Wales not given fair funding for rail, says Lee Waters
Wales does not get its "fair share of rail funding" and the system must be "fixed", said a former Labour minister responsible for transport.Plans for a £6.6bn Oxford-Cambridge rail line were previously classified as an England-only project, which means Wales could have been entitled to more money.But the Treasury announced there was a "publishing error" in a 2020 document and it should have been classified as an England and Wales project.Lee Waters, the Labour MS for Llanelli said the "cock-up" highlights the broader issue of how "unclear" and in need of reform the funding system is.
Rail in Wales is not devolved, which means funding is determined through the UK government using the Barnett formula. Speaking to BBC Radio Wales Breakfast on Monday, Waters said: "Is it cockup, is it a conspiracy? Who knows - almost always a cockup in my experience."But he said "it speaks to the broader truth" that "the system needs fixing".He said: "We have not had our fair share of funding, the formula does not work to our advantage. "It is not clear how the formula works and therefore we don't trust when things like this pop up."Waters said only a few weeks ago the Welsh government "had to dip into our own coffers" to pay for the national insurance costs, which should be covered by the UK government as per a Treasury agreement."We need to reform the Barnett formula," Waters said. "We need to have the UK treasury acting as a UK treasury for the whole of the UK, not just for whoever happens to be in government in England at the time."He added that this is not "a party issue" because "this happened under the last government, it's happening under this government".He said it is "the government machine" which must be "changed and fixed".He said he is "confident" his London colleagues are ensuring Wales gets more funding, but is "less confident" they are trying to reform the Barnett formula.He said part of the issue is there "is not a Wales pot of money for rail, we have to fight our corner in the England and Wales pot."Waters said: "There's a UK Labour manifesto commitment to create a Wales fund for schemes so there can be transparency."But he said he is "nervous" about "wholesale devolution of rail without the extra funding", because it comes with the responsibility of repair work. He said: "You can argue we should get the extra funding, but it's back to 'do we trust the UK funding arrangements to do that?'"The UK government previously said the "error" over the Oxford-Cambridge line classification "will be amended when an update is published at the spending review".The HM Treasury has been approached for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
25 minutes ago
- BBC News
Commissioner calls for extra police in Reeves' spending review
The West Midlands Police and Crime Commissioner (PCC) has called on the Chancellor to use Wednesday's Spending Review to restore the region's front-line policing numbers to "pre-austerity levels". Compared to 2010 there were nearly 700 fewer police officers in the West Midlands, "despite rising demand and increasing complexity in the nature of crime", PCC Simon Foster said. He called for a "fairer funding formula" in Rachel Reeves' statement that would allocate resources based on "actual demand and need" rather than "outdated metrics".The BBC has contacted the Home Office for comment. The Spending Review on Wednesday will see Reeves set department allocations for the next three to four on Monday suggested there would be an above-inflation increase for policing, but that the Home Secretary, Yvette Cooper, had not yet reached agreement on her department's Foster said the region had been left "short-changed for far too long" after "historic under-funding".He added that it was "not fair and not just" that other force areas "had more officers than they had ever had in their force histories". "It's time for the government to take this opportunity to put that right," the PCC said. 'Opportunity to invest' He described the current funding formula as "broken and unfit for purpose"."It fails to account for the scale of demand we face, from serious organised crime to safeguarding vulnerable people. "This is not about more money, it is about delivering a fairer allocation of funding, to keep our people and communities safe and secure."Mr Foster urged the government to use the review as an "opportunity to invest in public safety" and "deliver the resources" the force needed. Follow BBC Birmingham on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
The Independent
31 minutes ago
- The Independent
Reeves' winter fuel payment U-turn shows Labour is running scared of Nigel Farage and Reform
Last week's exclusive weekly polling for The Independent is perhaps the biggest indication of why Rachel Reeves has performed a huge U-turn on winter fuel. The breakdown of the Techne UK weekly tracker poll revealed that 36 per cent of pensioners now plan to vote for Nigel Farage's Reform UK — a full 20 points ahead of Labour 's 16 per cent. As any political analyst or experienced campaigner will know, the group of voters most likely to vote are pensioners. Which may explain why pensioners with a joint income of £75,000 will now get the winter fuel payment — but hard up younger voters who cannot even get a mortgage are left to struggle. The same logic has applied to the increasingly unaffordable triple lock on the state pension rise each year while the government looks to slash benefits for the disabled and says it cannot afford to expand child benefit to more than two children per family. Labour MPs and activists came back from the Runcorn by-election, which was narrowly lost to Reform, and the local elections in May with a simple message: at the doorsteps, people were complaining about the loss of the winter fuel allowance. The issue turned Sir Keir Starmer and Ms Reeves into hate figures with nobody apparently willing to buy the argument that they needed to fill a £22bn black hole left by the Tories. Angry pensioners also probably account for the biggest group of voters to turn to Farage and Reform from Labour. The statistics show that the older that voters are, the more attracted they are to Reform's message. So it seems likely that the winter fuel policy announcement by Labour at midday on Monday — the exact moment Farage was due to deliver a keynote speech in Port Talbot, a Labour heartland of south Wales — was deliberately aimed to stop the flow of voters moving away from Labour to Reform, as well as a slide in the polls, with Farage's party now around eight points ahead. It is fair to say that Farage was laughing at Labour when he took the stage 10 minutes late, no doubt to digest the news. But it handed him ammunition to back up his claim that there is 'no doubt Reform are making the political weather'. After all it was Farage who said winter fuel would be restored by Reform. Now Labour is doing it. Before, he announced Labour would nationalise British steel. Soon after, Labour did it. It is only a matter of time before Labour do another thing Farage has claimed Reform will do and remove the two child benefit cap. Maybe Labour will follow his suggestion of reigniting Port Talbot's blast furnaces too. The drop in support for Wales run for 26 years by Labour is terrifying those around Starmer. Whichever way one looks at it, the decision to restore winter fuel to 9 million of the 11 million pensioners who lost it and the way it was done underlines that Labour is running scared of Reform and Farage.
