KZN Treasury unhappy with Godongwana's R2bn guarantee to Ithala depositors
MEC Rodgers claims the proposal was made without consulting the government of provincial unity, which has rejected the minister's approach.
Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana has issued a R2 billion guarantee to the clients of state-owned Ithala Bank, much to the displeasure of the KwaZulu-Natal (KZN) government.
According to KZN Finance MEC Francois Rodgers, the minister informed South African Reserve Bank (SARB) Governor Lesetja Kganyago that a government guarantee exceeding R2 billion would be issued to facilitate payments to more than 220 000 Ithala retail depositors.
It is also alleged that Godongwana instructed Kganyago to appoint a private sector financial institution to oversee the repayment of funds.
KZN Treasury unhappy over Ithala developments
Rodgers expressed his dissatisfaction with the development, particularly the suggestion that the KZN provincial government, as Ithala's shareholder, would bear the financial responsibility for the R2 billion.
The MEC claimed this proposal was made without any consultation with the government of provincial unity (GPU), which rejects the minister's approach.
ALSO READ: Ramaphosa authorises SIU to investigate Ithala and its employees
He revealed that he had written to Godongwana seeking clarity on the matter.
'I, together with my team at KZN Treasury, have always engaged in good faith with Minister Godongwana and the National Treasury on the inherited challenges pertaining to Ithala.
'We have complied with all requests for information.
'We have also supplied detailed information of the liquidity of the entity and preferred action plans to address the inherited challenges,' the MEC said in a statement on Friday.
KZN Treasury seeking meeting with Godongwana to discuss Ithala
Rodgers explained that the provincial Treasury had indicated its intention to secure a separate guarantee for safeguarding the accounts of Ithala retail depositors.
This would involve appointing a private sector financial institution to enable depositors to access and trade on their accounts.
He also raised concerns over the status of the depositors' accounts, claiming they had been 'illegally frozen' by the repayment administrator.
READ MORE: KZN Treasury at loggerheads with Sarb over Ithala
'It is worth reiterating that Mr Godongwana's actions were never discussed with the GPU, but they have dire consequences for the provincial fiscus,' the statement further reads.
Despite this, KZN Treasury affirmed Rodgers' willingness to engage in dialogue with Godongwana and other relevant parties to reach a resolution.
'It is disappointing to note that numerous attempts by MEC Rodgers to meet with Minister Godongwana on this matter have not been met with a response.'
Ithala liquidation
This latest move by Godongwana comes in the wake of the Prudential Authority's application to the KZN High Court in Pietermaritzburg for the provisional liquidation of Ithala Bank earlier this year.
The authority claims Ithala was accepting deposits unlawfully.
Repayment administrator Johan Kruger, appointed after Ithala's banking licence exemption lapsed in December 2023, declared the institution both technically and legally insolvent.
Ithala had historically operated as a bank through several exemption notices issued under the Banks Act, despite never having been granted a formal banking licence.
The Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA) suspended Ithala's licence in August 2024 due to concerns over the institution's liquidity.
The bank's liquidation could affect at least 257 000 clients.
NOW READ: KZN government, Ithala Bank in a pickle as application removed from court roll
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
10 hours ago
- The Citizen
FSCA warning: These well-known people cannot help you to invest
The FSCA urges consumers to exercise extreme caution when investing their hard-earned money and to verify that they are dealing with a legitimate and authorised entity or broker. The Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA) is warning consumers to be cautious of deepfake videos featuring well-known individuals promoting specific investments, as well as fraudsters impersonating legitimate brokers and investment firms to scam consumers out of their money. The FSCA warns consumers to watch out for investment platforms claiming to be associated with business mogul Dr Patrice Motsepe, broadcaster Leanne Manas, President Cyril Ramaphosa and his deputy Paul Mashatile. The authority says in a statement that it has learned that the platforms may be providing financial services to the public without authorisation, while it promises unrealistic returns of between R13 000 and R17 000 per day, on an investment of only R4 500. These platforms also use fake images and deepfake videos using Motsepe, Manas, Ramaphosa and Mashatile's faces. In one of the deep fake videos, a digitally altered version of Motsepe promotes investments offered on the platform, while a manipulated video of Mashatile confirms that the platform is authorised and that investors will receive returns. Another video uses a deepfake of Ramaphosa to promote investments and guaranteed returns. The FSCA says consumers must remember that the individuals behind the platforms are not authorised in terms of any financial sector law to provide financial services to the public. When the FSCA tried to contact the individuals behind the platforms, there was no response. ALSO READ: FSCA says