Taylor Swift Promises Showgirl Will Stay at 12 Songs — & Fans Think She's Addressing Something Bigger
For a star who's been both celebrated and criticized for her multi-edition rollouts, the comment landed with extra weight. On Reddit, fans immediately connected it to backlash Swift has faced in recent years, particularly during The Tortured Poets Department. That album not only arrived as a surprise double release but also came with a flood of vinyl variants — a strategy that drew fire for both its cost to fans and its environmental footprint.
More from SheKnows
13 Showgirl-Orange Pieces That'll Get You Ready for Taylor Swift's Latest Album & Era - Starting at Just $10
'I actually believe this on the basis that a lot of this album and its concept seem to be a response to the criticism of TTPD,' one fan wrote. 'Overly verbose, overly long, overly overwrought lyrics on TTPD to a tight 12 track pop album sounds about right.' Another added more bluntly: 'TTPD had way too many songs and all the variants was ridiculous.'
The shift isn't just coming from Swift, either. In April 2025 — about a year after the TTPD variant avalanche — Billboard finally stepped in, capping the number of editions that can count toward the charts at four. It was a clear move to stop the cycle of endless covers, bonus tracks, and bundle tricks that made fans feel squeezed and critics cry 'manipulation.' As one fan put it, 'I hope this means the variants that are out now are the only ones, and she took the criticism of 'variant overload' to heart. The planet thanks her.'
This isn't the first time Swift's release strategy has been tangled in larger debates. In May 2024, she dropped new editions of TTPD the day before Billie Eilish's latest album, prompting speculation that Swift was responding to Eilish's public critique of wasteful vinyl practices. Whether intentional or not, it solidified Swift's reputation as an artist unafraid to multiply her product lines — much to the dismay of eco-conscious fans.
Now, the deliberate simplicity of Showgirl feels pointed. 'Do you guys think she will release a variant every few weeks for the next five months?' one commenter asked. 'I hope she doesn't. That felt very very greedy to me.' Another said they were simply relieved: 'I STILL haven't gotten a hold of everything from TTPD or Midnights. The oversaturation just makes me feel like I'm missing out.'
Of course, Swifties are also reading the numbers. Twelve isn't random in Swift's world: it's her 12th album, arriving on October 3, and fans have long pointed out her love of numerology and coded significance. 'This era is filled with her listening to criticism,' a Redditor argued. 'I would put money on her not adding ANY songs to the album. She would not have said that unless she was certain.'
Whether The Life of a Showgirl truly stops at 12 tracks remains to be seen. But for now, Swift's bluntness suggests a new kind of restraint — and fans can't help but wonder if the message is as much about the music as it is about the criticism that's followed her. And, if you're looking for signs, it doesn't hurt that her pared-back new era officially arrives on October 3 — a date forever immortalized in Mean Girls. For Swifties, it might just be another wink that she knows exactly what she's doing.
Before you go, click to see all of Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce's cutest PDA moments.
Best of SheKnows
20 Times Madonna Reinvented Fashion at the VMAs
The Best Photos of Madonna & Lookalike Daughter Lourdes Through The Years
22 Famous Women Who Have Played Roxie in Chicago on Broadway
Solve the daily Crossword
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
26 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Box Office: ‘Weapons' Slays ‘Nobody 2' With $25M as Sydney Sweeney's ‘Americana' Bombs at $500K
Bob Odenkirk's modestly budgeted sequel Nobody 2 is having to settle for a third-place finish in its domestic box office debut as Zach Cregger's Weapons continues to fire on all cylinders and stay atop the chart in its sophomore outing, followed by Disney's family comedy Freakier Friday. Nobody 2, about a seemingly average suburban dad who leads a double life as a stealth operative, is on course to open on the lower end of expectations with $9.3 million from 3,260 locations after receiving a B+ CinemaScore from audiences (its audience ranking on Rotten Tomatoes is more promising at 89 percent). Its early global total is $14.2 million. More from The Hollywood Reporter Sydney Sweeney Just Had the Biggest Controversy of Her Career. Now What? Black Bear Names Lionsgate Vet David Spitz Head of U.S. Theatrical Distribution Sharon Stone Has a "Moral Code" When Playing Bad Guys: "Villains Really F*** Up Your Life" The first Nobody opened amid the pandemic to $6.8 million on its way to grossing a pleasing $68 million domestically. The sequel cost a modest $25 million to make before marketing, so no one at Universal is losing sleep, since it is sure to make up ground when hitting premium VOD as early as three weeks from now (the studio has perfected the art of PVOD). From New Line and Warner Bros., Weapons had no trouble staying No. 1 with $25 million from 3,450 locations in its sophomore outing after dropping a scant 43 percent drop. That's a rare feat for a horror film, and cements the film's status as a water-cooler sensation. Overseas, it dropped 33 percent to $18.4 million for an early worldwide total of $148.8 million in yet another win for Warners, which paid $38 million for rights to the project. The female-skewing Freakier Friday, reteaming Jamie Lee Curtis and Lindsay Lohan, is likewise grinning in its sophomore