Young woman burns to death after tragic NDIS bathtub mistake
A regional disability provider has admitted to serious safety breaches after the death of a young Aboriginal woman who was badly burned in a bathtub.
Kyah Lucas suffered burns to almost half her body when she was bathed at a home in Orange, in central western NSW, by two workers from NDIS provider LiveBetter in February 2022.
Ms Lucas was removed from the bath with her skin peeling, and a temperature control panel showed the water was 60C rather than the usual maximum setting of 42C.
The 28-year-old, who had conditions that left her non-verbal and with thin skin, died in a Sydney hospital five days later.
LiveBetter was fined a record $1.8 million in the Federal Court in April 2024 after the NDIS Quality and Safeguards Commission took action against it over multiple failures to comply with its standards of care.
On Monday, the care provider pleaded guilty in the NSW District Court to a criminal charge in a separate case brought by SafeWork NSW.
It has admitted one count of breaching its primary duty of health and safety regarding Ms Lucas.
A charge of failing to immediately notify the workplace regulator of Ms Lucas's injuries was dismissed.
The risk to Ms Lucas, whose conditions left her vulnerable to burns, was being bathed in water that was an unsafe temperature, the regulator alleged in documents before the court.
The organisation was accused of negligent or reckless conduct through failing to implement safety procedures, like audits of the hot water system or double-checking the temperature with a thermometer.
LiveBetter was also accused of failing to develop adequate training for its workers on bathing NDIS clients in line with their needs or how to respond after a burns incident.
In February, LiveBetter said in a statement that while it could not comment on the case, it was working with the regulator and other agencies to ensure a safe work environment for staff and clients.
"LiveBetter continues to mourn the tragic death of Kyah Lucas ... and our thoughts remain with her grieving family," it said.
During the Federal Court case, Justice Elizabeth Raper heard LiveBetter staff looking after Ms Lucas learned "on the job" and that atheir training assessments were limited to an online quiz.
"The specific harm suffered by Ms Lucas was of the most acute kind, so too can it be said of the harm to Ms Lucas' family," Justice Raper said in her judgment.
"There are no words to properly express the degree of the harm suffered."
A sentence hearing in the SafeWork NSW case will be held at a later date before Judge Wendy Strathdee.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
01-06-2025
- The Guardian
Kathy has terminal cancer and cares for her son with a profound disability. At a crisis point, his NDIS funding ran out
Next to the bed Steven Rieger spends most his life in is a framed print that says: 'This is my happy place.' For him, it is – his small room on the eastern outskirts of Melbourne is covered in Collingwood paraphernalia and basked in warm light. Steven, 37, needs round-the-clock care. He lives with cerebral palsy, is nonverbal and suffers from seizures – natural light can trigger them so he spends almost all of his time in his room. His parents are both in their 70s – his father Rodger has had several strokes and is partly deaf. His mother, Kathy, who has cared for him most of his life, is dying – her breast cancer has metastasised, spreading to her bones and brain. In March, the family lost their national disability insurance scheme (NDIS) funding, and Steven's paid carers felt obliged to work for free – the family could not cope by themselves. They had been overspending on their plan, but the family say they were underfunded for their care needs. When the money ran out they panicked. Steven's sister Kylie started a GoFundMe and Kathy rang their local member of parliament, Julian Hill. They have now been put on a plan that provides 10 hours of care a day, but they need more. 'It was almost three weeks where there was no funding,' Kathy says. 'The carers that do look after Steven were nice enough to still come in here, but they weren't getting paid. They were doing their normal shifts but without pay.' Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email Advocates say participants have become collateral damage as the NDIS goes through massive changes, with many plans expiring and reviews dragging on. They say crucial funding is not getting where it needs to go. In January, Kathy had started preparing everything for the annual review of Steven's plan. As she was getting sicker she knew they needed to be funded for 15 hours of care a day. 'It was very stressful for me,' she says. 'I was getting things organised … and hoping the funding wouldn't run out, but it did. 'We started calling NDIS a few weeks before this funding was going to run out, and they said it wouldn't run out. They said they would escalate [the case] every time.' The family say they now owe around $15,000 to carers for the three weeks of work. Twice a day, Steven is lifted into a chair and fed through a drip. El Gibbs, CEO of the Disability Advocates Network Australia, says the NDIS is delaying plan renewals for so long, people run out of personal funds. 