Jury deliberates US pipeline case with free speech implications
At the heart of the case is the Dakota Access Pipeline, where nearly a decade ago the Standing Rock Sioux tribe led one of the largest anti-fossil fuel protests in US history. Hundreds were arrested and injured, prompting concerns from the United Nations over violations of Indigenous sovereignty.
The pipeline, which transports fracked crude oil to refineries and global markets, has been operational since 2017.
But its operator, Energy Transfer, has continued pursuing legal action against Greenpeace -- first in a federal lawsuit seeking $300 million, which was dismissed, and then in the three-week trial in a state court in Mandan, North Dakota.
Critics call the case a clear example of a Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation (SLAPP), designed to silence dissent and drain financial resources. Notably, North Dakota is among the minority of US states without anti-SLAPP protections.
In February, Greenpeace became the first group to test the European Union's anti-SLAPP directive by suing Energy Transfer in the Netherlands. The group is seeking damages with interest and demanding that Energy Transfer publish the court's findings on its website.
More than 400 organizations, along with public figures such as singer Billie Eilish and actors Jane Fonda and Susan Sarandon have signed an open letter in support of Greenpeace, as have hundreds of thousands of individuals globally.
gh/bfm
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
TechCrunch
13 hours ago
- TechCrunch
Appeals court says NLRB structure unconstitutional, in a win for SpaceX
A federal appeals court handed SpaceX a win on Tuesday, in a ruling that prevents the National Labor Relations Board from prosecuting unfair labor practices against the company. The ruling by the Fifth District Court of Appeals, which suggests the structure of the NLRB is likely unconstitutional, could have far-reaching effects. The ruling keeps unfair labor practice cases against SpaceX and two other companies, Energy Transfer and Findhelp, on hold while the companies pursue their claim that the NLRB structure violates the U.S. Constitution. While the court did declare it unlawful, this is far from a settled issue, and NLRB is undoubtedly likely to challenge the ruling. The three-judge panel said being subjected to a possibly unconstitutional administrative proceeding, which is what SpaceX claimed, is an irreparable harm – so the pause continues. The NLRB brought the ufair labor practices claim against SpaceX after it fired a group of employees who signed an open letter criticizing CEO Elon Musk and a culture of sexism in the company. The core of the dispute is over whether NLRB's in-house judges, called administrative law judges, enjoy unlawful protections that shield them from removal by the President. If that's the case, it violates constitutional rules governing the separation of powers, the judges said. The panel included two judges appointed by President Donald Trump and a third judge appointed by George H.W. Bush.
Los Angeles Times
15 hours ago
- Los Angeles Times
Indigenous groups demand action from South American leaders at Amazon summit
BOGOTA, Colombia — Indigenous leaders from across the Amazon are urging South American presidents meeting in Bogota this week to turn promises into concrete action, saying the gathering may be the first time at the conference they sit face-to-face with heads of state to demand a role in shaping the rainforest's future. The Fifth Presidential Summit of the Amazon Cooperation Treaty Organization, which officially begins in the Colombian capital on Tuesday, will bring together leaders alongside Indigenous representatives and scientists. The agenda includes public forums, cultural events and high-level meetings, culminating Friday with a joint 'Declaration of Bogota' setting regional priorities on environmental protection and climate policy. Indigenous groups from all eight Amazonian nations issued a statement on Monday evening, calling the rainforest a global lifeline that provides about one-fifth of the world's freshwater and acts as one of the planet's largest carbon sinks, absorbing vast amounts of heat-trapping carbon dioxide. They said decades of deforestation, mining, fossil fuel drilling and large-scale farming have pushed the region toward a point of no return. Among their demands are legal protection of Indigenous lands, recognition of their communities as official decision-makers within the treaty body, and a ban on new oil, gas and mining projects in the rainforest. They also propose a working group on a 'just transition' — a shift to cleaner energy and away from coal, oil or natural gas — and an observatory to track threats against environmental defenders. The groups noted that many commitments made in the 2023 Belem Declaration — a joint pledge by Amazon nations to cooperate on protecting the rainforest — have yet to be implemented, and cautioned against another round of 'empty promises.' They stressed that violence against activists continues to rise across the Amazon, calling for regional protection measures. The week-long program includes an 'Amazon Dialogues' forum bringing together civil society, scientists and Indigenous leaders; a panel on the rainforest's 'flying rivers' that help regulate South America's climate; and a 'Road to COP30' event meant to shape the Amazon's voice at the next U.N. climate conference in Brazil in November. 'There is no solution to any of the threats the Amazon is facing without its communities,' said Raphael Hoetmer, a senior advisor at Amazon Watch, a U.S.-based nonprofit, attending the summit. 'There is an historical opportunity to create a mechanism for permanent and direct dialogue and participation with Indigenous peoples through the ATCO,' he said, referring to the Amazon Cooperation Treaty Organization, a bloc of eight Amazonian countries. Leaders from Bolivia, Brazil, Colombia, Ecuador, Guyana, Peru, Suriname and Venezuela are expected to attend, with hopes that it will be the first time Indigenous representatives will meet directly with heads of state during the summit. 'There will be no future without Indigenous peoples at the center of decision-making,' the groups said in the statement. Grattan writes for the Associated Press.