outing with an estimated haul $14.5 million from 3,975 cinemas for a worldwide cume of $86.3 million against a budget under $45 million. The body-swap comedy fell 50 percent domestically. Nobody 2 isn't the weekend's only new player, but is by far doing the best of the bunch. Spike Lee's prestige pic Highest 2 Lowest, which reunites him for the first time in 18 years with Denzel Washington, is opening in select theaters before debuting relatively quickly on Apple TV+ in early September. While Apple is making a major push into theatrical — 51: The Movie is one of the summer's biggest blockbusters and is getting a traditional release in cinemas — Highest 2 Lowest doesn't appear to be part of that strategy. A24, which partnered with Apple on Lee's latest movie, isn't even reporting grosses so far, but those with visibility into numbers being reported by some theaters suggest Highest 2 Lowest is doing tepid business for a movie with such a high-profile director and cast, not to mention a splashy world premiere at the Cannes Film Festival. The Lionsgate-distributed Americana — starring Sydney Sweeney opposite Paul Walter Hauser and Halsey — is bombing in its nationwide debut in 1,123 theaters. The pic opened to an estimated $500,000 for a sixteenth-place finish. The crime-heist movie, which has been well received by critics, has taken more than two years to arrive on the big screen after first premiering at SXSW in 2023. Lionsgate insists the film is part of a multi-platform strategy, including premium VOD, and that it is no way a disappointment, financial or otherwise. Americana opens in the wake of a media firestorm engulfing Sweeney after American Eagle dropped its 'Sydney Has Great Jeans' campaign July 23. Almost overnight, some TikTok users took offense to a campaign clip that features Sweeney saying, 'Genes are passed down from parents to offspring, often determining traits like hair color, personality and even eye color. My jeans are blue.' They claimed the comments promote eugenics since Sweeney is white, blond-haired and blue-eyed. While countless users dismissed such theories as nonsense, the debate went viral. Even President Donald Trump weighed in after The Guardian reported that Sweeney registered as a Republican in Florida prior to the 2024 election. More to come. Aug 17, 8:15 a.m.: Updated with revised estimates. This story was originally published Aug. 16 at 10:27 a.m. Best of The Hollywood Reporter The 25 Best U.S. Film Schools in 2025 The 40 Greatest Needle Drops in Film History The 40 Best Films About the Immigrant Experience
Geek Tyrant
27 minutes ago
- Geek Tyrant
Universal Monsters – NECA's Classic Movie Monsters Action Figure Bundle Unveiled — GeekTyrant
NECA is bringing a nostalgic dose of horror to collectors with its new Universal Monsters 7-inch scale action figure bundle. This exclusive set features Dracula, Frankenstein's Monster, The Mummy, and The Wolf Man, each sporting a fresh paint deco inspired by the 1986 'Classic Movie Monsters' figures from Imperial. The retro influence extends to the special blister card packaging, designed to replicate the look and feel of those vintage releases. As NECA puts it, 'NECA is unleashing an homage wave of Universal Monsters action figures to haunt your shelves! Based on the Classic Movie Monster toy line from 1986, these articulated 7-inch scale figures blend vintage charm with updated, modern sculpts. 'This lineup features the legendary horror movie monsters Frankenstein, Wolfman, The Mummy, and Dracula. Each figure comes in special retro-style blister card packaging.' The set is available exclusively through the NECA Store for $99.99, with pre-orders now open and shipping expected in the first quarter of 2026. While the figures don't include accessories, their sculpt detail, articulation, and faithful retro presentation make them a standout for monster movie fans and collectors who grew up with the original 80s line. Whether you're a Universal Monsters devotee or just love the mix of old-school style with modern figure craftsmanship, this bundle is a perfect way to honor horror history while adding some vintage-inspired terror to your display.
Fox News
28 minutes ago
- Fox News
ESPN shelves Colin Kaepernick docuseries over 'certain creative differences'
A Spike Lee-directed docuseries featuring Colin Kaepernick that was set to air on ESPN is no longer happening, the network and filmmaker said in a statement on Sunday. ESPN said the issue was due to "creative differences." "ESPN, Colin Kaepernick and Spike Lee have collectively decided to no longer proceed with this project as a result of certain creative differences," ESPN told Reuters in a statement. "Despite not reaching finality, we appreciate all the hard work and collaboration that went into this film." Lee told Reuters on Friday that the documentary was not coming out and that's all he could say. He later added that he signed a nondisclosure about it. Reuters reported that a Kaepernick rep had no comment. It was nearly a decade ago when Kaepernick, then of the San Francisco 49ers, protested against racial injustice in the U.S. when he knelt during the national anthem before a preseason game. The demonstrated kickstarted a firestorm around the league, prompting NFL players and President Donald Trump to clash at one point. Kaepernick protested throughout the 2016 season and left the 49ers before the start of the 2017 season. He has not played in the NFL since then. He filed a collusion lawsuit against the NFL, which was settled in 2019. Production on the docuseries began in 2022, but the film reportedly faced delays and issues over the direction of the film.
