Implications of Adams' libel victory ‘profound', says head of BBC NI
Adam Smyth, director of BBC NI, said their legal team had warned that the jury's decision in the high-profile defamation case could 'hinder freedom of expression'.
The BBC has been ordered to pay the former Sinn Fein leader 100,000 euro (£84,000) after a jury decided they had defamed him in a 2016 episode of its Spotlight programme, and an accompanying online story, by alleging he sanctioned the killing of former Sinn Fein official Denis Donaldson.
Mr Adams denies any involvement in Mr Donaldson's death in 2006.
Journalist Jennifer O'Leary presented the Spotlight programme (Brian Lawless/PA)
Speaking outside Dublin High Court alongside Spotlight reporter Jennifer O'Leary, Mr Smyth said they were disappointed with the verdict.
He said: 'We believe we supplied extensive evidence to the court of the careful editorial process and journalistic diligence applied to this programme and accompanying online article.
'Moreover, it was accepted by the court, and conceded by Gerry Adams' legal team, that the Spotlight broadcast and publication were of the highest public interest.'
Mr Smyth said the BBC had not wanted to come to court.
But he added: 'It was important that we defend our journalism and we stand by that decision.
'Our past is difficult terrain for any jury and we thank them for their diligence and careful consideration of the issues in this case.
'The implications of their decision, though, are profound.
'As our legal team made clear, if the BBC's case cannot be won under existing Irish defamation law, it's hard to see how anyone's could.
'And they warned that today's decision could hinder freedom of expression.
'Of course, a case of this importance, duration and complexity involves significant expense. In common with other media organisations, the BBC has insurance and makes financial provision for ongoing and anticipated legal claims.'
Gerry Adams took the BBC to court over an episode of its Spotlight programme (Brian Lawless/PA)
Mr Smyth said the BBC would now take time to consider the implications of the ruling.
Ms O'Leary said she had entered the witness box in the trial with 'nothing to hide, only sources to protect and I want to thank them for trusting me'.
She paid tribute to the witnesses who had appeared for the BBC in the case, including Ann Travers, whose sister was murdered by the IRA in 1984.
She said: 'And there are thousands of Ann Travers across this island and in Britain – victims and survivors of the Troubles and the years after the peace agreement – who carry the burden of their grief and trauma with incredible courage.
'They are the people I'm thinking of – all of them.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
25 minutes ago
- The Sun
Coronation Street and Emmerdale humiliated at British Soap Awards as rival soap wins EIGHT gongs
CORONATION Street were brutally snubbed at the 2025 British Soap Awards as they failed to pick up any of the previously announced awards at this year's ceremony. The annual soap event made a return this year after ITV mysteriously axed the contest in 2024 as Jane McDonald returned for her second year as host of the event. 5 5 5 But it was bad news for Coronation Street as the programme suffered a devastating loss after managing to bag just the specially curated Outstanding Achievement Award which went to Roy Cropper star David Neilson. The show failed to secure wins in any of the main panel or viewer-voted categories amid ITV's ongoing cash crisis and the mass cast exodus at the soap over the past six months. Its ITV counterpart Emmerdale also faced a crushing blow ahead of the impending ITV schedule changes which will see 30 minutes worth of each programme cut a week from January 2026. BBC rival EastEnders swept the board after collecting a total of eight gongs in its 40th anniversary year - more than double its nearest rival, Channel 4's Hollyoaks who got three awards. EastEnders was awarded Best Soap after its huge live episode and anniversary week which saw Anita Dobson return as Angie Watts and Martin Fowler killed off in the arms of his love, Stacey. It was certainly not the only award that they picked up with actress Lacey Turner receiving the trophy for Best Leading Performer ahead of her impending exit from the show. The 40th anniversary also managed to clutch the Scene of the Year thanks to Angie's shock return. Steve McFadden a won a trophy for Best Dramatic Performance as Phil Mitchell but did not attend the ceremony with Angela Wynter and Rudolph Walker also receiving prizes as Patrick and Yolande - beating Corrie fan favourites Lisa Swain and Carla Connor, affectionately known as Swarla, to the Best On-Screen Partnership award. The Walford based soap also collected the Comedy Performance gongs and Villain of the Year. In a major blow to Coronation Street, only David Neilson picked up the Outstanding Achievement Award as Roy Cropper which was presented to him by by his on-screen wife Julie Hesmondhalgh. Emmerdale shock return as Aaron's wedding to serial killer is gatecrashed by ex Hollyoaks managed to win three awards with Isabelle Smith winning as Best Newcomer with The Osbourne family taking home Best Family and the sibling sexual abuse storyline being named Best Storyline. Emmerdale managed just two awards with Amelia Flanagan beating her Corrie star brother Will to the Best Young Performer prize. Mike Plant, one of the show's camera operators, picked up the prestigious off-screen Tony Warren Award accolade for his contributions to the soap behind the scenes. ITV's crushing defeats come amid a period of unrest backstage at the shows. Both Corrie and Emmerdale have lost a number of stars over the past 12 months amid cuts at the channel. In particular, Coronation Street has faced increasing criticism of its far-fetched storylines and dwindling viewer interest in many of its plots. Fans will be able to see all the reaction from the ceremony held at the Hackney Empire during the broadcast of the ceremony this Thursday evening on ITV. 5 5