Wales Online
34 minutes ago
- Wales Online
DWP confirms group that won't have £300 winter fuel payment restored under new rules
DWP confirms group that won't have £300 winter fuel payment restored under new rules After a hugely unpopular decision to strip universal payments and start means-testing pensioners last year, the government has confirmed more people will get support this winter - here is everything you need to know Millions of people will get a winter fuel payment this year in a major government U-turn (Image: WalesOnline/Rob Browne ) Millions of people will get a winter fuel payment this year in a major government U-turn. Pensioners with an income of £35,000 or below will get the payment worth up to £300 later this year, it was confirmed on Monday. The announcement partly reverses a controversial policy introduced last year to start means-testing the winter fuel payment, which slashed the number of pensioners receiving the support from 11.4 million to around 1.5 million. The payment, usually sent out in November or December to help with fuel costs during the colder months, had previously been automatic and the change was widely blamed for the Labour Party's collapse in public support following its general election victory. In a partial U-turn the government had earlier this year confirmed more people would receive the payment but had not provided further details until now. Under the changes around nine million people will now qualify for the payment at a cost of £1.25bn, which is expected to be recouped through recovering the payment from higher-income pensioners via HMRC. Here are the changes you need to know about and who will qualify for the changes under the new rules. For money-saving tips, sign up to our Money newsletter here What are the current rules for the winter fuel payment and what changed in 2024/25? Previously, winter fuel payments were universal and paid out to everyone over the state pension age. However, after its election victory last year the new Labour-led UK government announced it would start means-testing the payments to restrict them to those on benefits and pension credit in an effort to save money. The decision was widely criticised as targeting some of the most vulnerable and was said to have had an impact on the party's disastrous local elections performance. Article continues below In recent weeks the government confirmed a partial U-turn on its policy with Chancellor Rachel Reeves confirming that more pensioners will receive the winter fuel allowance this year but payments would not be universal. Ms Reeves told reporters at a press conference that "more people will get winter fuel payment this winter", adding that further details will be announced "as soon as we possibly can." What is changing now under the new rule? The changes, officially announced on Monday, June 9, will see all pensioners in England and Wales with an income of or below £35,000 a year receive a winter fuel payment. This extends eligibility to the vast majority of pensioners, with around nine million or over three quarters benefitting, ministers said on Monday. This change will cost around £1.25 billion in England and Wales and see means-testing of the Winter Fuel Payment save around £450 million, subject to certification by the Office for Budget Responsibility compared to the system of universal winter fuel payments. The costs will be accounted for at the Budget and incorporated into the next OBR forecast. Addressing potential questions about how the change will be funded, the government said it would "take decisions on funding in the round at that forecast to ensure the government's non-negotiable fiscal rules are met", adding that it would "not lead to permanent additional borrowing." You won't need to take any action as you will automatically receive the payment this winter if you qualify. If your income is above the threshold the money will be automatically recovered via HMRC. The payment of £200 per household, or £300 per household where there is someone over 80, will be made automatically this winter. Over 12 million pensioners across the United Kingdom will also benefit from the Triple Lock, with their State Pension set to increase by up to £1,900 this parliament. Chancellor of the Exchequer Rachel Reeves said: 'Targeting Winter Fuel Payments was a tough decision, but the right decision because of the inheritance we had been left by the previous government. It is also right that we continue to means-test this payment so that it is targeted and fair, rather than restoring eligibility to everyone including the wealthiest. 'But we have now acted to expand the eligibility of the Winter Fuel Payment so no pensioner on a lower income will miss out. This will mean over three quarters of pensioners receiving the payment in England and Wales later this winter.' Pensioners above the £35,000 threshold - around two million people in England and Wales - will have the full amount of the winter fuel payment they received automatically collected via PAYE or via their self-assessment return. No one will need to register with HMRC for this or take any further action. Pensioners who want to opt out and not receive the payment at all will be able to do so, with details to be confirmed. Article continues below
