Mamata Banerjee's new OBC list also hits high court hurdle
West Bengal CM Mamata Banerjee
KOLKATA: Calcutta HC temporarily stayed Tuesday Bengal govt's new OBC list of 140 sub-groups - 80 Muslim, 60 non-Muslim - till July 31, halting a move that had replaced the earlier 113-group list struck down by the court in May last year.
A division bench of Justices Tapabrata Chakraborty and Rajasekhar Mantha paused the June 3 gazette notification and all related state orders, including the portal inviting OBC caste certificate applications. HC found procedural flaws in the state's execution under West Bengal Commission for Backward Classes Act, 1993, after the 2012 law had been adopted.
"The next obvious step after passing the draft notification on OBC laid in the assembly would have been to introduce an amendment to the 2012 Act," said Justice Mantha.
"You complied with the legislative procedure the court ordered in May 2024. But then you abandoned the 2012 Act and took steps under the 1993 Act."
Justice Chakraborty questioned why the state was pushing ahead when the matter was pending before Supreme Court. "Keep your hands off until Supreme Court hears the matter. We are not going to pass any interim order," he said. Supreme Court's next hearing is scheduled for July.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Free P2,000 GCash eGift
UnionBank Credit Card
Apply Now
Undo
Bengal govt is weighing a challenge to the temporary stay. "It is an interlocutory order, but there are grounds to appeal. The apex court was informed during the March hearing that a fresh survey was underway," a senior official said.
The new list expanded the number of Muslim sub-groups from 77 to 80 and non-Muslim groups from 36 to 60. CM Mamata Banerjee had defended the formula last week: "Backwardness, not religion, was the sole criterion in the fresh OBC survey in Bengal."
The stay could affect admissions and recruitment as current OBC reservations will drop below 17% without the expanded list.
Senior counsel S Sriram, representing the petitioner, said the executive had no authority under the 2012 Act to declare OBC reservations. "The 2012 Act explicitly states that only the legislature can make provisions for reservation under the Act or Article 16(4) of the Constitution," he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
30 minutes ago
- Time of India
Ghost villages on paper: 413 Telangana hamlets never officially mapped; real estate boom meets legal chaos
HYDERABAD: Even in the 21st century, Telangana continues to grapple with a colonial-era legacy-413 villages across the state have never been surveyed and mapped. What makes this more startling is that nearly 25% of these villages fall within the rapidly expanding Hyderabad metropolitan region, where land prices have skyrocketed to crores per acre. These villages, including upscale and rapidly urbanising areas such as Hafeezpet, Raidurg Paigah, Budvel, Manikonda Jagir, and Future City areas like Kandukur, Meerkhanpet and Mucherla, have no official land survey records or authenticated village maps. Of the total 413 unsurveyed villages, 58 fall in Rangareddy district and 11 in Medchal Malkajgiri, placing them at the heart of Telangana's urban expansion. According to official sources, out of Telangana's 11,894 revenue villages, several hundred were excluded from land surveys conducted during the Nizam era, primarily because they were deemed agriculturally unproductive and thus not prioritised for tax-based documentation. These unsurveyed villages are spread across the erstwhile districts of Adilabad, Karimnagar, Warangal, Medak, Khammam, Nalgonda, and Mahbubnagar. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Click Here Expertinspector Click Here Undo Absence of records led to flood of litigations Post-Independence, neither the united AP govt nor Telangana state took corrective steps. Several of these areas remained unmapped or were recorded using rudimentary and often inaccurate methods. "In many villages, maps are either missing or unsigned, and critical documents like tippons and sethwars are absent or forged," said a senior revenue official. "Without these, there is no clarity on ownership or boundaries," he explained. In Rangareddy and Medchal Malkajgiri districts, where land prices can exceed ₹10 crore per acre, the absence of reliable land records has led to a flood of litigations, title disputes, encroachments, and fabricated claims. In Hyderabad's northwestern corridors, particularly Kukatpally, Moosapet and Medchal, similar issues persist. Buyers and developers often enter into transactions with incomplete legal backing, risking future litigation. According to experts, land records in these unsurveyed villages often depend solely on pahanis (annual land records), which record possession but not ownership or boundaries in the absence of survey numbers. "Between 1910 and 1940, the Nizam's govt conducted only partial land surveys, mostly carried out by teams from Marathwada. In the absence of official maps and survey numbers, most farmers have relied on notional surveys while continuing to possess and cultivate these lands," explained land law expert M Sunil Kumar. Land survey expert Ch V Subba Rao said two types of land surveys were carried out in Telangana-both during the Nizam era and later. "The Theodolite survey, which uses precision instruments, was conducted in some villages and provides accurate land measurements. In other areas, a less precise method known as the 'chain survey' was used," said Subba Rao, former joint director of the survey and land records department.
Time of India
30 minutes ago
- Time of India
Supreme Court greenlights razing of 17 illegal buildings on pvt land in Thane
Representative Image NEW DELHI: Supreme Court Tuesday okayed implementation of a Bombay HC order directing demolition of 17 buildings illegally constructed in Thane on private land and said if "such courageous steps" are not taken, the day is not far when Gateway of India will be encroached upon by the land mafia in collusion with the underworld and officials. A partial working day bench of Justices Ujjal Bhuyan and Manmohan refused to stay the demolition order, pursuant to which Thane MC had demolished 8 buildings, on a plea by one Danish Zaheer Siddiqui, who claimed he had purchased a flat in those buildings. "How did you purchase a flat? These buildings are built illegally on encroached private land without any clearance from authorities. Did you check documents of the property prior to purchasing a flat in the illegal building? You can file a suit to recover the money paid to the builder. But these illegal buildings must go," the bench said, forcing the petitioner to withdraw his plea. "It is shocking. HC suspects that the underworld, in collusion with land mafia and officials, are behind largescale illegal construction of buildings without any permission from any authority. For once, HC has taken a courageous stand," it said. The HC bench had also asked Thane municipal commissioner to undertake a detailed survey of all illegal constructions in his jurisdiction and initiate action.
India Gazette
33 minutes ago
- India Gazette
Calcutta HC grants interim stay on WB Govt's OBC list notification till July 31
Kolkata (West Bengal) [India], June 18 (ANI): The Calcutta High Court on Monday gave an interim stay on the West Bengal government's recently issued notifications on the OBC list till July 31. This order is a big setback for the Mamata government. A division bench comprising Justice Tapabrata Chakraborty and Justice Raja Sekhar Mantha passed the interim order while hearing petitions challenging the state's classification of communities under the Other Backward Classes (OBC) category. Judges said that necessary steps should be taken regarding the 66 communities belonging to the OBC category. In this latest OBC notification there are listed 140 communities. However, OBC certificates issued before 2010 under the 1993 law remain valid for employment and admissions. The bench warned that the executive cannot bypass legislative procedures, stating that half the process was followed and the rest done unilaterally. Petitioners claimed the survey was flawed, with limited samples and negligible changes from the earlier list. The state admitted that college admissions and recruitment are stalled due to the case. During the hearing, Solicitor General Ashok Chakraborty, representing the Centre, pointed out that the National Commission for Backward Classes (NCBC) had sought clarification from the state on how Muslim and OBC classifications were identified. The NCBC minutes mentioned that several communities had converted from Hinduism to Islam, complicating census data. Justice Rajasekhar Mantha raised the question to state, saying, 'You have done half the work according to the 2012 OBC Act. Then you have gone back to the 1993 Act. Why is this? Why didn't you amend the 2012 Act? You have been providing benefits for the last 15 years. The law says that a survey has to be done after 10 years. That survey has not been done.' (ANI)
