
Breakingviews - Railway mega-deal would require heavy engineering
Consolidation ground to a halt after a series of mergers in the 1990s shrank dozens of freight carriers into just seven, and was blamed for derailments, disruptions and losses. The government introduced stiffer rules requiring that any large deal enhance competition rather than simply not hurt it. Anticipation of widespread regulatory rollbacks under the Trump administration and sluggish railroad growth prospects have changed the calculus, however, with Union Pacific CEO Jim Vena recently touting the advantages of a cross-country line before the Wall Street Journal reported, opens new tab early deal negotiations on Thursday.
Setting aside how pliable Washington's Surface Transportation Board may be, connecting 50,000 track miles into one unified network has some logic. The existing regional system adds costs, including from transferring railcars and complicating service routes. With about 40% of all traffic directly tied, opens new tab to international trade, according to an industry group, higher tariffs also pose a fresh hurdle to increasing revenue at companies which have already firmly squeezed expenses.
The harder question relates to value creation. The best, albeit imperfect, comparison is Canadian Pacific's 2023 acquisition of Kansas City Southern, which was grandfathered into the older merger rules, for $31 billion. The buyer promised, opens new tab $1 billion in annual synergies, the bulk coming from growth equal to about 8% of combined revenue and the rest from slashing almost 3% of combined operating expenses.
On that basis, Union Pacific would be able to generate about $3.6 billion of synergies, according to Breakingviews estimates. Assuming Union Pacific were to pay the same 23% premium as Canadian Pacific did, valuing the Norfolk Southern enterprise at some $91 billion including net debt, the implied return on invested capital, with the revenue uplift and expense savings factored in, would be about 7%.
To just match the target's 7.9% weighted average cost of capital, as estimated by Morningstar analysts, would require some $4.6 billion of synergies. That considerable sum may be within reach, at least according to Bernstein analysts. They see potential benefits of between $4 billion and $5 billion. At more than 12% of the top lines for both companies, or nearly a third of their total operating expenses, it sounds optimistic. Absent some creative engineering, the effort hardly looks worth the long haul.
Follow Jeffrey Goldfarb on X, opens new tab and Linkedin, opens new tab.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Daily Mail
13 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Clue that Karoline Leavitt is closer than ever to Trump as he comes out swinging on Scotland trip
President Donald Trump was ready to apply some extra spin as he hit the links at his Turnberry golf course, bringing White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt to join him on his golf outing. It was just the latest demonstration that Leavitt has carved out a place inside Trump's close inner circle. Trump stood alongside Leavitt as he addressed reporters outside the White House on a recent trip – something he usually does solo. Now, he has his White House spin-master at his disposal should another shoe drop in the Jeffrey Epstein case – after top DOJ official and former Trump lawyer Todd Blanche spent two days meeting with Epstein's former girlfriend Ghislaine Maxwell. Leavitt has been fielding increasingly pointed questions from the press on Trump's behalf about the Jeffrey Epstein matter. This week, she accused the press of trying to 'sow distrust and chaos' – the same terms U.S. intelligence applied to Russian election interference in reports Trump's DNI Tulsi Gabbard declassified. The president blocked off his Saturday for golf at his treasured course, with no planned public events on what the White House is calling a five-day 'working visit.' He hit the course early on a crisp day with temperatures in the 60s, sporting a white USA baseball hat after a massive law enforcement effort to secure the course. (An eagle eyed Secret Service agent spotted a shooter in September 2024 when Trump was playing at his West Palm Beach, Florida course). He was joined Saturday by son Eric Trump, who Trump says 'is going to cut a ribbon' when Trump inaugurates his new course in Aberdeenshire. Also on the course with Trump at Turnberry was U.S. Ambassador Warren Stephens and his son, according to the White House. Stephens is a former CEO of a family investment fund who was an exec at Tyson Foods. 'He's a very, very successful man,' Trump told reporters Friday. A White House official wasn't sure if Leavitt got any swings in, but she was pictured riding in a golf cart and walking around in Trump's pack. Trump, 79, an experienced golfer, won't be needing Leavitt's advice on the greens. But his White House has been in crisis communications mode amid the evolving Jeffrey Epstein saga. Trump addressed Epstein as soon as he landed, accusing reporters of 'making a very big thing over something that's not a big thing,' he said. He threw out plenty of other issues to get people talking, telling Europeans to 'get your act together' on immigration and pleading to 'stop the windmills – you're ruining your countries.' There are accumulating signs that Trump is not here to pick a fight with his British hosts, however, after inking a trade deal with Starmer at G7 meetings in Canada this summer. Trump landed in Scotland Friday night sounding upbeat about British PM Keir Starmer, who he will meet on Monday. 'I like your prime minister – slightly more liberal than I am, as you probably heard, but he's a good man. He got a trade deal done,' Trump told reporters after landing in Glasgow. The fate of a trade deal with the European Union is less certain. Trump puts the chance of success at 50-50 – with bruising tariffs on autos and other products set to take effect August 1 if there is no deal. 'I don't want to tell you what the sticking points are, but the sticking points are having to do with maybe 20 different things,' Trump said. Trump's White House Chief of Staff Susie Wiles and Communications Director Steven Cheung remained home during the trip, where officials are contending not only with the Epstein matter but with a looming August 1 deadline for tariffs Trump has said he'll impose. Also top of mind for Trump is pitching his Turnberry golf course to host a future British Open. 'The best course anywhere in the world, is Turnberry. The players all want to be a Turnberry. Everybody wants to be a Turnberry,' Trump said, even bragging about electrical infrastructure the Royal & Ancient Golf Club has put down in the past.


