Escalate or back down? Experts weigh in on Islamabad's options
India-Pakistan tensions have risen sharply in the aftermath of Operation Sindoor, carried out by Indian forces in the early hours of Wednesday. Pakistan has stated that it reserves the right to respond to Indian military operations at a time and place of its choosing. As South Asia's two nuclear powers square off, Hindustan Times spoke to retired military officers and diplomats to understand the options facing both India and Pakistan. A damaged structure in the Kotli district of Pakistan-occupied Kashmir on May 7. (AFP Photo)
Scenario 1: Pakistan Steps Up Shelling Across Line of Control
Over the last few weeks, the Indian armed forces have accused Pakistan of multiple violations of the ceasefire across the Line of Control which was agreed to in 2021. In the aftermath of Operation Sindoor, Pakistan intensified shelling across the Line of Control which has hit civilian areas in India and reportedly claimed the lives of several civilians.
'I think the India-Pakistan ceasefire agreement is dead and you're going to see a lot more firing on both sides of the Line of Control,' says former Northern Army Commander Lt. Gen. DS Hooda.
But it may not stop at that.
Scenario 2: Pakistan Responds With Air Strikes
Former Northern Army Commander Lt. Gen. BS Jaswal says that Pakistan could respond to Operation Sindoor with limited strikes on Indian military airfields. Such a strike would aim to cripple India's ability to respond to Pakistan's air operations or support its own ground troops. However, retired officers made it clear that New Delhi would see this as a major escalation as Operation Sindoor only targeted terror camps and no military facilities. Jaswal added that any Pakistani attacks would see an Indian response, including heavy shelling across the Line of Control by the Indian Army and possible retaliatory strikes on military targets by the Indian Air Force.
Despite some nuclear sabre rattling by Pakistan in recent weeks, the unanimous view among retired Indian military officials was that Islamabad is not looking for either a limited nuclear war or a nuclear exchange with India.
'My own sense is that Pakistan's military retaliation will be limited,' says Lt. Gen. Hooda.
Or the country could choose to resort to its old tricks.
Scenario 3: Escalated Terror Attacks
Former Vice Chief of Army Staff Lt. Gen. AS Lamba believes that an escalated campaign of terrorism may well be Pakistan's chosen way to respond to India.
'Though Pakistan can, it must guard against escalating terror strikes on sensitive installations and other targets in India which will meet a tough response,' says Lt. Gen. Lamba.
Direct military action against the Indian armed forces could lead to significant escalation which Pakistan may not want to see at this time.
'If Pakistan responds to India's strike on terror camps, with a strong military option, or even artillery and missile strikes on border towns and civilian populations, such escalation would draw a stern response from India, that Pakistan with its internal security and economic crisis will find it difficult to handle,' adds Lt. Gen. Lamba.
All of these suggest that there are no diplomatic options. That may change.
Scenario 4: Diplomatic Backchannel Established
Former Indian Permanent Representative to the UN Syed Akbaruddin says that India and Pakistan have exhausted their diplomatic leverage against each other. Both sides have banned trade, closed their airspace, cancelled visas and expelled the other's citizens and diplomats. Pakistan's effort to follow its traditional policy of seeking multilateral diplomatic support for its position - including through the United Nations - has yielded little benefit.
'The only diplomatic option is a back channel. There cannot be a front channel as there is no space for that,' says Akbaruddin.
'If you see how many back channels have been established since Trump came in this year, there's been one between Russia and America and another between America and Iran. That is the only diplomatic option I can see at this time,' Akbaruddin said while noting that Pakistan was likely to take a more aggressive stand.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scroll.in
an hour ago
- Scroll.in
Bangladesh anti-Sheikh Hasina student protester Newton Das found to be Bengal voter
A man allegedly linked to the 2024 students' protests in Bangladesh was found to be a voter in West Bengal's Kakdwip Assembly constituency, The Hindu reported on Sunday. Several images of the man, identified as Newton Das, participating in the agitation in the neighbouring country were widely shared on social media. Das has claimed that he was an Indian citizen but acknowledged that he had actively participated in the protests in Bangladesh, The Hindu reported. 'I went to Bangladesh in 2024 for issues related to an ancestral property and got caught in the revolution,' The Hindu quoted Newton Das as saying in a video. 'I have been a voter in Kakdwip since 2014 but lost my voter card in 2017.' Newton Das said that he had received a fresh voter card in 2018 with the help of Trinamool Congress MLA Manturam Pakhira. He also claimed that he had voted for Pakhira, who represents Kakdwip, in the 2016 Assembly polls, The Hindu reported. The constituency is in South 24 Parganas district. 'This is a conspiracy against me by a particular community,' India Today quoted Newton Das as saying in the video. He did not specify whether he was currently in India or Bangladesh. His cousin Tapan Das, who resides in Kakdwip, claimed that Newton Das was born in Bangladesh and had exercised voting rights in both countries, The Hindu reported. Tapan Das claimed that his cousin had gone to Bangladesh after the Covid-19 pandemic to sell land and had not returned. 'Since he was born in Bangladesh, he is a voter of Bangladesh too,' The Hindu quoted Tapan Das as saying. 'It is his fault that he is registered as a voter in both the countries.' Kakdwip is close to the Sundarbans and India's border with Bangladesh. Political row The incident sparked a political row in the state. The Bharatiya Janata Party's West Bengal unit on Sunday criticised West Bengal's ruling Trinamool Congress claiming that a ' Bangladeshi protester ' was voting in both countries. 