Yahoo
16 hours ago
- Yahoo
Indigenous leaders demand action from South American leaders at Amazon summit
Colombia Amazon Summit BOGOTA, Colombia (AP) — Indigenous leaders from across the Amazon are urging South American presidents meeting in Bogota this week to turn promises into concrete action, saying the gathering may be the first time at the conference they sit face-to-face with heads of state to demand a role in shaping the rainforest's future. The Fifth Presidential Summit of the Amazon Cooperation Treaty Organization, which officially begins in the Colombian capital on Tuesday, will bring together leaders alongside Indigenous representatives and scientists. The agenda includes public forums, cultural events and high-level meetings, culminating Friday with a joint 'Declaration of Bogota' setting regional priorities on environmental protection and climate policy. Indigenous groups from all eight Amazonian nations issued a statement on Monday evening, calling the rainforest a global lifeline that provides about one-fifth of the world's freshwater and acts as one of the planet's largest carbon sinks, absorbing vast amounts of heat-trapping carbon dioxide. They said decades of deforestation, mining, fossil fuel drilling and large-scale farming have pushed the region toward a point of no return. Among their demands are legal protection of Indigenous lands, recognition of their communities as official decision-makers within the treaty body, and a ban on new oil, gas and mining projects in the rainforest. They also propose a working group on a 'just transition' — a shift to cleaner energy and away from coal, oil or natural gas — and an observatory to track threats against environmental defenders. The groups noted that many commitments made in the 2023 Belem Declaration — a joint pledge by Amazon nations to cooperate on protecting the rainforest — have yet to be implemented, and cautioned against another round of 'empty promises.' They stressed that violence against activists continues to rise across the Amazon, calling for regional protection measures. The week-long program includes an 'Amazon Dialogues' forum bringing together civil society, scientists and Indigenous leaders; a panel on the rainforest's 'flying rivers' that help regulate South America's climate; and a 'Road to COP30' event meant to shape the Amazon's voice at the next U.N. climate conference in Brazil in November. 'There is no solution to any of the threats the Amazon is facing without its communities," said Raphael Hoetmer, a senior advisor at Amazon Watch, a U.S.-based nonprofit, attending the summit. 'There is an historical opportunity to create a mechanism for permanent and direct dialogue and participation with Indigenous peoples through the ATCO,' he said, referring to the Amazon Cooperation Treaty Organization, a bloc of eight Amazonian countries. Leaders from Bolivia, Brazil, Colombia, Ecuador, Guyana, Peru, Suriname and Venezuela are expected to attend, with hopes that it will be the first time Indigenous representatives will meet directly with heads of state during the summit. 'There will be no future without Indigenous peoples at the center of decision-making,' the groups said in the statement. ___ The Associated Press' climate and environmental coverage receives financial support from multiple private foundations. AP is solely responsible for all content. Find AP's standards for working with philanthropies, a list of supporters and funded coverage areas at Solve the daily Crossword