'We had a meeting a few weeks ago, and all our members reported a 50% or more increase in their waiting list for help with AAT [administrative appeals tribunal] appeals, where people with disability and their families are fighting for the support that they need,' Gibbs says. Under the changes, NDIS plans are meant to automatically continue if the review has not taken place yet. Because the Riegers were asking to increase Steven's care hours, their plan ran out. The last quarterly reports show an increase in participants taking their review decision to the AAT, with the number of new cases as a proportion of active participants increasing from 0.66% in the March 2023 quarter to 1.05% in the March 2025 quarter. Gibbs says the delays mean people in crisis are falling through the cracks, as is the case for the Riegers – Steven's funding running out while Kathy is dying worsens the family's situation. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion 'Our disability support system has to be able to meet them where they are,' Gibbs says. 'If a family goes through a crisis, and informal supports aren't there any more then, of course, the NDIS needs to step in and do it quickly and make sure a terrible situation isn't made harder.' Gibbs says vulnerable families should not be accruing debt to get the right care and the massive reforms to the NDIS need to be more clearly communicated. 'At the moment, the changes are often rushed and harsh, and the communication about them isn't clear to people with disability, to families, to support coordinators,' she says. 'So it is really hard for everyone to understand what is happening and to have a clear pathway about what comes next.' A spokesperson for the National Disability Insurance Agency said its priority was 'ensuring every participant, like Steven, has access to the disability-related supports they require'. 'The agency continues to work with Steven and his parents regarding his future needs. 'When a participant's circumstances change a request for an early plan reassessment can be requested. The agency cannot make decisions to change a participant's plan without being provided appropriate evidence.' Jenny McAllister, the minister for the NDIS, was contacted for comment. An occupational therapist report to possibly increase Steven's care to 15 hours a day is set for three weeks' time, but Kathy is struggling. 'I physically can't care for Steven any more,' she says. 'With extremely high needs like Steven's, there shouldn't be a review in their plan. They're not going to get better. There's no change. 'They're not going to wake up one day and go, 'Oh, hi Mum, I'm all good. I'm going to work now.''
Daily Mail
01-06-2025
- Daily Mail
Lacie, 15, was excited about starting a new school. Three weeks later she was dead. This is her heartbroken dad's message to all parents
The grieving father of a 15-year-old girl who took her own life has spoken out, claiming the school she attended for three weeks before she passed away failed to protect her from bullying. Lacie May Murphy died on March 18 after a struggle with mental illness and bullying at her new school on the Gold Coast after moving from New South Wales in search of a fresh start. Her father, Todd Murphy, 39, said that the school dismissed Lacie's pleas for help and made her feel as though her concerns were 'not important'. Originally from Muswellbrook, Lacie had recently moved to the Gold Coast to live with her father. At first, things seemed to be going well - she even texted her dad to say she loved the school. But by the end of her first week, things changed. Lacie began questioning her dad about the way she was being treated by other students. 'Why are they bullying me - why are they saying this?' she asked him at the time. Lacie reported the bullying to the school, but Mr Murphy said she felt ignored. Mr Murphy said staff asked Lacie whether she wished to change schools but she decided to fight on. 'To Lacie's credit, she came back to me after a week and said, "Dad, I want to... battle through and and finish Year 10 at least. And that was her decision. 'And I said, "That's good, that's what I want." I said," I'll look after the bullying. I'll do what I can. I just ask you go to school and try your hardest".' Mr Murphy also hoped Lacie, who identified as Aboriginal, would connect with the school's First Nations liaison officer - but he said it took weeks for anyone to reach out. Tragically, the phone call finally came on March 18 - the same day he came home to find Lacie had died. 'The liason officer was three weeks too late,' her dad said. 'It is the worst possible fear that any parent could have - that you have to bury your child like that.' Lacie had a history of mental health struggles, including ADHD. Her father said the school made an effort to assist her including by giving her a card she could flash to leave the class when she felt 'overwhelmed or anxious'. But Mr Murphy believes the school should have done more to protect his his daughter in the three weeks she spent there before she died. Now, he's urging schools to take bullying more seriously and for parents to better understand warning signs in their children. 