'Let that sink in,' the Hindutva party said on social media. 'This isn't an accident. This is the TMC blueprint – flood Bengal's voter rolls with illegal infiltrators and secure elections with ghost votes.' West Bengal 'isn't just lawless – it's compromised from within', the BJP claimed. BJP leader Suvendu Adhikari claimed that lakhs of Bangladesh citizens were registered as voters in the state, The Hindu reported. The Opposition leader claimed that an alleged member of Bangladeshi militant group Ansarullah Bangla was also enlisted as a voter in Murshidabad. West Bengal BJP chief Sukanta Majumdar on Saturday described the incident as an example of the 'so-called Egiye [progressive] Bangla Model'. 'The same Newton who was seen wielding a stick during Bangladesh's quota reform movement is now a registered voter in Kakdwip,' the BJP leader said on social media. 'Thousands of Bangladeshi 'Newtons' voting in Bengal – courtesy of [Chief Minister] Mamata Banerjee's infiltration theory and appeasement politics,' he alleged. 'With illegal voters and these lathi-wielders miscreants as her support base, she's not running West Bengal… she's scripting a blueprint for Greater Bangladesh.' The Trinamool Congress rejected the BJP's allegations and said that the responsibility for border security was with the Border Security Force, India Today reported. The Border Security Force reports to the Union home ministry. 'Whether these people come from land, water or air, the BSF and Union government are responsible,' The Hindu quoted Trinamool leader Kunal Ghosh as saying. 'The state administration will do its role for sure.' The state's ruling party also claimed that the Election Commission was complicit in voter list tampering. In February, Banerjee had accused the BJP of allegedly attempting to add residents of Gujarat, Rajasthan, Punjab and Haryana to West Bengal's voter lists. The chief minister had also accused the BJP of adding fake voters to electoral lists to win the Assembly elections in Delhi and Maharashtra. In 2024, weeks of widespread student-led protests in Bangladesh against Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina and her Awami League government had led to her resignation and her fleeing to India on August 5. In August, weeks of student-led protests in Bangladesh against a controversial quota scheme for government jobs snowballed into a broader agitation against the Sheikh Hasina government.
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
Lt Gen Rajiv Ghai promoted as deputy Chief of Army Staff
Lt Gen Rajiv Ghai has been elevated to the post of Deputy Chief of Army Staff (Strategy), a role under which all operational verticals of the Indian Army report to the Deputy Chief of Army Staff (Security), news agency ANI reported. He will also continue to serve as the Director General of Military Operations (DGMO). Last week, Lt Gen Ghai, a key figure in military briefings on Operation Sindoor, was awarded the Uttam Yudh Seva Medal (UYSM) by President Droupadi Murmu. He led military operations for Operation Sindoor, launched on May 7, in retaliation for the April 22 terror attack in Pahalgam, Jammu and Kashmir, which killed 26 people. The operation targeted nine terror sites in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir. At a press conference on May 11, Lt Gen Ghai revealed that his Pakistani counterpart had proposed a ceasefire during an interaction on May 10, which led to both sides agreeing to halt hostilities. Clarifying media reports, the Indian Army later stated that the ceasefire agreed upon in the DGMO talks on May 12 has no expiry date. 'No DGMO talks are scheduled today. As far as the continuation of a break in hostilities... There is no expiry date to it,' the Army said. (This is a developing story. Please check back for updates)
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
Espionage case: Hisar court extends social media influencer's judicial custody
Hisar, A local court on Monday extended the judicial custody of social media influencer Jyoti Malhotra and fixed her case's hearing on June 23. The 33-year-old YouTuber appeared before the court of Hisar Judicial Magistrate Sunil Kumar through video conferencing on Monday which extended her judicial custody by two weeks. "The court has extended her judicial custody and fixed June 23 for the next hearing in this case," her lawyer Kumar Mukesh said. Hisar Police arrested Malhotra on suspicion of espionage on May 16. She was subsequently remanded to five days of police custody by the court. Following the completion of the remand, the court extended it by four more days on the police's plea for further questioning. On May 26, the court remanded her to judicial custody for 14 days. Malhotra, who hails from the city, ran a YouTube channel "Travel with JO". She was arrested at the New Aggarsain Extension and booked under provisions of the Official Secrets Act and the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita. Hisar Police previously said no evidence had emerged to indicate Malhotra had access to any military- or defence-related information but claimed she was in contact with some people, aware that they were Pakistani Intelligence Operatives . Police sources said she was in touch with Ehsan-ur-Rahim alias Danish, a staffer at the Pakistani High Commission, since November 2023. India expelled Danish on May 13 for allegedly indulging in espionage. The police have claimed Pakistani intelligence operatives were developing Malhotra as an asset. Punjab Police recently said Punjab-based YouTuber Jasbir Singh, who was arrested on espionage charges on June 4, was in close contact with Malhotra. Singh, who was found to be associated with a PIO, was in touch with a Pakistan High Commission official who was recently expelled from New Delhi on charges of spying and had met Pakistan Army officials during one of his three visits to the neighbouring country, Punjab Police said previously. After Malhotra's arrest, Singh attempted to erase all traces of his communications with these PIOs to avoid detection, Punjab Police added.