Telegraph
40 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Doctor Who finale review: Goodbye Ncuti Gatwa, hello Billie Piper – assuming the show survives
Amid mounting speculation about actor Ncuti Gatwa's future on Doctor Who (BBC One), an overwrought mess of a finale saw him regenerate into the show's next star – played, in a head-swivelling plot twist, by ex-companion Billie Piper. As the BBC continuity announcer said: 'What? What? ' The credits rolled on a whopping great cliffhanger – but one more about the show's future than the identity of the next Time Lord. With ratings in freefall, scripts slammed for 'wokery' and Gatwa's portrayal of the 15th Doctor misfiring, his short-lived Tardis tenure came to a creaky, confusing close. Thankfully, it saved some surprises for the final few minutes, due to the brief return of the 13th Doctor (Jodie Whittaker) and the shock reveal of the 16th Doctor. It could only have been more surprising if Gary Lineker had been seconded from Match of the Day or Gregg Wallace from MasterChef. Time travel doesn't get tougher than this. Piper previously played much-loved companion Rose Tyler who, in 2010, was left behind in a parallel universe with a part-human David Tennant clone (I know, I know). How she has now turned into a Time Lord will take some explaining. Showrunner Russell T Davies is desperately raiding his address book to help rescue the cult show. Tennant and Catherine Tate returned two years ago. Now he paid the Piper. Well, if all else fails, play your greatest hits. A patchy – and, for the franchise, potentially fatal – series meandered to its climax with an extended 70-minute episode titled 'The Reality War'. If you could keep track of what the heck was happening, you're a better man than I am and perhaps should apply for Davies's position forthwith. We last saw the Doctor tumbling from a tower in the sky. A perplexing penultimate episode had seen The Rani, a rogue Time Lord who'd split herself into two, snatch a baby who was actually Desiderium, the God of Wishes. She used the stolen infant to build a fake Stepford-style reality, with online conspiracy theorist Conrad (Jonah Hauer-King) installed as its Big Brother figure. Into this authoritarian dystopia, she dropped the brainwashed Doctor so his doubts could crack open reality, enabling the Rani to see into the 'underverse' and unleash Omega, another renegade Time Lord. Are we paying attention at the back? It wasn't what you'd call a straightforward plan. Davies threw a cast of dozens at the noggin-scratching narrative. By my count, we had not one but five villains versus the Doctor, plus countless companions. Talk about overstuffed and overpopulated. A stop-start finale found the Doctor risking everything to save one innocent life: Poppy, his daughter from the fabricated reality. It was never satisfactorily explained how the toddler came into being, but the Doctor and her 'mother', companion Belinda Chandra (Varada Sethu), moved heaven and earth to save her. Poppy was wiped from existence, then she wasn't. By the end, it was hard to care, no matter how cute she was. As for Omega, he bore no resemblance to the iron-masked monster who last appeared on screen 42 years prior. Instead he'd become a sort of giant zombie, swiftly zapped back to whence he came. Underwhelming doesn't cover it. At least leather-clad villainess The Rani (Archie Panjabi) got some good lines. She called the Doctor a 'strutting little pompadour' who spouted 'mimosa-scented platitudes about the power of love'. You'll find no arguments here. The first half hour mainly comprised characters standing around, spouting exposition at one another. What happened to 'show not tell'? Davies plotted his way into corners, before making his characters talk him out of them. Proceedings ended not on a big bang but a timey-wimey whimper. Reality was repeatedly 'reset', resulting in several endings rather than one. All the meddling caused a 'time schism', hence the brief return of Gatwa's predecessor Whittaker. Their scene together in the Tardis was poignant, if gratuitous. A homecoming for the Doctor's granddaughter Susan (Carole Ann Ford) had been teased but didn't materialise. At least with Whittaker and Piper parachuted back in, the future of the franchise looks female. Eventually, if viewers were still awake, the regeneration came. 'It's been an honour, a nightmare and a triumph,' said Gatwa. Not inaccurate, except perhaps the triumph part. As ethereal music swelled and more CGI was deployed, he morphed into Piper. 'Oh hello,' she grinned with a devilish twinkle. But was it too little, too late? All in all, Gatwa's premature departure – he lasted a mere 18 episodes and never even got to face the Daleks – felt hastily cobbled together and his regeneration fudged. It's now rumoured that Disney could cut off the cash that has been helping fund this latest iteration of the BBC stalwart, and Doctor Who will be 'rested' for only the second time in its 62-year history. This chaotic, compromised climax leaves it in a perilous position. This might have been the last episode for a long time, making it an even greater shame that it was such a sprawling stinker.
