&w=3840&q=100)
Why India's air defence is superior to Pakistan's
Russian S-400 air defence mobile missile launching systems take part in a military parade during celebrations marking Independence Day in Minsk, July 3, 2014. File Image/Reuters
India's ability to intercept and destroy incoming aerial threats with speed and accuracy has grown dramatically over the past two decades, giving it a decisive advantage in regional air defence.
The scale of this technological and strategic superiority came into sharp focus on Thursday night when Indian air defence systems successfully foiled all aerial attempts by Pakistan as many locations in the western states were targeted.
'Pakistan Armed Forces launched multiple attacks using drones and other munitions along entire Western Border on the intervening night of 08 and 09 May 2025. Pak troops also resorted to numerous cease fire violations (CFVs) along the Line of Control in Jammu and Kashmir,' the Indian Army said in a statement on X.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
'The drone attacks were effectively repulsed and befitting reply was given to the CFVs,' the statement added.
While both nations have continued to invest in upgrading their defence capabilities, India's air defence apparatus has emerged as far more advanced — both in technological sophistication and operational readiness — compared to Pakistan's largely foreign-dependent systems.
Why India's air defences are superior
India has invested significantly in a multi-tiered air defence system capable of countering a variety of threats — from fighter aircraft and cruise missiles to UAVs and ballistic missiles.
Central to this network is the Russian-origin S-400 Triumf, one of the most advanced long-range surface-to-air missile systems in the world. With its ability to detect and engage multiple targets at extended ranges, the S-400 is a significant force multiplier for the Indian Air Force (IAF).
The system's capabilities were validated in a recent exercise conducted by the IAF, where the S-400 reportedly intercepted and destroyed 80 percent of simulated aerial targets.
According to a July 2024 report, India has inducted three squadrons of the S-400, with two more scheduled for delivery by 2026, bringing full operational capability within reach.
The S-400 can detect threats up to 600 km away and strike targets within a 400 km radius. Its radar can track approximately 300 objects simultaneously and guide missiles to engage 36 of them at once. These features offer a qualitative edge over any comparable system currently fielded in the region.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
Beyond the S-400, India has developed and deployed a range of other systems to cover short- and medium-range threats. These include the indigenous Akash missile system developed by the Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO), with an interception range of around 45 km.
The Akash plays a key role in India's medium-range ground-based air defence layer and is deployed across several sensitive locations.
The medium-range Akash air defence system is in service with the Indian Army and Air Force. Image/BEL
For rapid-response capabilities, the Israeli-origin SPYDER (Surface-to-air PYthon and DERby) system is operational with both the Indian Air Force and Indian Army.
Designed for low-altitude and short-range engagement, the SPYDER system fills a critical niche in protecting forward installations and airbases.
India also maintains a number of legacy Russian systems such as the Pechora (with a 25 km range) and OSA-AK-M (with a 10 km range), as well as upgraded L-70 anti-aircraft guns, which, though initially inducted decades ago, have been modernised with electro-optical fire control systems and integrated into contemporary air defence networks.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
Portable systems are another critical layer. The Igla-S and Igla-1M, both Russian-origin man-portable air defence systems (MANPADS), are deployed with the Indian Army and Air Force for close-in protection. These lightweight systems offer quick reaction time and are particularly effective in mobile and mountainous deployments.
Additionally, the Indian armed forces are preparing for future air defence needs through the development of new indigenous systems. Among these is the Very Short Range Air Defence System (VSHORADS), designed to replace older MANPADS and offer enhanced targeting through an integrated optical and infrared seeker.
At the higher end, DRDO's long-range surface-to-air missile project, known as Project Kusha, aims to deliver missiles with ranges up to 350 km — another step toward reducing dependence on imports and establishing full-spectrum indigenous capabilities.
How Pakistan's air defence are lacking
Pakistan, for its part, has continued to modernise its air defence with a primary focus on Chinese technology, along with some legacy Western systems. The HQ-9, Pakistan's long-range surface-to-air missile system, is derived from Chinese designs and is roughly comparable in architecture to older versions of the Russian S-300.
Its base version can strike aerial targets within a 120 km range, while extended variants can reportedly reach up to 300 km. It is equipped with tracking and guidance radars but lacks the multi-target engagement breadth and sensor integration seen in the S-400.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
Pakistan also fields the HQ-16, a medium-range system also supplied by China, with an engagement envelope of about 40 km. Though effective for area defence, it cannot match India's Akash or SPYDER systems in reaction time and overall mobility.
An older but still operational component of Pakistan's air defence network is the Spada 2000, a short-range missile system of Italian origin. It provides coverage over smaller, high-value installations but is considered outdated by modern standards and may not be sufficient against saturated or complex aerial threats.
Despite these systems, experts note that Pakistan lacks the kind of layered redundancy that India has built. The Pakistani military relies on fewer air defence platforms and a smaller detection and tracking infrastructure, which could leave gaps in comprehensive national coverage.
Another major difference lies in indigenous capacity. India's emphasis on developing its own systems, from radar and missiles to command and control systems, allows greater autonomy in both strategic planning and logistics.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
Indigenous systems are easier to maintain, upgrade, and adapt to specific regional needs, and they reduce vulnerabilities to foreign sanctions or supply disruptions.
Pakistan, by contrast, remains heavily dependent on Chinese suppliers, and any escalation could expose it to supply chain and maintenance limitations. This over-reliance not only affects operational endurance but also limits the ability to rapidly adapt or scale capabilities during a prolonged conflict.