Daily Mail
13 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
How nine families in Silicon Valley have total wealth of $638B
Silicon Valley is the epicenter of America's tech hub, attracting many of the world's richest individuals and generating an estimated wealth of $638 billion. But now it has emerged that the eye-watering sum is shared between just nine families. And a new study conducted by San Jose State University concluded that the city's wealthiest households are only gaining wealth. Their collective net worth was up by a staggering $136 billion from 2024, according to the recent data. The annual report, titled the Silicon Valley Pain Index,is designed to measure 'personal and community distress' through data tracking structural inequalities in the region. Silicon Valley refers to the southern part of the San Francisco Bay Area, including Santa Clara, San Mateo, the western edge of Alameda, and Scotts Valley in Santa Cruz. It represents a high concentration of wealth and can be an increasingly difficult place for working and middle-class families to make ends meet. Meta boss Mark Zuckerberg is among the ritzy residents, accounting for $253.5 billion of the area's wealth. Zuckerberg's net worth is more than 20 times the wealth of the bottom 446,505 households in the area. The Meta CEO purchased a five-house compound in the area, estimated to be worth a whopping $37million. He bought a $7 million mansion in 2011 before buying the neighboring residences to create the compound. The report also estimates that the region has $1.01 trillion of liquid wealth. Three companies based in Silicon Valley - Adobe, Alphabet (Google), and Meta comprise a combined net worth of $535 billion. Even outside of the nine wealthiest families, the annual income needed to afford just a median-priced house is $370,000, up 54 percent in the last six years, according to the report. The report also found that renters need to have an average annual income of $136,532 to afford an apartment at 30 percent of their take-home pay, representing the highest rents in the country. In San Mateo County, a household annual income of $156,650 for a family of four is considered 'low, ' compared to the state average of $94,500. Nearly 71 percent of homes sold in the area were priced around 1.92 million and were considered the 'median home price.' The median home price in Santa Clara alone was 2.171 million in May, which is a 3.4 percent increase from last year. The study doesn't explicitly state the nine families contributing to the mass concentration of wealth in addition to Zuckerberg, but listed Google's former CEO, Larry Page, as the second richest billionaire in the area. Sergey Brin , who co-founded Google with Page and served as the president of Alphabet, is the third-wealthiest billionaire in the region. Jensen Huang, the CEO of Nvidia, an artificial intelligence company, comes in fourth. Page and Zuckerberg live in Palo Alto, while Brin and Huang have properties in Los Altos Hills. Former Google CEO Eric Schmidt is listed as the fifth-wealthiest billionaire in the region, with Dustin Moskovitz of Facebook as the sixth. Financier George Roberts was listed seventh, while Laurence Powell Jobs of Apple came in eighth. Venture capitalist John Doerr came in ninth, and Charles Schwab of Charles Schwab brokerage ranked tenth. Silicon Valley is home to major enterprises including Apple, Alphabet, Chevron, Meta, Visa, and Wells Fargo. The companies employ a significant portion of residents in the region, leading to the high concentration of wealth from executives and engineers reporting high incomes. The success of these companies has solidified Silicon Valley as a wealthy enclave and the tech capital of the world, but the region has a long history of advancement. The silicon chip, which is used in computerized machinery, was invented in the region, and electronics reporter Dan Hoefler coined the name 'Silicon Valley' in 1971. Since then, the area has grown wealthier and wealthier, and is now home to the world's richest billionaires.


The Guardian
13 minutes ago
- The Guardian
‘Hundreds' of people have been removed from ‘Alligator Alcatraz' detention camp, says Florida governor
Florida has begun deporting people from the notorious 'Alligator Alcatraz' detention camp, the state's governor said, and deportations are expected to increase in the coming weeks. At a press conference at the controversial facility, Ron DeSantis said 'hundreds of illegals have been removed' from the facility. He later clarified that most of those were flown from Alligator Alcatraz to other detention facilities in the US. DeSantis, who has built a political career on his anti-immigration views, said 100 people had been deported from the US. 'I'm pleased to report that those flights out of Alligator Alcatraz by [the Department of Homeland Security] have begun. The cadence is increasing,' DeSantis said. 'We've already had a number of flights. … Hundreds of illegals have been removed from here,' De Santis said. He added: 'We look forward to this cadence increasing.' Officials said two or three flights have so far departed, but didn't say where those flights were headed. Last week, a number of non-profit organizations demanded the closure of the facility, which is based in the rural Everglades region, about 40 miles (64km) from Miami. The facility's conditions are reportedly appalling, advocates said, with detained immigrants sleeping in overcrowded pods, along with sewage backups 'resulting in cages flooded with feces', and, in addition, 'denial of medical care'. Advocates said the 39-acre camp, which was built in a matter of days, now holds more than 1,000 men in 'flood-prone' tents. Donald Trump said the jail would be reserved for immigrants who were 'deranged psychopaths' and 'some of the most vicious people on the planet' who were awaiting deportation, but in mid-July it emerged that the jail contains hundreds of detainees with no criminal records or charges. Democrats have sued DeSantis, demanding access to the facility. Kevin Guthrie, executive director of the Florida division of emergency management, said the facility had grown, in less than a month, to have a current capacity of 2,000 people. That will increase to 4,000, he said. Sign up to This Week in Trumpland A deep dive into the policies, controversies and oddities surrounding the Trump administration after newsletter promotion Guthrie defended conditions inside the facility, claiming that 'whether it's Florida standard or national standard [of conditions and services in detention facilities], we meet or exceed the higher standard'. Since the jail opened in early July, the Trump administration and local officials have specifically touted the brutality of the facility, including its remote location in a wetland surrounded by alligators, crocodiles, pythons and swarms of mosquitoes. Officials have also seemed to revel in the crude name the facility has been given, echoing the long-shut and notoriously harsh Alcatraz prison in San Francisco Bay.