Attitudes to immigration more negative in disadvantaged areas
Research has found that it is not the case that migrants in Ireland are more likely to live in disadvantaged communities.
The findings relate to a survey of just over 1,200 adults conducted in April 2023, Census 2022 and additional data on the communities they live in.
Last year, applications for asylum in Ireland rose sharply.
However, there has been a decline of around 40% in those seeking international protection so far this year.
Based on the data used in the research, living in a rural area was associated with more negative attitudes towards immigration, compared with living in an urban area.
However, rural areas with high percentages of migrants had attitudes toward immigration that were "very similar" to those in urban areas.
This may reflect the importance of "social contact" with migrants for fostering more positive attitudes, according to the report authors.
The study found that more segregated areas - where migrants live in clusters rather than evenly spread across the area - show more negative attitudes towards immigration.
It reiterates the possibility of social contact with migrants as a means of facilitating understanding.
Researchers investigated whether people living in areas with greater pressure on services like health, housing and education held more negative attitudes towards immigration.
Using indicators such as the number of GPs per household and housing affordability (high rents and high house prices), they found no evidence of a link.
When it comes to pressure on services, it says indications are that it may not be direct local experiences that impact attitudes but "may instead be concern about pressure on services in Ireland as a whole".
The ESRI study is the first to consider the role of 'community characteristics' in shaping immigration attitudes in Ireland, which it describes as "a new immigration country" that experienced a rapid increase in asylum seekers and refugees in the year prior to the survey.
According to the report author Fran McGinnity, it shows that local communities can generate both obstacles to, but also opportunities for, social integration between non-migrants and migrants.
"Communities are spaces where migrants and non-migrants not only encounter each other but can also form lasting social ties," he said.
"This could be as next-door neighbours, as parents of children going to the same school, or in community groups.
"This kind of positive social contact between migrants and non-migrants can go a long way to generating positive relations between groups as well as building stronger, more cohesive communities in the long run."
Co-author Keire Murphy said the report offered an "important insight" into what makes anti-immigrant sentiment more likely.
"Echoing international findings, socio-economic factors like community-level disadvantage seem to matter, implying that the broader social and economic context is important for attitudes towards immigration," she said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Post
5 days ago
- Irish Post
New report shows people in disadvantaged areas have a more negative view of migrants
A NEW report from the Economic and Social Research Institute (ESRI) shows that public opinion on immigration is more negative in disadvantaged areas. The study is based on a survey of over 1,200 people in 2023 along with data from the 2022 Census. Researchers suggest that fears about pressure on national services and crime are driving sentiment on the issue. Despite public concerns, the ESRI found no direct link between local shortages in healthcare, housing, or education and negative views toward immigration. Using indicators like the number of general practitioners per household and housing affordability, the study concluded that attitudes are influenced more by perception than by local experience. Geography also plays a role. People living in rural areas tend to have more negative attitudes toward immigration than those in urban centres. However, rural communities with higher proportions of migrants expressed similar attitudes to urban areas, pointing to the impact of everyday social contact in shaping views. Places where migrants live evenly among the broader population show more positive attitudes compared to regions where migrants are concentrated in clusters. This reinforces the idea that regular, informal interaction between neighbours, school parents, or community members can foster understanding and social cohesion. Dr. Frances McGinnity, lead author of the report, noted that local communities can be both a barrier and a bridge to integration. 'Communities are spaces where migrants and non-migrants not only encounter each other but can also form lasting social ties,' she said. Her co-author, Keire Murphy, added that socio-economic disadvantage is one of the strongest predictors of negative sentiment, echoing similar findings in other countries. 'The broader social and economic context is important for attitudes towards immigration,' she said. Meanwhile, Irish authorities are dealing with more immediate concerns related to immigration enforcement. Under 'Operation Sonnet,' the Garda National Immigration Bureau (GNIB) has returned more than 440 migrants to Northern Ireland and Britain since the beginning of 2024. These include individuals who crossed into Britain via the English Channel and then travelled on to Ireland to make secondary asylum applications or claim additional benefits. In one case, an Afghan national who had already applied for asylum in Britain attempted to register again in Ireland. Another case involved a man claiming to be Afghan, who was later found to have a Pakistani passport on his phone. Officers say they are increasingly aware of attempts to exploit the Common Travel Area between Ireland and Britain, with strong cooperation between Irish and British authorities to address these issues. The ESRI study states that fostering social integration in disadvantaged areas should be a key focus for future policy. Encouraging social contact and addressing underlying socio-economic inequality could be more effective in improving public attitudes than focusing solely on enforcement or deterrence, it says. See More: Asylum Seekers, Dr Frances McGinnity, ESRI, GNIB, Immigation
The Journal
5 days ago
- The Journal
'No evidence' of link between attitudes towards immigration and pressure on services, says ESRI