'We did know Lacie was struggling, but ultimately, Lacie didn't have the tools in her toolbox to be able to explain well enough to us what she needed, or all the feelings she had,' Mr Murphy told Daily Mail Australia. 'And, you know, [she] bottled them up, and put on a brave face and a smile and didn't want to confront her own demons that she had. 'This mental health stigma and this bullying... it needs to stop. We need to do something.' Lacie has been remembered as a kind and loving soul with a passion for rugby league. 'She was the epitome of selflessness - she cared about others far more than she cared about herself,' Mr Murphy said. 'In the football team it's the same... she would run the ball to get as far as she could for her teammates, she would always stand up for them and always stand up for her friends but she carried so much of that weight herself. 'You know, she cared too much, she loved too much, she didn't know how to let go... she thought she had to do it all and carry it all.' A spokesperson for the Queensland Department of Education admitted it had do more to ensure safe and inclusive environments were created for all students. 'Our thoughts and sincere sympathies are with the student's family, friends and loved ones during this devastating time. It is a tragedy when a young person's life is cut short,' the spokesperson said. The Queensland Government recently announced a $33million investment to help tackle bullying in schools. The new program includes the establishment of 'Rapid Support Squads' designed to fly into schools in need of extra support, funding for wellbeing staff and the expansion of a hotline to provide guidance to carers. 'The Anti-bullying Stakeholder Reference Group, consisting of experts in the field will inform the department's anti-bullying actions and measures and guide future initiatives to prevent and respond to bullying,' they said. 'Furthermore, all students have access to wellbeing professionals at school, and access to a team of experts providing specialist assistance in student protection, mental health and wellbeing.'
BBC News
12-05-2025
- BBC News
Stoke-on-Trent family 'at breaking point' over three-year care fight
The parents of a teenage boy with a rare genetic condition have said they are at "breaking point" after spending three years sleeping with him on their living room floor. Lucas, 13, from Stoke-on-Trent, is one of only dozens of children in the world with the CNKSR2 genetic disorder, he has regular seizures and needs around the clock has a social care package for three support workers to look after him during the day, but his family is fighting for an NHS continuing care funding package to cover overnight care. NHS Midlands and Lancashire Commissioning Support Unit said it was "actively working to address" the delays in Lucas' care. Following a lengthy battle with NHS Midlands and Lancashire Commissioning Support Unit, a package of two carers for the overnight period was agreed. However, no care provider will take on the contract, and there is still disagreement over whether staff can lie with him, something his family said was vital. Lucas has epilepsy, is non-verbal and is fed through a tube into his stomach, and his mother Becci said he "needs someone with him at all times.""He's an active sleeper," she said, "he's given himself nosebleeds in the night. He has medication through his feeding tube which can get tangled, which is a strangulation risk. He even managed to pull his feeding tube out and we had to go to hospital with him."Becci added: "It's very frustrating. You're battling for something you should be entitled to. If you need that support, you should be able to get it. It's very draining, we are on the verge of breaking point." Father Andy, who gave up work to focus on Lucas' care, said they were surviving on four to five hours of broken sleep each night, which was "breaking this family, mentally and physically."He added: "He never asked to be the way he is. Follow the guidance, so we can have some quality of life. We don't know how long we've got him for, all we want is to make the most of every single day." NHS Midlands and Lancashire Commissioning Support Unit said: "There have been differing opinions of clinicians and parents, which has led to a delay in the assessed care package being delivered, and we are actively working to address this."However, Andy said "that's a blatant lie", and only the nurse assessor who made the recommendation for funding had disagreed with them. He added that 20 other health, care and teaching professionals agreed with them that Lucas required two carers to lie with him overnight. The family said their quality of life would only improve when an appropriate overnight care package was agreed. Becci said: "We will keep going. We have to, it's our job as a parent, but it's slowly draining away at us every single day. " Follow BBC Stoke & Staffordshire on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
