great kindness when he was quite a young man. I think you may count on him as a friend.' It appears that Lytton took Churchill up on the offer as he took his seat in the House of Lords as a Conservative six months later, in January 1902. The handwritten letter, marked 'Private', has emerged for sale for £4,200 (5,000 euros) at International Autograph Auctions Europe, of Malaga, Spain. Auction specialist Richard Davie said: 'Lytton married Pamela Plowden in April 1902. 'Pamela had been an early flame of Churchill, but that relationship was amicably broken off when she decided to marry Lytton instead. 'The letter demonstrates how Churchill was able to set aside any differences or hard feelings he may have had about Lytton marrying Pamela Chichele-Plowden, although the marriage didn´t take place until nearly a year after Churchill wrote the letter, so I am not sure what the state of the personal relationships were at the time. 'The letter is also a wonderful example of Churchill as a skilled political manipulator, attempting to pave a way into politics for Lytton. 'It is a good and early example of the political manoeuvring that Churchill would become so adept at later in his career.' He discloses that 'my friend Goulding, to whom I introduced you the other day in the Lobby... would be a most powerful, if not an all powerful ally in the matter' The third page of the letter Churchill sent to Victor Bulwer-Lyttton He ends the letter by stating: 'I was speaking to G. Wyndham the other day of you and your wish to enter politics Churchill was a 22-year-old subaltern in India when he met Plowden, the daughter of the Resident at Hyderabad, in November 1896. Churchill was instantly besotted with her, telling his mother in a letter: 'I was introduced yesterday to Miss Pamela Plowden-who lives here. I must say that she is the most beautiful girl that I have ever seen.' But she rejected his marriage proposal after he returned from the Boer War in 1900, and in April 1902 married the Earl of Lytton, with whom she had four children. Two years later Churchill first met his future wife Clementine at a society ball. Although nothing happened on that occasion they were reacquainted in 1908 when they were seated together at a dinner party. They became an item and Churchill proposed to Clementine at a house party at Blenheim Palace in August 1908 and they married a month later. Despite his earlier heartbreak, Churchill and Plowden remained lifelong friends while he went on to marry Clementine Hozier in 1908. In a letter to Pamela revealing the news, he wrote: 'I am to marry Clementine & I say to you as you said to me when you married Victor - you must always be our best friend.' They exchanged sweet letters on the 50th anniversary of Churchill's failed marriage proposal, and continued to meet until his death in 1965. Plowden died in 1971. The letter being sold, dated July 17, 1901, reads: 'I have heard of something which may or may not be of use to you. 'Lord George Hamilton has vacated the Chairmanship of the London Municipal Society, ´and supposing you were inclined to undertake the various duties in connexion with this office, it might be possible to obtain it for you. 'It is, so I understand, a position closely connected with local & national politics in London and which would fit in with county council work excellently. 'If you think it worth while to hear more about it, I suggest your coming to the House of Commons on Friday afternoon and asking for me. 'The present idea is that Lord Shaftesbury should be put forward. 'I was speaking to G. Wyndham the other day of you and your wish to enter politics. 'He tells me your father showed him great kindness when he was quite a young man. 'I think you may count on him as a friend.' In a postscript, signed with his initials 'W.S.C.', he writes: 'Please let me have an answer at your convenience.' The sale takes place on June 17.
Reuters
2 hours ago
- Reuters
Spanish judge calls on top Sanchez ally to testify over alleged public works kickbacks
MADRID, June 12 (Reuters) - A Spanish Supreme Court judge on Thursday invited a senior official in Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez's Socialist Party to testify, saying there was evidence he was involved in kickbacks from construction companies in exchange for public contracts. In a report provided to Judge Leopoldo Puente, police said they had a recording of Santos Cerdan, a lawmaker and the Socialist Party's organisational secretary, discussing kickbacks with former Transport Minister Jose Luis Abalos, according to the left-leaning radio station Cadena Ser. The judge, who unsealed the case on Thursday, called for Cerdan to testify on June 25 after finding "there is strong evidence of the possible involvement" of Cerdan in the "improper awarding of the aforementioned public works in exchange for a price," according to a court statement. Such acts constitute crimes of criminal organisation and bribery, the statement said. Sanchez's fragile coalition has been hit by a series of allegations over the past year that have threatened to destabilise the government, including a high-profile probe into whether his wife Begona Gomez used her status to influence her business dealings. Cerdan on Thursday said he had no recollection of the conversation. "I have not been involved in any such conversation and this afternoon or tomorrow, when we know the contents of the report, I will call a press conference to which you are all invited," he said in comments to the press in parliament. The Socialist Party on Wednesday said Cerdan was innocent and would provide explanations once the police report was made public. "Santos Cerdan neither participated in nor influenced the awarding of public works contracts. He has never received a commission for doing so," it said in a statement issued late on Wednesday.
The Guardian
2 hours ago
- The Guardian
David Lammy addresses Air India plane crash in parliament
The Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office has a crisis team on standby in Delhi and in London, the foreign secretary said. 'My thoughts, and I'm sure those of the entire house, are with those who've been affected by the tragic plane crash in India this morning. We know that British nationals were on board and I can confirm that the FCDO is working urgently with local authorities to support British nationals and their families,' he added