The IAF's operational doctrine increasingly leans on integrated air command and control, allowing for real-time coordination between detection assets, missile batteries and interceptor aircraft. This was on full display during the night of May 8, when Indian air defences were placed on high alert and succeeded in intercepting all aerial attempts by Pakistan across the border and LoC.
The lack of any damage or successful penetration has put a spotlight on the preparedness and efficiency of India's air defence forces.
Also Watch:
With inputs from agencies
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
19 minutes ago
- First Post
India plans to open uranium sector to private players to boost nuclear expansion
The move aims to attract billions of dollars and support the country's ambitious goal to expand nuclear power capacity 12 fold by 2047 India is planning to open its uranium mining, import, and processing sector to private companies, ending a decades-long state monopoly, according to a Reuters report, citing government sources. This move aims to attract billions of dollars and support the country's ambitious goal to expand nuclear power capacity 12 fold by 2047. In April, Reuters had reported that Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government is also planning to relax requirements to allow foreign players to take a minority stake in power plants. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Currently, India's government tightly controls uranium mining and processing due to concerns over nuclear material misuse, radiation safety, and strategic security. It will, however, continue to manage spent uranium reprocessing and plutonium waste handling, in line with international norms. To meet rising demand for nuclear fuel amid this expansion, the government is drafting a regulatory framework that would allow private Indian firms to participate in mining, importing, and processing uranium. The policy is expected to be announced within the current fiscal year, reported Reuters. In addition, private companies may be permitted to supply critical control system equipment for nuclear power plants, sources said. Globally, countries such as Canada, South Africa, and the United States already allow private firms to mine and process uranium. Domestic supply not enough According to government data, India has an estimated 76,000 tonnes of uranium — enough to power 10,000 megawatts of nuclear energy for 30 years. However, sources cautioned that domestic reserves would cover only about 25% of the fuel needed to support the country's planned nuclear expansion. The remaining demand would require imports, along with a significant boost to uranium processing capacity. In its February 1 budget announcement, the government revealed its intention to open up the nuclear sector, though it did not provide specifics. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD The move has since prompted several major Indian conglomerates to begin drafting investment plans. Still, experts warn that implementing the policy may face hurdles, as revising existing legislation could prove legally and politically complex. 'It's a major and bold initiative by the Indian Government which is critical for achieving the target,' Reuters quoted Charudatta Palekar, independent power sector consultant, as saying. 'The challenge will be to define quickly the rules of engagement with private sector,' Palekar added. New Delhi will have to change five laws, including the ones regulating mining and electricity sectors and India's foreign direct investment policy to enable private participation in many identified activities, the sources said. With inputs from agencies
India Today
28 minutes ago
- India Today
Can India afford to ignore Pakistan's repeated threats? Experts debate on Gaurav Sawant's show
After Field Marshal Asim Munir, Bilawal Bhutto Zardari and now Pakistan's Prime Minister Shahbaz Sharif has threatened India over the Indus waters treaty, which has been held in abeyance since May following the Pahalgam terror attack. On Tuesday, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif said, "I want to tell the enemy today that if you threaten to hold our water, then keep this in mind that you cannot snatch even one drop of Pakistan.' A day earlier, former foreign minister Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari termed the IWT's suspension an attack on the Indus Valley Civilisation and said the nation would not back down if New Delhi forced it into war. There's a clear pattern to these threats that are emerging from Pakistan. So, can India afford to ignore these repeated Pakistani threats and has US President Donald Trump sacrificed the India-US strategic partnership at the altar of a cryptocurrency deal with Pakistan or to regain a toehold in the region to keep an eye on Iran or is there another game at play here? Watch as experts discuss these and more on the show.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
J&K: Soldier killed in Uri as Army foils LoC infiltration bid; Chinar Corps expressed 'deepest condolences'
SRINAGAR: Havildar Ankit Kumar of 9 Bihar Regiment was killed early Wednesday while fighting armed intruders near the Loc in Uri sector of north Kashmir's Baramulla district — the third Army fatality in five days in counterterrorism operations, raising the year's security death toll in J&K to 17. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Army's 15 Corps, or Chinar Corps, confirmed on social media the death of Kumar, 35, and expressed 'deepest condolences' to the bereaved family. Sources said the infiltration bid was foiled, but the intruders exploited poor visibility and monsoon rain to retreat into PoK. It was the first such attempt in Uri since Operation Sindoor in early May when heavy Pakistani firing and shelling followed India's destruction of terrorist infrastructure in PoK and Pakistan after the April 22 Pahalgam massacre that left 22 people dead, most of them tourists. 'This is clear proof that old patterns of infiltration attempts backed by Pakistan will persist,' said Luv Puri, former UN counterterrorism official and Kashmir analyst. 'In the current climate where renewed US-Pakistan engagement is being discussed, the purpose of the infiltration attempt seems to be to signal that nothing has changed and that shifting geopolitical winds may only have emboldened them to make this point. ' The Uri clash came a day after the Army ended an 11-day offensive in south Kashmir's Kulgam district, where two soldiers — Lance Naik Pritpal Singh and Sepoy Harminder Singh of 19 Rashtriya Rifles — were killed and 10 personnel wounded before a terrorist was shot dead. Of the 17 security personnel killed in J&K operations this year, four have died in Kashmir and 13 in Jammu division. Security forces have killed 14 terrorists in Kashmir so far in 2025, among them three top Lashkar-e-Taiba operatives linked to the Pahalgam attack, gunned down in Srinagar on July 28. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Tight security is in place for Independence Day events across Kashmir valley, with intensified patrols along the border. On Monday, soldier Banoth Anil Kumar died after falling into a deep gorge during a routine patrol near the LoC in Uri sector. He was from Telangana.