Scottish Sun
40 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Celtic Boys Club victim agreed to settle legal claim over fears he would end up dead or bankrupt
He could have been hit with a massive legal bill FIGHT FOR JUSTICE Celtic Boys Club victim agreed to settle legal claim over fears he would end up dead or bankrupt Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A CELTIC Boys Club abuse victim revealed he agreed to settle his legal claim over fears he would die before receiving compensation or suffer financial ruin. Gordon Woods, 71, told how he could have faced paying a massive legal bill for Parkhead bosses had he pushed on with his long fight for justice. 3 Celtic Boys Club abuse survivor Gordon Woods 3 A number of boys were abused at Celtic Boys Club by a gang of predators 3 Beast Jim Torbett abused Gordon when he was just 13 years old We told last month how the Hoops agreed to pay millions of pounds to end a class action brought by dozens of traumatised ex-footie starlets. But Mr Woods was not included. He was just 13 when he was abused by beast Jim Torbett, 77, who founded the boys club in 1966. Now the dad, who suffers from a lung condition, has explained why he finally agreed to settle his case. Mr Woods said: 'They made me three offers. I accepted the third one. "Rules for civil cases mean that if I'd refused and gone to court and won — but the court awarded me even 1p less compensation than what Celtic had offered me — I'd then be responsible for their legal costs from the date I had refused the offer. 'Would you take that chance? Are you going to roll that dice that could bankrupt you and your family? 'Or are you going to take this offer on the table and walk away?' Mr Woods, who has a teenage daughter, also feared he might not live to see his case end. He added: 'I worried that if I died before it concluded, then it would all be for nothing.' Previously, he had hoped that hearings in the Court of Session in Edinburgh would reveal who knew what and when. But last year he discovered a class action would only focus on whether Celtic FC was 'vicariously liable'. Last night Mr Woods blasted the Parkhead outfit for failing to admit a direct link with the boys club — and called for a public inquiry. He said: 'They said they feel sorry for the children abused at Celtic Boys Club. But they still separated it from Celtic Football Club. 'What they should have said was, 'These children were abused while they played under our banner, representing the name of Celtic.' But they didn't. 'So they have not made any official acknowledgement they were responsible. It's disgusting. 'My campaign will switch from the class action to a public inquiry. It's really necessary because, without that, nobody will ever know the truth.' Two top cops accused of mocking a colleague's Irish accent in 'grossly offensive' leaving video Gordon is also demanding a public inquiry into abuse across football in Scotland. He added: 'My campaign is now going to switch from the class action to a public inquiry. It's necessary, because without that public inquiry, nobody's going to know the truth.' Last month Thompsons Solicitors confirmed around 70 per cent of cases had been settled for a seven-figure sum. They said: 'Justice has finally been achieved.' Celtic said: 'The club is very sorry that these events took place at Celtic Boys' Club.' They added that they took 'this abuse extremely seriously because of the historic contacts between the two organisations'. But Mr Woods hit back: 'Celtic paid that money to silence victims, silence the media, and anybody else who might have questions.' Concerns over Torbett's conduct were flagged repeatedly for almost three decades but it wasn't until 1998 that he was finally convicted of sickening abuse of young footie starlets. The monster was jailed for three years in May 2023 for preying on Mr Woods in 1967. He also got six years in 2018 for molesting three kids. Disgraced ex-coach Frank Cairney, 90, was caged for three years in 2019 for sex attacks on young players. Celtic were contacted for comment.