THERE IS 'NO evidence' of a link between negative attitudes towards immigration and pressure on local services in a community, according to a new study. However, broader economic and social policies, and factors such as disadvantage and segregation, play a 'key role' in social cohesion and attitudes towards immigration. The findings are part of research published by the Economic and Social Research Institute (ESRI) which is investigating attitudes around immigration at a community level. Overall it has found some importance in 'social contact with migrants for fostering more positive attitudes' towards immigration in communities. 'While some communities perceive immigration more negatively than others, positive social contact can play a key role in improving attitudes and therefore social cohesion,' the ESRI said. 'The findings about pressure on services indicate that it may not be direct local experiences that impact attitudes, but may instead be concern about pressure on services in Ireland as a whole.' It added that the findings have important implications for policies aimed at improving migrant integration. The study is based on a representative survey of adults in Ireland looking at views on immigration, conducted in April 2023, matched with Census 2022 and additional data on the communities they live in. Advertisement An earlier ESRI report found that education, financial strain and optimism about the future were factors related to attitudes towards immigration. As part of the research it looked at whether people living in areas with greater pressure on services like health, housing and education held more negative attitudes towards immigration. Using indicators such as the number of GPs per household and housing affordability, high rents and high house prices, it has found 'no evidence of a link', the ESRI said. The share of migrants in a community were not linked with attitudes towards immigration in Ireland overall, the study added. However, people living in more disadvantaged communities had 'more negative attitudes' towards immigration, in particular, disadvantaged communities where there was an increase in migrants since 2011. Living in a rural area was associated with more negative attitudes towards immigration, compared with living in an urban area, but this differed if the rural area had a high percentage of migrants in the community. In that case, had attitudes toward immigration that were 'very similar' to those in urban areas. 'This may reflect the importance of social contact with migrants for fostering more positive attitudes,' the ESRI said. Attitudes to immigration were also 'not related to the proportion of Ukrainian refugees' in people's local area. 'Surprisingly, the proportion of asylum seekers in the community is linked to more positive attitudes to immigration overall, though only a small number of respondents had asylum seekers living in their local area,' the study added. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Irish Examiner
5 days ago
- Irish Examiner
People living in disadvantaged areas ‘less positive' about immigration
People who live in communities with higher levels of socio-economic disadvantage are 'less positive' about immigration, research has found. A new Economic and Social Research Institute (ESRI) research paper examines the role that community context plays in understanding people's attitudes towards immigration in Ireland. The research found that the share of migrants in a community and recent increases in migrants between 2011 and 2022 were not associated with attitudes towards immigration in Ireland overall. However, people living in more disadvantaged communities had more negative attitudes towards immigration, in particular, disadvantaged communities where there was an increase in migrants since 2011. This has important implications for policies aimed at improving migrant integration The study is based on a large, representative survey of adults in Ireland looking at views on immigration, conducted in April 2023, matched with Census 2022 and additional data on the communities they live in. It follows a report published earlier in the year that analysed individual and household-level factors associated with attitudes to immigration, which found that education, financial strain, and optimism about the future were factors related to attitudes towards immigration. The latest research found that migrants are not more likely to live in disadvantaged communities, however, it also found that people in communities with higher levels of socio-economic disadvantage are less positive about immigration, even after accounting for their own financial situation. Disadvantage is captured by proportions of households headed by lone parents, unemployed, with low education, or semi or unskilled. The report found that an increase in the number of migrants living in the area since 2011 had a more negative effect on attitudes in disadvantaged communities. Living in a rural area was associated with more negative attitudes towards immigration, compared with living in an urban area. However, rural areas with high percentages of migrants had attitudes towards immigration that were very similar to those in urban areas. The report stated that this may reflect the importance of social contact with migrants for fostering more positive attitudes. This research shows that local communities can generate both obstacles to, but also opportunities for, social integration between non-migrants and migrants The research also found that more segregated areas, where migrants live in clusters rather than evenly spread across the area, show more negative attitudes towards immigration. This also suggests that positive social contact with migrants in communities may facilitate understanding. The research investigated whether people living in areas with greater pressure on services such as health, housing and education held more negative attitudes towards immigration. Using indicators such as the number of GPs per household and housing affordability, high rents and high house prices, the ESRI said it found no evidence of a link. It also found that attitudes to immigration are not related to the proportion of Ukrainian refugees in people's local area. Surprisingly, the proportion of asylum seekers in the community is linked to more positive attitudes to immigration overall, though only a small number of respondents had asylum seekers living in their local area. The research shows that community-level factors can give important insights into attitudes towards immigration. While some communities perceive immigration more negatively than others, positive social contact can play a key role in improving attitudes and therefore social cohesion. Echoing international findings, socio-economic factors like community-level disadvantage seem to matter, implying that the broader social and economic context is important for attitudes towards immigration 'This has important implications for policies aimed at improving migrant integration, but also indicates that broader economic and social policies and factors, such as disadvantage, segregation, urban/rural settlement, play a key role in social cohesion and attitudes towards immigration,' the report said. 'The findings about pressure on services indicate that it may not be direct local experiences that impact attitudes, but may instead be concern about pressure on services in Ireland as a whole.' Report author Fran McGinnity said: 'This research shows that local communities can generate both obstacles to, but also opportunities for, social integration between non-migrants and migrants. 'Communities are spaces where migrants and non-migrants not only encounter each other but can also form lasting social ties. 'This could be as next-door neighbours, as parents of children going to the same school, or in community groups. 'This kind of positive social contact between migrants and non-migrants can go a long way to generating positive relations between groups as well as building stronger, more cohesive communities in the long run.' Report co-author Keire Murphy said: 'This report gives important insight into what makes anti-immigrant sentiment more likely. 'Echoing international findings, socio-economic factors like community-level disadvantage seem to matter, implying that the broader social and economic context is important for attitudes towards immigration.' Read More Government to invest €200bn in infrastructure under updated National Development Plan