watch out for these scammers FSCA also warns about Momentum Metropolitan and Risto Ketola impersonators The FSCA also warns consumers to look out for fraudulent WhatsApp groups where individuals impersonate Momentum Metropolitan Holdings Limited and Risto Ketola. It says consumers must be careful when engaging with a WhatsApp group operating under the names 'Q23 Momentum Official Securities Group' and 'Q923 MOSG Official Securities Group'. These groups falsely claim to be affiliated with Ketola, the group finance director of Momentum Metropolitan Holdings, after receiving reports of a scheme where individuals use WhatsApp to solicit funds from unsuspecting consumers. The FSCA points out that the administrators of these groups fraudulently impersonate Ketola and misuse his name, image and professional credentials to promote what is described as 'structured guidance and risk-managed investment strategies'. The group claims to offer returns exceeding 160% and advertises a so-called 'check-in reward initiative,' promising up to R2 000 per month to individuals who promote the group. According to the FSCA, Momentum Metropolitan confirmed that neither it nor Ketola has any association with the WhatsApp groups. Momentum Metropolitan expressed its concern over the growing number of advertisements on Telegram, Facebook and WhatsApp fraudulently linking its brand and executives to unauthorised investment schemes. ALSO READ: FSCA warns consumers about investments with these unregistered entities FSCA also warns about individuals impersonating Brokstok The FSCA also warns consumers to be careful of individuals impersonating Brokstock SA, an authorised financial services provider (FSP) with FSP number 51404 after it received information that Zibu Masotobe Sibiya with WhatsApp number +2771 768 4632 and her associate Mike Mabuyakhulu with WhatsApp number +2779 429 3027 are impersonating Brokstock SA. The FSCA says Sibiya and Mabuyakhulu are unlawfully acting as representatives using Telegram and WhatsApp groups called Brokstock Beginner/s and an FNB bank account in the name of Brokstockshares and the account number 62871907790, with an email address brokstockshares@ Sibiya and Mabuyakhulu lure consumers into depositing funds into a fraudulent bank account. The FSCA points out that Brokstock SA confirmed that the individuals are in no way associated with Brokstock and that any representations suggesting otherwise are entirely false and misleading. Brokstock SA emphasises that it will never share its banking details on public communication channels, such as Telegram or WhatsApp. The FSCA urges the public to exercise caution regarding scams conducted through messaging services and various social media platforms, as these incidents are on the rise. ALSO READ: FSCA warns against FXnonstop offering 40% returns per week Scammers even impersonate the FSCA The FSCA also warns consumers about people impersonating the FSCA and financial services providers. The impersonators use the FSCA logo, details of its staff and fake FSCA certificates to claim an association with the authority to entice consumers to use their services or make investments. The FSCA impersonators offer members of the public help to claim refunds from investments they made with financial service providers, and also offer help to recoup losses they suffered through trading in investment instruments such as crypto assets. 'The impersonators of the FSCA are not authorised in terms of any financial sector law to provide financial services. The FSCA has no association with those impersonating it.' The impersonators also use the FSP numbers issued to authorised financial service providers to solicit investments from members of the public. In addition to using the FSP numbers, the impersonators also use the details of staff and management of financial service providers to lend legitimacy to their operations. The FSCA emphasises that the impersonators are not authorised in terms of any financial sector law to provide financial services. The financial service providers who were impersonated denied any association with these impersonators: Geronimo 2 Audacity Capital, USA Sarasohn Ximen and Aguilar Navarro Joaquin. Despite its attempts, the FSCA was unable to get hold of any of the impersonators. The FSCA reminds consumers to treat any entity or individual purporting to represent the FSCA or to be a financial service provider on any platform with suspicion and to contact the FSCA immediately. ALSO READ: FSCA fines 2 pension fund bosses R30 million each, debars them for 30 years FSCA says this is how to stay out of trouble with the impersonators The FSCA says to avoid unnecessary risk, consumers must not accept financial advice, assistance, or investment offers from individuals or entities not authorised by the FSCA. Authorised financial services providers must clearly display their authorisation status in their documentation. 'If this is not present, consumers must first investigate further before making any payments. We also urge consumers to exercise caution when considering investment or trading offers on social media platforms or any unsolicited offers,' the FSCA says. The authority recommended that you protect yourself by first verifying: That an entity or individual is authorised by the FSCA to provide financial products and services, including giving recommendations about how to invest The category of advice the person is registered to provide, as there are instances where companies or people are registered to provide basic advice for a low-risk product and then offer advice on far more complex and risky products. The FSP number of the entity or individual offering financial services matches the name of the financial service provider on the FSCA database. The FSCA says you can use one of these methods to confirm the status and FSP number of a service provider or someone who claims to be an authorised service provider:
IOL News
13 hours ago
- IOL News
KAP flags lower annual earnings ahead amid challenging trading conditions
Unitrans completed a major organisational redesign in November 2024 Image: File KAP, the group with industrial, chemical and logistics divisions, on Tuesday warned that it expects lower earnings for 2025 amid challenging trading conditions. Earnings per share (eps) is expected to decrease by more than 30% for 2025, which is a decrease of at least 13.1 cents per share from 43.8 cents the prior comparative period. Headline earnings per share (heps) is expected to decrease by more than 30% for 2025, which is a decrease of at least 13.6 cents per share, when compared to the heps of 45.3 cents for the year ended June 30, 2024. In an update guidance on the company's operational performance for 11 months of the 2025 financial year up to May 31, 2025, compared with the prior comparative period, KAP said trading conditions have remained challenging, with sentiment further dampened by the uncertainty created by the delay in the approval of the national budget, the resultant instability of the Government of National Unity and the potential negative effects of the US's tariff war. Additionally, April was a particularly weak month due to the limited trading days. In this context, the group delivered a modest growth in revenue, a reduction in Ebitda, a decline in operating profit and meaningfully lower earnings during the period. KAP said it continues to make progress with the execution of its strategy, to realise value from the major capital projects; improve the financial performance of underperforming businesses, mostly Unitrans; and the reduction of net debt. Divisional performance: PG Bison successfully started and ramped up its new R2 billion MDF (Medium-density fiberboard) line in Mkhondo in the first half of 2025. Revenue was higher due to a 90% increase in MDF domestic and export sales volumes, primarily attributable to the higher MDF production. Particleboard sales volumes were stable. Operating profit declined as the depreciation and running costs of the new MDF line were absorbed during the period, with utilisation not yet optimal due to the ramp-up process. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Next Stay Close ✕ Safripol delivered an increase in revenue and operating profit, largely due to higher production and sales volumes. Unitrans completed a major organisational redesign in November 2024, which formed part of a deep restructuring focused on the cessation of low-margin, low-return activities, improved asset utilisation and reduced costs. Feltex encountered challenging trading conditions, mainly because of lower vehicle production, with two major OEM customers being meaningfully lower due to temporary operational constraints at their plants. Sleep Group increased revenue and operating profit, primarily due to growth in sales of bedding units, despite a subdued bedding and furniture market. Optix delivered lower revenue and operating profit, with suboptimal conversion of the sales pipeline. Balance sheet KAP said it has completed a major investment cycle, with all projects commissioned and operational. "The only remaining major capital commitment relates to improving the average fleet age of Unitrans' vehicles. This catch- up capital expenditure will be phased over three to five years and we therefore do not expect it to have a major impact in any single year," it said. "We invested in future growth, of which PG Bison's new MDF line is the largest and most recent investment. The line resulted in a 33% increase in the division's total production capacity and offers compelling growth opportunities for the group, it said. KAP said it was making good progress in addressing areas of underperformance, the most material of which relates to Unitrans, where an operating profit of R700 million is targeted over the medium term. Reducing net debt is also a priority.
The South African
15 hours ago
- The South African
The small SA town where property prices grow by R1m each year
Demand for property in South Africa's Western Cape has increased tenfold, with property prices in some areas surging by the million each year. As reported by BusinessTech , these areas, especially the smaller seaside towns, are attracting both local and foreign property buyers. One such popular area is the fishing village of Kalk Bay, which has seen property prices go up by R1 million every year since 2020. Kalk Bay, a small, quirky fishing village on the False Bay coast of Cape Town, is known for its bohemian vibe, colourful harbour, and mix of old-school charm and modern edge. BusinessTech reported that from 2020 to 2025, house prices in areas along False Bay increased from 20% to as much as 150%. According to Lightstone Property and Seeff Property data, Kalk Bay full-title house prices increased from R4.9 million in 2020 to R9 million at the start of 2025 – a staggering 83% increase. On average, sectional title property (apartments, town houses) prices also increased by 150% over the same period, from R2 million to R5 million. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
